I bought my spinach feta pie at Publix on sale! Made it in my convection oven today.. It's very good. Good quality and tasty. Baked at350 degrees for 90 minutes and I let it rest for 30 minutes. I will say for $12.00 I would buy it and keep it in my freezer for when I work 5 days in a row-12 hour days . It's a very tasty option for me to have 5 meals ready. But I can make it for $$5.00. I understand why they charge so much but it does have very unhealthy ingredients to preserve it! Really! It's pie crust, spinach, dill, basil, egg and feta( i would add ricotta too). I work 3 jobs and definitely can't afford $12.00 often. I don't eat chicken so I can't try their other options! read more

See all

Home made PIES like mom used to make! Freshly baked right out of the oven or frozen to take home and bake yourself. Absolutely wonderful!! Check out Centerville Pie Images on the internet! read more

See all

Delicious! I had their sausage breakfast sandwich on a portuguese roll- yum! I took home a small chicken pot pie and a shepherds pie (for the hubby), both were great and a chocolate pudding cream pie for dessert! Didn't see a seafood option or I would have gone there! Staff were very friendly & helpful! read more

A Taste of Home and Exceptional Service We're huge fans of Goldbelly and Centerville Pies--their pies are truly a touch of home. They're easy to cook, made with good, wholesome ingredients, and always deliver that comforting, homemade taste we love. What really made us raving fans, though, was how they handled a recent mix-up. We ordered two chicken pot pies but received one spinach and feta by mistake. When we reached out, they immediately made it right--no hassle, no excuses--and sent us two replacement chicken pot pies free of charge. Everyone makes mistakes, but it's how you handle them that defines you. Their quick, gracious response turned a small issue into a moment of genuine appreciation. We'll be sharing one of the extra pies with our neighbor, and who knows--maybe their great customer service will win over another loyal fan! read more

I was so excited to have a Centerville Chicken pie for dinner tonight! Unfortunately dinner wasn't as I had planned. The Centerville Chicken pie that was purchased frozen @ Market Basket & had a good use buy date of Nov 2026. Was the worst Chicken pie I have ever had. The chicken was so small dark black pieces. A few small white meat pieces with jellied gravy. It all tasted so bad. Nothing like chicken tastes at all. So very disappointing & such a waste of $14.99. Centerville Pie Company should be ashamed. read more

Heard great things. Bought an all berry pie. When warming crust was very, very greasy. Thickness of crust made it undercooked. Filling was scant many berries, more like gummy canned filling. Really disappointed. Not worth the money. read more

there was a time when I could eat one a week. I buy them at Roche Bros. The one i bought there the oy day was awful. Cubes of chicken and not many. it smelled more like hot dogs than chicken. This is a serious review. I loved these. What the hell happened? read more

Chicken pot pies are very dry, no gravy and has a strange taste. Crust is very dry. Not a lot of filling

The death by chocolate ice cream pie is sinfully delicious, outstanding job. Chuck M. Kingston Ma.​ read more

We saw a display of thse pies at our local supermarket for the first time while shopping Monday. A Spinach and Feta pie went in the basket, then was on the table that very night. We'll defintely be back. We hope to get at least one every shopping trip in the future. We like to support local businesses, especially with goods of this quality! read more

We loved Centerville chicken pies until now! They changed the recipe and added onion and garlic. Terrible. We used to buy this pie because it is hard to find a chicken pie w/o those ingredients and Centerville was tasty and great. But now...the onion and garlic are overwheming. We were shocked and disgusted to find our favorite pie (and $14) wasted. read more

Bought a frozen chicken pie and made it as directed. At correct temperature checked with thermometer, the pie crust looked good but inside was a disaster. Looked and smelled like chicken soup, very liquidy, extremely salty. Terrible. We threw it out. We have given these pies enough chances. Once, we got a good one. Another had a chemical tasting crust, way too sweet. This one was liquid and salt. Never again read more

