Wow, thats what I've got for you folks wow. Lets start with ambiance, its cute here i loved it. Its a small, quaint little downstairs with more space upstairs. The decor is spot on, just so nice all around! Let's go on to the service. I'm going to shout out Caleb he was great all around very attentive. Answered all my annoying questions haha. Really fantastic. The wait times for food were just right, didn't take too long but didn't rush you. So now for me to talk way too much. OH MY GOD THE FOOD! This is easily the best food I've had in southern delaware. Hands down, full stop. I got a blackened catfish over a red beet salad. The fish was fresh! Yes fresh in February I'm impressed. The blackened seasoning was so good, just spicy enough to make me smile but not too spicy to be unpleasant. Flaky and perfectly cooked I was not disappointed in any way or another. How about the salad? Well, it was a kale salad which I'm not normally a fan of. But the elements of the salad were perfect, the toasted walnuts, the beets, apples, just everything about married in flawless harmony. Even my mother-in-law agreed the kale salad was great. 10/10, 5/5, whatever you want to call it this was an out of the park experience! Drinks, a new addition to my review this week haha. The bar tenders do a "great pour" per my wife and father-in-law. Me, I stick with non-alcoholic and oh man they nailed that too. This is just all good, like whole thing is great. Thank you for an awesome lunch, keep rolling folks! read more

Catch 54 - My wife's delightful valentines day lunch. - Seafood Near Me - Selbyville, Delaware

See all

As you can see from my many prior reviews this is one of my top 3 restaurants for happy hour and dinner. I will summarize my two most recent family dinners here during the Thanksgiving and Christmas weekends: Marlene took our 5:30 PM dinner reservation over the phone. I was here with my family of nine including two children for Friday night dinner after Thanksgiving day upstairs at a corner table. I started with my spicy margarita for $14. We also shared a bottle of Duckhorn Decoy Brut champagne for $52, which was reduced down to $26 by 50% off due to Friday 50% off on all wine bottles. The Decoy brut champagne was excellent. We also shared and enjoyed the crab dip for $21. We also shared and enjoyed three dozen raw oysters samplers for a total of $81. I also enjoyed my crispy duck confit special with pappardelle, basil pesto, fried onion and garlic chilli vinaigrette for $32. My total bill was $455 excluding gratuity. Morelia C. (nicknamed Mo) served us very well as usual despite us having two children. We first met Mo, when she bartended at the downstairs bar, when we were here prior for many Sunday afternoon happy hours. We returned here again with my larger family of 14 including five children for dinner on the Saturday after Christmas. We had a 5:30 PM dinner reservation. We were again seated immediately upstairs. I started with and enjoyed my two Makers Mark Manhattans up for $15 each. We also shared and enjoyed two dozen raw oysters samplers for $27 per dozen. We also ordered and enjoyed one dozen of the more expensive Raspberry Points for $48. Raspberry Point Oysters are premium, cold-water farmed oysters from Prince Edward Island (PEI), Canada, prized for their firm meat, distinct briny flavor with a sweet finish, and deep cups, taking 5-7 years to mature in New London Bay's tidal waters. They're known for being easy to shuck and popular in gourmet settings due to their consistent quality and appealing salty-sweet profile. We also shared the calamari for $17 and the devilled eggs for $19. I also enjoyed my confit lamb shank for $38. Caleb M. served us very well despite us having five children. My total bill was $737 excluding gratuity. Caleb applied our Indian River High School band 10% discount to our bill, which reduced the total from $737 down to $663 excluding gratuity. On Sunday's our favorite bartender is Nick C. Nick said hello, when we visited during the Thanksgiving holiday. We will continue to return here with family and friends for happy hour, lunch or dinner. read more

See all

Great food with a view! We had wonderful dinners and the one with serious gluten issues was treated very well. There was a dedicated allergen menu and we were told many dishes could be prepared specially without gluten ingredients. We were also pleased to find non-alcoholic Prosecco and it was half price bottle night! read more

Catch 54 - Butternut squash risotto with pickled mushrooms - delicious and gluten free - Seafood Near Me - Selbyville, Delaware

See all

We sat upstairs and it has a really great vibe. Our waiter recommended the crab deviled eggs. Great! Also had the scallop fried rice, add tuna. A winner!! Ordered a dozen oysters that were exceptional. The service was perfect. Highly recommend read more

