What a pleasant surprise. We were just passing through. This diner has such a cool feel to it. The food was so good. The huevos rancheros was amazing. Our server was so polite and attentive. I would highly recommend this diner. read more

Catalina's Diner - Huevos rancheros with a mimosa - Italian Near Me - Elizabeth, Colorado

See all

Have taken out here before but never dined in. Very good experience. Good was great and the dining area is much bigger than I expected. Will continue to carry out and dine in. read more

We ordered delivery while at EBC . Husband had the western burger and he said "that's a good burger"...I went with the pizza. We are happy. read more

Service was excellent. The steak breakfast skillet was delicious. Kids ordered the chicken and waffles. The gravy was good, but the chicken and waffle were just ok. Would definitely come here again. read more

What a cute little place! Decided to take a morning motorcycle ride out east from Aurora and saw this place on the map and decided to stop for brunch. So glad we did...it was excellent! Service, food, atmosphere and pricing are all wonderful. If you ever want a small town quaint brunch spot this is the place to go! read more

See all

My family & I visited this restaurant this morning. My son lives in Elizabeth & we were visiting his family & decided to eat breakfast here. The food was great! I had hash browns & the serving was huge and good. I also had bacon & once again another huge serving. Sourdough toast finished off my meal. My DIL had French toast & said it was really good & my son had a Denver omelet & another rave. There is a sign on the dining tables stating there can be a 30 minute wait because they use fresh foods. The service was excellent. We will definitely come back here next time we're in CO. read more

We ate at Catalina's twice while we were in town visiting our son. Both times the food, service and atmosphere were great. It is a quaint restaurant with friendly people who are so accommodating! Will definitely be back read more

Great food, great service. It was very quiet and clean. Nice selection of sandwiches and love the all day breakfast options.

Great food and good people I've been going here for many years. It is quick service unless restaurants really busy and the food is always incredible. I recommend it. read more

Our waitress was awesome. Food was awesome. I love that they have signs on the tables telling you to be patient they actually make their food from scratch so it's not gonna be quick and I love that. If I wanted processed quick food I'd go to McDonald's. Will be back cause their menu is massive and I saw a bunch I would love to try! read more

Great service and food. Excellent bloody marry. Waitress was great and personable. Open Sundays until 1

Dinner was not good at all, my wife ordered the Buffalo chicken salad and I ordered the special, Chicken fried steak. The buffalo chicken in her salad was processed pre frozen chicken nuggets (YUCK). My Chicken fried steak was the same, A pre frozen processed chicken fried steak (YUCK). We have had breakfast at Catalinas before and it was good, however our dinner experience was just awful could have stayed home and heated up a couple of Banquet frozen meals and had the same result as eating dinner at Catalina's read more

Super neat interior. A lot more seating room than I expected. Waiter was Jonny on the spot. Even after asking for a few more minutes, he noticed when we put down our menus and took our order. I ordered the eggs, meat and Bacon. Wifey got the ranchero burrito. A very pleasant experience and we will go back. read more

Love this little gem! With a traditional diner feel, this mom-and-pop restaurant is all about the details. The hop-up bar seating has character. The dining room has a massive fireplace. We had breakfast - chicken fried steak.... YUM! The only criticism we have were that the homemade biscuits weren't very good. Recommend! read more

See all

I've loved everything that I've had here! They have a very wide range of options which is nice for a family dinner so everyone can get what they feel like. I usually get their Italian food either the manicotti or the lasagna and they're both delicious but I've also had their street tacos and I've had their burgers and both were very good as well! Its located right in the town of Elizabeth and is a great place for lunch or dinner. read more

The Best!! We eat at Catalina's 2 to 3 times a week. Everything is great! We love the staff. Javier always makes us feel welcome.

Everything is delicious. EVERYTHING! You can't be disappointed here. Javier is the best, he'll make you feel at home. And Catalina is just the cutest! read more

There is something for everyone! Love going here with my daughter that is gluten free. I have not had a bad thing there!