1st time buyer. not good at all. dry, not worth the $. don't waste your $. MB usually has quality items, but this is not one. AVOID! read more

The pies and pasteries are just okay to me here. Somewhat pricey. Customer service was excellent however. read more

Centerville Pies - Bakeries Near Me - Centerville, Massachusetts

See all

I've been dying to try this place and we finally made it on a trip to Cape Cod. I had seen Oprah had listed it as her favorite things a couple times and according to a sign in the pie store the travel channel did a piece on them too. We went on a Thursday afternoon. There are a LOT of pies in this store. There was a freezer filled with frozen ready to bake savory pies (meat, chicken etc) and a freezer with ready to bake sweet pies. There was a refrigerated cooler with cream pies and a case of ready to eat pies (apple, cherry etc). Because we were a couple hours from home without any cooler big enough for pies we decided to get a ready to eat cherry pie to eat at home. The pie was good. But, it wasn't any $20. good!! Yes, this skinny little pie cost $20.00!!!! They were very cheap on the filling and I've gotten way better cherry pies for $11.00 from local bakers. I struggled between 2 and 3 stars. I was going to give 3, but decided for the price it definitely wasn't worth it. It was good, but not worth it. I won't go back. read more

See all

Wow! Where to begin? Ran in the other day while I was visiting Centerville and thought I would pick up a pie..something quick one night for dinner. First of all, the prices are ridiculous for what you get. The pie hardly had any chicken or vegetables in it..there was a big thick crust (which tasted good), but I would have rather had a thinner crust and more filling! Also, it didn't taste the same as in the past..I haven't had one for a year or so and they must have changed the recipe. Not good! The Service? The people behind the counter were not friendly..tried to make small talk, and they looked at me like I had 2 heads. I will NOT be going back. Smarten up Centerville Pie Company...Customer Service is important. I will take my business elsewhere! read more

Highly overrated! The pies are expensive and very average at best. I've had better fruit pies from a supermarket. The all berry/mixed fruit filling truly tasted like it came from a can! Their reputation far exceeds their quality. One good thing I can say is that the people that work behind the counter are helpful and friendly. read more

Had one with my wife yesterday; the chicken was hard to find. Bought one last week and the chicken was plentiful. Centerville needs to improve its quality control so it is consistent from pie to pie. read more

The first time I ate here I was a little girl and it immediately became my favorite pie place. I stole my brother's slice of chicken pie it was so good. Definitely worth going! Their frozen pies just are not the same. read more

Not a fan. I hate to say that, as to I've heard rave reviews. The crust is way too sweet for a savory pie. As far as the taste of the pie it self, it was just ok. I don't think I will buy another pie associated with this company. read more

I received the Oprah's favorite chicken pie as a gift. The pastry was sickly sweet and completely distracted from the otherwise excellent savory filling. The sweetness essentially made the pie unbeatable. I checked with the supplier and they said the sweet pastry in their savory pie was normal. Disappointed. read more

Had the chicken pot pie. It looked good while cooking, but in the end it tasted bad to me, there was little chicken and were very dark almost black chunks of chicken, the pie was over filled with peas they seemed to be the main ingredient. The only thing that tasted ok to me was the crust. The runny pea filling was just not like any other chicken pot pie I have eaten, I would not purchase again. read more

`Not sure i understand the popularity of this place (or perhaps its former popularity given recent reviews). I had a chicken pot pie and it was not very good, but most importantly, when i reviewed the ingredient list, it is a disaster, especially hydrogenated oils...just about the worst thing ever. Very surprised as i would have expected a business that markets itself as a wholesome, old fashioned pie shop would default to nasty stuff that i would have expected to see in a cheap grocery story frozen pie. They should really show some respect and concern for their customers by trying to use ingredients that don't kill people. Perhaps the place was taken over by corporate greed? read more

