Transparency, I've only been here once, but that was enough for me to confidently give this Windermere pizza staple 5-stars. I'll explain why: - The pizza is the thinnest, most legit NYC pizza I've eaten in Orlando. I ordered a margherita pizza and it came out delicious, crispy and mega flavorful. - The 18-year-old pizza oven is constructed of heavy old bricks with a real fire and stone. - They serve ice cold Peroni which goes great with all foods Italian. - Finally, the owner and staff there are mega-friendly guys who are passionate about making pizza the right way. Plus, I found a nice little cozy spot off to the side and got some work done in an unexpectedly delightful new pizza shop for me, but a long-time piece of the Windermere scene. Bravo! read more

See all

The staff were always polite and gracious when calling in orders. If you order frequently from them, they seem to have a knack for remembering names well. It's in the same plaza as Walmart and China Garden. Parking is shared with all of the businesses but usually it's easy to find a spot to park. The pizzas are usually ready a little early to on time when they quote the timing. Flavors are good. Their wings are cooked well and have a good cook on them - I think they cook them in the same oven as the pizza? read more

My family loves Castello's. We love pizza and Castello's is where we go for good pizza. It is always consistently good. We go and pick ours up and the owner is always so friendly and inviting. He makes you feel like family and you can tell he takes great pride in the pizza he sells. Love Castello's! read more

Castello's Pizza | Windermere - Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Orlando, Florida

Really Italian style pizza! The best part n town! They deliver too! Try their supreme for a culinary challenge!

The pizza here is so good. If my family and I ever want to enjoy a lazy day, Castello's is our first choice for a pizza to enjoy at home - they also have seating inside if you prefer to dine-in! Very friendly people working here. Never had a bad experience or received a bad pizza. We do not plan on leaving this pizza shop anytime soon! read more

Castello's Pizza | Windermere - Pepperoni Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Orlando, Florida

My family is VERY particular about pizza. My husband and I were born and raised in Chicago and we prefer authentic cuisine over commercial brands. I never want pizza unless I'm in Chicago- until today. Today we tried Castello's! It's authentic, fresh and DELICIOUS. Courteous, welcoming staff as well! read more

Tried white gluten free pizza for 1st time. It was disappointing in that crust was burnt and the pizza had no real taste, unless u like lots of onions. I may try a different pizza before I make a final decision. read more

Great thin crust pizza Delivery service prompt and staff is friendly. Have never eaten in but seating appears adequate . read more

This is the second location that I tried and this one is awesome too. Great cheese pie, well done with light sauce. I also had a piece of a cheese calzone and some Caesar salad. Everything was on point. Good customer service and easy ordering makes me a fan. Super local business that I will definitely frequent again. read more

My brother in law and sister in law moved near Universal Studios from Windemere and we needed to find some good pizza. (Note: in Windemere , check out Stromboli's). I saw this place while waiting for my wife to get out of Walmart. Anywhooo...we ordered two large pies. The biggest they offer is 16". Which was plenty for the four of us. We ordered sausage and pepperoni on one and sausage, pepperoni, onion, peppers and mushrooms on the other. The delivery, just a few miles was faster than quoted and the driver was very nice. The pizza is pretty good by NY'er standards and very good by Orlando standards. The crust is very thin, crispy enough, and plenty of toppings. The sauce is good but it could maybe use a little bit more. Check em out! read more

Great pizza and wings! Variety of flavors. Delivery and pickup available! A must try! We love it!

Great pizza - super fresh. If you call on a Friday night make sure you call at least one hour before you want to eat. They are always super busy but definitely worth the wait. Sometimes we also get the Caesar Salad. When We call in they know our address and what we have ordered before so ordering is fast and easy. I'm giving it 5 stars as it's the best pizza we eat - I've never dined in the restaurant or ate anything else from there. read more

Castello's Pizza | Windermere - Siciliano pizza - Pizza Near Me - Orlando, Florida

See all

I love to support local businesses. Who I believe is the owner was compliant to COVID-19 suggestions and he was great. The gentleman making my pie with the long beard didn't have a mask on ‍. read more

