First time trying this place today. I came for dinner with my boyfriend and his parents. We had an occasion we wanted to celebrate. We were seated fairly quickly but sat for a while before anyone came to get our drink orders. Server came back with drinks quickly and again, took a while before he came back to take our food order. When our food arrived it looked and smelled great. However, 2 out of 3 steaks were cooked incorrectly. I ordered a rib eye medium rare, while bf ordered the NY steak Medium. His dad ask for medium well and it came out with some red but he didn't mind. My steak was pretty much well done.. Very little pink, pretty tough. Bf's steak was almost raw. We asked sever for some steak sauce since well I was gonna be eating cardboard, he never returned with it and I had to ask someone else who immediately brought it to the table. I ate 1/2 my steak hoping A1 would improve it, sadly, it didn't. Never got offered a refill on my ice tea. I waited for my ice to melt for something to drink. He never brought the water that I asked for either. Thankfully he didn't forget the beer orders. Bf's dad's steak was good... Seasoned well. Bf's steak was raw so we took it home, can update after he microwaves it for lunch tmrw. Mine was tough and seasoned well but I had to drench in A1 to moisten it a bit to eat. Bf's mom just had a salad which had way more iceberg than she liked but she said it was still good. Manager tried to fix it by offering to cook my bf's steak longer or making 2 new ones or dessert but we just wanted to go home, it was a long day. In the end he gave us a discount on our meal which was appreciated. Maybe server got tied up with larger parties or whatever. Who knows,. Overall, I feel that once I mentioned something they tried to fix it which I appreciated. I'll give this place another shot one day and hopefully I can update my review with a more positive one. read more

Cattlemens - Over cooked ribeye with veggies - Steakhouses Near Me - Selma, California

See all

Great place to eat get there early might be a long wait but we'll worth it food is great real steakhouse service is great you will leave satisfied read more

Some people drive to Fresno, but we're very lucky to have Cattlemen's in town. I love their Steak & Lobster, Pete's Special, drinks, sourdough bread, all you can eat salad, and bacon wrapped shrimp. It's delicious every single time. The waiter and service were awesome! We'll be back soon!! read more

Cattlemens - Steak & Lobster - Steakhouses Near Me - Selma, California

Food was great. Dinner came with a little salad bar that was wonderful. Service was top notch!

I was a guest in a party of 10, and my first time eating at this restaurant. I have heard a lot of good things about Cattleman's, but never had a chance to visit. Bread was good, service was good, food was cold, wait time between order and receiving the food was very long. I won't be returning. read more

Definitely worth the money for steak. They have a special for two and you can't go wrong with that. Portions are plentiful and price is fair. Service is great read more

1st time I went my steak was not cooked the way I asked and i asked the server if I could move to another table because we were under the A.C. But I guess he forgot ... and I was very cold and my food came out cold .. the manager did remove my plate from my bill so that was nice and my 2nd time I went I ordered steak and lobster and that food came out cold so I wasn't happy at all !! read more

Delicious meat. Amazing service. We came early at 4:30pm on a Friday - so we didnt have too many tables to compete with to get our servers attention. Shannon was our server and she was great. Brought us everything needed very promptly and was very attentive. Last time I was here later on a Friday and the service was sub par with a different server - but the food was still great. I had the cowboy steak and my husband had the cattlemen's cut prime rib. We shared both. Can't say which was better as they were both soo tasty! You certainly can't go wrong with a flavorful bone in rib eye though! Also, they are the first place I found in the Fresno vicinity with Campari so that is a major plus. read more

See all

Was visiting the area on business and ended up at Cattlemens based on a recommendation from the hotel I was staying. Service was good and food was excellent. Had the rustlers rib eye and it was cooked perfectly. When I am back in town I will make this one if my goto places to eat. read more

Amazing service Amazing appetizers. Steak uou can cut with a fork will be back soon.

