3 stars because the food is good & employees are really attentive. Classic Good Deli food!! Way to expensive- $16 for a breakfast egg white, turkey, swiss cheese, avocado wrap??? There was a smear of avocado. No where else, not even Manhattan will you pay that much. Sorry but a lot of people are writing you are way too expensive. So I know its not just me. read more

$17.89 for a omelet wrap n a coffee. GTFOH! Then the guy goes to me I knew u wasn't going to pay. Should have told me the price when I ordered since it was advertised. read more

Had job in the area, got super lucky finding this place nearby. food was delicious, I enjoyed a garlic bread sub with breaded chicken, fresh mutz, roasted peppers and a sweet balsamic glaze to top it off. really enjoyed this sandwich and the employees here were very sweet and polite. 10/10 read more

Chubby's Delicatessen - Delis Near Me - Bay Shore, New York

Paid $16.99 for turkey, bacon, lettuce, tomato on a roll. Wasn't even a lot of meat! This is not worth the money and the prices are borderline criminal. Will never go back. read more

I work locally and have ordered from here a few times over the last 2 years. I've always felt it was a bit over-priced but today takes the cake! I ordered a signature hero -The Exstacy and nothing else. The hero was $19! It is supposed to be a hot hero, it was cold and the bread was stale, they skimped on the ingredients, definitely not worth $19.00. I forced myself to eat it because i didn't want to waste the money. Do yourself a favor, find somewhere else to eat, it'll save you money and you'll have a better experience. I won't be back. read more

This place is way to expensive. $10 for a sausage, egg, and cheese or a bagel is ridiculous. read more

Chubby's Delicatessen - Sausage, egg, and cheese - Delis Near Me - Bay Shore, New York

I wish I could give it six stars. The service was quick and efficient and the workers are nice. The food was so good I will be dreaming about the chubby checker with Cesar dressing for the rest of the week. Portion was a good size the sandwich was huge. I recommend this deli. read more

So I used to come here religiously after work. I haven't much of their food, everything I've had is decent. Service is typically fine. They're always busy so expect to wait or call ahead. My suggestion, try the bada boom panini! This is what had me hooked in coming here. I can't really rate this deli higher than a 4 only because that's all I ever went there for but if you get that panini you're in great hands! read more

This used to be my go to deli when I worked in the area. They have a variety of veggie and fruit salad plates and different types of hot & cold sandwiches to choose from. Oh yeah don't forget there fresh croissant and bialys early in the morning. The only bad thing I found about them is they can be a little expensive. They are conveniently located on the north side of the Deer Park train station in walking distance read more

See all

This Deli is a more expensive than others but the food is very good and the employees are always attentive and polite.

If you're going to charge me $9 & change for 3EW cheese and avocado on a roll can you at least put more than one slice of unmelted cheese and unripened sour avocado on it? Also, only offering one sized iced coffee beverage and charging 4.50 for it is wild. so disappointed the quality has gone down significantly since I was last in the area. read more

Ordered Pepper Turkey, Swiss, LT Mayo on a hero and a small bag of chips. $18.82... when I asked how much the chips were it was $2 and change. Okay that works whatever. But I look up and a Pepper Turkey Club that's with Muenster LT and Russian dressing on a hero it's 13.99... I guess Swiss is more? Not sure. But every time I order here I get the same thing and the prices never are the same. One day it's $14 next it's 16 then 15. Now 18. What the actual f? read more

Chubby's Delicatessen - a bag of food on a desk - Delis Near Me - Bay Shore, New York

Great sandwiches, friendly staff, but definitely pricy for some pretty basic sandwiches.