While I would go back for the delicious chicken pie I would skip the cherry pie. I got a mini cherry that was very then. I'm assuming because the cherry is so tart which I didn't mind so much but the lattice crust had no taste and the bottom crust was inedible as it was raw. read more

Centerville Pies - Raw bottom - Bakeries Near Me - Centerville, Massachusetts

I have now bought chicken pot pie four times over three years. They are delicious. A real treat. Nice for company. Next time I'm going to branch out. I'll try another kind of read more

Would of been a great chicken potpie if the chicken was hand shredded as said there were square chunks hard dark and white meat what a shame as crust gravy good not much vegetables we're inside pieces of chicken terrible. read more

The crusts alone tell a sad story of this brand's current state. Their wonderful restaurant and homemade pies were once a darling on upper Cape Cod. The peach pie we ordered tasted like it was ordinary canned fruit. The lemon merenge and coconut pies were now nothing to write home about with doughy gross crusts. Overall the products tasted like commercial bakery desserts you might get at a hospital cafeteria. read more

Pricey, but much better than the usual ones on the shelf. The crust is a dream - flakey, rich-tasting; and the pie really looks handmade. It was better than I was expecting, but I guess everybody likes their own signature pot pies better. (In the South, you'll often find the addition of sauteed onions, chunks of potato, more black pepper and just a little more gravy with at least a few tablespoons of butter added). Ladies, if you invent a lobster pot pie, I'd definitely love to try one of those, too! (Is there such a thing?) We enjoyed this, for a change of pace. It was nice. read more

They still tout themselves as one of Oprah's favorite things, which happened first over 12 years ago and last over 5 years ago. The staff was very friendly. The pies come three different ways. Order ahead of time for hot pies, go-in and see if they have one variety of hot pies available, or buy the always-there frozen pies. The pies taste okay. They are not all-natural (lots of preservatives, MSG, etc.) nor made on the premises. The chicken pie, their flagship pie, has no veggies in it. I called later to ask why, and they said they had so many complaints about the lack of vegetables in the pie, they made a new variety with the vegetables. I wish they had informed us about this before we purchased the plain pie. We would go back; it's a nice change of pace for dinner every once in a great while. I would beg they go all-natural, especially when they bake the pies same-day or have them in the storefront freshly frozen. (They said even the freshly baked hot pies have the preservatives and additives because it's the recipe.) read more

Wife surprised me with my favorite strawberry rhubarb pie from centerville pie company this week and I must say it was the worst pie ever I have ever eaten, hardly any strawberries and very tart given the rhubarb taste, anyway I'll stick to buying table talk pies or supermarket brands We have bought and eaten other pies from them and equally unimpressed Sorry centerville pies Oprah likes your pies and I don't read more

It had crust. That's honestly all I have. It took way too long. Even then, I had to put it back in.....you know adjust for indiv. ovens. The gravy, was soooo runny after another 30 minutes....it was so bland, and I didn't see enough veggies. Even if.... it was way too bland. I really wanted to like it, as I love chicken pot pies, as grown as I am! Luckily, I have a Callenders still in the freezer. I guess my nephew and I will fight over that tonight. I'm just not happy after forking over 13 bucks, after seeing that the Big O' gave it a thumbs up. My fault, that was 6 years ago. This one's on me! read more

This store makes a wonderful pie. Our family favorites are the Shepherds Pies and the Spinach Feta Pies. My boyfriend got a Peanut Butter cookie on the way out and he wished he got a half dozen. The berry fruit pie is also staying on our list - it's so good!!! Thanks for some great pies, we look forward to returning once again and wanted to add that the employees are so friendly and polite. Thx again! read more

Aww, so sad! Their restaurant section is closed! Their bakery is still open, however, and it looks like they plan to expand that section into the restaurant space. We got a big chocolate cream pie for the family and took it back home. read more

