The store was nice and clean when we walked in. We were immediately greeted by the employee behind the counter. He was more than happy to answer our questions and help us figure out what we wanted! The waffle bowls were nice and fresh and he did awesome making our mixes! read more

Creamery at its finest! Loved the banana pudding mixture like eating an actual pie freshly made. Blueberry muffin mix was great but didn't neee the extra sugar on top! read more

See all

Great delicious tasting ice cream, milkshakes, and smoothies. You have more options mid day when they're full of inventory. Don't come too late because they'll run it off flavors or they'll have to close the doors early due to a long line, long wait, and low staffing. Pretty chilling spot with a few tables outside of Starbucks read more

See all

Food is great service is fantastic my man first time n he loved it we are full feeling on ambiance on going back read more

Cold Stone Creamery - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - West Allis, Wisconsin

I hadn't had lunch today and I thought that I would do something a little different and going to get a bowl of something cold and sweet would definitely be different. So this would my first visit to a CSC so I didn't know what their deal was and I noticed trays of different flavor of cold goodness and tons of toppings to add to them. I ordered the founders favorite thinking that the pecans, brownie, carmel and fudge would be sprinkled on top of my ice cream bowl and you also get one topping to add so I got a peanut butter cup. To my surprise they actually put all the ingredients on a board and hand mix it all together and then put it in your base of choice. I don't go out for ice cream often but I will say that this was so awesome and it hit the spot for something cold and sweet. read more

See all

This location seems a bit run down. I was disappointed that they put 4 gummy bears in my sons ice cream and would charge $1.19 more for a couple more when their small ice cream was already so expensive. I think I'll stick with Baskin Robbin's and DQ. read more

Nobody picked up phone when I called 4 different times. Place was clean. Server did not go out of her way to give me the points that was due to me. Worst looking cake I've ever received. I feel so ashamed to serve this cake at a huge retirement party for a person who is retiring. If I had known this cake was going to look like that, I'd have gone somewhere else! It looks like a 4 year old made it. read more

Cold Stone Creamery - Reeses Peanut Butter Mix in with yellow cake and white topping. - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - West Allis, Wisconsin

ordered a Barbie ice cream cake. It was tasty and everyone loved how cute the cake was. read more

Cold Stone Creamery - Best Ice cream cake ever - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - West Allis, Wisconsin

Ordered on the app 20 mins in advance, waited and came in and nobody seemed to be there for about 3 mins then one lady comes out and I told her my order and she began making it then. What the point if the app if it's no more efficient than coming in? Why advertise speed and thoroughness on the app and it's not attainable? I paid extra for a waffle bowl and didn't get it in the bag, and I could've mixed the ingredients better myself it was barely incorporated I had the apple pie a la cold and the banana pudding pints. Very disappointed won't come back again read more

Typical CSC in that it's small and staffed by underpaid workers who can't take tips. So, safe distancing in a Pandemic is a problem, and the way they prepare the desserts constant cleaning between patrons isn't possible either. It's really labor intensive, I can't blame the young workers for having lackadaisical attitudes and mediocre customer service. In spite of this, the turnover at this location is better than other CSCs, and the couple times I've been here I have had pretty good service. If you've never been, what they do is they take ice cream, they have a good variety of flavors, put it on a cold stone (see the connection?) and mash in various ingredients to order. So maybe you want fruit loops flavor ice cream (delicious) and you want some of those little marshmallows in it, they'll fold them in front of you. You can get a regular paper cup, but they also make fresh waffle bowls or cones to order. Very tasty. Like other fast food places, lots of non recyclable plastics, very hostile to the planet though not more so than other fast food. The parking lot is spaced for mid sized 1980s sedans, and of course most of the vehicles are monster SUVs. read more

Cold Stone Creamery - Anyone who doesn't tip at these places is heartless. - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - West Allis, Wisconsin

