Ambiance of the old converted bank is beautiful (my mom got her first bank account here). However, they overcrowd the space with many tables; taking away the intimacy on a busy night when you're elbow to elbow with the people next to you! It's often loud due to over-crowding! The service is impeccable and for the cost per dish the wait staff really is top notch. The food is delicious! I did not enjoy the bacon because I thought it would be thick slabs but it was one very thick piece, more like prosciutto. Colossal crab meat app (MP), 1/2 dozen BP oysters ($18) and Caesar salad ($18) were very fresh! 5/5 duck fat French fries ($10) .Whipped potato, creamed spinach and 5 cheese Mac sides ($16/each) are served à la carte,and delicious! Bone marrow butter ($6) = delicious. While rich and not preferred to American, the 4 oz Japanese A5 wagyu ($65) melts in your mouth. Snake River Farms 10 oz filet ($95) is delicious but pretty expensive, can def tell the difference between the quality beef and the re regular 10 oz filet ($79) but both are delicious. The regular 16 oz bone in cowgirl ($76) ribeye is marbled well and tastes incredible! They offer two course pricey fixe($29) lunch during the week, guaranteed in under a half an hour! 5/5 food 4/5 ambiance (loud/close during weekends) 5/5 (lunchtime) Service 5/5 The food is great. The service is great and the bill will be larger than many, other equally delicious high-end steakhouses! If you go out on a lunch, it will run you upwards of $300 read more

Celebrated my birthday with family at Tellers tonight. My brother raved about this place and I totally see why. The staff was very friendly and courteous from the moment we entered the building. Our server was very patient and informative. I don't recall his name but he was tatted and handsome! All of the apps we ordered were delish. The crab cake and blue joint oysters were the stars for me. My wagyu filet was a perfect hot pink medium! My family also enjoyed all of the entrees and sides. Cheers to the bartender for a perfect creamy espresso martini. Thank u Tellers for a great experience! read more

See all

The atmosphere is one of ambiance and old school tablecloth steakhouse! Service by a team of waiters were superb and of course the food is top quality! USDA Prime steaks did not disappoint ( ordered the Cowgirl Bone-in Ribeye with bone marrow butter- just delectable) and surprisingly the seafood dishes were fresh and done just right- not dry at all! ( both the Scottish Salmon and Grilled Branzino were perfectly cooked). And the appetizer Bkack Pepper Bacon was so addictively delicious! Overall an excellent experience in a classy restaurant. read more

See all

I just came for a Sunday evening solo date night. Service and ambiance were top tier. I will be back read more

Tellers An American Chophouse - Blue point 1/2 shell 1/2 dozen and house chips - Steakhouses Near Me - Islip, New York

One of my favorite spots for steak on the island! The food is always delicious, and the steak is juicy (I love a medium steak)! Their calamari is really good and well battered. I popped by for lunch and it was quiet. Dinner can get a bit busier. Service is prompt and food is delicious! read more

See all

I came here for a birthday celebration and had an amazing time. The atmosphere was great with a sophisticated vibe on the inside. The staff were friendly, they checked on us throughout our meal and were very pleasant to speak to. The food was great, the oysters were fresh, the mac and cheese had a good ratio, and the steak was perfectly cooked and juicy. It was on overall great experience and will definitely be coming back. read more

See all

2/21/22. Great cocktail party (open bar) at Tellers Next Door. Apps were passed around (favorites were the tellers sliders, mini filet mignon wellingtons and shrimp/lobster wontons) along with 4 cocktail stations (antipasto, carving, Italian and Mediterranean) and a churro dessert station. Enjoyed the filet mignon, turkey, truffle gnocchi, meatballs, falafels, hummus and whipped feta. There were so many choices and everything was presented nicely. The one minor complaint I have is that the ice cream had no flavor. I would expect better quality from this higher end establishment. Also it was odd there wasn't any creamed spinach or mashed potatoes considering it's a steakhouse . Service was friendly and on point. read more

See all

An upscale steakhouse that will treat you well and have you walking out feeling stuffed! This is the perfect spot for a date night or special occasion, or maybe you want to take advantage of the amazing lunch specials. We came for dinner, and our waiter was great. He tended to our party of six, catered to allergies and adjustments. The meat was cooked to perfection - every one of our dishes! Nothing bad to say - this was a great first experience, and I'm definitely looking to come back for lunch or a cocktail. This is ranked as a must-visit Long Island steakhouse in my book! read more

