After waiting NINETY MINUTES for this shepherds pie to bake, BLEECCCHHH! How hard can it possibly be to make hamburger, corn, and mashed potatoes taste edible?! The crust was awful, and the rest of it was disgusting. And it's ridiculously expensive to boot. What an incredible disappointment! Worst thing is, we're still hungry! This pie sucks. read more

So the story goes that Oprah was visiting the Cape for wedding or other event. So, the owners of Centerville Pies found out where she was staying while here and sent her over a pie or two as a small welcome. Oprah was so impressed, she had them as guests on her show and the rest is history.... the fame and fortune I must say is well deserved. As good or better than the other famous pie shop on Cape Cod, we couldn't resist a chicken pie, clam pie, and a spinach feta pie to take home and enjoy for another day! Reasonable prices, fast and efficient service. read more

Tonight for dinner we had the BBQ style pork pie. You pre heat the oven to 350 and let it cook for 90 minutes. I cooked up some basmati rice to serve with it. My house smells amazing. Time to eat the pie! I let it rest for 10 minutes before we ate it. The pie crust was so good and flaked like a homemade pie should. The filing is all bbq pulled pork. You can taste the attention they put into making the pies. It was not overly liquidity. Perfect amount of BBQ. We will definitely make the 2 hour drive to try the other kinds. read more

Centerville Pies - Bakeries Near Me - Centerville, Massachusetts

The pies this Thanksgiving were absolutely horrible. We have been buying our pies each year from Centerville Pie Company and the pies seem to get worse each year. There is always minimal filling with a bulky bland tasting crust. This year the cherry pie seemed as if it was frozen. Very sour cherries and runny with water. Each time we say we will give it another try but we will not do it anymore. The people in the store don't care about quality or customer satisfaction. It's all about volume with them. Unfortunately once they were listed as one of Oprah's favorite things, the quality went straight downhill. I would never buy a pie from them again. read more

Centerville Pies - Where's the filling? I see sour cherries, runny water and a bulky bland crust. Absolutely the worst pie I ever ate. - Bakeries Near Me - Centerville, Massachusetts

A precious gem on cape. I live in Franklin, MA but I grew up on Cape Cod, I recently went to cape for a short vacation. My wife has never been to centerville pie, so it was the FIRST place I took her so she can experience their sweet breaker breakfast sandwiches. As good as anyone could tell you, they make the best breakfast sandwiches I have ever had in my life. Period. They sell bakery items of course and pies, I have not had the pleasure of trying their pies, as I am blindsided by my desire to eat their breakfast sandwiches, but I love their chocolate chunk cookies as well. Protect Centerville Pie at all costs. read more

A new annual tradition was born this year in our second trip to Centerville Pies. Last year we took a chance on a hole in the wall, this year we knew we had to be back. This year we knew their chicken pie is the best and the gravy is amazing, never heavy or greasy. We also got the turkey burger, garnished with fresh herbs and a savory yogurt sauce. We even took home a pair of chicken pies for later in the week as well, which were just as tasty. The staff is so friendly and familiar, and treated us tourists like family. They even sneaked us a taste of their amazing key line pie as a treat! Make sure you visit Centerville Pies, it's a must. read more

Centerville Pies - Bakeries Near Me - Centerville, Massachusetts

Bought a blueberry pie recently. The crust tasteless. The Blueberry filling could only be compared to the paste we used in grade school. Twice the cost of other pies such as Market Basket. No one in our group wanted to eat the pie and we ended up throwing it out. The rating of ONE STAR is too high but there was nothing lower. read more

I ordered two pies from Centerville pies and was anticipating that they would be good, seeing even Oprah likes them, but I was so wrong. This evening I baked the pie as directed, but it was primarily dark meat and very chewy. I feel too embarrassed to let my family know what I paid for them because I purchased them from the Gold belly and will never use their site again because the pie was awful. read more

I have mixed feelings about the chicken pot pie. I purchased it frozen and saved for a special dinner with some of my friends and family due to the hype. Be prepared, your house will smell delicious while this is baking in the oven. Simply divine! As others mentioned, the pie is literally just chicken and gravy...no vegetables. In my opinion, the pie lacks heavily in flavor. Seasonings and spices really are needed to elevate the dish. The real savior in this pie is the crust which is buttery and flaky. It's seriously delicious but not enough to make up for the blandness of the chicken and gravy. I'm not sure how this is one of Oprah's favorite chicken pot pies or why it ended up on the Travel Channel. Perhaps their other dishes shine, but the chicken pot pie is nothing to rave about. EDITED TO ADD: The pot pie is 10x better reheated the next day. read more