Came here for lunch while out and about on the island with the husband. He thinks it's one of the better delis around, so he wanted to take me. I felt the food was average. We ordered an Italian Cold Cut Hero, which is a standard Italian sandwich with pepperoni, mortadella, capicolla, provolone, and "The Works." We also got two A&W cream sodas and some of their homemade Cajun seasoned chips. The sandwich was large enough to share and was served on a fresh Hero. There didn't appear to be a lot of oil, if any, which I appreciated, and the sandwich was seasoned with oregano. The flavors were fresh, the lettuce crisp, and the onions were not overpowering. The homemade Cajun chips were okay. We loved the seasoning, but they tasted a bit oily. The chips themselves were dry, but I think the oil may have soaked into the chips themselves. Don't think e'd get the chips next time. It was a pretty good sandwich. I liked it. I would eat here if I was in the area, but I wouldn't go out of my way. read more

See all

I find the heroes top notch in my wholehearted opinion, especially the buffalo bill but it really is on the expensive side.

Great food. Huge portions. Excellent service and business delivery. An amazing daily selection of freshly prepared steam table items served on a rotating basis. read more

This review will be short and to the point.... A one egg, meat and cheese sandwich on wheat toast $10. And they didn't even put a napkin in the bag. Rip off! Not worth the money! read more

Never the one to leave bad review, but there's a first time for anything. The staff are always polite and friendly, and from what I can see the place is always clean. But $11.00 for a Sausage, Egg and cheese on a English Muffin is insane. I asked the guy why it was so expensive he said there was a charge for the muffin $1.25/ $1.25 for the cheese. If you're going to charge me $11.00 at least put a napkin in the bag. Unfortunately, I'll be bringing my business else where. read more

Place is extremely expensive. 9$ for a breakfast sandwich is outrageous. I would suggest going elsewhere.

I'm recently really obsessed with Chubby's. I've been searching for a deli in my area that makes BEC on a croissant and FINALLY! I've found a wonderfully butter flavored, slightly crunchy roll! There's no skimp on the bacon and SPK is spread evenly every time. It's perfect. I'm in love. They have a make your own coffee area that's always clean. I normally stop in during the morning and there's rarely a line. The staff is super friendly and talkative. Always a good environment. So far I've only ventured breakfast but I'm sure the sandwiches are going to be good too! read more

i could put 0 stars if i could. i ordered an açaí bowl , which if you haven't had an açaí bowl before you know they have the consistency of a smoothie. that's is NOT what i got here. i got ICE CREAM ( as per the photo ) i called and spoke with a manager i'm assuming about my issue and he told me to let it sit for about 30-40 minutes. why do i have to wait 30-40 minutes to wait for my açaí bowl to defrost ? what's going to happen to my fruit? my bananas are going to go brown. i've never seen something like this before. NEVER again. i have now eaten my fruit before the açaí & now will have to wait to my ice cream to defrost. THANKS CHUBBYS read more

Chubby's Delicatessen - chocolate ice cream in a bowl - Delis Near Me - Bay Shore, New York

See all

First thing is first the food is good but trying to charge 10+ dollars for a Hungry Man breakfast hero is absurd and there no sausage at all just 2 meats and 2 eggs not 3. They don't even know how make over easy eggs so that's sad.. On most Hungry Man hero's is 3 meats and 3 eggs plus cheese and some spots put Hash style browns but not needed everywhere. Below par if you ask me and will go to Emma's from now on for this particular sandwich and it's only 7.99 there. Sorry but had to read more

Went here for the first time today. Ordered a sausage egg and cheese with ketchup. While I was waiting, one of the workers brought a sandwich out for the man in front of me. It was on a roll and the man said he ordered it on a hero and paid extra to be in a hero. So the one girl blamed it on the other girl and they started arguing in front of everyone. 13 minutes pass and I still didn't have my sandwich. Then the lady says to me, "I'm not sure what happened to your sandwich. I'll tell them to make another one." Another 9 minutes passed and I finally got my egg sandwich. I got to my office and opened up the sandwich. Cheese wasn't even melted, the sausage was burnt and crunchy, and the eggs just plain sucked and they forgot my ketchup. So I wasted 22 minutes of my time just to buy the most expensive and shittiest egg sandwich I've ever had. Will never go back. read more