Centerville Pie has been a light for us during this year of COVID. Every week we try something new and haven't had the same thing twice. The owners and staff are so kind and generous and make you feel right at home while you decide what treats to bring home. We love the Taco Pie, Chicken Pie, Key Lime, BBQ Pulled Pork, Chocolate Cookie, Cape Cod Crunch, Buffalo Chicken, Pecan, Macaroons, Sandwiches, Salads, muffins and scones and on and on! Lol! Best to weigh yourself the first visit, Lol. Looking forward to next week! read more

Centerville Pies - Our Thanksgiving! - Bakeries Near Me - Centerville, Massachusetts

So here I am back at centerville. Too long of an absence, let me tell you. I have a few days on the cape in a cabin and I got my chicken pie, a berry pie and some muffins. A lobster and I'm set. This is the best chicken pie ever. You are paying for meat. Not cheap veggies. Buy a frozen pot pie from banquet if you want that. Or buy a sack of veg if you must need it on the side. I will stick to cranberry sauce. This is the best New England chicken pie you can buy. Fabulous. The people in shop are wonderful too. Call ahead if you want hot baked pies. You can always take home frozen to bake. I'm stopping on the way home to NY in a few days. I'm persona non grata if I don't bring home these pies!!! read more

Stopped here on a Friday morning to pick up some chicken pie and something sweet. We opted for the blueberry pie and the cape cod crunch pie. The chicken pie: got it frozen to have later. I was looking through the ingredients and was shocked to see that there were no vegetables. I was very disappointed to see this but was going to the grocery store later and decided to pick up a bag of mixed veggies (carrots, peas, corn, green beans). I mixed the veggies with my helping of the pie and it was delicious. The pie itself was moist and the chicken was melt-in-your-mouth good. The crust was delicious and flaky and just YUM. I can see how some people could enjoy the pie without the veggies but I grew up with veggies in my chicken pot pie and it adds a lot of flavor. So big tip is to buy a .99 cent bag of frozen veggies to have with the pie if you bring it home! The sweet pie: the cape cod crunch pie was absolutely amazing. Seriously, this is one of the best chocolate pies I've ever had. Incredibly light yet decadent. The toffee adds the perfect amount of crunch. Make sure to keep it in the fridge! The blueberry pie was nothing to write home about but it was tasty and refreshing. I wish the filling was juicier because it's basically just sweetened-up blueberries. Take the trip and plan accordingly :) read more

See all

It has pro's and cons. PRO: THAT CLAM PIE. Con - the chicken pie was way too salty as was the gravy. PRO: THE DANG CRUST! Will I mail order? YES. Will I stop again on my way back from the cape with more pies (clam pie totally!). ABSOLUTELY. I just think they may have had a salty batch. People are lovely, and they hire Americans with Disabilities which makes them rock stars in my heart. Oprah loved them? What's not to love?! Their pie crust is the absolute best! Don't let a 3 star scare you, because I will order and I WILL return! read more

I thought these pies were the closest thing you can get to a homemade pie but I guess not based on the ingredients. Look at this ingredients list! Heart attack, heart attack, artificial filler, cancer, sodium bomb, hydrogenated oils, heart attack. No, thank you! read more

Centerville Pies - Yikes! This ingredients list could make a chemical company jealous. - Bakeries Near Me - Centerville, Massachusetts

nope. agree with the other reviewers, not good. you could buy a pie at stop shop that would be fresher, tastier and cheaper. or a table talk pie even. i hardly ever write reviews but i didn't want others to waste their time going to this place. read more

These are the best savory pies I have tasted. The chicken pie is great for those that fine prefer the vegetables, the Thanksgiving pie is delicious any time of year and the taco pie is great for Taco Tuesday. But my favorite is the spinach and feta! You can't go wrong with any of the pies. For sweet pies, I have only tried the all berry, but that was a huge hit too! Savory pies comes frozen and shrink wrapped. Perfect to bring home from a trip to the Cape. Centerville Pies is a mandatory stop for our family when we visit the Cape! Delicious! read more