Catch 54 - Crab DEVILED EGGS - Seafood Near Me - Selbyville, Delaware

the last person I would want to be the face of my business is the hostess at catch 54. Just such a nasty attitude. Like I have walked into her kitchen as she was eating breakfast. Never been pleasant or offered a smile. Fortunately for the restaurant the rest of the staff is friendly and the food is good. For her I would suggest a job where she doesn't have to deal with the public. read more

We had a nice experience at Catch 54. No reservations, so we arrived early in the evening. Upon arrival, we were promptly seated. The ambiance is clean and stylish. Good choice of music playing too! Our service was excellent. As far as the food, everything was excellent. My wife and I started with the Pan Roasted clams and a nice little summer salad, with tomatoes, fresh mozzarella and watermelon. We decided to both go with the Swordfish, On their "Fish Board" menu. The flavor was on point, with a southwest flair. I was impressed with the freshness and tenderness of the swordfish. Other than the Mocktail that my wife ordered which she felt lacked the flavor that was the described, everything was excellent. read more

Catch 54 - Swordfish, "Fish Board" Menu item. - Seafood Near Me - Selbyville, Delaware

I've been missing out! My new favorite happy hour in the area. We've been coming to Selbyville now for years and typically frequent all of the same bars/restaurants. I was looking for good happy hours in the area and the daily buck-a-shuck at Catch 54, open (4pm) - 6pm. We arrived 10 minutes before open to give us the best chance to get a group of bar seats and there were already some guests waiting at the door. Once they opened we headed right up their spiral staircase and to the bar that exhibited beautiful bay views. We started with a Vodka Martini, Grapefruit Crush, Orange Crush and a Margarita - all $8 on HH. I definitely recommend the Grapefruit Crush as they were delicious and we ordered a few more throughout our visit. This being our first time here we had to order a wide variety of Happy Hour food to try a bunch of things. We started with 12 oysters and they were so fresh (also loved the SoDel Shuckin' Sauce). Wings were crispy and delicious, and I really enjoyed the sticky honey drizzle (I can see them not being for everyone if you're more of a traditional Buffalo style). The Happy Hour burger ($12 + $2 to add fries) was phenomenal featuring a thick, juicy, perfectly cooked patty, lettuce, red onions, and ripe tomatoes. I'd come back for the burger and oysters alone. The Buttermilk Fried Calamari was also a hit as it was lightly battered, flash fried and incredibly tender. On top of the food and drinks being great, the bartenders were also both very nice. They had no problems talking to us when they weren't busy making drinks. They also gave some other local recommendations for us to try. My mom enjoyed everything so much she said she wants to come back again with dinner reservations. Catch 54 will definitely be a new regular added to our bar/restaurant rotations and I'm sure we'll be back again this year before the week is over. I can't say enough about how great our experience was yesterday evening. read more

See all

My parents and my partner and my favorite new local spot to go to really sad about my SIL and our experience as she now is afraid to come back to Papa grande or a sideline restaurant because it was a rough day for her waiting in the parking lot an hour. That review posted on PG. but anyways we love the oyster happy hours and end up ordering the entire menu and come back at least 2-3 times in a week when we're in town. (With the other days we go to Matt's fish camp) read more

See all

We're back for our third Happy Hour visit with our extended family, Mom, dad, sis and the 4 boys. The food is amazing here! Dollar oysters are the big draw for us, but quickly matched by the roasted mussels! But the other apps and happy hour specials - wings, calamari, burgers, are All excellent too. They have draft beet specials and delicious. Now the service - every server we've has been excellent but our past 2 visits we've been served by Peyton who is AMAZING! Covered the menus thoroughly, lots of great recommendations and dealt with our chaotic crew and big crazy orders. I owe her a 5-stars review from last time too - sorry I dropped the Ball Peyton. Highest recommendation- we will be back soon! Beautiful design and views too! read more

Catch 54 - Roasted mussels in a Creamy sauce. - Seafood Near Me - Selbyville, Delaware

See all

We had a great experience at Catch 54. We came on a recommendation of a co-worker and were happy we did. Catch 54 offered amazing happy hour specials including some of the best calamari we've ever eaten. The restaurant itself is very pretty and had a nice water view. All of the staff that we interacted with were friendly and professional. This place has their service down pat. We got burgers, calamari, shrimp, wings, and fries and were extremely pleased with everything. The food came out hot and cooked perfectly. We will be back next year when vacationing in Fenwick. read more