Good crust with great flavor. Thin and I like more sauce which they oblige. Next up I'm going to get their Calzones. Windermere is lucky to have them. Big slices with a soda would bring me in for lunch instead of other choices. They use Grande cheese which is the best cheese not sold to us over the counter. If you love pizza order with their large selection of toppings. read more

We order from Castello's often and have never had a bad experience. The pizza, wings, and desserts are always fresh and taste phenomenal! read more

I was really quite thrilled to discover Castello's the other day. I have lamented for the past decade that Dr. Phillips needed a good hole in the wall pizzeria and, apparently, I was blind to one just around the corner. Castello's may be small -- a counter with half a dozen bar stools against a window for those who want to eat in the restaurant -- but it's staff has a very sincere way of greeting customers. As a result, the store does not seem small as much as it seems intimate, as if one were getting a slice in a friend's kitchen. I've ordered slices at Castello's twice now. Both were consistent. The sauce was flavorful but not too sweet. The saltiness of the cheese was a perfect match to sauce. A few droplets of oil lingered on my fingers when I was done eating but I as not bathed in an excess of fatty oils. The crust was tasty but could have been crispier to suit my taste. Of course, on my second visit I could have asked for my slice to be thrown into the oven a bit longer. Castello's is a great find and one that I will return to again and again. You should, too! read more

Excellent Food, Service & Prices. Delicious NY style thin crust pizza. Wings were large. The hot & teriyaki sauce was perfect. Phone rep had pride in his job. Employees were all wearing masks & offered to bring food to my car. Highly recommend & will return. read more

I am shocked to see any less than stellar reviews for Castello's! I've never had a bad experience here, the employees are always awesome and the pizzas are consistently amazing. This is actually the only pizza place in Orlando I still trust to be consistent. I first heard about Castello's from friends who lived in New York for many years and told me that this is one of the very few pizza places in Orlando that they found to be on par with real NY pizza, so of course I had to check it out. I've been going now for years and never been disappointed! My family and I love Castello's! read more

Have ordered pizza, calzones, and dessert over a dozen times, and never have they disappointed us. The food quality and delivery speed is outstanding! Castello's is the only place we get pizza in the Orlando area. I highly recommended it! read more

Amazing Pizza!!! So much better than Papa Johns, Pizza Hut & Domino's for about the same price. Delivery was fast and friendly. We will definitely be reordering from them. read more

Good pizza. We frequent Castello's for both take out and delivery. Pizzas are consistently tasty. Staff is helpful and friendly. We've done big orders with them and they get it done timely and correctly. For delivery, they get it right without a big delay. Overall, the place is wonderful. If you are looking for good pizza in the Dr. Phillips/Windermere area, this is one of the best options you have available. Definitely give them a try! read more

I really anticipated "Gourmet Pizza" to be somewhere near that description. One dimensional flavor, skimpy toppings & dough lacking crunch, chew or flavor. The sauce lacked any layers of herbs, seasonings. Both our pies were lackluster. Too bad, I just moved close by & was hoping for a new pizza place.. read more

This is a hidden gem!!! I honestly have lived within 10 minutes of Castello's for a long time but for whatever reason, didn't order from them! What a mistake! This place is sooooo good. Seriously. The pizza, salads, calzones, abs bread were all so fresh and balanced with great flavors! Their sauce is delicious and just the right amount on the pizzas! Great price for the quality! We are hooked!! read more

This place has gourmet pizza, the most delicious in town, NOT like a chain pizza place! Cannot compare this place to Papa john, Pizza Hut level pizza. Its more expensive, but if you like the good stuff, this is the place to order from. I never go to the actual store because its really small and not much of a restaurant. Its gourmet take out or delivery pizza for me. Just had some today! read more

A few years ago my husband and I loved this place. It seems it has really gone down hill :/ We got the Margarita pizza and wings tonight. The pizza was EXTREMELY thin, tomatoes were not fresh or of decent quality, and the crust was under cooked. The basil was also poor quality and extremely wilted. It seemed like pizza that had been sitting under a heating lamp all day. The wings were just okay. They used to be great, but now they seem very fatty, no crisp to the skin, and the skin is so thick and slimy. Grossed me out. What happened to you guys? :( read more

