I'll be brief. The best Old Fashioned! Hot Honey Chicken was sweeter than expected. Needed more Hot kick. Open faced Reuben needed more sauce. Otherwise the dining experience had great service and ambience. read more

See all

We've been to Cobblestone on Main several times and have had mostly great experiences. The steak salad is amazing--always fresh and flavorful. My husband is a big fan of the wedge salad, and the French onion soup is also excellent. The service and atmosphere are generally very enjoyable, but the only downside on our last visit was the live music. For the size of the space, it was way too loud and honestly a bit of a turn-off, making it hard to have a conversation at our table. Other than that, the food and overall experience are excellent, and we'll definitely keep coming back. read more

Congratulations. The toughest piece of shoe leather disguised as corned beef. Try as I might, it was literally inedible. The fried potatoes that came with it were good so it wasn't a total loss. Got the stuffed mushroom appetizer. The filling was good but the mushrooms were barely cooked. My wife got the chicken salad which she said was good but the bun was greasty. All in all, you could say this was not a good experience... read more

went here a few years ago and was not overly impressed , but went back today and was wowed by the food! Most excellent salmon BLT and perfect crispy Brussels sprouts. Friend loves the Cobb salad. Excellent service, and impeccably clean . read more

See all

Good food in a casual farmhouse style restaurant and bar. Service was good. My salad was made to order and came out how I asked. Prices are on the higher side but worth a splurge. read more

Cobblestone On Main - Cobb salad - New American Near Me - Webster, New York

Delicious food, and charming, classy ambiance but not stuffy. Our server provided excellent service. We will definitely be back! read more

See all

Joey provided amazing service to us on Friday night. We were the 3 person group that loved the colorful carrots. Thank you for being attentive & fun. read more

At its core, Cobblestone On Main is a great establishment with good food and fast service. The interior portrays a sophisticated restaurant, but that vibe is backed up by high quality food and an innovative kitchen. They take the staples, add a twist, and it turns out exceptionally delicious. They also focus on presentation, which is not something you can always count on at this price point. I'd highly recommend this place to locals, or those just passing through! read more

See all

Have had 2 experiences at Cobblestone so far and both were great! The food is good, the drinks are pricey but good, the servers and staff and all great. The bunched up girls in the front host/hostess table make me wonder tho. Anyway, Im looking forward to dinner for my 15th Anniversary this coming weekend. Happy Halloween read more

The food is DELICIOUS!! The skirt steak was so flavorful and the sauce on the soba noodles was perfection. The salmon was perfectly cooked with a crispy top and moist center. Not only the food but the staff is amazing. We went two nights back to back and had two different servers. They were so friendly, helpful and attentive. Next time I'm back in the Rochester area I'm coming back here. read more

See all

Had the most disappointing lunch here yesterday. I ordered the special chicken salad sandwich, which was to be made with cranberries and walnuts and served on a toasted croissant. When it arrived, it didn't look like any croissant I had ever seen--more like a flat-topped hamburger bun. Then I took my first bite and bit into a fairly large chicken bone, the kind you could choke on. The waiter (Sean C.) came back around and asked how my sandwich was. I showed him the bone and told him he served me more than I had expected. He turned on his heels so quickly I expected he was going to come back with some remedy. Nothing. I ate very little of the lunch afraid of coming across another bone. Still the waiter offered nothing. So when the check arrived, I expected that Sean would either have deducted the price of the sandwich, or at least a discount. Nothing!!! I won't even talk about my husband's open-faced Reuben served with little if any sauerkraut and scant dressing. read more

They sure know how to do French Onion Soup, for sure, and we always order the shrimp tacos off the apps menu. You can't beat these! Delicious! The perfect meal: French onion soup and Shrimp Tacos. We've ordered the Brussels sprouts each time also but these usually come swimming in oil so just a warning. Still, the soup and tacos deserve a 6 so I'm not going to ding them on the oily Brussels. read more

