Weird experience, and not in a good way. Saw the Shepard Hills Tavern website and Instagram posts,…read morethought it looked good so booked a rez on Opentable for a Thursday night when they were supposedly serving dinner. One must navigate a badly graded narrow gravel road with several hairpin twists and turns and no lighting to get there. Not what I expected. The lovely stone clubhouse, verdant golf course and lush flowers were welcome sights. We were greeted by a pleasant young server and shown to an outside table. Unfortunately the metal table had no covering and was quite dirty; even worse were the thin red chair pads that smelled of some very unpleasant PP-like substance. Eww. Since all of the other tables looked similar or were occupied and service was slow, we thought we'd stay put and make the best of it - but also planned to shower in hot water soon afterward. We were given single sheet paper menus showing a limited selection, but our hopes were raised (and then dashed) when we saw the statement "ask your server about dinner specials and desserts." Well we asked - only to be told there were no such offerings except maybe on weekends. I had a nice fresh Greek salad and tiny dried out chicken wings. Hubby had a bland grilled chicken sandwich with fries. Iced tea tasted canned not brewed. We finished our meals, and as night descended we were the only ones left outside with our server MIA. After over 15 minutes of waiting we finally went inside the clubhouse to find our server socializing among a hopping bar scene of locals. Guess she forgot about us. While some restaurants are using post-COVID staff shortages as an excuse for slow and limited service, this bizarre experience went way beyond that rationale. Accordingly, we we will not risk life or limb to brave the winding road up to Shepard Hills Tavern again anytime soon.

Just had the BEST Fathers Day at Shepherd Hills- the food ( outrageous) the service (fantastic) and…read moreas an awesome bonus was great music-the prices for the amazing amount of food was very reasonable besides delicious! Big thanks to Rich and Peg for pulling off a venue like this to bring the community together- and for anyone else who happened to be here today- Could not have been any better- highly recommend !!!

Probably the highlight of our trip to the Catskills. Everyone was so friendly and we loved the…read more"Hate Had No Place Here" sign. So come as your are! The beer is flavorful and I recommend "hooking up" your Brookie. Think Michelada, but with more citrus. They have a set menu for snacks so not really a place for a full meal. However, check the website as they seem to have rotating food vendors. We had the vegan nachos with Indian flavors which was amazing. It's a small space but that adds to the charm! Lots of outside seating, hunter lounge feels, and friendly staff with their mascot cat.

We have been wanting to stop in for a while now based on recommendations from friends…read more We finally got to stop in after hiking a section of Devil's Path with our dogs. We arrived about 2 hours after opening on a Saturday afternoon in August and it was pretty packed. Since we had the dogs with us so we searched for a shady spot on a sunny afternoon so that they would be comfortable. Luckily we found one! The beer was good. We really enjoyed the Catch & Release, Mountain Life and the Dutchie. The basil in the Dutchie was really refreshing! We purchased Mountain Life and Dutchie in cans. The food was definitely not the highlight. They told us they were very behind and that the pizza would take an hour or more. They also wouldn't take our order initially because they had no buzzers left. We came back two times to see if any buzzers had come back. We ended up ordering the smash burger, the chicken sando, and fries. This order took about 20-25 mins. The Smash burger had a nice caramelization. The chicken sando was tasty, but not worth the wait. We will be back!

Don't order the fish! I had the Baked Cod - it was really off-tasting (something you don't want in…read moreseafood!), overly fishy and unpleasant. My dining companions ordered the short rib, which was much tastier and tender. Perhaps this is one of the places that exceeds when it comes to "turf", but you should avoid the "surf." I also ordered an asparagus soup, which was too salty, but had the texture of a bean/split pea soup. They also served generous pours of wines and had friendly service, otherwise. Keep in mind this is a very pricey establishment. For a dining party of 3 people, our bill was nearly $200 for something very middle range -- it's not the glitzy-est of atmospheres for that high price. Instead, it was dark, dank and basement-like. I expected more affordable pub style food with that feel.

The restaurant is cute & warm, an actual old mill. Our 1st time to Roxbury NY & a last minute trip…read moreto celebrate our 18th wedding anniversary. We walked in without a reservation. We were seated within 10 minutes which was very nice but the waitress/host seemed a bit annoyed. To be fair there were only 2 women serving the bar & restaurant and as someone in the service business, it's not easy BUT it's not an excuse just understandable. THE FOOD...it was good but I was disappointed in my Smoked Duck app which had three small thin slices of duck. The apricot vinaigrette was the star of the dish. The scalloped potatoes were good & were not soaked in cream & butter which I liked. Hubby had his go to drink, a Manhattan and it was ok. His entree was Pasta Carbonara, it was very good. All in all 3-stars maybe 4 because the ambiance was romantic or maybe that was us LOL.