Castello's Pizza | Windermere - a whole pizza in a box - Pizza Near Me - Orlando, Florida

Horrible, my cheese pizza 16 in for $16.00 Pappas d 3 dollars cheaper and way better. Castello: it was delivered to my house I waited 1 hour. Cold, cold, cold and each slice was crumble up. I just to own a pizzeria in the past and I know what happen, they gave us us a old pizza that was already pre-sliced and reheated.. Good flavor but my god it was 8 small slices. I eat 2 and I think I could of eating the whole pie. Normally when I order from Pappas ds I eat 2 slices and I am good. Very disappointed. read more

Castello's Pizza | Windermere - Crap!! - Pizza Near Me - Orlando, Florida

I just got this pizza delivered. My first reaction was Meh. The sauce and the cheese were slightly above Domino's quality, but how hard is that. The crust was as thin as I had hoped but unfortunately had no flavor. All I can say is I would order this over Domino's or pizza Hutt but there are better local pizza joints. I also wanna mention that the picture of the garlic cheese bread online was a traditional loaf of bread. What I got was a small pizza crust with garlic cheese melted on top. Pretty disappointing. read more

A local people joint that serves delicious pizza. Whenever I'm not in the mood for the commercial stuff like Pizza Hut or papa johns Castello's is where I go. read more

We from here all the time. Delivery time is great. The white pizza is Awesome. I love the thin crust. The salad and desserts are always fresh. I hope in the future more locations are opened. read more

Don't know who is writing bad reviews of this place. Love their pizza and have delivery from them at least 15 times. This is our closest pizza restaurant, and I don't grade on a curve. Pies are always on point, and when my family comes to visit, my father always Orders the Meatlovers Calzone. read more

This is fabulous pizza! Nice thin crust. Everything home made and fresh. Brick oven. Reminded me of New Jersey pizza. Very small seating inside and nice little cafe tables. Love that the have so many choices of toppings. My favorite is prosciutto and arugula. Love this pizza!! read more

I can truly say that since we moved here 3 years ago we've been ordering from Castello's and it's the only pizza our entire family agrees on; but if you're expecting American style pizza, it's NOT! It's very much thin, lightly sauced and gooey in the center, just like in Italy. We've also had good service. read more

I really liked this place- went several times asking for "vegan pizza" and everything went great until I called and was told "there's just a small bit of cheese in the marinara- but it's barely anything so it's fine". No that's not how things work. What if I'm allergic? WHY IS THERE CHEESE IN YOUR MARINARA?! Why was I lied to about it several times. read more

I have had Castello's before and it was good but tonight I want overly impressed with our food. We ordered 6 wings and a 14" buffalo pizza. I have never had the wings before and probably won't order them from here again. All 6 were burnt and dry with little sauce to add any flavor. The pizza was good but the crust felt like it was missing something. I can't put my finger on it but just was not a huge fan tonight. read more

It's one of the best NY style pizza places in Orlando. I just wish delivered to my house.

Searched for a gourmet pizza restaurant on here. Found this place and gave it shot! Ordered a meat lovers pizza and it was delish!!! A tad greasy but hey it's pizza! Definitely quality pizza! We will definitely return next time we are in Florida! 4 stars is for lack of seating but our family of 5 managed to make the seating work! Highly recommend! read more

This was by far the most disgusting, revolting pizza I've ever had in my entire life. They used canned sour tasting mushrooms, cheese that won't melt, and a heavily over floured crust. It arrived cold and had such a vile taste I literally spit the food out of my mouth. Gross just absolutely gross. read more

Great food, the calzone is by far the best I ever had. Delivery got here with in 30 minutes. I truly recommend this place read more

Castello's Pizza | Windermere - Pizza Near Me - Orlando, Florida

We're staying at the Hard Rock hotel. These guys left a flyer on our door, saying they'll deliver. It takes an HOUR for the pizza, my husband not only has to meet them in the lobby but the pizza was COLD. Not just room temp, but COLD, like I just got it from my fridge. This was the most ridiculous pizza delivery I've ever had! Terrible! I'd give zero stars if I could. read more

They usually have really good pizza but charge about double the cost of anywhere else.