Catch 54 - Happy Hour Appetizers - Seafood Near Me - Selbyville, Delaware

Wowee, this was delicious. Arrived after the boat parade in December. Was seated fairly quickly at a table overlooking the water. It was dark but there are enough lights around to see a little bit. We started with the Oysters Rockefeller and they were phenomenal. For our mains. We got the chowder and the rainbow trout special. Both were incredibly delicious down to the last bite. For desert, we had the apple crisp which was just ok but still good. Can't wait to come back! There is a tiny parking lot out front (maybe 10 cars), street parking, or a bigger lot a little bit down the road. read more

Catch 54 - Oysters rockerfeller - Seafood Near Me - Selbyville, Delaware

See all

We have been back several time mrs and each was just great! Brought my fiancé here for pre valentine day and food and service were spectacular! Just happy every time I eat here! read more

Perfect beach front spot. We got a table on the patio, enjoyed a glass of crisp cold Rose wine while waiting on food. I ordered the crab cake sandwich because welllll when in Maryland, thats you should do. It was FAT and delish. Upgraded to fries and were ok but a sad little pile. The massive crab patty made up for it though so 5 stars for the crab. read more

We loved the lively atmosphere & the food was amazing! Caleb was our server and he provided exceptional service recommending all of the dishes. The crab cakes tasted like they came straight from the sea. The fresh fish was exceptional. We went with the tuna, crusted halibut, and salmon. All were delicious! We ended the meal with the key lime tart and the blueberry bread pudding with a scoop of peanut butter ice cream. Both were delicious! This will go on our list of MUST GO-TO places when we come to the beach! read more

See all

Becoming another favorite we had a party of four and reservations for 4:30 we arrived a little early and were seated immediately! Another great dinner for us. My BIL had the Salmon which came with a chutney. My SIL decided on the Southern Fried Chicken very tender lightly breaded and crispy With whipped potatoes and a bacon corn gravy in the side and farm beans. My better half had Buttermilk Fried Shrimp Salt Fries , Coleslaw, Cocktail Sauce of course she ordered a side of melted butter! I ordered the Jumbo Shrimp and Parmasean Grits Andouille Sausage , Trinity , Tomato- Beer Jus & Rosemary Butter! Another great meal for all of us! Great friendly service and you can't beat the views of the Bays in Fenwick Island BUTTERMILK FRIED JUMBO SHRIMP read more

See all

Food: this is what a restaurant is all about right next to service. Food is worth the price. The food is not bad, however; you can go to other places that have a better menu and cheaper. Service is is not friendly or accommodating. Ambiance is ok because of the bay view. That's about it they want to present a higher end vibe without good service and great food. Save yourself the trip. read more

When was the best local restaurants in our area. Food is fresh. And the menu is diverse. Services always. First class. And the location is lovely. Especially during the summer seasons. They are one of a few restaurants that stays open in offseason which is really appreciated by the residence. The wine selection is outstanding. A must go to place by all residents and guests. read more

What a gem! Love this restaurant in Fenwick. Great happy hour from 4-6. Cute bar surrounded by a few high top table. I tried the buck a shuck oysters. They were delicious! The spicy Rita for $8 was great to was down those oysters. I also tried the cheeseburger. It was cooked to a perfect medium rare and very flavorful. I highly recommend if you're in the Fenwick area. The also have seating upstairs with nice views of the bay. read more

See all

Fantastic vibe overall! The food was delicious & you can't beat their happy hour prices & food offerings. The view is beautiful and service was impeccable! read more

Great burger, great chicken and great oysters!! Thanks Peyton for the awesome service!!! read more

Catch 54 - Seafood Near Me - Selbyville, Delaware

See all

My wife and I had dinner here with some family members while visiting them. The restaurant sits by the water and offers beautiful views of the bay. There is a lower and upper level of dining ateas. The food here is very good. I had the blackened salmon with mashed potatoes. It was delicious and not too spicy. My wife had the broiled salmon with boiled potatoes, also very good. There is a clam and oyster bar offering locally caught oysters and clams. The service is friendly and attentive. The dining areas are very clean but a little on the tight side. Prices are on the higher end but it's to be expected because the area is touristy, especially during the summer months. Parking can be difficult to find due to the very small parking lot. Thankfully there are nearby parking lots as alternatives. Reservation are highly recommended. I definitely recommend this restaurant especially for group gatherings. read more