Probably one of the best T-Bone steak I have had in my entire life. It was cooked perfectly and the taste was absolutely flavorful. The house steaksauce complimented the flavor and texture of the steak wonderfully. My wife ordered a regular steak and it was super bland. Yuck! But she liked it. The potato skins was very good. HUGE potatoes with real bacon. I took a point off because it was pricey as heck. Geez. We paid almost $80 for our meal. Overall, I would only come here on special occasions. Solid A- in my book. read more

See all

I would agree with other reviewers that Cattlemens is "hit or miss". Unfortunately the last few visits have been a resounding miss. Quality of steaks is marginal at best, but given the price point (inexpensive), expectations are set relatively low. Steaks are clearly not great cuts or aged, but again at the price quality is comparable to Sizzler or Perkos. Salmon was presented raw (cold), and chicken arrived a full 15 minutes after the steaks were served. On our most recent visit, for which we had a reservation, we were seated at an extremely uncomfortable and inconvenient "booth". The hostess informed us that was our only option - so we ended up eating in the bar. At least our server in the bar area was attentive. Probably won't be back anytime soon. read more

We stopped by here once waited a little by the bar and were sitter pretty fast Great food portions are decent good meat Prices are reasonable it was my birthday they came out with desert and sang song for me it was fun I got to keep cowboy hat read more

Cattlemens - Steakhouses Near Me - Selma, California

See all

A 3 star review is rather generous given the meal we were served. I will begin by saying our waiter was an absolute doll! He was attentive and communicative throughout the entire dinner and he deserves a 10 star review. The service from the hostesses outside is a completely different issue. We were given a wait time of 1 hour and 15 minutes, no problem, we anticipated this. Upon giving your name and number cattleman's send you a link via text so you can track your wait time (standard protocol these days). Once our timer was at 0, we waited another 10 minutes for a text... nothing. I then walked up and asked the hostess if she could check on our table. She went inside and never returned. We continued to wait at the kiosk/pedestal and to our right and left we had two other parties approach. A second hostess then comes out and completely ignores the crowd of hungry patrons waiting for an update. I finally ask her if the original hostess sent her out to seat us. She looks confused and unaware. She asks our party name and then tells us to go in. I couldn't believe this girl was a hostess. She avoided eye contact and did not greet a single person when she came out. She stared down at her ipad and fiddled around as if her job was just to stand in front of the restaurant, ignore people and look cute. Okay, so we get seated and as mentioned earlier our waiter was a delight. He seemed busy but kept us updated throughout the entire dinner. Now my review about the actual dinner.... I would never return. We were seated by 8 and the restaurant was out of prime rib, no problem, I ordered a rib eye instead and my bf ordered a New York. We both requested medium rare but were served medium steaks. I wasn't a fan of my ribeye but didn't send it back because my bf doesn't like sending food back at restaurants. My bf offered me a piece of his NY steak and I was disgusted at the flavor. It taste like it was cooked on old burnt grease, as if the cook hadn't cleaned the grill in between steaks. It was bitter and tasted borderline chemical- like. I would have sent that steak back regardless of my bf's thoughts on sending food back The only thing cattleman's has going for them is their cheap prices. It's one of the cheapest steakhouses I've been to but I'ld rather pay more for better quality. Like I said, this was our first and last time coming here. Wasn't worth the drive nor the wait. I had no clue it was a franchisee and thought we were supporting local. It wasn't until after I found out we went to a chain steakhouse. No wonder... Drinks- the legendary margarita was actually made well. So I would give your bartender 4/5 stars. read more

Strong drinks and polite servers. However, it was not enough to distract from the refrigerator cold fries, bitter cucumbers in my salad, and dirty utensils. Our server was attentive and really did their best to make it right, but I gave up after sending my knife back two times and ended up sharing a steak knife with my husband. Had high hopes after making the trip here to celebrate my birthday. Never again. Save your gas money and save your steak money. This is not the place to spend your hard earned cash. read more

restaurant is clean. The food can grt pricey. You can get unlimited sour dough and salad and beans if you order a plate. The steak however lacked flavor but overall the food was good. The alcohol drink lacked alcohol though lol . read more