I stopped by for breakfast. The service was excellent. The omelet was quite large, and well cooked. My instructions on the toast were followed correctly, as were they on the hash browns. The hash browns were a bit greasier than I would have liked. I really enjoyed the green chile here (it is a great accompaniment ti the eggs). I do think the price on the breakfast sides/add ons could be a little lower. read more

Catalina's Diner - Eggs Benedict - Italian Near Me - Elizabeth, Colorado

Our first time here. We ordered breakfast and it was outstanding! It was fresh and delicious! My husband saw a burger and fries go past as we were leaving and asked if the fries were made fresh. When he was told, "...yes they were cut fresh , in house!" I think he would have sat right back down and had lunch. We'll definitely be back to try lunch! read more

Dis place is da bomb!!!!!!! The people are so friendly, the atmosphere is awesome and the food is out of this world amazing!! We will be back!!!! read more

As always great food and service. We haven't been here in over a year. I had a Buffalo chicken salad Spivey but so yummy. My husband had his go to the patty melt. We can't wait to go back again soon. read more

We have been coming to Catalina's for years. It has changed ownership a few times since we started dining here. This ownership is by far the best. Great food, and great service. My wife loves the Eggs Benedict. The cornbeef hash is my favorite. read more

Always love the food. Especially the breakfast burritos or the eggs Benedict. The service is great. Breakfast or lunch. Never disappointed.

We so wanted to like this place. It's clean, menu has it all, and small town business....what's not to like. Turns out, the food. Alas, service was mediocre (we asked for opinions about what to get and the young girl was polite but distracted and apathetic) so we both ordered burgers. Reviews showed some frustrations over how long it took to get food. Our food came out reasonably quickly, although the burgers out were 5 minutes before the fries which was a bit frustrating. The fries are hand cut and they were pretty good. The beer was cold (only one draft choice, but Stella was ok for me). The burgers were awful. I ordered a patty melt which showed a burger with cheese and onions on grilled sour dough. When the server brought it out it was a nice thick burger sitting on lightly toasted (not grilled) sour dough bread. We were waiting on the fries anyhow, so I explained I was expecting grilled sour dough as described in the menu, and asked her if that was how they normally served a patty melt? She pointed at my plate and said that's how we always do them. Oh well, I can deal with that, but when I later bit into my luke-warm burger (after waiting for the fries) it was so dry I could barely chew it without sipping my beer to swallow. First bite resulted in a big chunk of gristle which I had to spit into my napkin. My wife had the same gristly experience as she ate hers, and if anything hers was even dryer than mine. Both were unseasoned and flavorless as well. What a shame. We won't be back anytime soon. read more

Good atmosphere. The food: Cheeseburger and onion rings and a beef burrito. If you can't say anything nice, don't say anything at all!

Ate here twice. 1st breakfast I ordered was eggs, hash Browns & bacon with sour dough toast. Nothing special but it is the regular go to breakfast. 2nd time I wanted something with more flavor. I ordered Huevos Rancheros. Yummy! Very flavorful. This place was very clean with friendly servers. Large menu with lots of variety to choose from. Not a favorite in my book but it does have old school diner charm with friendly people. Not half bad! I say try it! read more

I really tried to like this place. The last two visits were not good. The ones prior were good... not great but not horrible. One visit the staff was very unorganized and it took 30 to get our order taken. Only half the restaurant was filled and no one was waiting to be seated, so not sure why it took that long. Then when we finally got our order taken, we waited almost an hour for our meal and it's wasn't "fresh out of the oven." The second time we went everyone in our party got sick. We were a group of 5 each time. It's too bad for us that service went down because it would be a convenient local spot. read more

Great service, clean, and good food. Great locally owned joint. We had the Alfredo (delicious) street taco special, eggs Benedict, and ice cream. It was all superb. read more

The first time I went here was for Pizza and wings - they were really tasty. Had a beer to wash the goodness down and all was great. The second time I went here with my wife for breakfast and I have to admit - it was really good. You will not find any fancy foods like French baguette French toast with peanut butter and strawberry jam (bonus points for the person who knows where to find this exotic delight). Only good old American favorites here! Had two eggs with hash browns, a biscuit and one fluffy pancake. And everything was of gargantuan proportions and inexpensive prices. I did forget to mention the homemade gravy which enhanced that biscuit ten-fold! read more

Our family enjoyed an early lunch here, everything was pretty good. The small town feel was great, I love that! The waitstaff was very friendly, and accommodating to our special requests. Overall, I would recommend this place for a quick bite to eat :) read more

