First visit to this chain in the newly opened Shirley location. I ordered via their AP and it was ready to be picked up in 15 minutes. The location is closed to dining customers, pick up is at the door. The food was decent. Guacamole was good, vegetarian taco was tasty. The chips had a slight lime flavor and complimented the queso. Several healthy choices. read more

Old servers used to be good, new ones skimped me out of like 1/3 the usual bowl. If you want a bowl that's hungry itself i'd go here lol

The lid on the burrito bowl was not closed tightly. By the time I walled to my car it had leaked and soaked thru the bottom of the bag.

Worst chipotle. There is never a time I go there and say hey they got it right today. When I order online I have to wait. When I go in and stand on line I have to wait.. today there was no line on either side (maybe because it was an hour before closing) rice undercooked and what got me was he had 2 white rice out and 1 brown rice. I'm like oh what's the difference between the 2 white rice. He tells me it's the same that one is just fresher as he scoops out the "not fresh rice" (REMINDER.. no lines and less than an hour left to be open) the new chimichurri sauce was trash! Chipotle needs to invest in the same measuring cups Cabo Fresh had because their portions are never the same. annnnnddddd I didn't get my receipt! He just all together didn't print it. At that point I was trying to go so I didn't even bother. read more

I would like to commend the staff at this location. Due to a leak they were unable to take walk in customers and could only provide pick up orders that were placed via the app. While I was there the staff explained the situation so politely and kind to the customers. I witnessed customers challenging the staff and being rude not understanding the circumstances are completely out of their control. I don't know if the woman handing out the orders was the manager but she was extremely patient and handled a challenging situation with grace. read more

I'm guessing this location just opened. So I will re review at later time when I visit again. Based on this visit...they have many things to work on. Customer service is very friendly, but very slow. Not up to snuff with other Chipotle locations. I'm sure it's because they are brand new. It was clear they could not keep up with the volume as much of the food was running low, food prep area you could see hadn't been cleaned off in a while and they ran out of chips. No liquor license here yet, but it's coming. 40 minutes to get food with only 5 people ahead of you is waaay too long. Of course the food was good, and of course we will be back when they've been open longer and get things running smoother. Staff seemed pretty disorganized. The manager was doing his best to corral the troops and getting things moving but it wasn't working like it should. More time and I'm sure it will improve. So if you visit now, expect to wait. Be patient. Props to the manager for giving us extra chips because there were none and we had to ask twice to remind people that's what we were waiting for. They were made fresh and was really goody read more

Chipotle Mexican Grill - New location. Corner of William Floyd & Montauk Highway on southwest corner - Mexican Near Me - Shirley, New York

Absolute joke of a place. Employees are extremely rude especially the fat tattoos white woman that rings you up and gets pisses if you pay cash. They play explicit thug music throughout the restaurant. Looks like they're about to close at 6-7pm. Always running out of food. They make the customer feel like they're bothering them by simply ordering food. And if you door dash from here you're really asking to be disappointed. They allow anyone to just walk in and take orders unchecked. Multiple times had dashers drop the order because the place said someone already picked it up. Takes over an hour to get food delivered. And if you're lucky enough to actually get food delivered chances are the order is incorrect. Ceiling leaking Ice machine always broken. The windows are absolutely filthy and that's what they're willing to show us. I cannot imagine how the behind the scenes stuff is treated like where they store the food and how it's treated. read more

RUDEST PEOPLE EVER. Took 40 mins to make a mobile order burrito. No one was even in the store. When i asked if my order was ready the lady at the front had the most disgusting atitude. Everyone was on their phones too. Literally a joke of a place. Don't go here. read more

Only been here once before in the early spring. Food was okay. Today I could barely eat the bowl I always get. The black beans are SO SALTY. I'm aware the guy that helped me didn't drain the beans, but come on. It's so salty I can't even eat that part! What has happened to chipotle ?? All I've heard as of late is negative things about this place. Don't think I'll be back at this location. read more

The old hag who was working the register today 11/15 around 4pm was rude af, no customer service skills at all.