See all

Intimate!! Very beautiful and intimate dinning experience. The food was delicious and steak was cooked to the perfect temperatures. We came here the day before Valentine's Day to avoid the crowds on the actual day and it was well worth it! The staff here is extremely friendly and attentive! This is our third time here and we will absolutely be back! read more

See all

I'm surprised to see less than 4 stars for this restaurant. I've been coming here since I was 18 and it always has quality food and service. I was there for their awesome prix fixe lunch option to kick off my 4th weekend on Friday and sat outside underneath a great umbrella watching the bustle of Main Street in Islip. To start I had delicious shrimp and lobster wontons (hand made each morning I'm told by the server) with a few scallions and a soy glaze. My entree which was an impeccable crispy skin salmon almost cooked to perfection, just 30 secs over. The broccoli rabe, purple rice and puree that accompanied were good but not great needing some acidity and salt overall. I would highly recommend checking out this place. No way it's less 4 stars read more

This was by far one of the best steaks I've ever had -- cooked to absolute perfection. The shrimp and lobster wontons were packed with flavor, and while the crème brûlée was just okay, the banana cream pie was outstanding -- definitely a must-try if you stop by. I also opted for the wine pairing with my meal, which I'd highly recommend. The service was excellent; our server checked on us frequently and made sure everything was perfect. This spot is definitely on the higher-end side, so dress to impress, casual wear not recommended. read more

See all

I have heard good things about this restaurant but it was my first time going this week during Restaurant Week (a great way to try different items). First off, the restaurant has a great upscale environment. For the meal, I had the shrimp/lobster wontons, the Filet Wellington and the chocolate sauced strawberries for dessert. I loved the Wellington! So delicious and cooked perfectly medium rare. The wontons were good too. We also got the scalloped Parmesan potato side, duck fries and banana pie. The potatoes were a bit undercooked but flavor was good. DEFINITELY get the banana pie it was 10/10! I also opted for the wine pairing with each dish and I highly recommend it. The pours were generous lol. Service was also good with the food coming out in a timely manner. Definitely will be back again! read more

See all

Wednesday night during restaurant week led to me and my girlfriend getting a 3 course meal for 65$ each. Fantastic crab cakes and for our entree a Fillet Mignon. Fantastic food with even better service left me wondering when I'm coming back. read more

Came here and had dinner at the bar, I wasn't very hungry so I split a burger with my boyfriend, they were kind enough to serve it in half for the both of us. I also had the shrimp and lobster wontons. The food was delicious. I've had other dishes from the menu before but I wanted to try something new, and of course I was not disappointed. I almost forgot to mention the dessert and the oysters! Also very delicious. read more

See all

Tellers is one of my favorite places on Long Island! It's a beautiful steakhouse that used to be an old bank (hence the name, Tellers!) I've been here plenty of times for lunch and dinner but decided to try their new brunch menu this weekend. The meal started with complimentary cinnamon roll which was delicious. The texture was more danish/croissant-like than a traditional cinnamon roll but it was warm and fresh and served with an extra side of cream cheese frosting which was PERFECTLY sweet and tart. For mains, I got the short rib egg dish and my fiance got the biscuits and gravy. We also got a side of potatoes. Our mains were fantastic. The biscuits and gravy could've been warmer but I know it's very hard to keep that dish at the appropriate temperature. The short rib was cooked and seasoned perfectly! The home fries were unfortunately undercooked. We contemplated not telling the waiter about it but given brunch is a new offering and they are still working out the kinks, we decided to let the waitstaff know. The response was extremely polite, and the manager took the home fries off the bill. The service here was impeccable as always! I look forward to returning for brunch with friends and potentially taking advantage of their bottomless options. read more

See all

I had an amazing birthday dinner tonight! The steak was cooked perfectly, and to top it all off, I got a free dessert. It was such a nice touch. read more

One of my absolute favorite places to celebrate birthdays or any special occasion! The food is consistently delicious, and the service always exceeds expectations. The staff is knowledgeable, friendly, and truly makes every visit wonderful. I usually make a reservation, but even same-day bookings are often available, which is super convenient. I love coming here and often recommend it to friends and family. And the banana cream pie? Hands down the best thing I've ever tried--absolutely incredible! If you go, don't leave without ordering it. read more

See all

What should've been an hour and a half dinner turned into an almost three hour dinner. We were a large party of 11 but we knew what we wanted and had to wait a very long time for our waitress to even order. Food took forever to come out. Then, after dinner, we waited a good half hour for cake. We were twiddling our thumbs and had to ask multiple times to bring out the cake. Food was great but not worth it for the mediocre service. read more