I came in a 5pm and sat at the bar for 20-30 minutes while at bar I saw at least 6 employees go behind the bar and pour shots for themselves while pitching about management and the restaurant. Went to my table and Hayley was our server, we ordered and ate while catching up on our lifes when Hayley came to the table and asked us to leave because there was a 1 1/2 hour wait for tables. We looked at eachother as we were still drinking our wine and realized we were being kicked out of our table by this horrible server Hayley. We got up and began to walk through the restaurant to the door and saw that there were open tables everywhere. Really? Hayley just wanted her table turned over! Never again will I go there. read more

Nice atmosphere, friendly staff. The French onion soup was really good and the crispy chicken sandwich was excellent. read more

Cobblestone On Main - Crispy chicken sandwich - New American Near Me - Webster, New York

See all

My daughter took me here for lunch. She had heard from a friend that it was good. They offered to sit us on a high top but being petite it is much more comfortable to sit at a table where your feet touch the ground! It was difficult deciding what to order because there were so many choices! I was impressed by the variety on the menu, but since it was Friday fish fry was the featured entree! I like my fried fish served with malt vinegar. It was very tasty and fresh! The crust was not as greasy as others. Very light and crispy! My daughter ate bacon cheeseburger which was also good with maple wood bacon! I would definitely return to try some other entrées! read more

See all

Hubby and I have driven by a few times and decided to stop in tonight. The Yelp reviews were mixed but the menu looks fantastic, so we decided to give it a try. Good sized crowd inside, but no wait for a table or seat at the bar. Saw plenty of staff working and the owner was on site. There is a parking lot on the side of the building and a door that will take you inside on the lower level of this two-story restaurant. There is a flight of stairs to get to the upper level & the hostess stand. If you enter from Main St., there is a ramp for walkers/wheelchairs although there are no automatic door openers. And, there is a handicapped parking spot directly in front of the building on the street. There are bathrooms on the lower level and bathrooms on the upper level. The ladies room is one person at a time. Decor was nice - mix of antiques and farmhouse. There is also a mix of booths, tables with bench setting, and high top tables. We sat at the bar where we could watch the game. Carly took great care of us and she makes a fantastic Cosmo! We started with the pork belly tacos, there were three so hubby had two and I had one. It was juicy, flavorful, and just the right amount of spice (not too much). The flour tortilla held up well to the all the juices from the meat and the slaw. Would definitely order these again. We both ordered burgers and salads for dinner. I like the lemon vinaigrette dressing - homemade & fresh! The bacon cheddar burgers were tasty, cooked as we requested (medium), and a good size. The only thing I would change is to not dress the burger with the onion jam on the bottom bun. The bottom bun got very soggy and almost disappeared which is problematic when eating but not the end of the world. Maybe cut the bun so there is a thicker bottom? I don't know. I flipped mine over and no problem. All of the desserts are made in house as are the tater tots and many other things. Carly gave us the scoop but the Cosmos are now affecting my memory of those details lol. There were out of all desserts but we did see the last blackberry bread pudding go by and it looked amazing! We would dine here again no hesitation. Looking forward to trying dessert too! read more

See all

Food was worth the hype. Slightly expensive but worth it. Clean and new. Will go again soon with family for occasions!!!

Fish Fry Friday, OH YEAH!!! Excellent haddock dinner here. This was the primary reason I came to Cobblestone on Main. The downstairs ambiance seemed to have a nicer air about it than the upstairs. Better decor, just a nicer feel to it. Enjoy them while they are young, they said - they weren't talking about my children, they're talking about my hips, back and knees! With that said, I do wish they had a host station downstairs and a few more parking spaces for those who hold disabled persons parking placards. Being physically challenged due to a history of traumatic injuries, makes it difficult to walk long distances across parking lots and go up and down stairs, and the fewer times I have to do it in a short period of time, the better for my back, hips and knees. When I got upstairs to the host station, they asked if a high top was okay - I said no, due to the physical discomfort associated with sitting at a high top. So they said "follow me" and back down the stairs we went. Ugh! I had just gotten up them. Food was great, atmosphere was great. Service was also pretty terrific. Our party of six seemed to have multiple servers. Water stayed full, in fact, pitchers of water were brought to the table. Service might have started out a little delayed but the attention we received from our servers was nothing short of fantastic after that. Looking forward to a return visit during one of my ROC trips. read more