I went into chubby's this afternoon and boy am I PISSED. My coworker's and I had never been there before, so we were looking at the menus. The lady behind the register asked if he was ready to order, and he said yes and started ordering his sandwich. Well unbeknownst to him, he couldn't order lunch with her. She only took breakfast and grill orders. So, whatever we order our sandwiches with a lady who really didn't give a flying fuck. I got my sandwich and went to pay for it with lady at the register. The sandwich was $12, and no it was not made with gold. I gave her my credit card, she swiped it through the machine then threw it on the counter. She then proceeded to throw the PEN on the counter. Sandwich sucked, but I'll go someplace else. Get new staff, chubby's. the women are bitches. I'll get a Big Mac next time. read more

Just got done with an interview and I happened to come across chubby's deli when a train going back to NYC would take an hour to come. I had better sandwiches back home but close to $10 for all your sandwiches. Give me a break. If there was more options around deer park station, I would have been out of there. The cubano was decent. The guy making it let me know the grill has not been working right so he did what he could (microwave). Nice try chubby's deli you get a 2 read more

I'm usually not too hard to please with LI delis but I'm really not crazy about this one for a couple reasons. I try to avoid it but once in a blue moon I cave in just because I already parked at the Deer Park train station and there's no other food in such close proximity, and their food isn't that bad from the few items I've had. Nothing special but okay. The first problem is they charge so ridiculously. $15 for a grilled chicken sub and a monster is steep enough, but I saw the monster was charged as a red bull for $4! When I pointed this out to the cashier she unenthusiastically responded they're charged as the same item. That's just absurd considering red bull is more costly then a monster. Secondly, on two occasions they almost made me miss my train because of the delayed service. On both occasions I got to the deli and ordered a breakfast sandwich around 8:30-32 and was supposed to catch an 8:46, and both times my sandwich didn't come out until 8:44 which made me have to bust my ass sprinting across the street to make the train. It's not that I mind a deli being busy in the morning, but they should at least give forewarning its gonna be 10+ minutes for eggs and sausage on a roll. When I looked at my phone and saw 8:43 I was this close to being put in the awkward situation of having to tell them just keep the food because I didn't want to miss the train. Really wouldn't recommend this place unless you need to grab a beer for the train ride. read more

Horrible service. Don't bother delivery. Food takes forever to arrive. Waited about an hour and a half for 2 sandwiches. Ridiculously overpriced. Will never order from here again. read more

I eat her regularly. The price point is a bit higher than the surrounding areas, but it's conveniently located and provide a great hot lunch selection. The chicken Marsala and the penne a la vodka are better than many Italian restaurants I've eaten at. No exaggeration, other stuff is great too. Never really has a bad meal.. but yes , you certainly get what you pay for. It's busy during lunch, seemed to be clean, and staff is friendly. read more

Amazing deli. Steam table food is wonderful. I ordered a sliced roast pork loin hero with swiss, peppers, red onion and mustard. The pork was juicy, tender and had a wondeful au jus with rosemary. Mmmmmm. Clean and the staff is very friendly. Will be back many times. read more

Wow I'm surprised there's so many bad reviews. I always drove passed this deli and I finally went in and they have such a big selection of food. I ordered the mexican chicken wrap it was delicious!!! Then I came back the next day and bought a premade buffalo chicken salad and it was so good. The staff is very nice. The only thing Is that this place is a bit expensive for the portion size read more

I feel bad writing this review, I eat here usually 2x a week but today I happeend to choose the meatloaf dinner with Spanish rice & Mac & cheese but within 5 minutes of sampling all three items I became physically ill and was lucky that I had the plate in front of me and regurgitated my lunch back into the plate instead of my lap. I'll give this place some time off until the new year and stick with the turkey sandwiches. read more