Centerville Pies - Chicken pot pie. Great crust! - Bakeries Near Me - Centerville, Massachusetts

See all

Stopping for lunch on the drive down to Provincetown was a must with the one-year-old in the back seat. He was at his limit, and my head was about to explode, so we pulled off route 6 to find a lunch spot despite the fact that we didn't see any signs for food. We drove for about 5 miles before we hit on a stretch of road with a few strip malls, and we pulled into a parking lot with a pizza joint, intending to stop there. But then the small Centerville Pie Co. sign caught my eye, and there was no chance we were going to settle for pizza pie. This place was a real jewel. We ate delicious food cooked right in front of us at the grill. I had a fabulous fresh spinach and cheese quiche, the baby had grilled cheese with tomato, and my husband ate an omelet. The owner/head baker then came out of the kitchen with fresh flaky turnovers for us. She said we'd be her guinea pigs for a new recipe she was testing, and we gladly accepted the job. They were buttery, warm, flaky cherry-filled delights. But the best part of the meal was the warm blueberry pie with a scoop of vanilla. The crust was delectable, the filling divine. This was one of the most pleasant lunch experiences I have ever had. read more

See all

Adorable! This place was featured by Oprah Winfrey as a best things. It is not the holidays without a pie from Centerville Pie company. Pumpkin, blueberry, a chocolate pie to die for and more. They also make big and small pot pies and more.... It is among one of my favorite places! read more

I've been going to Centerville Pie since 2008 for my fix of delicious pies! Naturally, when I got married on the Cape in October, I thought what better dessert then PIE! Instead of cake, we went all pie and ice cream from Four Seas! And let me just say, our guest had thirds. Their pies are always delicious, my favorites being the WILD BLUEBERRY and the MIXED BERRY. Of course, their apple pie is a staple. The staff was super accommodating for our wedding, and delivered fresh pies on the morning of our wedding. Thank you Centerville Pie! read more

See all

Intrigued by memories of great savory pies from my Midwestern American in-laws I ordered two of Oprah's favorite Chicken Pot Pies from the Centerville Pie Company. Though the website did not offer any ingredients, it did say that there were no veggies, only chicken and gravy, in these greatest of all chicken pot pies. And that was true. All the rest was hype, a lie, BS, a con, unwholesome and unhealthy. We cooked it according to instructions and let it rest, etc. and then we proceeded to be appalled. The crust was proper brown and crunchy, etc, and inside it was chock-full of diced chicken floating in an amorphous mass of goopy, starchy, slimy, ugly-smelling, SALTY-AS-ALL-GETOUT, stuff that no one wanted to eat. I picked up the box at that point and started to read the inexhaustible list of ingredients. It reads like the back label of any commercially produced crap--innumerable chemically altered fats and oils and many salts and stuff unknown to most humans. But this is a $35 pie, and Oprah's fave! How can it be? Hasn't Oprah even heard that hydrogenated fats are bad for her chubby bod? This pie has not one, but if memory serves me, at least two different ones--if one won't kill ya' the other one will! Doesn't she know that excessive, disgustingly excessive, salt not only tastes bad but will kill you too? What has happened to all her down-home food know how? Next time you're near Centerville Mass, take a detour. read more

Worst pot pie I ever had. Not one single vegatable in the entire thing. Have you ever had a pot pie with nothing in it but gravy and chicken. Even the gravy was bland had to add pepper. Some pieces of chicken were not even cut in bite size as one piece was like an entire whole leg. Gravy like water. Never buying this again. Really bad. Also rip off price for what you get. Save your money If Oprah thought this was good she has no idea what a real pot pie is. read more

The friendliest people paired the amazing food. This place is definitely a go to when you're down the cape. We got a few slices of different pies - chicken, spinach & feta, pecan, mixed berry, and cape cod crunch. And all were amazing. We also got Lobster Benedict, which was phenomenal as well. (There was four of us) The prices are fair and good. There's a parking lot upfront and you can buy pies and other pastries to go as well. I bought a Chocolate Creme, Chicken and Shepherd's Pie to go as well! I'm so excited to eat it. Go here if you're in the area! Or not...it's definitely worth the trip! I hope to come back in August when I'm back down in the area! read more