Wonderful family oriented restaurant with all the right types of food for your comfort and enjoyment. Well worth the trip

We love Catalina's for breakfast, lunch and dinner! There are limited restaurant choices in Elizabeth and luckily they're all fairly good. The service here is good, the burgers great, Italian is their speciality and I have yet to find something I dont like. Husband loves the lasagna and a majority of food is homemade ...rare these days. Give it a try. I think it will surprise you. read more

Catalina's Diner - Lasagna - Italian Near Me - Elizabeth, Colorado

Have been here three times for breakfast and it is the food that keeps me coming back, definitely not the service. So first the service: always slow, but friendly. Never once have I arrived, been seated, and eaten in less than an hour, no matter what size a group I come in with. With that said, when the waitress finally arrives, they have always been friendly, attentive to our group's needs, and checked back often. The food is very good. I try something new each time and have always walked away full and with a smile on my face and needing a nap. My review is strictly for breakfast, not lunch or dinner, someday maybe. Pancakes are great and their burritos are of nice proportion and full of flavor. I think I end up paying around $16 for a burrito, coffee, large orange juice, and tip. So not cheap, but you really do get a lot of food for your buck. I live 15 minutes down the road, so the travel time is minimal. Would I make the trip if I lived in Denver? Maybe every so often. Watch your speed as you enter the city - police love to sit right below the hill and collect you cash donation. read more

Clean place with great service and a very diverse menu. We did breakfast for dinner. Mine was very good and my wife was just ok with hers. Felt hers was a little over done... That said, We took home a pizza for the kids, I snuck a slice and it was excellent. We'll be back for another visit. read more

This place used to be really good, when it was Constantino's. Since the new owners took over-not good. About a month ago we met friends for lunch. They ordered Mexican food, which tasted like Picante sauce. My fries were raw. Tonight, we ordered pizza. Terrible! The crust was burnt, no sauce and nasty tasting cheese. They are using cheap ingredients. Very disappointing. read more

What a cute place and great location in Elizabeth. I have to give our waitress tons of credit for going toe-to-toe with one of my dining companions - I believe she said something about him being a stalker (but that could be for a whole different review). He had fabulous things to say about the food. My meal was a good solid breakfast although there didn't seem to be enough seasonings today. I loved the potatoes. The pancakes and eggs were good. I'm glad that they served standard pancakes, anymore you go to a place and they get too fancy and start putting all kinds of crap in my pancakes. I also ordered the spicy Italian sausage - it was okay and not sure that it really went with breakfast. When I was ordering I was thinking about getting the biscuits and gravy, as I shouldn't eat these - ever - but I love them so much. But I'm glad that I didn't. My companion ordered the chicken fried steak with peppered gravy and eggs. So I got to the try the gravy anyway. I'm very very picky about the gravy and this didn't have a lot to it and found it very bland and I was wondering where the pepper was. You can also ask for a sample of the green chili - so we did. I'm glad that we did and we loved it. They said it was a little on the sweeter side but I found it be not be sweet at all. It has just a hint of heat and the green chili tasted like they just roasted it yesterday. Next time visit I will be sure to order something that is smothered in the green chili. read more

Delicious! My husband and I ate here for the first time last week and I keep thinking about it. I had the chicken burger with fries and jalapeño ranch. It was cooked perfectly! Sometimes I'm scared to get chicken sandwiches because they can be dry, but it was not the case at all. The jalapeño ranch is sooo addictive. My husband kept stealing it from me for his fries. I really didn't expect the place to be so big on the inside, but it was big and clean. Our server was on the ball and it was a great experience. We will definitely go back. read more

This place is hands down the best food in Elizabeth. I can't believe it doesn't have a higher star rating! Best PIZZA AND BURGERS. I can't wait to go back for a banana split! read more

This is our second time to Cosentino's. Both times, the food was awesome! I had the Italian Scramble, the hubby had the omelet stuffed (really stuffed!) with ham, sausage and other goodies. The problem both times was the service. I can cut them a bit of stack for our first visit as the place was completely packed. Unfortunately, when we visited today, it wasn't busy but our server wasn't very attentive. We may give Cosentino's one more try due to the great food, but if there is still a problem with the service, it'll be off our list of restaurants to support. read more