See all

I cannot say one bad thing about my experience here last night! We came here for mine & my brother's Birthday and I am sure glad we did! We arrived and were seated right away, the waitress was very sweet and the environment is very cozy. Love the western style decor, we sat right in front of the fire place & it was such a nice view. I ordered the special of the day which was the T-Bone steak. I asked the waitress how much it was & she said $20. I thought that was great. I had a code from when I signed up for Cattleman's newsletter in doing so you get a free onion tumbleweed appetizer so we put that order in. You also get complimentary bread & salad, the bread was good but the salad was absolutely delicious! When the tumbleweed appetizer arrived it came with two sides, ranch & a delicious BBQ sauce. It tasted great...imagine a large thin pile of onion rings lol. Now the T-Bone steak was amazing! I was really taken back by how big it was! For $20 I was literally in shock...also I like mine cooked medium rare & it was cooked to perfection! It was juicy & flavorful, the fries I got as a side were ok...not great but good. For $20 I was blown away...definitely a steal! Overall the waitress & servers were great! They were very attentive & so sweet! They kept checking on us throughout our entire time there...the only thing I will say is we waited about 15 minutes just to pay our tab. We ended up going to the hostess because it took way too long, but that is minor. I had a wonderful experience & will be returning for my Dad's birthday! I recommend this restaurant if you love great food, and a cozy, family oriented environment! read more

Cattlemens - Delicious T-Bone steak - Steakhouses Near Me - Selma, California

This is one of our favorite places to eat. The food and cocktail beverages are great. The greeter's and server's are very professional and friendly. It does get alittle loud in there at times, but only because everyone is having a great time. They start you off with your drink and home made sour dough bread accompanied by an all you can eat salad, both are awesome! We usually have the ribeye and New York steak with shrimp scampi. Our fave! I gave it a 4 stars because there is always some room for improvement. Never the less we do love eating here. read more

See all

I just left Cattlemen's in Selma. The restaurant has the legit look of a great steakhouse and chill ambiance but it needs help, maybe better management. Upon arrival, the greeter (kara) was cold and pretty much cried-out UNDERPAID; pretty but without a smile for a mile. The menu was full of promising selections. I was torn between the prime rib and the beef back-ribs and so I went with the Prime Rib. I ordered fried Brussel sprouts and they were delicious. Next, my dinner salad which was served in a metal bowl and it came in almost at room temperature (terrible for a salad). Then the steak came in with a small bowl of beans that were just above room temperature. The worse of all was the steak! I literally could not chew it as the surrounding 1/3" was dry and super hard. The inside was tender but I would have had to deal with most of the steak to get to it- simply not worth it so I left it. My waitress adjusted the bill and was apologetic- super professional. I have never, ever had a restaurant screw-up a Prime Rib so Cattlemens gets a bad review. read more

Ok- I just went back yesterday... I don't think I'll be going back anymore. Same thing happened again. I went with a couple of my friends and none of our steaks were cooked how we ask for them. They were all over done. We ordered fillet mignon's. WORST IDEA EVER. It's so easy to over cook this type of steak, one of the steaks was literally gray inside. Not worth the price or the chewing. Another thing I disliked was the hostess giving us three options for seating and then unapologetically saying "we'll seat you at a table ok?" (I chose the booth option) Like why give me an option of a booth and not being able to seat me there or tell me it'll be a wait? I would've been fine with waiting. I stood there for a few seconds confused and just gave in to sitting at a table in order to avoid a fuss. Also the bacon wrapped shrimp were probably old or expired. One my friends was sick all night after eating dinner here. PROCEED WITH CAUTION read more

Cattlemens at one point was a great steak house to go but the service has gotten worse and worse over the years. Even with a reservation I had wait ~30 minutes to be seated. The service was slow and my server was rude. I was asking for basic things like: "Can I get silverware?" or "Can I get a refill on my water?" And was met with a rude response. We left before ordering because service was too slow and the server was being rude. read more