Tellers An American Chophouse - Steakhouses Near Me - Islip, New York

See all

We had a beautiful meal for restaurant week with wine pairing. The service is top notch h! Unfortunately no Ada wheel chair access. We had to go through the kitchen. So not sanitary or safe. It's a shame. read more

The service was good . The noise level in the restaurant is very high due to the fact that there is nothing to dampen the sound. I ordered the lobster bisque to start. It was OK, but I have had better. My main course, flounder, accompanied by sautéed spinach tasted as though salt was the main ingredient for both items. I could not finish my meal due to the high salt content. Personally the prices do not reflect the quality or preparation of the food. Overpriced! I will not go there again. read more

Great fun local hot spot! If you're looking for a dressed down business casual or a full on dressed up spot it's a go! Good oysters. Lovely entrees read more

Tellers American Chophouse has a Power Lunch $29. You can add $10 for a Chardonnay or Red Blend. Didn't realize there was only 2 choices of $10 wine selection. I ordered Sauvignon Blanc. When bill arrived it was $17 per glass (Fernhook). We ordered the baked clams for appetizers. I had the chicken paillard and my friend ordered the Spicy Chicken Sandwich. Unfortunately, order was wrong. Spicy chicken sandwich was replaced with the Pastrami sandwich. I had to wait for the chicken paillard. Chicken was a little dry and needed seasoning. A lot of red onions in the salad. The Baked Clams were good but I remember them being much better in the past. The best part of the Power Lunch was sitting by the fireplace which was turned on. Today was 1st day Tellers put fireplace in use so I was very happy with our seating arrangement. Our server was pleasant and Kevin was training. Both very nice & friendly. read more

See all

Service was awful. Our server David was more attentive to all of the other tables than ours all night. Groups that sat after us were greeted, ordered drinks and food, and left well before us. He rarely came to the table to check in. He checked on the tables around us, but kept ignoring our table for some reason. For a restaurant this expensive, they should have exceptional service and it was disappointing from start to finish. The food was good, but after this experience we would never go back. read more

I haven't been back to Tellers since covid. It was okay last time but not great. This time: Teller's is back! We did the porterhouse for two, filet, and NY strip with blue cheese. Every steak was perfection. Sides: burnt broccoli was the table favorite! Desert - best Tiramisu I've had in a while, great cheesecake, and an huge ice dessert with whipped Baileys (I forgot the name). Literally everything was melt in your mouth perfect!!! read more

See all

I've come here multiple times over the years. Usually excellent. A couple of years ago I came again for a work dinner. It didn't go as planned and we all avoided visiting again. Fast forward to recently. My husband, son and I came to give it another try. Our waitress was awesome. She was so sweet. They did not offer high chairs. First time that's ever happened and we have taken him to so many places. We had to be very quick since my 1 year old couldn't be trusted in a booth for too long. We ordered a skirt steak, bone in prime cowgirl ribeye, mash,creamed spinach and an espresso martini. My husband's steak and martini were very good. My skirt steak was pretty good. Presentation was very messy. Overall everything was pretty good and inside is beautiful. read more

Teller's does all the right things. This is a classic steakhouse that knows what's good. The service is always on point and the food is always perfect. They are always busy - especially on the weekends, so absolutely make a reservation otherwise you will be waiting. This is the perfect place for a special occasion - because they sure are pricey. However, they're well worth the dough. Teller's is becoming our favorite birthday/anniversary spot because it's consistently wonderful! read more

See all

Tellers never fails to delight. The food and service are impeccable. I had the cowgirl ribeye with blackened seasoning, the bacon appetizer, and green beans with shishito peppers and tater tots for sides. My wife had the chopped salad. Everything was delicious, and perfectly cooked and seasoned. Even the cocktails are on point. Highest recommendation. read more

See all

Total miss on last night's dinner. The Fritto Misto (calamari app) must have been cooked a few hours before we arrived. The burnt Brussel side dish was mushy. The demonic steak was over cooked. The server told my wife she got the last Bronzino as they sold out of it. I guess they saved the worst piece for last. So disappointing. read more

A top favorite spot for a great meal with family, friends, or a business lunch. The food is always delicious , service impeccable and the ambiance is wonderful...Must Try! read more