See all

I'm pretty disappointed with the customer service here. A while back I placed an order for an ice cream cake a week in advance for an event I was hosting. When I went to pick up my order I waited patiently while they went looking for it in the back. After a few minutes the manager came up and said he wasn't at work yesterday so he couldn't make the cake. I was a little confused why the cake wasn't made earlier since I placed the order a week prior. The manager didn't have an explanation, so I let it go. What was really upsetting is I needed a cake for the event, so I had to purchase one of the pre-made ones. I wasn't expecting a free cake, but a 10% discount or something would have been nice. Instead I was charged full price without an explanation. Also, is there only one person who knows how to make cakes here? Why? read more

After waiting more than 10 minutes in line, we find out that they are unable to process gift cards. They offered no other solutions and since one of us had already eaten half of the ice cream while waiting for our turn to pay, we didn't really have a choice but to pay with another method of payment. This is the closest Cold Stone to us and is more than 20 minutes away because they keep closing them. Guess I know why... Shake was not very good, Kopp's has nothing to worry about! read more

Very dirty and run-down location; super underfunded and employees were undertrained. Employee hygiene is a huge issue. Girl with pink hair was using gloves, but dragging her watch band and pride bracelet strings through the ice cream on every scoop. I wonder what she drags them through outside of work. Nasty! I ended up throwing 90% of the ice cream in the trash at home. Don't recommend. read more

We've been to this store multiple times and the employees are consistently rude. The place is also really dirty. On our last visit, we ordered an "everyone" container to go and when we opened it at home, it was only 3/4 full and the ingredients weren't mixed in evenly. You'd get a bite of just ice cream, then a bite with a huge glob of peanut butter, then a bite with all cookies. I love Cold Stone but really don't ever want to go back to this store. read more

Ran low on ice cream tonight and kicked us out, but let the family of 6 before us in when we only had two people. Very dissatisfied and disappointed, drove quite a distance for Cold Stone tonight. read more

This place is a pig sty inside and out!!! Trash everywhere. It's a shocking display of disregard for their shop, the brand or their business neighbors. The ice cream is the same here as it is any other location.... Overhyped and over priced, mistaking quantity for quality. Needs a serious clean up! read more

Birthday cake remix -- need I say more!? Cake batter ice cream, sprinkles, a brownie, and fudge -- it is the perfect combination! They are all mixed together on marble in front of you. The only downfall is that cake batter appears to be so popular that the past two times I've been there they have been out or on the verge of running out (yes, I may have begged them to scrape the container the most recent time -- I needed cake batter!) My only request is that they have more cake batter so they never run out, it is that good! Tip: if they are out of cake batter or mostly out, get what you can and have them add some chocolate. That is really yummy too :) read more

Used to come here all the time but took a break from eating tons of crap. Came here two nights ago and boy was the customer service HORRIBLE. There were three ladies working and they all seemed irritated that they had to work. They did not smile ONCE and barely said anything the whole time. I asked for cake batter with sprinkles, as I watched her scoop it, she was putting in the wrong type of sprinkles. My husband stopped her and told her they were wrong and her response was "that's all we have today". ??????????? Ummmm what? You advertise jimmys and put in sequins instead. I was craving my specific order like I used to get ALLLL the time. So whatever, I let it go. We still purchased it and then got a small cup of vanilla ice cream with sprinkles. She scoops vanilla and doesn't give me sprinkles. I said, "oh are the sprinkles in there?". She looks at me annoyed and said I didn't ask for any. If you're gonna choose to work in customer service then fake a smile at least and be nice. And even after all of that my husband gave them a $2 tip. Then I get in my car and open the lid on the ice cream and there is CARAMEL drizzle in the lid. At no point did I order anything with caramel. So they are being unsanitary and mixing stuff. Disgusting. I will not be back unless there are all new employees who wanna act right. It was better when there were high school kids there. Grown adults acting like this? Then find a different job. read more

