Recommended this place by a 30 year Keene resident. Service: It seemed a bother to come and pick up my take out order. Food: Wings: they were gummy and undercooked and had to be cooked to eat. 10 piece order that included two pieces that were drumstick nor Flat. temp was 125 degrees. Pizza: Flavor was good but not cooked all the way and not even cut. Do not recommend read more

Cheshire Village Pizza - Raw chicken and fragment of wing - Pizza Near Me - Keene, New Hampshire

See all

Where else can you get a pitcher of beer for a little more than five bucks? And the pizza is good too! A nice place to bring the family and friends for nice food and drink. read more

Ordered a sandwich w/ lettuce, tomato, pickle and cheese. Got a sandwich with pickle and cheese. Sub roll was not fresh - I'd say at least several days old as it was hard. Called back to them know and the man on the phone said he "would let them know." No apology or offer to make it right. I haven't ordered from here in a long while due to inconsistent food quality and service. It looks like this has not improved. read more

Ordered pick-up for 5:24 pm, husband arrived to pick up order at 5:34pm...all of the order was ready except a small cheese pizza...at 5:54pm the SMALL cheese pizza STILL was not done, so we left it. We used to go here all the time but we're done. Each time we order, we always end up waiting! read more

one of the best pizza places in town! highly recommend :) they also are so kind to support a local youth group in town! read more

Wings were raw. They didn't even completely cut my pizza. I work professionally in a kitchen and they will literally end up killing someone with raw food like that. If they can't cut a pizza. Imagine the whole process of "care" they use to make everything else. read more

Cheshire Village Pizza - Pizza? - Pizza Near Me - Keene, New Hampshire

We hadn't tried this place and wanted an affordable pizza. The menu here is quite large and the prices seem fair. We decided to order a large pepperoni with light cheese, well done. Unfortunately, they misunderstood us and made a cheese pizza. We were hungry so decided not to say anything. After all, they were busy and it looked great! It really was a good pizza. The crust was crisp and cooked all the way through with no doughy sections. The sauce has a slight zing to it which was nice. The amount of cheese was perfect. Many reviews said the pizza was greasy. It may be the toppings. The cheese wasn't really greasy at all. This is a very clean place with lots of seating. A nice stop for a quick lunch. Will probably come back. read more

See all

Not sure what you all are b******* about in your reviews. Haven't been here since I was in school at KSC 25 years ago, and it's pretty much like I remember it! Ok, so the decor probably hasn't changed too much, but it's typical pizza place. As for service, they were SLAMMED. It's Monday night and it took a few minutes because they were stuck on a phone order. Tons of takeout, as they are one of the few places open. We ordered hot grinders (chicken parm and meatball) and sat down. The way the reviews described it, I was expecting someone to holler our name and make us come get the food. Which wouldn't have bothered me, because like I said, they were slammed. Both grinders... delicious. Perfect amount of cheese, meat, and sauce. Not much more to say, but bon appetit! read more

As I do think quality wise and taste is the best in town, they're sooo slow! 40 minutes now on 1 pizza for take out. The ambience reminds me of old school Pizza Hut with the dine in tables. I like the pizza overall but they're extremely slow, watching employees take breaks while I wait for my meal. read more

This place was good yrs back but now when you order delivery, they tell you 25-30 mins and why I decided to leave this review. I was told 25-30 mins over an hour and half ago. I tried calling three times and all three times a busy signal. The only option I see on their website is to call...no text or email option i see. The last time ordering pizza by the time it arrived. was cold and horrible tasting not happy .....this is our last. With all the numerous options in the area for subs, wings and pizza.....not staying with this place! The owner is quite abrupt with complaints and his staff couldn't care less if you come back or not...less work for them. read more

So we have had repeated problems here-the usual is they get it wrong with my boyfriends sub-every time...he gets "extra black olives and extra pickles" on anything he gets whether it be steak and cheese or tuna salad lol... & we've had him get none of it/or it's like we've pissed them off cuz he straight gets a sub roll FILLED WITH ONLY black olives & pickles hahaha...tonight we weren't so lucky...or Atleast for once I WASNT ...I barely had any meat in my steak and cheese and as always I forgot to say onions and COOKED PEPPERS..lol for some reason they cook the onions but I get raw green peppers...yucky...the food is good once in a while-I will admit that, not trying to down the restaurant but I guess maybe better eye on the service/the quality in what they give out seems too be less this year.,.I've sat in there to wait for take out but never ate there...I saw I guess we can call regulars that distracted the employees enough to the newbies like myself walking in, don't get the full attention like the friends do lol...just a little touch on service and quality & I'd give it a 100%! read more

Cheshire Village Pizza - Lacking the STEAK in STEAK & CHEESE lol also the green peppers are raw...ugh...always something - Pizza Near Me - Keene, New Hampshire