Centerville Pies - Cape Cod Crunch Pie - Bakeries Near Me - Centerville, Massachusetts

See all

Tasty, but there are trans fats (hydrogenated oils) listed in the ingredients of the meat pies (some of them at least). There is little enough that they are allowed to round down to 0 (zero), but no amount of trans fat is healthy. I'm really disappointed because the pies were pretty good. read more

Shut Your Pie Whole...AND EAT! Needless to say these guys know pie! My aunt got me a bday gift certificate here and I was super excited because of the reviews I had heard, they outdid themselves! They had small pies which were perfect for me to try several flavors with! I ended up with a banana cream pie, blueberry pie and a chocolate chip cookie pie! The best was the blueberry, the crust is just perfect and the filling tasted fresh and delicious, a good balance of the actual fruit and sweetness! The most decadent was by far the banana cream pie, it was mouth watering! Strong but natural flavor of banana mixed with the creamy pudding and whip cream top, sheer perfection! Honestly I was not blown away by the cookie pie but my wife was a huge fan and as we all know a happy wife makes for a happy household! read more

I ordered 2 pies during our home confinement from Centerville Pies. They had an advertised special, buying 1 pie, getting another at a reduced price. The only pies available were BBQ Pork, and Pumpkin for a non-savory pie. I have purchased Centerville Pies at our Stop/Shop, our store carrying only Chicken and Shepards. Both have been fine but wanted to experience something different. Neither pie came fully frozen, but due to very cool temps here, I was not concerned. I baked both pies @ 350 for the directed amount, and was so disappointed when I took them out. The BBQ Pork had grease spilling over the sides (I had used a cookie sheet under it), flavor was less than spectacular. The Pumpkin Pie was flat, dry, and overly seasoned with what I thought may have been cloves. Crust overcooked, and I think that the pie may have been a Thanksgiving leftover. I am disappointed, as we are trying to maintain a stay at home policy, and hoped this would be a special (and expensive) treat. We certainly did not get the treat we hoped. read more

Yum! Ok - I didn't actually eat the pie as we brought one somewhere for a gift. However, my sister and I did try the clam chowder, which was delicious! GREAT prices, good food, friendly atmosphere and delicious looking pies! read more

great pies , , loaded with meat, easy to cook , will easily feed 3-4 peeps , a little pricey though

READ THIS ENTIRE REVIEW For some reason this place is popular and I suspect only because OPRAH got pies there once. That, and the anomaly that it's owned by women. I stopped there a few weeks ago to try one of their small chicken pies, having heard about the place for years and pass their store in Centerville on a daily basis. The woman behind the counter was slightly less than marginally helpful and appeared to be working alone. OK,... no big deal I get it but it wasn't that busy. I realized I forgot my wallet but had $20 cash in my pocket so I picked up one of their small, table talk size, chicken Pies, the only kind they had in that size. I gave it to the woman behind the counter and she rang it up and told me it was $15.00. I was shocked but didn't let on, so I told her I left my money in the car, intending to go to the car and high-taildout of there and leave the tiny chicken pie on the counter. Unfortunately my wife wasn't as stunned by the price like I was and offered up the cash so I paid the woman and left. When I got to the car with the pie and told my wife I had the money but I didn't want to pay a ridiculous price for a chicken pie she told me that she wasn't even thinking about the price and only wanted to help and then agreed and wanted to return the pie. I didn't want to embarrass anyone so I said, lets just take it home and see what it's all about. Well.... I found out. Average. Its a chicken pie. Not outrageously spectacular in a way that would come close to justifying the price. HOWEVER...... READ ON. A few night ago I was cruising the frozen food section at the local Stop & Shop and stumbled on....... yup. You guessed it. Centerville Pies. Chicken Pies and Shepard Pies. Mammoth in size compared to the one I purchased in their own store for $15.00. Size wise the one in Stop & Shop was a whopping 2.5 pounds in fact. What was most surprising was the the price of $12.99. Comparatively speaking. SO.... when you see the Centerville Pie company store.... keep on trucking. The two and a half pound pie is worth $12.99 but the tiny pie they sell in their own company store is an abominable rip-off for $15.00. But, I suppose, .... If you're lucky enough to have Oprah's money, disregard my review. read more