Cold Stone Creamery - Caramel in the lid of my cake batter ice cream with sprinkles. - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - West Allis, Wisconsin

This has to be one of the worse customer service places I've been to. Made my order at 7:53pm arrived at 8:15 and order wasn't ready. The three caucasian girls that were working there were talking bad about the customers. I told them my name and that I was there to pick up an online order, 15 min go by and still nothing. They all start to laugh because they thought one of them was taking care of me, order was ready at 8:35pm. Not sure why they hire immature girls to work here. I was a regular rewards customer with a following on Instagram and Facebook of 10,000 people. I will be talking about this location so that no one bothers going here anymore. Ridiculous. Please have a talk with those 3 immature girls that were working on 12/7/20 in the PM hours. read more

Awesome ice cream that has a major sticker shock unless you have coupons. They have an app but don't see any advantages in having it over signing up for emails etc. this location can get a Major rush at a moment notice. So be prepared to wait. read more

See all

I went there for a dessert day because I had planned a dessert even though the line was long it came outside of the building amazing mint mint chocolate chocolate ice cream! read more

The workers on August 3 Night Shift had to deal with a rude woman and handled it respectfully and even accommodated to her demanding needs. I was impressed with how they handled the situation. I will be returning to this Cold Stone. (Would give 6 stars if possible) read more

Just went here at 5:30 pm and was told they had to close for 30 minutes to clean before they could accept any more orders. There is a problem every time i go here. read more

This is the closest Coldstone to me at the moment. I remember YEARS ago when Mayfair had a Coldstone, I would always get the same thing every single time: cheesecake ice cream with heath bar pieces mixed-in. Made a special trip yesterday on a hot June afternoon to this place, and I have to say...my usual order still tastes exactly as delicious as I remember. The employee behind the counter was pleasant and professional and offered a tasting sample when we walked in without us having to awkwardly ask if we could have one or two. I took her up on the offer and gave the Oreo flavor a try, but ultimately decided to stick to cheesecake. I'd gladly return to this location! read more

I couldn't find my Holy Grail ice cream cake in stock at DD, and ended up here instead. We picked up a Midnight Delight petite cake to-go for my birthday. I was pleasantly surprised with how good this little cake was. It was rich without being overly sweet, and the texture was smooth and creamy. The ganash, paired with the coolness of the chocolate ice cream and the moistness of the devil cake, really made this melt in my mouth. It was a bit pricey for the size though, considering the standard size is only a few bucks more. When in doubt, size up. read more

Oh Cold Stone, how I love you. Good ice cream, fun and tasty toppings, and employees you can extensively and repeatedly embarrass with a simple jingle of change into the tip jar. We went to the Cold Stone on Hwy 100 in Greenfield last night for some after dinner indulgence. I was surprised to find that we were the only people in there for most of our visit. Every other time I've ever entered any Cold Stone, it's been packed with customers. Maybe it's a sign as to why so many Cold Stones in the area have closed. *Sad face* But I think it has to do with the fact that Milwaukee is getting a lot of great new ice cream (or ice cream-esque) places and the shine of gimmicky Cold Stone is dulling. Anyhow, no matter how passe Cold Stone gets, they still serve full-flavor ice cream and tons of tasty mix-ins and in my book, there isn't a damn thing wrong with that. Bring on the Cold Stone! I got the Chocolate Cake Batter ice cream with crushed graham cracker pie crust, Reese's Peanut Butter Cups, and bananas. I wish I would have skipped the banana as it overwhelmed all of the other ingredients. (Though I don't hold that against Cold Stone as it was my mistake, not theirs.) Otherwise, it was a very delicious treat. read more

When I say RUDE I mean rude with a capital R!!! From the manager to the employees. Threatening to call the police on customers for voicing their opinions?!?! The system they have is so slow!!! We didn't mind waiting though but the nasty attitude by the manager (who almost knocked me down trying to open the door without saying excuse me) was what made my experience here so awful. I love Coldstone Creamery but I will NEVER patronize this location ever again. read more