Good pizza -- they never cut it right, though. Saw them SLAMMING the slicer down on the pizza in the shop; either it's a dull cutter or they don't know how to cut pizza. read more

We rotate ordering from one place to another in Keene because it seems once you choose a favorite, that's when you're let down however I doubt I will change my place ordering salads for Cheshire Pizza not only has very generous size salads but packed full with fresh veggies. My favorite is salad with chicken. Delivery is always a good experience as well........arrives all in tack by a courteous employee while other places have had salads and/or fries delivered with containers partly opened and salads appearing to have slid around in travel. read more

Three strikes, what I once considered the best is gone. I haven't gotten what I ordered three times now. Ordered a village special and got no meat whatsoever. last time they forgot pepperoni on half and asked if I wanted them to just toss them on. No my dude I want a fresh pizza with cooked pepperoni. I don't think my family will eat Cheshire Village again read more

I got the grilled chicken salad and it was fabulous. The chicken had such a perfect amount of seasoning and wasn't dry at all. Some places give you chicken so dry you can literally try using a chainsaw and still can't cut through them. read more

Too many times I call to order buffalo wings and ask that they are not over cooked, repeating that I don't want them crispy. They assure me they will let the cook know, and every time they are over cooked. This last time I ordered 2 bottles of 2 liter drinks and buffalo wings, along with a few pizzas, sent my son in and when we got home, the bag was missing both 2 liter drinks and the buffalo wings were not only NOT buffalo wings, just plain wings, but SO FRIGGIN crispy. Since we moved here, the experience there has been up and down. They HAD the best buffalo wings around but now get them wrong too many times. For the prices they charge and the reduction in food quantity now, isn't worth the risk. Sadly, we are saying goodbye to our Friday night takeout establishment. read more

Cheshire Village Pizza is a typical American style pizza place. The staff is friendly, the service is fairly quick, and the restaurant is clean. However, the food is just below average and nothing about it sticks out. The quality and style of pizza is comparable to dominos or Pizza Hut, but Cheshire's pizza is a lot more greasy. I'd probably pick a chain pizza place over these guys because it's cheaper, faster, and of a similar quality. read more

Cheshire Village Pizza - Philly cheese steak - Pizza Near Me - Keene, New Hampshire

Service and quality is lost upon place. Can't make a sandwich how u ask..nor care about the quality of ingredients when making..go to athens instead ..foods to expensive to be disappointed every order. read more

Staff and manager were very concerned, helpful and friendly when there was a delivery problem and were most accommodating!!!

I will never go back again! I ordered a large pizza and instead of cutting it in normal pizza slices we got 2 inch squares, strips of pizza some fat some thin we did get 2 pieces that looked like pizza it was completely hacked. When I called to complain the person on the phone asked who was eating it I told her . Her response then what's the problem your getting the same amount. The problem I told her is that it's a mess. She just repeated herself. I am so pissed off. If they don't like their job then go somewhere else. I paid for a pizza not a hacked up mess. From now on I will go somewhere else. read more

DO NOT WASTE YOUR TIME! The food quality is incredibly inconsistent and the staff and management are beyond rude. I always go out of my way to support local businesses and when I kindly brought up a discrepancy, I was met with extreme hostility. THEY DO NOT DESERVE YOUR BUSINESS. read more

Waited an hour for a pizza. When we complained the manager told us to go somewhere else if we didn't like it. Just said, "Oh well, guess we lost a customer. " This is a poor attitude and no way to run a business. We'll never go back again. read more

VEGETARIANS BEWARE! Apparently, Marinara sauce has ground meat in it; at least according to Arthur at Cheshire Village Pizza. My daughter, a vegetarian for 2 years, just ate a large mouthful of this sauce with her mozzarella sticks!!! I'm not complaining about the food or the service, just a warning! read more

My brother was generous enough to get 3 other people grinders plus himself. He order the grinders and items dropped off and payed for. 3 out of the four grinders where incorrect and this isn't the first time they have messed up on orders. He had spent 43 dollars and they where extremely rude when we called them back to let them know. Will never order from them ever again. read more

Cheshire Village Pizza - half eaten sandwich on paper plate - Pizza Near Me - Keene, New Hampshire

As a native Keene resident, there are many choices in the city for Pizza. Cheshire Village is and has been for decades the best and most consistent for what I love: a bready warm crust that is the perfect texture, a well seasoned sauce that doesn't overpower or distract, and a balance of cheeses that is perfect for NH. Their toppings are all quality. Some of my favorite combos: eggplant, garlic, jalapeño; pepperoni and green peppers; spinach feta tomato. The other food is good too but like fair food. The Pizza is outstanding. read more