Easily one of my favorite steakhouses on LI. This restaurant is inside an old bank, so it has a very cool ambiance. For appetizers, we got the sesame potato loaf and blue point oysters. The loaf was delicious... might actually be the best bread I've ever had. For our entree, we got the porterhouse for 2, with fries and mac & cheese as our sides. The steak was amazing! Plus the side portions are huge, so we even had some left over. I would've loved to get dessert too, but we were so stuffed at the end that we had to pass. However, they brought over a small scoop of ice cream since it was my boyfriend's birthday. They even gave him a small gift card for his birthday, which was unexpected but so nice! The service there is incredible, and overall experience was great. read more

See all

Very nice experience, delicious food. Great ambience and friendly staff. Service was slow but it was worth the wait read more

See all

Chelsea is the best bartender ever. She was so nice. We have to come back for dinner some time. Fantastic espresso martinis!! Tellers is awesome!! read more

We were celebrating a birthday and have not visited Tellers yet. We made a reservation and when we arrived were seated right away. Luke was our waiter and fantastic. He explained the menu, gave recommendations, and asked if we were celebrating anything. We started with the potato sesame loaf which was delicious but filling. For entrees we did the flounder oreganata (AMAZING), tellers Delmonico steak (also amazing), and some family style sides. These can easily be shared for 4 people. Burnt broccoli and max and cheese was delicious. The only thing we did not like was the "cheesy Tater tots" they were honestly more of a cheesy potato croquette, we were not a fan. As for dessert we were stuffed. But since they knew we were celebrating a birthday they brought out a scoop of ice cream with a candle. It was such a nice touch! They also gave us a $25 gift card to use during the week. The restaurant is a very nice fancy setting, it was an old bank too! We can't wait to come back again. read more

See all

We came here to celebrate my friends 60th birthday. A group of 4 ladies. We all enjoyed our dinner and the atmosphere. What a lovely place to go celebrate something special. The staff is top-notch and the food is perfection. The star of the show really is that place itself. What a great atmosphere. It's expensive but it's worth every penny. read more

See all

Food was delicious to start they provide a complementary cinnamon roll it was not sweet. Cooked perfectly and fresh. I was craving a good pancake so I ordered the ricotta pancake you don't even need syrup the flavor is perfect! They also paired it with a house made vanilla whip cream this is all you need. My husband ordered the lobster huevos rancheros and he loved it, lobster was poached in butter(perfection). They offer endless mimosas and provide 3 different mixes, including orange juice and peach juice. I really like the peach juice flavor. Service was good overall they forgot the French fries but took it off the bill. Ambiance is old steakhouse vibes. Dining area can be a bit loud. I also ordered oysters not my favorite but good. read more

See all

Incredible experience here. I attended a private party hosted at this location with a prefix menu and open bar. This has to be one of the best meals I have ever had. The appetizer was a generous portion of pork belly served in a bbq sauce that was delightful, followed by the main corse filet mignon which was cooked to perfection. The staff were incredibly attentive and helpful throughout the evening, and the ambiance and overall condition of the restaurant was what I can only describe as being the pinnacle of a luxury dining experience. read more

Tellers An American Chophouse - Filet Mignon, 12 oz* - Steakhouses Near Me - Islip, New York

Overall good experience, the decor inside was beautiful. The steak and sides were very tasty as well. read more

Tellers An American Chophouse - Tellers Signature Ribeye* - Steakhouses Near Me - Islip, New York

Awesome. The food service is wonderful. We always enjoy ourselves when we go there. The waiter Luke is amazing!!

Mother's Day lunch done perfectly!! The last time I was here was over 12 years ago maybe more Mark Bynum was the chef at that time. I don't know who's throwing down in the kitchen now but they definitely blew me out the water with the flavor & presentation of the food. Also the attention of the staff by Maitre d' Miguel & awesome waiter Chris was impeccable. Table for 4 including my Son, Dad & sons GF was attended to magnificently. Our drinks were potent & refreshing. The Babylon Express was my favorite. Cucumber & citrus. Great combination. The food was 5 Star all around. The steaks aged and seasoned perfectly. Nothing needed anything extra. The Foie Gras butter on top of mines really made the meat shine. Medium Rare has never tasted so good. I've been back several times since last years Mother's Day. And each time......Perfection! 11-14-2023 read more

See all

Sooo good! Amazing staff and the steak! Ughhh chefs kiss! Get the tota and go for brunch! And sooo worth it. If you got for brunch get the endless sips! Everything from the cinnamon roll to the steak ti the gelato is the best!!! David was our server and he was fantastic. Super knowledgable on the menu and so attentive. read more

See all