Great place and atmosphere... food quality and drink prices way off. Had corn beef and cabbage... $28 a plate... so not worth that. They should go to Shamrock Jacks to learn about how to make that dish... Orange Tee shots...$8 per shot lol.... 6 shots $48.... lol.... for well pour. I will never go there again... Too bad bartenders were very good. read more

It's been a while but disappointing to find they no longer serve their amazing meatloaf, I'm guessing there was a chef change since I last visited. I'll still give them 5 stars but they should consider bringing it back. read more

Visiting from out of state, and I came upon cobblestone on Main. Fortunate for myself, Joey the staff was phenomenal. The food was hot and tasty. 5/5. Whether you're local or just in the area, you need to try it out Fabulous spot will come back again. read more

I rank this place with 5 stars because I have lots of experience with restaurants. The bartenders are great they are generous on the pour every single time.One of the best HANG OUT places for me .I don't think u can judge my salad till u try it Courtney is my fave read more

Cobblestone On Main - Salmon Salad - New American Near Me - Webster, New York

So we went out mid week for a no cook night, we made a good choice. The Cobblestone is very quaint.. we both ordered this Steak burger mine medium his well done. It was perfect. Our server was very nice, not terribly attentive but courteous. We sat in their very impressive bar ,in a huge booth. I can't wait until the good weather to sit out side and watch people. We will be back. read more

They don't accept reservations so get there early for a very nice dinner. The staff were perfectly attentive, the drinks were reasonably priced and the food was excellent. Please consider Cobblestone On Main for an altogether pleasant meal. read more

Have better service and also have better food there too and the atmosphere was not very good

Got a burger and a chicken sandwich and shared! It was really yummy. Chicken and beef could use some more spices tho. We had a sangria and a spicy margarita, they were tasty! Definitely a must if you are in webster! read more

Cobblestone On Main - Burger - New American Near Me - Webster, New York

I went to Cobblestone on Main with some friends for dinner. The burger was delicious and the fries were an interesting shape, but it worked. Our waiter was very nice, however we did feel a bit rushed by the person bussing the table. read more

A bit expensive but wonderful fish fries and burgers. Excessively busy from 5 to 7pm. Worth the wait.

Took the in-laws out to local place for dinner. It was not overly noisy, so communication was easy. We were sat quickly and had a nice relaxing meal. Steak salad was large and tasty, the men enjoyed their burgers and stated they were very tasty as well. My mother in law had the French onion soup and ate every bit. Definitely will go back again. Great experience with wonderful ambience read more

We went here last nite for the first time. Drinks are good but pricey. I had the salmon which was perfect. My honey had the bone in pork chop also perfect. Service was great! I watched as other dinners came out to be served... presentation was excellent! read more

I really liked this place. It is centrally located and easy to get to. Staff was very nice and welcoming. My friend had the special of the day salad with grilled peaches, blueberries, and goat cheese. Which she liked. Would definitely go again. read more

See all

My friends and I stopped by to have a few drinks the other night. I had an $8.00 Black & Tan (reasonable) and my friend ordered a Gin & Juice. After ordering some food and sometime there after I paid and we left. Went I got home I looked at the receipt and discovered they charged $14.00 for the Gin & Juice. I thought it must be a mistake so I called and was told they make their cocktails with special ingredients to justify the cost. I guess inflation has hit Cobblestones. I know how much a premium (?) bottle of liquor costs and how many shots it yields. Glass was mostly ice so enough said.. Going back to see my friend Jay Speranza at Tony D's where I get a better value for my buck! read more

Dinner was amazing!!! We each ordered the chopped Caesar salad. It was generous in proportion and not overly dressed, with plenty of sliced Parmesan and fresh croutons. As delicious and satisfying as the salad was, the entree was even better! Two of us shared the roasted chicken with fingerling potatoes and Brussels sprouts in the most delicious and perfectly seasoned sauce. The chicken was perfectly cooked, juicy and tender. Same can be said for sprouts and potatoes. If I could have tactfully licked the plate of all the remaining sauce on the plate I would have. I must also mention our server, Ben. He was just the right amount of attentive and was friendly and knowledgeable about the menu. Looking very forward to returning! read more