I praise God for Chipotle as much as the next person, but this location really grinds my gears. I've ordered here about 3 or 4 times and my order has never been 100% correct. Unfortunately, I kept torturing myself by reordering because it was convenient but I've since rediscovered my self worth and determined that I won't return. Between the inadequate service and underwhelming version of the typical chipotle food, I don't regret my decision. read more

This place is going to make someone sick with their bad food practices! Corporate needs to come in and retrain everyone. Orders for delivery are never right because they know you're not coming in to complain. They just slap together whatever is available and it's never right. I want a quesadilla so I have to digital order which is stupid on corporate's part. You can't substitute pork for steak or chicken, people have allergies and religious restrictions and these people give ZERO F's. Thank god I'm moving and won't have to deal with this dumbass location. read more

Terrible terrible terrible! There is zero supervision from management, it looks like the employees basically do whatever they want however bad they want. Be prepared to wait! My recommendation is to NOT Order ahead of time, you can trust that ordering ahead is the worst thing you can do because the team responsible for preparing food AHEAD of time is actually the slowest team in the entire store. People order ahead and are seriously waiting there for 25 minutes or more. If you order right on the spot you will get your food much faster...but even that is slow. The owner/operator of this restaurant should be ashamed of himself (or herself). This chipotle is an embarrassment to the franchise, I have eaten at many chipotles and never have I experienced the slow Service and lack of attention to detail that I experienced at this restaurant. THE CUSTOMER's TIME DOES NOT MATTER HERE. The front counter staff even has trouble scooping food up and putting it inside of a bowl without spilling. So sad to see that standards aren't important to whoever operates this location. If you can, go to the one in Patchogue. You will be a lot happier doing that. To say that the Shirley location has poorly trained staff is to say the least. From the looks of it, I doubt training even happened at all. read more

This chipotle is trash. They are always out of food. Two people only work at a time. You wait on line for at least 10 mins every time. This place needs a new manger read more

Got my mobile order wrong twice in one hour. It was a very simple order. I guess I shouldn't have tried a second time. Nice service if you go in person. read more

Came in on crutches and the guy working helped bring my food to the car and held the door for me. Portions were good too. God bless u bro

Staff doesn't know how to run the register. Overcharged me for my bowl for no apparent reason. Overpriced and bad customer service in general read more

this place is not good. Do not come here the steak taste like fish. The rice was so salty and it wasn't even cooked. Do not come here.

This location really sucks. Was very excited when I heard chipotle was being added to Shirley / Mastic. But just for the few times for me to be just to be disappointed. Why is the food always cold ? The workers are very rude & there only 2 in the front while the others are on the side just talking or on their phone. They always seem to be running out of food. The last two times I had gone they don't have chicken Al pastor & the guac always looks black. read more

I saw some bad reviews here for when it first opened, which made me nervous but I will say I came here and the workers were nice, loaded my bowl fairly. Overall positive experience. read more

steak is always hard, rice is always over cooked, employees are friendly enough but mobile orders are consistently wrong. literally 2 nights in a row my order has been completely incorrect, sucks that it's the only chipotle around but i'm still never coming back. would give it 0 stars if i could. read more

We ordered from this restaurant last night which happens to be the night before Thanksgiving, and the order was very large it costed me about $170. When the order got here more than half the items were missing. When my husband called the restaurant and spoke to a young woman there she acknowledged that they were short on food but there was nothing she can do about it. I don't know what is worse? Deliberately making up replacements for an almost $200 order and then not collecting it or just the establishment itself. How about a phone call? I will never order or give them a dollar of my money again. read more

If I could give a 0 star review I would. This is the absolute worst chipotle on Long Island. Trust me I've been to them all. I love chipotle as much as the next chipotle lover. But me and my boyfriend keep trying to give this place a chance because it's a convenient location. Every Sunday we come back and every Sunday we wish we didn't. The drink machine never has any carbonation. The sprite sprays in all directions. One of the cokes is just water. Half of the syrups need to be changed. We waited for 15 minutes while the person on grill kept yelling line over and over. The food isn't season properly. The portions are never consistent. The employees are rude and don't do their jobs. The manager of this location clearly doesn't care about their job. It's honestly sad. This location is a infected blemish on the face of this entire chain. read more

