Slices are semi made to order. Different than shops that have them sitting there and reheat. The pizza was fine. I'd stop back to try some of their other options. I do appreciate a shop that has slices. They do accept credit cards. read more

Center Avenue Slice - Pepperoni slices - Pizza Near Me - Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

I think it's fabulous Pizza. Sadly, this establishment is a memory to me. Me and my ex-girlfriend got pizza from here a few times. I can't bring myself to drive over and pick one up. I did enjoy sharing it with her son. It's not always about the food, but they have excellent pizza based on my experience. ~R read more

I came in the around 4:30pm on Friday 6-05-26. GREAT pizza at a popular crowded business is worth the wait. The two cheese slices that I ordered were fresh out of the oven. For $5 this is possibly the best pizza deal around. The crust was perfect. I greatly love the old school feel and ambience. read more

See all

Appetizer portions are small for many options per price, but the fries and pizza are simply to die for. Everything is piping hot upon pickup. I wish they started offering online ordering because I don't love calling in to order, but I can manage read more

for a party we ordered 5 pizzas, 2 hoagies and 3 dozen wings pizza was flavorless! wings and hoagies average read more

Grew up eating pizza from here but since I moved I completely forgot about this place for a while. We only ordered a large 2 topping pizza. Pepperoni and half mushroom, we normally order well-done but forgot this time. Didn't really matter it was still good! They use fresh mushrooms incase that's a deal breaker for anyone! Also for my ranch lovers, they have pretty good ranch- coming from someone who doesn't like any store-bought ranch! We were too excited & I forgot to take a picture before eating it! Probably one of my favorite local spots! We ordered pick-up, about 35 min wait time. read more

Center Avenue Slice - Large pepperoni pizza with half mushroom - Pizza Near Me - Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

horrible food, horrible service, rude staff Don't waste your time going to this restaurant it is not worth the money we will never go back very rude people read more

This has been my family's go to place to order place since I was little, and it still is. We ordered a pizza for pick up on Friday night. The food was hot and ready when we went to pick it up, and the pizza itself was delicious. I'm always in search of the perfect crust, and Center Avenue has hit the nail on the head. They've got the perfect balance of bready and crispy. The flavors of the white pizza are well balanced. read more

Center Avenue Slice - White pizza - Pizza Near Me - Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

See all

Always great, one of our favs, got an awful burnt one tonite and was craving it! burnt underneath and the four corners black with no cheese, not the one to complain but $30 ‍They fixed the problem and will try them again for sure. read more

First time ordered. I ordered pizza. It was good. (& I will eat it again). My husband doesn't eat tomatoes and ordered their chicken strips. Let me just say they give you a ridiculous amount that you will eat in one sitting because they are literally the best chicken strips that have been placed on God's green earth. I don't know magic they use for them but it works. read more

I hadn't had center ave since high school and let me tell you the pizza is still as great as I remember!! It was ready when they said it would be and they even threw in some extra ranch's. The guys and girls behind the counter were super attentive too! I'm moving soon and I'm SOOO going to miss this place. read more

We ordered a heart shaped pizza yesterday for pick up, for Valentine's Day! Pizza was delicious! My husband loves the smaller pepperoni which is what they used and we also got mushrooms. We appreciated that they cut it as well! This was our first time ordering from here but will not be our last! We Will definitely be back! Also the 2 guys in the shop couldn't have been nicer! read more

Center Avenue Slice - Heart shaped pizza for Valentine's Day! - Pizza Near Me - Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

This place is the real deal. Great food made with the best ingr,edients. Three kinds of pizza, traditional, pan and Sicilian, all fabulous. I have been a customer here since Brent opened the shop in 2020, and I have never been let down. If anything, the food has improved. Kind, friendly people. Great service. The only negative comment I have is that the fries are greasy. I wish they would fix that because I like fries on my hoagie. To sum it up, a great eating experience. Eddie L. read more

The pizza and hoagies are excellent. I particularly liked t cheese pizza . It was well done , the sauce didn't bother my stomach , and the crust was crunchy. read more

I knew a girl in Pitt so I center a slice from here and she liked it. I like it too, even though it's not amazing and is far from my fave in town (Aiello, Fiori). They have lovely service, and serve a decent slice. It's not really Pittsburgh-style Pizza, just generic pizza but still pretty good and worth a try if you're in this area. If you live in Pitt and haven't tried it yet, my question is... why avenue tried it yet? read more

Center Avenue Slice - Did you make the sauce today? Is it old? So what is the sauce age? - Pizza Near Me - Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

See all

Last Friday in Lent. We ordered three (3) Big Wig fish sandwiches. These folks put together an awesome sandwich, The order was ready when they said it would be and we were surprised by the size. They certainly can cook. Looking forward to trying one of their calzones in the near future. Well done Ladies and Gentlemen. read more

In my 32 years of experience, never have I been so appalled. Astonishingly rude and truly bad customer service for gross food. wouldn't recommend. read more