I tried to respond to your request but was unable to do so ... contact me at theresaguthrie978@gmail.com

I had an amazing dining experience at Cattlemen's. The service was awesome. The waitress Kelly, was on top of everything. To add to that positive, the food was cooked to perfection. I had the cowboy rib eye steak. It was juicy and tasty. It had a good balance of seasonings. There was large portion sizes that included an all you can eat salad as well as all you can eat sourdough bread. The environment was relaxing. It is a large and roomy restaurant with different types of seating. Thanks for a great Friday night out! I can't understand why there are only 3.5 stars. I will be back! Cattlemen's did not disappoint. read more

This was my first time coming here, but my mother, who had been in the 1980s? had nothing but good things to say about her experience. The lights were dim and building shows signs of better days, which only ads to the old west charm. The employees were professional (my only complaint would be that no one offered to refill our glasses), the food was good (especially their steak; I took mine medium rare), and the atmosphere pleasant. We had reservations, but saw quite a few people waiting and the place was more-or-less packed the entire time. Growing up, I remember seeing a lot more restaurants like this, so it was also quite the blast from the past! read more

This restaurant and service was THE BEST. Our server was Leonard. He was on point and so were his co-workers. Always made sure to top off our drinks. Always had bread and made sure our food was good too. It is a country western themed restaurant. We went to celebrate my husbands birthday. They sang happy birthday, gave him a free cowboy hat and ice cream and said Yee Ha at the end. It was so cute. There food was Delicious!! I ordered the steak and lobster with twiced baked potato. Lobster was on point! I'm often disappointed with Lobster being too rubbery tasting but NOT here! So yum! Steak cooked to my liking and the twice baked potato was bursting with flavor! read more

Dimly lit place with a beautiful ambiance. Food was on the spot. Perfect place to go to if you want a gourmet steak! The Dakota chicken was great too. Oh, and they also have an unforgettable chocolate cake! Definitely going again. read more

Astounding job to the cooks and staff! Cattlemen's is a great place to go and enjoy and nice dinner with others. The server and manager are so hospitable and make the extra effort to consistently make sure that you are taken care of. As for the food, the cook did an incredible job. The steak was perfectly cooked. It was so juicy and tender that the flavor just melted in my mouth. The shrimp scampi I ordered was also delicious. I 100% recommend coming here read more

I'm a Midwest girl from Kansas and this place DEFINITELY gets my approval. Steak grilled perfectly, flavor is fantastic fresh bread is perfect and service is great! Everyone friendly. This is my new birthday restaurant! read more

I've been to Cattlemens twice and had good experiences both times. The service is stellar and food is usually very good. This last time my husband had the porterhouse and I had prime rib. My husband enjoyed his meal. My prime rib was a tad over cooked but that was probably my fault more than the restaurant. They made a big deal about presenting it but I didn't particularly care for the stoneware they put it on. I know its nitpicky on my part but cutting on stoneware is not a great sesation. We had dessert and the server made a huge deal about how good and big their serving of cheesecake was. It was overhyped. It was good but not the best I ever had and the slice was average sized. Not disappointed it just wasn't amazed by it. All in all I love the restaurant. read more

Been here several times and hit and miss is the best way to describe it. Granted it was busy, but they screwed up 4 of the 6 steaks ordered. I ordered the bone in ribeye medium rare plus. They got the plus right, but it was medium well plus. The other steaks were severely undercooked. Needless to say we sent them back and 40 minutes later we got steaks that were even worse. I wish I had a picture of my ribeye, it was curled up, ran in color and cooked well past well. They seemed apologetic, but this isn't a salad place, they should know how to cook a steak when you have Cattle in your name. Probably won't go back for a long long time. Sad. read more