I come here often because its right next to construction site i work at and literally half the time or more the rice is undercooked and hard like how hard is it to make rice read more

I keep trying to give this location a chance but they fail me every single time. The last order I placed from them, I placed an order for delivery. I asked for sour cream on my order and they forgot it. Not a big deal. Today, I placed an order for delivery, and I ordered an organic bottled iced tea, nearly $4 for a damn bottle, and not only did I not get that drink, I got an empty cup in my bag. No top. No straw. No drink at all. Just an EMPTY cup, thrown into my bag. I PAID for my drink and I never even got it, nor did I even get a refund. That will be my last order to this place. read more

Chips are ALWAYS stale. I get the same bowl every time & it's always inconsistent. This location is 5 mins away from me but I drive to the next closest location because of how bad this experience continues to be! read more

i usually don't need to leave a review to any place. I have absolutely no issues with the food or the staff. I have simply never bought a glass beverage at an establishment that had little grains of glass in it. might wanna make sure you don't throw the glasses as you stock them as I ended up getting glass fragments in my black tea tonight. read more

Terrible. The guys working the front putting the food together are terrible. One guy watched most of the time while the other did all the work and when he finally pitched in he exploded my burrito and the other guy rewrapped it at half the size! They are very slow and all thumbs. They need more staff and to be properly trained. Worse experience at a Chipotle Ever. read more

Best one I've been too. Very nice staff and helpful as well , clean environment, fast service, and good tasting food. Better service here than at most restaurants. read more

Ordered online from the new Chipotle in Shirley today. When I got home and opened the bowls there was hardly anything in both plates. It was less then halfway full. We order from Chipotle a lot and this one is definitely not up to normal standards! This location will not succeed if they don't meet up to other locations standards! Super disappointed, was super excited to have one close to me! read more

Service was bad. They push us to person to person just to pick up our order. Ignoring their customers. They didn't ask who we were to match the order us. Turned out our order was ready and we waited 10 mins. Food was cold. Plus a hair... blonde hair in my boyfriends bowl. Will not return. read more

I will only return to this location if the guy who served us tonight is still there. He was super nice, gave us so much food and was freaking hilarious. 10/10 will return if that guy is working. read more

I love chipotle but some of us feel really sick and i have food poisoning after we got from this location. Does anyone else ever feel like that after this one? read more

Firstly - the food is certainly nothing to write home about -- just a little too much heat in everything, but hey -- it's Mexican. The real issue here is that this is supposed to be a Fast Food Joint which by definition should offer a fast food pricing scale. Not so -- Figured I'd try it out and order the 3 Taco deal with the new Brisket Special -- The Taco's will offer no more than 2 bites per Taco -- or 1 big bite for a Gaavone -- Either way -- this was certainly not worth almost $12.00 bucks. Are they Nuts ? In the end, I can see a quick shutting down of this place once the new Sonic opens up in the same Shopping Center very soon. I'll be there to tell them Adios to their over priced snacks which are priced like main course entree's read more

Disgusting service, lady coughed on my change then handed it to me and after doing this she threw my food onto the counter in my direction. The person who handled my food was nice, helpful and doing their job well enough but the lady who rung me up was horrible. Wouldn't recommend this place if they let employees treat customers like this. read more

Good service with great prices only problem was the food took a little longer than i would have liked to be prepared overall good service

I love chipotle favorite fast food great service I'm always not always but mostly not mostly but often yea I love chipotle thank you the great service 5 rating star for every worker thank you read more

The first bite I had hair in my food and the chips are stale. I have been to many on Long Island and this by far is the worst one ever. The first time I got food there it was terrible and I said I'd give it another chance I got the bowl tonight and again terrible do not recommend read more

For those of you saying don't hate on this location and that the food is good brings me to two conclusions.. 1. You are probably one of the rude and nasty employees who were in this place or you don't know how a REAL restaurant should be ran. For these many issues management and their lazy employees need to go and a while new team brought in read more

Every time I have ordered from here, my order is wrong. It never fails. I was offered a BOGO for making a complaint but why would I want to come back after they keep fucking up? Doesn't make sense. read more