This is the worst value place. Expensive for the quality..guess.it is only game in the area. That is fine but i went there a whole week neciase of time constraints and spent over $100. Ans the guy that served me.was not friendly as all that told me to stop going to this place. read more

Awesome food and friendly people behind the counter...I stop in here on my way to work for breakfast and the breakfast sandwiches are fantastic! read more

Way over priced for a deli. Could of went out to a sit down dinner for what I paid for lunch. They have you because it's the only deli in the area. Hit an ATM before you go. read more

A nice deli by the Deer Park train station and neighboring industrial parks. A good selection of sandwiches (I likes the chicken cutlet one,w. swiss cheese, bacon, hotsauce, and their wicked intense bleu cheese dressing) and platters (roast turkey, chicken cordon blue, and corned beef). There is also a grill, and some pretty old-school guys in their 40s and 50s working behind the counter. They deliver, but the hours are pretty much weekdays only when the factories are open. read more

EXTREMELY OVERPRICED! I literally paid $11 for a tuna salad wrap, this is absurd, it had no sides and no drinks or anything that came with it either. The food is good, I have never tasted anything bad but they definitely take advantage of being the deli by the train and the business park and think they can charge astronomical prices, it makes me feel taken advantage of. Also the staff is rude. NEVER a smile, everyone looks miserable to work there its crazy. I only gave them more than one star bc the food is good, but that is it, if you have another option don't come here unless your rich. read more

Things I love: Sandwiches Things I don't love: having to wait for my client to finish their tour so I can eat my sandwich Chubbys is great - they have a tremendous selection of sandwiches, paninis, hot lunchs, salads, whatever you want. Sometimes I find that when there are so many different things offered, the quality of the food lacks, but not here. Their subs are so large. Its an entire loaf of italian bread. Now, I can put down a pretty decent amount of food when I want to, but even I can't finish one of their subs for head. They also have a large selection of different types of bread - and if you haven't had a grilled chicken sandwich with fresh mozzarella and roasted red peppers on a garlic bread hero, then you just haven't lived. The people that work here are also extremely friendly - I've always come here with large orders; around 6 or so individual sandwiches, drinks, snacks, etc. and each sandwich is made carefully. They offer my company a discount, which is fabulous - cause they do tend to be a little more on the pricey side, however I think it's worth it considering the amount of food you get. Sure, 10$ can be a bit much for a hero, but if you can eat it over two meals. Boom. Its got a good location, for the business itself, considering there are very limited options around the Heartland and the train station unless you want to drive out to deer park. What does that mean? Gets super busy, super quick, if you don't like to wait on line call ahead or go there about 10 minutes to 12, cause the line literally explodes at noon. They're quick though, so you won't really wait too long. Unless, of course, any wait is too long, which is kind of how I feel when it comes to food. Hurry up, client, I'm hungry. read more

$12 for a Chubbys Ecstasy!!! The quality has really gone down hill. Picture of the sandwich attached. A little bit of chicken for a sandwich that is no where near as good as it used to be. I'll be going down the street now and paying $8 for the same small sandwich. Chubbys used to put a fair amount of chicken and meat on the sandwich so it was worth the premium. Now they charge a premium price and give small portions. Go down the street and pay the right amount for a small portion! Not worth it anymore. read more

Chubby's Delicatessen - a person holding a sandwich - Delis Near Me - Bay Shore, New York

Good sandwiches, nice people. To elaborate, there is quite a wide selection of sandwiches (and other meals), which is wonderful considering there are not many other options around (at least that I am aware of). I was lucky enough to get my sandwich (a special made vegetarian panini), served with a perfectly timed wink. read more

Went to chubbys yesterday for breakfast .......I think it is the last time I'm going ......food was eehh and the service was so unfriendly......I almost felt as if I was asking someone a favor instead of feeling like a valued PAYING customer !!! Also way way way over priced Thanks but no thanks read more