See all

I ordered their signature chicken pie. It was delivered in a nicely right pacage with ice. If came in frozen and it was cooked for an hour and half. The crust was so buttery and flaky, the chicken was a lot of it( white and dark), and the sauce was rich. I would definitely try it again with different ones they offer. When I called to place the order, the lady who answered the phone was friendly and cheery. It was easy and quick. read more

Delicious baked goods that you can tell are homemade! I can only speak for the pie, but I would definitely return here to try more. I tried the chocolate chip, the cherry, and the blueberry pies and they were all freshly made and delicious! Pies were served freshly baked, in individual slices, and even frozen. The staff was super helpful and the store was separated from the restaurant part which was very convenient. Can't wait to try more!! read more

Centerville Pies - Chocolate chip pie!! - Bakeries Near Me - Centerville, Massachusetts

Delicious food and very friendly staff. The restaurant was closed so we got ours to go. I bought a quiche and others got breakfast sandwiches. We also bought pies for later today. The breakfast was great and pies look like we will enjoy them. Lots of frozen pies available for sale, both savory and sweet. We may be ordering some by mail for special occasions! read more

I had stayed away from Centerville Pie Company because of the "Oprah Factor", but instead of a celebrity-hyped dining hot spot, I found a bright, welcoming pie shop with a cozy breakfast and lunch nook attached. The fact that the storefront opens up into the retail pie shop shows where the emphasis is, but the restaurant serves not only the signature pies, but also above average omelet, sandwich and soup fare. My wife and I both had a cup of clam chowder featuring a generous portion of freshly chopped clams. For an entree, I had the guilty-pleasure grilled cheese sandwich with bacon, while my wife had the cranberry chicken salad sandwich. Both were served with a pickle and a bag of Ruffles potato chips. How can we not come back? read more

There's really no way to give an accurate look of these marvelous pies here. There is nothing like them anywhere that I've seen. They make a chicken pie with just a kind of gravy that is just simply to die for, it really is that good. read more

Centerville Pies - Bakeries Near Me - Centerville, Massachusetts

Stopped in on my annual cape cod trip. Saw the great reviews. Made my friends try it with me... Savory Pies: The chicken pie with gravy was really good. Took other yelpers' tip about adding a side of veggies. Would definitely get that pie again. Also tried the sausage/apple/sage pie. Solid all around. Over all a really hearty filling meal. Sweet pies: key lime pie filling was good bur the crust was fantastic. The cape cod crunch pie was OK. Wish there was more heath bar on top though. The ladies at the shop were super friendly and helpful. This is definitely a worthwhile stop. read more

Centerville Pies - Cape cod crunch could do with more crunch - Bakeries Near Me - Centerville, Massachusetts

Centerville Pie Company makes the most amazing pies! The chocolate creme pie was heavenly and the blueberry pie was excellent! Thank you so much to Kristin Broadley for her outstanding customer service and the entire team at the Centerville location. I cannot wait to order another pie real soon! read more

What an awesome spot for breakfast/lunch! We came for brunch. I had the French toast, corned beef hash, and bacon. It was cooked perfectly (real corned beef not from a can), fresh local bread, real maple syrup, and crispy bacon. The hot chocolate has real whipped cream on top - made in house. My husband had the lobster Benedict and said it was awesome! The poached eggs were cooked perfectly and the lobster claws were tender, not over cooked. He loved the home fries that came with it. He has a culinary arts degree and is picky about how things are cooked. The staff was really friendly, the restaurant is small but clean and we only had to wait about 5 minutes for a table. Highly recommend!!! read more

See all

This place rocks!! Love the service and the people are amazing!! Food is great, you'll see it being made in front of you. Pies are good make sure to get extra gravy with chicken pie. If going into the restaurant, it is unfortunately busy on Sundays!! So you have to wait a little but it is totally worth it! Savory pies are delicious and filling. Fruit pies are juicy and delicious read more

See all

Great People Making Great Pies! That should be their new slogan. Seriously. My family has loved all the pies we have gotten including chicken, shepards, beef, cherry, clam, bbq, lemon meringue... and last but not least....cape cod crunch.. We also love the egg salad.. the chicken salad... and all the pastries.Especially the Cinnamon Scones.. and the HERMITS! oh.. and the chicken soup is perfect when someone you love is sick and you don't have time to make homemade! Keep up the GREAT WORK Pie Ladies! and pie crew! ...and yes the pie crust is amazing! read more