Open space area with both booths and high top tables. Server arrived less than 5 min from being seated so off to a very good start. For drinks, I started with the Peach Tease, peach vodka, raspberry iced tea, and lemonade. Tastes refreshing. Ideal for a summer night. Had the hint of peach and raspberry that pair well together. Mostly tastes like iced tea but you can tell there is a hint of alcohol. Grandma's Pumpkin Pie was a vanilla vodka drink with a pumpkin pie flavoring, and Kahlua. You mostly taste the Kahlua with the hint of pumpkin, which was not overpowering. I'll admit, the flavor overall reminded me of drinking a pumpkin scented candle, so I'd advise to try another drink. The fried calamari taste salty and savory. Crust was lightly crispy and the sauce was delicious but the calamari was good all on their own with their almost sweet meat. The Pout-tots is a take on poutine with cheese curds. Came with a side of warm gravy, ideal for dipping. The tator tots were ok still but then you bring it together with the cheese and gravy and that's when the magic happens. Forgot about the panchetta as they all fell to the bottom. No complaints; saved the best for last. This explains why the tots weren't as salty. If they salted the tots while keeping the panchetta, it would have been overkill. The swordfish entree had a citrusy blackened crust but when cut into, it was incredibly tender and juicy. Not overly seasoned to allow the flavors of the fish to shine through. It but like a medium rare steak. The hot pastrami sandwich is one of those sandwiches where you'll want to cut in half. The pastrami was thinly sliced and tender. The meat just falls apart as you bit into it. The horseradish sauce isn't overpowering. Just gives a slight hint so the flavors are not offensive. Definetly enough to take home as well, assuming you had an appetizer prior. Service was stellar. Portions were large; you'll bring leftovers home. read more

See all

It's a great space with a lot of seating in multiple floors. The salt bread with butter was a fantastic start. I ordered the peach tease cocktail which I felt was very sweet so I went with the sweet and spicy which was refreshing. All the food was delicious. read more

See all

The food was delicious and everyone enjoyed their meal. We were visiting with cousins and appreciated that they didn't rush us.

Excellent quality food . Nice friendly service. A bit pricey . Beautiful space. Nicely renovated read more

This restaurant just opened. It's in the heart of the village. I was pretty excited to see another dinner option in the village. There are three rooms: the large main bar area, a small rear dining room, and a downstairs dining room. The main bar area is open, has high ceilings, huge windows, and has several different types of seating areas. This is a great place for a drink and appetizer with friends. Might be the best in the village honestly. The décor is nicely appointed. The back dining area and the downstairs area are darker and quieter. I would request this if you are looking for a more intimate setting. They have a lot of different options including appetizers/small plates, upscale sandwiches, and full dinners. Most options have a twist to them. We started with the poutine. It wasnt traditional poutine. The gravy is served on the side and tasted like real gravy. It was rich and not artificially thick. The potatoes were fried chunks instead of just normal french fries. The sandwiches are priced fairly and there are a bunch of different options. I opted for the shrimp boy. It was great and I would definitely order it again. My wife had the crab cake and prime sirloin. The steak was a little overcooked and not too flavorful. One side was different than what was on the menu. She said she probably wouldn't order it again. Maybe the sandwiches/burgers are they way to go. This was kind of a letdown. Kids meal came with an entree, two sides, and a drink. I'm pretty sure a dessert is included but we didn't recieve one. We ordered fruit as a side and it was a bowl of orange wedges (probably from the bar) that was forgotten when they brought out the food. Im guessing the waitress didnt known they were out of fruit. All meals are served with bread. Dinners include a soup or salad plus 2 sides. Portions were a good size. Overall it was a nice place and we would visit again. I went on a Monday night and it was surprisingly busy and lively. No wait since there is ample a seating. read more

See all

We went for my husbands birthday. We started with calamari which was ok. I had the meatloaf which was salty and dry. I returned that and got the pasta dish which was all grease. Husband ordered the very expensive ribeye which was meh. They didn't take the meatloaf off the bill so I basically paid for 2 awful entrees. A large bill with a disappointing experience. I will not be returning. read more

Another favorite to take clients to lunch! Great food, great service and excellent place to take clients!