Had a nice lunch at Jacks Pub. We started with cheese jalapeños which were deep fried to a really…read morenice crunchiness. I ordered the fish sandwich which came with fries and my friend had the Rubin sandwich. Everything was perfectly cooked and served. We were a bit amazed because the Bartender did everything from greeting to cooking to cleaning up. Definitely worth the trip.

Easily the best salad around! "Jack's Salad" is perfection!…read more I've also heard that their burgers are great!

We attended an event yesterday in Bovina. Then ended the evening at the Hidden Inn, with receiving…read moreexceptional service and accommodations as we had a larger party than expected with the reservations we had. They totally made us feel welcome and accommodated our needs. The food was delicious and arrived at the table all at once. We could not have asked for anything better. We will be returning, to this very comfortable establishment.

The Hidden Inn is an amazing restaurant (with guest rooms upstairs) in a very picturesque part of…read morethe Catskills. Great menu and wine list and a terrific professional team working there. Just a really nice place in the country worth traveling for!

We love it here such a great place the prime rib is to die for…read more Service is great Ambiance is great

I had high hopes for this place given the mostly positive reviews on Yelp. Unfortunately, my family…read moreand I were sorely disappointed. We came here on a Wednesday evening at 6pm and there were fewer than 10 people seated (not including a half a dozen or so at the bar). We had two young kids with us so we ordered quickly in hopes we could get the kids settled, fed and back in the car before they started acting like kids. We ordered chicken fingers and fries for the kids, wings and French onion soup for ourselves followed by a cheesesteak and a cheeseburger. We did not see a single piece of food until 7pm. Literally - one hour from when we ordered until even the kids food showed up. We asked the waitress to check on everything about 45 minutes into the evening and could hear the chef say, "you tell them it'll be out when it's ready". Two stars rather than one because when the food did finally show up it was mostly good. The wings were great, the cheesesteak was great - the burger was tragic, borderline inedible. It tasted like it had been grilled directly on charcoal that was doused in lighter fluid. I'd have sent it back if I wasn't 100% sure we'd end up waiting another hour for a replacement. I'm fairly certain this place won't care about this review - but I hope if you're reading this you'll be dissuaded from wasting your time, money and energy and look to any of a number of other amazing restaurants in the area that serve great food and provide amazing service.

Wow! What a place. The appetizers were fantastic and their chicken sandwich was incredible. They…read morealso have a good beer selection and a great outdoor area to sit in. They are also dog friendly outside! I'll be sure to return!

Stopped by for some quick snacks and drinks, and it was a great little spot to relax! The staff was…read moreincredibly friendly and welcoming, which made the experience even better. Our food came out surprisingly fast....I wasn't sure if it had been prepared ahead of time and just needed to be heated, but it was good enough for a quick bite. The atmosphere is casual and inviting, making it a nice place to catch up with friends, share a few appetizers, and enjoy some drinks. Overall, it's a fun spot if you're looking for a laid back place to grab a quick bite and have a good time with friends.

The food was delicious. I had the Mezzo plate and a spinach salad. Both great, but what was even…read morebetter was our server! He was attentive, funny and accommodating. The ambiance was typical pub/tavern. Nothing fancy, just what I was looking for. Highly recommend.

Stopped in for a snack drink . Best nachos very tasty. Excellent longgg island drink. I everyone…read moreneeds to stop by

Hey Hey! Claire B signing in! I just had to hop on my yelp app and share about my amazing time at…read moreBluestone! I had my first Jameson Pickle shot and woohoo; it was rough. My hubby has to drive me back! Still Drunk! Anyways lol, ask for Laurel and Liam they were my bartender and they took care! Signing out, Claire B!

It was our first time at the Blue Stone Restaurant. Chef Bill and staff prepared a fantastic…read morebuffet!! The wait staff was attentive and atmosphere was great. We and our friends will definitely be returning soon! Ken D

Great food. Cozy atmosphere. Wonderful drink selection. Friendly and attentive service.read more

Best veggie burger in the area IMO, and their beef burger can hold its own against any of the big…read moreguys. Crisp fresh fries made to order. Amazing wings (I suggest ordering them dry and getting all of the sauces on the side.) Great selection of local beers and ciders. Service can be a bit slow, however, it is definitely worth the wait. If weather permits, I suggest sitting outdoors.