Ahh, one of the favorite local establishments frequented by Western Maryland College students. What's that you say, its McDaniel now? Don't even get me started on that atrocity of a name, but I guess those students can go to Classico too, but this place opened up when it was still WMC. The place has some seriously good pizza, although it isn't anything to be confused with brick open or specialty pizza. It is a very thin crust, and it makes it perfect to be folded while eating. The sauces and toppings fit very well with this style of pizza. And it is certainly a grease fest, as in you'll probably want to use some napkins to get rid of it before it goes into your freshmen fifteen body. I honestly can't speak about other dishes, because I've only ever had the pizza here. But if I had to choose between pizza here or at Roberto's, I would definitely choose Classico. read more

Best Italian cold cut I have ever had! The pizzas they had on display were so appealing that I had to try a slice and it was an amazing decision! I will definitely be back for their Monday night special of a 16" pizza for $8.99!! read more

I love this pizza. It is my favorite pizza of all pizza places. Never eaten here just gotten carryout. I live five min away and normally call when I am leaving the house because service is that fast. They always say 5-10 min and it is literally that. Or I will call while j am at Safeway checking out and it will be ready. Always friendly. Little pricey but worth the price to me. My only complaint is sometimes it's too hot and fresh and cheese slides around in the car on the way home. If you want a good NY style pizza go here. Seriously. now. P.s. Also have GF pizza but yet to try read more

Best pizza in Westminster! Family owned and operated business that always has stellar service. read more

The owner's kids went to school with mine,so this used to be a regular for us. Haven't been in years,the kids got kinda burnt-out from their pizza being served at every school event, pizza party,etc. So glad we tried the Monday Special $8.99 carryout large cheese pizza. It reminded me why it was served at every school event: tasty, cheesy, with a crispy yet chewy crust. Even the sauce tasted super fresh,thick but not chunky (a sticking point for one of my offspring...) This is one local business I can happily add back to the rotation!! read more

Honestly one of the best pizza places in the entire STATE! Grew up in New York City eating pizza and this place always reminds me of home! I've yet to have a bad slice to date and will continue to support amazing pizzerias just like this! Thank you Classico Pizzeria read more

This place has the best pizza in Westminster. OK, I grew up on Long Island, and I will admit that nothing outside the NYC area even comes close to NYC area pizza. But I live here now, and Classico's is the best in the area. The garlic knots are also excellent. I have tried a special or two here, and though they are generally quite good, the pizza is their true specialty. Very good, friendly and attentive service. I have both eaten in the restaurant and gotten take-out. To the best of my knowledge, they do not deliver. It is a small place that doesn't have many tables, but I imagine the vast majority of their business is take-out (particularly with the McDaniel College campus within reasonable walking distance). read more

The best Pizza, ever! My Mom brought my brother and I here when we were younger and now that I'm married I continue the tradition and bring my husband. If you ever are craving a really good cheese pizza or some amazing can oils, check this place out! read more

Classico is my favorite pizza place in Westminster! They truly have the best crust and sauce around. Monday night is Pizza night in my house since they run a special on large pizzas. They also make great cheesesteaks, calzones, and they cook their steak fries to perfection. We usually call ahead and do carry out, but they have a decent seating area and bathroom for those who want to eat in. read more

Excellent pizza, subs, calzones, Italian dinner favorites, panni, saladsetc. Has wine and beer. A bit weak on desserts, but the Italian dishes are excellent. read more

Always satisfied! Fast service and great food. Probably the best pizza place in town! I love their spaghetti too. read more

Best pizza I've ever had in my life the guys behind the counter in a cool, friendly and very kind. Iv been there multiple times never had a bad experience and never had one complaint about the food. read more

A great little Italian carry out (with tables to eat-in, if you like) offering a wide variety of Italian cuisine. I can particularly recommend the salmon dinner! read more

I cannot say enough good things about this place the owner, even the gluten free pizza all the food is delicious here everybody is nice and it's the best pizza I've ever had! The spaghetti is delicious here too. The calzones are a really good size for the price. Trust me you won't regret eating here! read more

It is a good pizza place. There isn't much to sing about after that. Most everyone will know what that means. The pizza is good, some of the subs are good. Convenient to the area. read more

Being a Baltimore native, I obviously love Pizza Johns THE MOST, but this place was realllllly good too! Came here with the 'rents after visiting a really depressing cow farm. We got the thin crust pep with extra cheese. It was amazing and it helped lift my mood after seeing a field of soon to be cheeseburgers. I promised my dad I wouldn't mention the fact that he mishandled the first slice of pizza like a clumsy virgin at a key party and as a result, all of the cheese slid off of his slice and into a sad wet pile on the table. It was the most upsetting part of my day and I literally just left a cow killing farm. I highly recommend this place if you make it out this far. Yum! read more

I work across the street....and any new employee that starts here, I ALWAYS recommend their food for lunch. So good!