I've lived in other states and traveled to all, and this steakhouse has great specials better than any I've visited or frequented. Manager David has the best managerial skills and is very outgoing and attentive. He also fixed the tiny television that wasn't broadcasting in HiDef in the bar area which you need binoculars to view a sporting event, hopefully they upgrade to @ least a 65" Hope this review finds the upper management well. ***Update*** since I can't make a second review or every time I come here which is 3 or more times a week, tonight Bartender Christie went out of her way to bring me the tray of the T-Bones so I could choose which I was going to order. Mariah was also in the mix filling up my ice tea as she was pouring drinks, Ignasio greeted me by name as I sat at the bar watching sports on the tiny 32 inch television that soon will be upgraded. Nickelodeon brought the food out and was very attentive to detail on the presentation of my food and asked a few times if there was anything else needed. Top notch crew on this wonderful Thursday night... A must visit if you're in the area. read more

Cattlemens - Decisions Decisions Decisions - Steakhouses Near Me - Selma, California

So amazing! Service is amazing! Steak is the best! Lobster tail is so tender! Like i said everything is amazing !!!! read more

Cattlemens - Steakhouses Near Me - Selma, California

Amazing for the Central Valley. Price for food is very reasonable for a steakhouse. Very good portions. The appetizer cheesy artichoke dip is a must try. The fresh sourdough bread suites it well. Sirloin steak melts in your mouth. Definitely got full. read more

We sat in the bar, to have dinner. Our waiter was friendly, but a bit slow. That was fine and it gave us a chance to visit. The food was wonderful as usual. This store should be proud to be part of the Cattlemens family. read more

We dined here Friday night because we had a gift certificate. While the western theme is cute, the place is really run down and we left feeling disappointed. The food was mediocre in comparison to the steakhouses we eat at in Fresno. Attached is a photo of the seats we sat on with food crumbs in the cracks. We hear the place is always packed and the prices are somewhat pricey, so we don't understand why customers are sitting on seats like these. read more

Cattlemens - Steakhouses Near Me - Selma, California

No matter which location we visit, and we are trying to hit up them all! This place ALWAYS delivers! Our favorite is the Petes Special, a juicy perfectly seasoned steak, potato with ALL The fixings and break and salad, even the drink is included. If you want a good steakhouse food and vibe! Go here !! read more

Don't try going unless you make reservations. It is frustrating sitting there waiting 30-40 minutes when there are tables open waiting for those with reservations to come. We could have been in and out before they showed. We left and found agreat new place in Kingsburg. read more

This place has really gone down in quality and customer service. From forgetting part of my order, then telling me "if you still want it, you will have to pay for it", to hanging up on me when I call to place an order,( they have an option of ordering online, but to my knowledge it has never worked). I've talked to the 'manager' about the rudeness, only to be told "yeah, well, sorry". Only to find out when I pick up my good- 2 hour wait for the part they forgot- there is not a manager or an employee by that name. I know what you are thinking- it's a pandemic, everyone is doing their best- but this is over about five visits and it is not getting better. The picture is a twice baked potato I got with my order on my last visit. And I do mean last. read more

Cattlemens - This is a twice baked potato I received in my order. - Steakhouses Near Me - Selma, California

So much goodness I don't know where to start....oh yes the wonderful salad and sourdough bread. Yum Took my bf to eat here for his bday and it did not disappoint. He ordered the Steak & Alaskan King Crab and I had the Steak & Shrimp. Both were cooked perfectly and seasoned well. Our sides consisting of Sweet Potatoes and regular baked potatoes were delightful. Service was great as well. read more

Cattlemens - Sirloin Steak and Alaskan King Crab - Steakhouses Near Me - Selma, California

See all

You had me a sour dough. No, really! It's that good! Of course the steak is phenomenal ( Pete's Special) and the baked potato is even better loaded! The salad has excellent ranch dressing. The beans were good also. But the sour dough is excellent! Don't know how, but it's up there with the S. D's of The Bay Area! And I love Boudin! But the freshness, The warmth, the sour dough taste and the great butter all add up to the best sour dough you'll ever have! Or maybe it's just me... Find out for yourself! read more