See all

We came for dinner and were seated upstairs via the spiral staircase, however, there is an elevator. Our server was awesome. She was friendly and showed us the specialty drink options and told us about the appetizers. As always, we ordered the oysters and they were so good with no shells! The deviled eggs were good and we also loved the calamari. I had the crab cakes and loved them and the cucumber salad was so fresh. Our other dinner orders were a rice bowl with an egg on top, a chicken Caesar salad, tuna entree and shrimp with clams. Every single person absolutely loved everything they ordered. For dessert my husband ordered the lemons cake - I said I only was only going to have a couple bites but ended up eating almost all of it! The service here could not have been any better. The place is beautiful with seating upstairs and down and plenty of parking. Can't wait to come back! read more

See all

We absolutely loved this place! (We were pains in the ass when it came to being 1st time patrons here) We wanted outside atmosphere. We had a rese..but we were late getting into Fenwick, nevertheless they were so~ sweet & accommodating! They sat us at a beautiful table overlooking the water. Our waitress was amazing & extremely efficient, lemondrop martinis were chefs , food was delish & I give them a 10/10 ! We will definitely be back! read more

Food is decent. Parking is atrocious and while the atmosphere is great is super loud.

I recently visited Catch 54 with my family, and unfortunately, our experience was marred by the treatment we received from the older female hostess. Upon arriving, my 6 year old was excited for a steak, but our enthusiasm quickly faded when we encountered the older hostess. She seemed less than welcoming and made it clear that having kids with us was a problem. When we asked for a happy hour table, she informed me and the 6 year old that it would be "at least an hour wait" but we could immediately have a full-priced menu, so the 6 year old and I left the restaurant. To make matters worse, my husband (who had been in the car with a napping kid) decided to go inside without the kids to see if he could grab a table. To our surprise, he was seated at a happy hour table within five minutes. This stark contrast in treatment felt unfair and left us feeling unwelcome as a family. The way we were treated by the older hostess was disheartening - I guess she was never a child herself whose family liked happy hour prices like the tables full of campers downing cheap oysters and lite beers. It's disappointing when a dining experience is overshadowed by poor service, especially when it comes from someone in a position of hospitality. That being said, the younger hostess (name began with an S) was kind and seemed to have much more empathy for us, our actual server (one of the male bartenders) was great. I hope Catch 54 can address this issue - and let me be explicitly clear - I understand that wait times are estimates and thing change quickly, but this was not one of those times - the attitude and lack of an sense of hospitality were palpable from the older hostess. read more

This is a lovely restaurant on the bay. The pineapple martini and espresso martini were refreshing and light. The oysters were delicious and fresh. The service was good and the restaurant had clean, open layout with lots of windows. It was really nice to step outside to enjoy the view of the bay afterwards. read more

See all

I love this place! My family has been coming here for years. It's so consistent and good. Tonight, we had a server named Katie who was so great! We were overwhelmed by a swarm of mosquitoes on the back deck and were able to find seats inside. read more

What a beautiful restaurant! My friend suggested Catch 54 even though they only take reservations up to 6 p.m. When we got there, we waited about 20 minutes before we were seated (we had been told it would be a 30-minute wait). The booths were comfy and spacious , and the view of the bay was lovely. We started with the crab deviled eggs which were delicious although there wasn't a ton of crab. The entree was my favorite part of the meal. The day boat scallops fried rice was different, a little spicy, and delicious especially with a sunny side egg on top. We ended our meals with the honey cream cheese poundcake. The maple anglaise and brown butter crumb was the perfect combination especially with the scoop of vanilla ice cream on top. Our server couldn't have been any nicer and gave us good recommendations. A wonderful meal all around! read more

See all

An amazing local restaurant with beautiful views of the Assowoman Bay in Delaware. Their food is always simple but delicious! Consistent every time with a great Happy Hour and very friendly professional staff. Off season they have specials every day of the week. If you at the beach make sure you it's in your plans to stop in and have some great food! They post on FB they daily specials. read more