Love their pizza... we live close so it's quite convenient having this little piece of pizza heaven within walking distance. The combination is cheeses is unique in flavor and the sauce is just right. The breaded mushrooms leave a little something to be desired but the pizza is definitely worth a shot among the hundreds of options for pizza in Pittsburgh. read more

Our favorite pizza place! They are always courteous and quick, and have never messed up an order. Quality food and pricing in line with other shops. Their delivery staff is consistent, we usually have the same couple of guys. Super nice! read more

A Westview staple- we love ordering from center Avenue slice! The pizza doesn't disappoint- taste like boardwalk pizza. The shop looks like an old fashioned pizza place- everyone is friendly. Make sure to ask for the daily special. read more

I've lived in Pittsburgh for almost ten years now one neighborhood over from West View and this is my first time ordering from Center Avenue Slice. My order consisted of a side salad @ $4.50 and a 10" hand tossed junior size pizza. The salad was a good size and and included iceberg lettuce, tomato cubes, fresh sliced mushrooms, green pepper and two types of cheese. They include additional veggies or peppers that I told them to hold including olives, banana peppers and a couple other items. It also came with a nice sized round container of my selected dressing - Italian. The salad was well worth the price and was very fresh. The pizza I ordered was the hand tossed pan crust with mushrooms, hamburger, green peppers and diced tomatoes. The taste was very nice and the toppings were plentiful. The toppings were spread well and no one topping dominated in any area of the pizza. This is just good normal pizza. I called at 8:37 p.m. on a Sunday and my husband drove and collected the order, so I have no experience with their delivery service. They close at 9:15 p.m., so I was very pleased by the fresh food provided so close to closing time. I will be ordering in good faith again from this eatery. read more

See all

This place is the best! Customer service: The owner always strikes up a conversation with me, he's super friendly and so is the rest of the staff I have encountered. He will tell you about the history of the park too. The pizza is delicious. The cheese is the best money can buy, they made their dough fresh every morning and the toppings are fresh. I ordered a pineapple pizza and when I arrived to pick it up I saw him slicing up a real pineapple.. imagine that! SO GOOD. I loved the atmosphere.. there are old photographs and news clippings from when the West View amusement Park was up and running. Very interesting to learn about West View's history and something to do while you are waiting since there are things to read all over the restaurant. Also, the huge mural on the side of the building is pretty cool! read more

Center Avenue Slice - Pizza Near Me - Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

Center Avenue Slice makes a pretty serious pizza. Their crust is thin, and mildly floppy but not so much so that you end up losing all of the toppings between your plate and your mouth. The outer crust is very light and crispy, and snaps in half when you try and fold it. The thing I liked most about their pizza is that they hit a nice balance with their toppings. While the sausage and banana peppers were plentiful on my pizza nothing was so dominant that you couldn't taste the other toppings. Their delivery service was prompt and friendly and the cost, $16 for a medium 2 topping, was a bit steep but ended up being worth it. I will definitely be ordering from Center Ave. Slice again. read more

Center Avenue Slice - Medium Pizza with Sausage and Banana Peppers - Pizza Near Me - Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

Truly one of the best pizza in Pittsburgh Up there with Fiori's and Beto's Sandwiches, salads, wings etc. all good Great homemade ranch dressing. We go quite often after church. read more

This particular establishment provided the worse service I have ever received. I placed a order for two deep dish pizza one personal one large. It was a simple order. After waiting for an hour I gave them a called to inquire as to the where about of my order only to be I told that they had input the incorrect and the pizza was delivered and paid for by the incorrect address. After speaking with the establishment they then informed me that they don't deliver to our address. The pizza is not worth the incredible Ill manner phone receptionist who is incompetent at a basic skill. This establishment deserve to go under. read more

Great pizza! Thin too just how I like it! Wings are great! Tastes like home! Or Ny style pizza. We got garlic wings. Delicious! Delivery was fast also. read more

I am a GrubHub driver and went to pick up the pizza. Staff had not been looking at their grubhub order tablet, and we're surprised, yelling back and forth. I was told I'd have to wait 20 minutes. I asked if I could use patron restroom, was told it was for customers. Assuming I was considered a customer, I went to the bathroom. Came out and was angerly told they had cancelled the order, because I didn't follow directions and used their bathroom. Good luck surviving Covid that way buddy. You are relying on similar food services to stay afloat, but you'll.fa.with your terrible customer service and insulting attitude. Grow up. read more

We have ordered from them for years. We orders pizza tonight. From past orders we know to order with extra sauce because if not it's very dry. Pizzas arrived no extra sauce and extremely dry. I called to complain. They said they put the extra sauce on but it must have dried out in the oven. Really?!? They offered to reimburse us. When I told the girl I paid in cash she said sorry and hung up on me. I have been a customer for many years but I will take my $40 elsewhere!! read more

Sicilian pizza is WONDERFUL! So good. We also got an Italian hoagie, also really good. We went on a Sunday afternoon, sat outside, it was really nice. In addition to good food, The staff was super friendly which made our experience even better. If we had room, we would have tried the chocolate chip cookies that just came out of the oven. Really happy we came here, we will be back. read more