So I'm clearly ok with spending $5 on ice cream if I walk through the door here, right? But I expect to get what I paid for. Instead, the ice cream was so soft that employee couldn't really mix it for fear of it becoming total soup before she even got it in my bowl. This meant I had two hockey pucks of unbroken cookie dough floating in a bowl of oreo ice cream soup. Total disappointment. I should have known when the employee didn't struggle at all getting my ice cream out of the case. Instead of digging and pulling the ice cream to get enough, it pulled right up. The mess was so gross and drippy and seriously there isn't a better word than disappointing. I ended up throwing most of it out. They'll likely get another shot at my business, because I've had good experiences at other locations and the bf's was fine and sometimes you want a 5,000 calorie ice cream sundae of goodness. But on this occasion, not so much. read more

This creamery is amazing! Not to busy at 6:45 at night, so no wait. It's a bit pricy, but it's really good! It's too bad that the cold stone closed in delafield, because this one is out of our way so we don't go much. I think it's super cool how they make your ice cream on literally a cold stone in front of you. Definitely worth a try. One of my suggestions would be more seating, inside and out. Our fam of 6 took up 3 tables. Otherwise amazing! read more

You are greeted as you walk in the door with smiles and a clean shop! Lots of different choices to create a delicious masterpiece with! Awarded 3 stars from me due to the lack of 'toppings'. Out of brownies, Reese's and tried to substitute. Still tasted phenomenal but could have been WAY better! No take home lid for the waffle bowl so it was a awkward drive home! read more

Cold Stone Creamery - Mint Mint Chocolate Chip; missing brownies (still good) Peanut Butter Deluxe; missing a lot of Reese's (still good) - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - West Allis, Wisconsin

Love the cupcakes and the coffee lovers ice cream the best! Service is friendly and great plus store is always very clean as well!

Ordered Cold Stone to be delivered through door dash for TWO people, on a Thursday night. Two medium, very simple desserts. It arrived around the 45 minute mark and only ONE was delivered. When we called the store, we were offered two free larger sizes of ice cream the next time we stopped in. Don't offer delivery services if you're not capable of checking to make sure the proper delivery will be received. read more

Okay, its a chain store that I actually like. The concept here is cool. Create your own sundae from the selection of mix-ins, or choose one of their signature blends. On me recent visits we choose one of the signature blends Strawberry & Banana with Pie Crust. It was yummy and one was perfect for sharing with my husband. The other flavor combination that we had recently was the banana ice cream with chocolate and peanut butter mixed in. Delicious. There is something about the consistency of the ice cream wit the mix-ins that is different and defiantly better here that getting ice cream from other establishments in the area. It is expensive, but share with a friend and it brings the cost down quite a bit. read more

Just bought a Groupon for Cold Stone Creamery only to find the location on Hwy 100 near National Avenue in West Allis had a sign on the front door this evening saying "temporarily closed". Wondered if anyone knows (a) is they are re-opening or closing permanently and (b) whether the other locations are also closing? Wondering if I need to ask Gropon for my money back. Would be sad as it is my wife's favorite ice cream stop. read more

I love ice cream especially Cold stone.... but this wait is not worth it. There's only 2 employees working and the line is almost out the door. I have been standing in the same spot for close to 15 mins waiting. Giving it three stars because of the quality of the ice cream. If I could rate the employees it would be a 1 because they are acting and look extremely pissed. read more

Long line and only 3 girls working. Not to mention the place was a disaster and totally unorganized. Also one of the girls didn't have a hat on and found a hair in my ice cream later on. Love cold stone but I'll think twice before going back read more

Went here a few mins before closing. Employee locks the door just as we are walking up. Sent message to corporate website. Owner emails me. Apologizes and asks for address to send coupons. Coupons never come. Forget this place. read more