Catch 54 - Crab cake off season special - Seafood Near Me - Selbyville, Delaware

If you want a view of the marsh and some lovely bird life -- this is the spot for you! Tons of seating and a bar in the back..! You can sit outside too--- may be a bit breezy but you can bring a little sweater. They have outdoor heaters too! I had a Pom fizz-- it's on the tart side. Definitely not sweet. I thought it would be lighter but it's dense with all pomegranate juice. Loved my refreshing farmer's bowl with grilled shrimp! read more

See all

LOVED it here! They don't take reservations so .. good luck on a busier evening. I thought a place like this would but luckily we didn't have to wait for more than 25 minutes. It's a huge place with a couple of bars. It's definitely a beach coastal vibe but tastefully done. We sat upstairs and our server was awesome. She was helpful with making food selections. The salad was massive but so good. We got clams and they were on the smaller side but the broth was so good we were sopping it up with the bread. The seafood stew was a huge portion but I felt it lacked flavor. The views are stunning especially at sunset. Recommend if in the area. read more

See all

Good seafood in a casual setting Parking is the biggest problem so we usually only visit off season

Well. I wish I could say I tried the food. It looks really good on their website. Studied the menu and knew exactly what I wanted. So I get there for a bit early for my reservation (I am anxious you know) and then it hits me. BAM! There is no parking to be found anywhere! Not in the lot, not on the street. Across the street there is a plethora of signage telling you where NOT to park. Being disabled, I cannot park way down the street and walk 3 blocks to get there. I had to cancel my reservation using my phone. I hope someone else enjoyed my spot. What a complete let down. Oh well, I guess you can say it is very popular when looking as how all of the parking was taken up. Just be warned about the situation and plan accordingly. Good luck, I sure didn't have any. read more

The service was great staff friendly. The place is clean. This place has the honor of being the first bad restaurant we ever ate at in Sussex county!! We were very dissatisfied and disappointed the reviews are not honest reflection of our experience. But foood ick. We were disappointed they ran out of fish and chips at 530 on a Sunday! We ordered salad and shrimp instead. Both were bland ok no flavor. Salad greens. needs to be washed The calamari appetizer was over cooked and a bit chewy We ordered profiteroles dessert. The filling was watery. The outside shell stale soggy and tasted old. We could not finish anything! Go eat some where else. This place is not for foodies. read more

My sister and I went here for dinner and it was amazing. We started with oysters which had amazing flavor. The appetizer also came out quick which was great because we were very hungry. For my entree I went with the Country Fried Chicken, which is something I typically wouldn't order at a restaurant. I'm glad I went with our server's recommendation because I loved it. The gravy on top was so so good. The chicken was crispy and juicy. Our server was great and made sure we were enjoying everything and was very quick to refill drinks. We sat right next to the water, which gave us a great view of the sunset while enjoying our meal. I have been here in the past with larger groups and haven't had the best experience. This took a turn for the best and will definitely be back next summer! read more

Catch 54 - Southern Fried Chicken - Seafood Near Me - Selbyville, Delaware

See all

I regularly patronize Catch 54 but have concerns over the food quality my last 2 visits. Most recently I had their Sunday night Chicken Parmesan. The chicken was overcooked that the edges were burned and the chicken was dried out. There was no cheese on the chicken at all and not enough sauce to even make it bearable to eat. Very disappointed read more

Super cool atmosphere right on the water. A great spot for scenic views and pictures during dinner. The food was pretty good. Not the best seafood we have had down here but overall good. The crab bombs had a good amount of crabmeat but the texture was a bit off for me. The add on chicken was a lot of chicken and the add on shrimp was only 4 pieces. We all liked the apps and the cocktails. Service was excellent. We sat outside on the dock and had about a 20 min wait for 5 people on a Friday night. I'd go back here for sure! read more

See all

We got food poisoning from the oysters they served us. However opened them up should know the difference between a good one and a not good one. read more

What a cool spot with both indoor and outdoor space for drinks and diner. We were greeted by a very accommodating hostess and picked the outdoor dining first level. The server was great and very knowledgeable about the menu specials wine and cocktails. The dishes were very tasty perfectly seasoned and came out hot. Portions are generous and a good value. Get there early if you want a dining location preference. We'll done ! read more

See all

We came in on Thursday night, when they were offering an amazing 25% off. Went to the main floor bar which was hopping. Immediately greeted by friendly bartender. We soon got the perfect outdoor table. Our server was really friendly, knowledgeable and fun! Great food all around! I love soft shell crabs and they saved the last ones for me. Yummy crab cakes. Everything was great!!! read more