This is a review of the chicken pie. I read a few others where people said the crust was sweet and the sauce was extremely bland, but also read some other good reviews so I threw caution to the wind and bought 2 pies from Roche Brothers for Easter, as we are tired of the usual ham. What a mistake.....maybe quality has really gone down hill, or the frozen pies that go to the grocery are not the same as in house. Awful.....the crust, as others mentioned was surprisingly sweet, the sauce was incredibly bland and the chicken was bone dry. And I mean BONE DRY. No one said anything as the pie was being eaten, too polite to speak the truth, but no one said, "this is so good"!.....just......silence. $26.00 for two pies, money gone and the leftovers I threw outside for the critters. No one wants the leftovers. Never again...... read more

Centerville Pies is hands down the best place to go for all kinds of pies. My husband and I were never big on key lime pie, but the key lime from Centerville is on another level. Also, if you've never tried the blueberry muffins, you are missing out! Above all, the staff and owners are extremely friendly and make the whole experience such a treat. I truly can't express how much I love coming to Centerville and can't wait to go back again soon!!! read more

We made a huge mistake. We always buy Willow Tree chicken which we love. We figured we would try Centerville chicken pie. It was the absolute worst. No comparison. Sweet crust Bland chicken overall one big Yuk. One and done never again . read more

I don't understand the negative reviews of the chicken pie. I bought it at my local Stop and Shop, and I thought it was really good. HUGE chunks of chicken, good crust and gravy. First off, it is A FROZEN PIE. What do you expect for a frozen pie? People complain that the chicken is dry. Maybe you cooked the pie too much and THAT is why the chicken was dry?? I have purchased other FROZEN pies and if I cooked them too much, yes, the chicken was dry. Including the much revered Harrows pies, which I frankly thought, were not anything to write home about. All in all, I was happy with my chicken pie. I do wish that someone would make a chicken pie with dark meat as I find dark meat much more flavorful! read more

I really want to like your chicken pot pie. 2nd time trying. Way to salty!!!! I like salt but not a whole box. Thought it was a recipe mistake the first time. Nope. YOU LOVE SALT!! read more

We drove down here from Lynn one Saturday morning after hearing about Centerville Pie Co. on Kiss 108. We placed an order ahead of time, for a famous chicken pie, a meat pie, a clam pie, and a chocolate chip cookie. I must say I could not figure out what all the fuss is about, especially the Oprah buzz. Maybe they have got too big and the quality is not as great? The gravy had no taste whatsoever, the pie crust for the Chicken pie was good, not outstanding but definitely tasty. The actual chicken left a lot to be desired, dark mean and white meat, not at all stuffed to the brim and not with a lot of taste/seasoning. The chocolate chip cookie pie was good, but very dry. The clam pie, not sure what I was expecting, but it was pretty uneventful, and like the other savories, pretty tasteless. Really Oprah?? Definitely not worth the 3 hour drive time roundtrip. I somehow thought going directly there we would get the best quality as opposed to ordering the outrageouns prices through Harry and David. Not worth my gas. read more

I had their Chicken Pot Pie recently.... One of my neighbors mail ordered it and had us over for dinner... It was very good but... I can see why Oprah has a problem controlling her figure if she is eating these... One serving had enough sodium to kill a small pony and was a semi heart stopper with the fat... That being said... It tasted good read more

For the second week in a row I have went to the centerville pie company for Sunday breakfast. For the second week in a row the inexplicable rudeness from the staff has left me with a sour taste in my mouth. Last week , the food as usual was very good, the people behind counter were also friendly. Our waitress however was extremely rude, our waitress was a 20 something, snotty, rude, entitled person. She treated us as if it was a chore to be bothered by us. When more than 1 person asked for milk for their coffee made it perfectly clear that we would only be getting 1 side of milk that we could share. Not that I mind sharing it, most times that is how it works. We enjoyed the food and tipped well. Because the food was so good, we decided to try our luck again. This time we did not even make it through the door. With a formidable storm, torrential downpours, and 50mph gust of winds the staff decided it had to take their time in reattaching a chain to the door then letting us inside. After we stood in the the rain/wind for two minutes as the staff watched on as we became saturated we decided to go somewhere a little more "welcoming". Although the food is great, for my sanity, I will not be back. read more

Short and Sweet...the best chicken pie we've ever had! This is a great alternative to another dinner out on the Cape..bring a frozen one home for a great family meal. Highly recommended! read more