Having lived in/near Baltimore a few years and traveling to NYC many times I've become what I call a Pizza snob :) We just moved here less than a month ago and I was told to check out Classico Pizza. It was very good! I have been there twice now and both times got pizza. We all loved it. The black olives are whole which was odd but it didn't stop me from ordering them. The white pizza was delicious also. I would recommend this place to all. read more

Easily the best pizza in the Westminster area. Love the family owned vibe of the place too.

as good as it gets in this area. 3 brothers from Italy are hands on here. The menu, ingredients, and recipes are authentic. The TV often is showing soccer or moto-racing from Europe. They also have thoughtful, rotating, very good italian entrees available here. While not their mainstay, these dishes are top notch in a more casual environment. Family friendly, eat in or out. Reasonable prices If you really like authentic, good tasting pizza, see if your family of 3-4 teens/adults can polish off one of their silician pizzas. I bet they can't read more

This place by and far has the best pizza in Carroll County, and without a doubt some of the best pizza in Maryland. Although the restaurant has only been open about 10 years or so, the owners have been making homemade pizza in the westminster area for almost 25 years. The difference maker here, fresh ingredients, homemade dough and sauce and each pizza is hand made to order by the owners Nunzio and Pepe. If you visit Classico Pizzeria in Wesminster you wont be dissapointed. And if you dont think its the best pizza, then I would like to know where you can get better. read more

Yummy pizza. All tastes fresh and the chocolate mousse desert is divine! Great service with friendly family atmosphere. As good as a NY village pizza. read more

From a world traveler's perspective, I'm floored to find the best sicilian slice on Earth here in Westminster.

Love Love Love the Pizza!!! The owners are brothers and at least one is always working which guarantees great service if you ask me! The restaurant is always clean! read more

The pizza is good here. No doubt about that. I just got off the phone with them after my wife took one bite of a disgustingly spoiled sour tiramisu. I called and a young female voice picked up, made no apologies for the rancid tiramisu, and simply stated "Thanks for letting us know." No apology. No attempt to make it right. The tiramisu literally smelled like vomit. I hope we don't get food poisoning from the Monday cheese pizza special and cannoli we ate. They lost our business for good with their uncaring response. read more

This is our favorite pizza place. The guys behind the counter are a bit stoic, but that doesn't mean they can't make the best New York style pizza we've had in this area. read more

There's not much to offer in the town of Westminster, but Classico Pizza is the best pizza I've been able to find! Can't get pizza by the slice though.... kinda lame read more

Very good floppy cheese sort of greasy pizza. Best if eaten immediately in the restaurant.

Great pizza. We always make sure to hit up this place when visiting the in-laws around the holidays. The meatballs are fantastic and best I've had on any pizza. The service is always good and Birch beer fountain drink is a favorite for my wife. read more

I loved this pizza - not fussy, good crust, just the right amount of toppings - great flavor. It's so hard to find great quality pizza with just the basics - no weird sugar or 'butter flavored' coatings that it was just joy to eat this pizza. We also had the tiramisu - it was wonderful too! Not gummy or overly wet - great coffee flavor and good cake under the custard. The staff was very nice too. Thanks Classico! read more

Fantastic Pizza, friendly people, easy to get to. Good value for the money. May not be New York, but it's as good as it gets this far away!

Excellent food and top notch service, great people. Nothing but positive things to say, we go back often.

Moved to Finksburg but will still drive the 30 mins each way to get their pizza! By far the absolute best in the area!

This used to be my favorite pizza place and my families favorite also. If you do get their food at least get carry out so hopefully your food won't be sitting out at all. We went in to actually sit and eat with my toddler. I ordered and as we sat and waited and waited they burnt our pizza which was already cooked they just put it in to make warm again. Then almost did it again. Then as we were waiting for the rest of our food we noticed something gross. Since it is hot out I know it is hard to control even with all of the fly traps everywhere but flies were landing on the pre made pizzas over and over. They did nothing when we told them about it. Then we asked nicely if we could get our money back since we would not feed our son something with 20 flies landing on it for long periods of time and then being recooked after. They were furious but gave us our money back. When we said maybe they should try better at shielding their yummy food they said it was fine and swatted at the flies. Disappointing since they have good tasting food when flies are not involved. read more