Wow. Peace out Center Avenue Slice. The quality on the pizza has crashed, and the customer service SUCKS! The parents ordered a pizza a few weeks back to pick up. The order was simple: large pepperoni pizza. When they arrived, the workers said the pizza still needed ten minutes, despite this being longer than the quoted time. Ok, things happen. Five minutes later, a man walked up, ordered, and was given a large pepperoni pizza a few minutes later. This pizza turned out to be my parents. Want to hear the solution to this? The employee gave my dad two options: 1. He could pay the LARGE price for an already made MEDIUM pepperoni pizza. Because they don't correct mistakes (WTF?) or do refunds. 2. He could wait ten minutes for a new pizza. (What kind of pizza is ready in ten minutes?) How long did that new pizza take? 45 minutes. And the cheese and sauce quality is now on par with Papa Johns or Dominoes. The pizza is now passable and nothing more. No one would miss them if they closed tomorrow with their new attitude. Bye, Center Avenue. We will never order from you again! read more

Updated Review. In the past review I had only ordered their sandwiches and calzones, which were really good and will be talked about. However I finally got around to ordering their pizza which has been named best pizza in some category. I will start by saying that I really enjoy big floppy slices with not a lot of sauce and good toppings. Center Ave gave me just what I wanted. A New York style pizza for a good price. The crust was cooked well and had enough crunch. The sauce was good and did not overpower the toppings like some pizza joints. I really enjoyed the pizza and now see myself not waiting so long to get again. Here's the portion of my last review that addresses their sandwiches. The fish sandwich was large, crisp, good flavor, and not soggy. Not the greatest, but definitely worth it. The Pittsburgh sandwich, think Primanti's, was better than the original. More meat, not as soggy and messy, and full of flavor. I must warn though that they charge quite a bit for delivery so if you want to save, pick it up! I can't give Center Ave 5 stars because while the pizza is very good and the sandwiches are good to very good, nothing is great. That being said it's definitely worth a try. read more

Worst service ever. Called and ordered food, they told me 1/2 hr...an hour goes by and I called back. They couldn't find my order then proceeded to tell me it would be another hour before I could have my food. This included the girl on the phone talking to the manager and him saying "make him wait" guess they didn't think I could hear them. I'll never order from here again. BUYER BEWARE!!!!!!!!!!! read more

We are always on the lookout for good pizza. We've found it! You know when you get hit with that pizza craving? We got hit hard last night around 7, when we were out by Ross Park Mall. Not wanting to do a chain restaurant, I searched nearby pizza places, and put this one into the GPS. It's super close to Mcknight road, but definitely off the beaten path. We ordered it to go, we had wine at home, and pizza and red wine is my favorite football watching combo. The whole way home, I could smell that these pizzas were tasty. The sticker on the box said that they were made with the best italian cheese you could get. It took all my restraint to not just start eating it in the car right then and there, but then my daughters would want to do the same, and pizza is not good car food for 7 and 8 year old girls (at least not mine). Once we dug in, they did not disappoint. The pepperoni on my older daughters half were tiny, and she loved that (they have large ones too). She said that way when you bit into a pepperoni, you don't have to try to bite it in half. There were tons of olives and FRESH (I hate canned mushrooms) on my and my younger daughters half. And they accommodated my husband with dollops of ricotta on his half (It's not listed as a usual topping). The pizza was excellent, the toppings were tasty and plentiful, and they didn't screw it up! We aren't the easiest of orders, we are always halving this and that, and lots of times our orders are wrong, but not this time! We have found our pizza place! read more

I love pizza but this is the WORST pizza I've ever ate. Two bites and threw the whole box away. Avoid this place!

Horrible quality of food. Pre-made crust and very little sauce. All that aside, we ordered a pizza at 9:30 and it did not arrive until 10:45 after a "30 min" estimate. Aaaaand cold. Worst pizza joint in the Burgh by far. read more

Its okay. Hand tossed dough was good, classic neighborhood pizza shop, but the rest is not for me. The sauce was a sweet sauce, but I've had better. The cheese was just the standard. I'd WOULD order if it was my local pizza shop, but as I was just passing thru I won't be back. read more

Great subs, wings, calzones and slices....salads are outrageous. The owner, Brent is a great family man who takes a lot of pride in his product. Great staff as well. The epitome of a classic neighborhood pizzeria. Eat here. Everything is good. read more

Another average Pittsburgh pizza shop. Been wanting to try a lot of different places and heard this was one to try. It wasn't bad but wasn't great by any means. read more

I received my delivery in the pizza was dry in the crust was very dry and my husband threw it in the garbage won't eat it tomorrow we are moving to leave been very helpful to have for tomorrow won't order from you again,Spoke with management and he said I don't know we need presto this morning there's no compensation or anything worst pizza in the North Hills. read more

They got our order wrong and forgot a pizza and then overcharged us twice for the missing pizza. Be sure to check keep your receipts and check your bank statement. read more