Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Catskills Bake Works

    5.0 (2 reviews)
    Closed Closed

    Catskills Bake Works Photos

    More like Catskills Bake Works

    Recommended Reviews - Catskills Bake Works

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    5 years ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 1
    Oh no 0

    5 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Ask the Community - Catskills Bake Works

    Verify this business for free

    People searched for Bakeries 149 times last month within 10 miles of this business.

    Verify this business

    Shandaken Bake - Yes please. Super cute bakery in town.

    Shandaken Bake

    5.0(16 reviews)
    12.3 mi

    Wow, just wow. Run, don't walk to Shandaken Bake. This is a very special place. It's a one man…read moreshop. The owner, Craig, bakes everything fresh and he really knows what he's doing. Everything we tried was so phenomenal that we came and waited in line for 20+ minutes the following day. He even remembered us! It's a small shop but they have a few tables so if you can get a table, it'd be a comfortable place to sit and enjoy. Cream biscuit- simple and perfect. We were all fighting over this one. If you ask he'll give you jam and butter too. Chive and cheddar biscuit- deliciously cheesy and a real winner. Chubby squirrel- if you like fruit filled coffee cake, you'll be a fan of this one! It wasn't my favorite. Banana crumble cake- this was a definite favorite! The cake wasn't too sweet and the crumb added a nice sweetness. Apple tart- this was well received by our group! I liked it. All in all, this bakery is amazing! I wish I could eat the banana crumble cake for breakfast every morning.

    There are literally... no notes for this place. It's beautifully considered- from the design and…read moremusic choices, the baked goods are addictive- and the key lime ruins you for others. My personal favorite is the chubby squirrel which hits all the notes of baked fruit, a little crumble and a buttery dough. Craig is a pastry genius and when you finally get to the front of the line you feel like you're the only one there...

    Photos
    Shandaken Bake
    Shandaken Bake
    Shandaken Bake

    See all

    Overlook Bakery - Nutty Meet Fruity [@ Home]: (Almond & Regular Flour Cupcake+Raspberry Buttercream)

    Overlook Bakery

    4.7(50 reviews)
    18.6 mi

    The reviews are not exaggerating. This is the actual best bakery I've ever been to. We arrived…read morethere like 5 minutes before they closed, and everything looked great so I wound up buying two giant sea salt/chocolate chip cookies, a kitchen sink cookie, a sprinkle cookie, and a small yellow/vanilla cake with chocolate frosting. I regret not taking better photos, but at least I got a quick shot of the delightful cake. It was all absurdly good. I can't get over how fluffy the frosting is and how perfect the cookie textures are. The woman working was also really nice and, despite it being the end of the day, I didn't feel at all rushed or like she just wanted to close up. Here's how much we loved it: My husband and I went there yesterday while on a weekend trip. Today, we had to get back home fast to beat the snowstorm, and we seriously considered just risking it and driving out of our way to go back here. We didn't (safety first, etc) but we've decided to order our wedding cake from this place *and* our wedding favors. Seriously, everyone should go to this place. Everyone deserves this magic in their lives!

    Picked up some yummy treats for my husband and I including the Magic bar, chocolate cupcake, sesame…read morecookies, and raspberry thumbprint cookie. My husband loved the chocolate cupcake. I thought the vegan gluten free cookies and magic bar was delicious. Everything looked great. Service was friendly. Overall I'd definitely recommend for treats when in the area!

    Photos
    Overlook Bakery - Almond Flour Thumbprint Greatness @ Home: (Raspberry/Peach)

    Almond Flour Thumbprint Greatness @ Home: (Raspberry/Peach)

    Overlook Bakery - Sweet, Soft, Buttery & Full Of Sprinkles

    Sweet, Soft, Buttery & Full Of Sprinkles

    Overlook Bakery - Self-Serve

    See all

    Self-Serve

    Catskill Mountain Country Store - Windham - Tall Tale ($16.99)

    Catskill Mountain Country Store - Windham

    4.4(183 reviews)
    7.2 mi
    $$

    Located in the Catskill Mountains, this place is an absolute gem. It is obvious from the moment you…read morewalk in that you have just stepped into a special place. You'll find something for everyone at catskill mountain country store. Fresh food is prepared according to your order. However, the wait is well worth it. The eggs were fresh and fluffy, just the way I like them. As a tea lover, I enjoyed the assortment of teas. All staff members were friendly and attentive to all guests. Those traveling alone, with families, or visiting for a weekend will find this to be very enjoyable. Don't forget to pick up some fresh baked goods from the gift shop. Apple donuts are also addictive. On the ride home, I ate them all.