I got a large BLT with all the veggies paid $9.76 for it...The sandwich contained: 3 pieces of bacon, shredded lettuce, sprinkle of olives, 2 tomato slices, mayo, 5 squares of green pepper, shredded lettuce, onion (I think I tasted onion), 2 slices of provolone (one slice per half), 4 pickle slices, mayo. Did I mention the shredded lettuce and mayo? I am not sure what you would get on a small BLT with all the veggies. if you get one let me know. I am curious :) You think I am crazy for counting my pepper, but 5 is not a hard number to count. LOL read more

Cheshire Village Pizza - I finally found the bacon in the meadow of lettuce.Pictured 1/2 of a LG. BTL w/all Veggies. Taken after a large expedition to find bacon - Pizza Near Me - Keene, New Hampshire

My boyfriend ordered sandwiches and they messed up my order when he ordered me a bacon cheese and pickle grinder and Instead of have bacon I got steak so I got to wait for my food to be done and it turns out that my brothers sister found out that her and her boyfriend just messed up their order as well and when my brothers sister called the place the person on the phone was very rude , disrespectful , and very unprofessional never in my life I've been so angry. Not only they messed up my ordered once but twice. I am never eating there ever again. read more

Are here after picking up our new Mitsubishi in Keene and this is a decent little place. The food was good and the employees were very friendly. We got gyro dinners and they were very tasty. read more

Greek style and super oily pizza. We used to come here all the time as a youth. After my skating and dance recitals. Zesty sauce, heavy cheese and a medium crust are what you get here. Still better than most of the pizza in NM! read more

work in the area and figured I'd try them out- won't make that mistake twice... bought a $9 turkey club, which basically had 1 slice of turkey, a handful of shredded lettuce, a few diced tomatoes, 2 slices of bacon and a slice of cheese. it's the sorriest $9 (large) sub I've ever paid for. subway uses more meat! let the photo speak for itself... read more

Cheshire Village Pizza - a half eaten sandwich on a paper plate - Pizza Near Me - Keene, New Hampshire

See all

This is our place for our monthly Porcupine meetings. The food is decent and there is plenty of room for our group. read more

With so many Pizza places in Keene I find this one pretty reliable. The dough sauce and toppings are consistent. We always pick up so I can't speak for their service but for a solid pizza loaded with toppings and some decent buffalo wings give it a try read more

Pizza was ok, not overly greasy. Lasagna was like meat sauce and cheese. The noodles were overcooked and mushy. Staff was nice, polite, and friendly. read more

July 10, 2010 I ordered a meal, a substitution was made with out asking me. When I complained, the manager grabbed my plate from my hand and tossed it in the garbage and I was told "pasta is pasta, and I could eat else where", then he proceeded to the register and handed me some money, which was not the full amount I paid for the meal. I will gladly eat else where after this, and encourage my friends to do so as well. If I owned this busisness, I would be horrified to think my customers were being treated this way. Shame on you! recomendation. read more

i had the steak and cheese ginder,i unraped it and picked it up only to have the grease drip out,the grinder roll was dripping grease took one and all i could taste was grease,threw it in the trash,never again read more

This is a good place for a quick, cheap meal. The food is ok and there were no problems.

If you would like to let someone else decide what you should eat for lunch this place is perfect! Not only are they slow, the food is mediocre at best and the service is terrible!. I ordered an Italian with all the veggies and got a ham sandwich with lettuce. I called back and told them and the "manager" said he would remake it and send it out right away. To his credit...he followed through. Or so I thought....When I received my sandwich i found that the replacement sandwich was no better than the initial sandwich. (it had ham, salami, and lettuce) So I called again and spoke with the "manager" for a second time. I told him the problem and he replied that I was wrong and he made the sandwich, it had all the veggies, and I must be confused or looking at the wrong sandwich and then promptly hung up the phone on me. so like I said, if you would like someone else to choose your lunch...eat here. They serve it up how they want it with a healthy dose of rudeness on the side read more

Fantastic pizza place in my book, although I have not personally had any of their pizza. I know plenty of people that have and they rave about it. Their eggplant Parmesan grinder is great and the Greek salad is huge and perfect. The service was quick and professional. Nice atmosphere, definitely my pick of pizza places in Keene! read more

I was at this establishment last evening, and experienced a customer encounter with the manager that absolutely floored me. A man received some pasta which was not what he ordered and when bringing it to the counter the manager threw the plate in the garbage, put a $5 bill on the counter, and said "pasta is pasta, if you dont like it go somewhere else". UNREAL!!! I own 2 local businesses, and would terminate an employee immediately if they delivered such poor customer service. I will no longer support this business. read more

I placed a very large order for my business and they complied, totally. No mistakes, everything was perfect and very, very tasty. Delivery was exactly as requested! read more