    Quirky fun place in Windham. It's a mix of general store, souvenir shop, bakery and restaurant…read more The store is packed to the brim with a mix of small business goodies, big box names, and everything in between. The sauces and jams are made in house. They sell main stream candy repackaged in general store packaging for an up charge. There's Windham and Catskill souvenirs. There's stuff made by local artists along with big box toys and items. There are a few cats living in the store and restaurant - all are super friendly. The restaurant is nice but the service is extremely slow and could be a touch nicer. There are multiple signs talking about the whole world being understaffed. Just be prepared to spend a while. The waitress was fine but clearly very busy. We had mentioned wanting to get dessert at the beginning but when we were done eating, she had just brought us our check - we were too fully anyway. I had the garden salad sandwich on farm bread. The avocado wasn't the freshest and there was only one tiny piece of tomato - this will probably be a good sandwich in peak summer. The sandwiches came with chips and salsa. The store made mango salsa is delicious. Locally made root beer in a bottle was delicious and unique. The baked goods were quite pricey (almost $9 for a small square of raspberry bread). The bathrooms are on the otherwise by the kids toys.

    Photos
    Catskill Mountain Country Store - Windham - Fruit preserves, sauces, seasonings... Bacon

    Fruit preserves, sauces, seasonings... Bacon

    Catskill Mountain Country Store - Windham - Fries and

    Fries and

    Catskill Mountain Country Store - Windham - Cup of Coffee ($2.50) - free refills!

    See all

    Cup of Coffee ($2.50) - free refills!

    Fellow Mountain Cafe

    Fellow Mountain Cafe

    4.1(91 reviews)
    8.0 mi
    $$

    We are pretty consistent Fellows patrons. Their coffee is great- even just the drip is very…read moreflavorful but a latte is a treat. Their baked goods- yes, the cinnamon rolls but don't overlook the seasonal GF cake they have- dates, cranberries- it's always delicious. The lentil bowl or the Lockwood are both savory morning choices and hit the right flavors and the scene is ... always the scene. Servers get the food and coffees out quickly even when it's busy

    This is a tough review because I genuinely wanted to give this place a 5/5…read more I worked with the team to cater brunch for my fiancé's birthday and the planning process was fantastic. Communication was seamless, they helped create a custom birthday cake with flavors I requested, and the entire ordering experience was smooth and stress-free. The food was outstanding. From the bread and cinnamon rolls to the focaccia and cake, everything was fresh, delicious, and a huge hit with our group. Every item felt thoughtfully made, and it was clear why so many people rave about their bakery. The only reason I'm not giving 5 stars is the pickup experience. I had a prepaid order of over $250 scheduled for 8:00 a.m. pickup, right when the café opened. We arrived about 15 minutes early.. because it was raining and simply hoped to wait somewhere covered until pickup time. We weren't expecting the order early or asking anyone to rush. Given the size of the order, the custom cake, and the fact that I had brought someone with me to help carry everything, we just wanted to avoid standing outside in the rain. When I knocked on the door, I could see several staff members inside. One employee looked at us and gestured toward the clock, essentially pointing out that they weren't open yet. I completely understand that we arrived early, and I respect opening hours. What bothered me was how the situation was handled. A simple "We'll be open at 8" or "Sorry, we can't let anyone in until opening" would have been perfectly reasonable. Instead, the interaction felt unnecessarily cold. Even once we were inside, the employee helping us came across as dismissive and unwelcoming. It was especially disappointing because every interaction I'd had over email leading up to the event had been so thoughtful, friendly, and accommodating. The food was exceptional, and the planning process was excellent. I just wish the same level of hospitality had carried through to the pickup experience. Had that interaction been handled with a bit more warmth, this would have easily been a 5-star review. Ratings: * Food & ambiance: 10/10 * Communication email: 10/10 * Pickup Experience: 4/10

    Photos
    Fellow Mountain Cafe - Interior behind the counter

    Interior behind the counter

    Fellow Mountain Cafe - Special Corned Beef Hash

    Special Corned Beef Hash

    Fellow Mountain Cafe - The Lockwood

    See all

    The Lockwood

    Catskills Bake Works - bakeries - Updated July 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...