This place was good years ago. Lately the food has been pretty bad and flavorless. Pizza slice special was doughy and not fresh at all. It's hard to mess up pepperoni pizza but they did. Seems like there is no care or passion in the food. Pasta was chewy and had very little sauce. If you want good and fresh pizza, there are far better options around. I was hopeful I had a bad a bad one-off experience but sadly it has been consistently no good. I really want to support local businesses but please do better and take pride in your food. I'll take my business elsewhere until then. read more

Stromboli's NY Pizzeria - Pizza slice special. Cheese wasn't fully melted and it just had no flavor. - Pizza Near Me - Windermere, Florida

Nice little place in Windermere. I was pleasantly surprised with this slice. It's a little thinner than a few other places but it has a good cheese to sauce ratio and a great mouth feel. Service was prompt read more

Stromboli's NY Pizzeria - Slice o cheese - Pizza Near Me - Windermere, Florida

Drove half an hour only to find a sign that read "Closed for renovations". A little notice would be nice.

Visited from Miami and really enjoyed the atmosphere--very family-friendly. The food was tasty, and I'd happily return and recommend it to friends and family. The only downside was that the staff seemed a bit untrained in communication, and the dessert took longer than expected. Otherwise, a solid experience! read more

First time coming here and I came in to order a large Margarita pizza to-go, the young man in the front seemed to be nervous or maybe even new. I could barely hear him talk, it's like he mumbled under his breathe, just a little off. After ordering my pizza I asked how long it would be and in a very low tone the guy said "I don't know" so I just said "okay well I'll be back in about 15 minutes" and he just looked at me. Strange! I came back and my pizza was done. When I got home the pizza had great flavor but not enough sauce towards the crust. Im definitely gonna come back and order another pizza and ask for more sauce. The outside signage needs to be fixed. read more

See all

Really good pizza with fresh toppings and a flavorful sauce. The crust was a bit thicker than I prefer, but overall a great meal.

I wanted take out /delivery and the other Italian restaurants in the area that work with door dash are way over priced. I've had pizza from here in the past so decided to try other items. I ordered lasagna, garlic rolls and tiramisu. The Food was mediocre at best. The lasagna wasnt bad but theres a reason its considerably less expensive than every other restaurant in the area. The garlic rolls were not soft, actually tasted like greasy day old rolls. The Tiramisu is a joke. No wonder they dont have a picture on their menu. Its tiny. It may be an ok portion but not for over $7. PS it was still frozen... Ive had the pizza and a Stromboli here in the past but I will not ever order their Italian dishes again and do not recommend it. read more

Stromboli's NY Pizzeria - Tiramisu - Pizza Near Me - Windermere, Florida

New to the area so thought we'd try a local pizza spot. We ordered the BBQ Hawaiian Pizza and 10 wings. The pizza was a decent pie. The structure of the pizza held up to the toppings. Flavor was good. Not too sweet considering we got the BBQ Hawaiian pizza. The wings didn't have much flavor. Texture wise, they were good. We ordered delivery and it took about an hour for delivery. We'll definitely be ordering from here again. read more

Stromboli's NY Pizzeria - Wings - Pizza Near Me - Windermere, Florida

See all

Good NY thin and crispy but not burnt and good flavor. Right next to Publix. From a NYer

Delicious! Some of the best pizza I've had in a while. Love the NY style. Highly recommend read more

Stromboli's NY Pizzeria - Meat pizza - Pizza Near Me - Windermere, Florida

We are located in Clermont and when we want pizza drive all the way to Windermere. That tells you how much we love this pizza place, pizza is very good. The service is always good, they are very attentive and accommodate our needs. 100 % recommended. read more

Food is great if you do pick up. We've ordered 3 times delivery, messed up every time.

Food is so delicious!!! Best Stromboli in town and the fried zucchini is also amazing!!

It's hit or miss. It's either fantastic and delicious or cold and not so great. Very pricey compared to the chain pizza shops but when it's a good night it's delicious. read more

Food delivered fast and food was fantastic!! I recommend the hangover pizza! The kids 2 slice deal is fantastic as well.

This place has some of the best NY style pizza you can get and you can tell they really put the hearts out into the food and the food is amazing I mean just the taste of the cheese is to die for and the sauce isn't too strong and they always provide decent service but, the price. You can get one pizza for like 17 dollars! That is pretty absurd and the pizza is really good but it's just too expensive. read more

Order was not even started at the time that pick-up was due. Customer service did little to apologize for order not being ready.

I don't understand where all these bad reviews are coming from but I've been coming to this pizzeria for years and it is by far the best in Orlando. There's no comparison. I'm not always crazy about customer service when I go there but the product is unbelievable. We live 30 minutes from there and anytime or anywhere close we make sure to go read more

I am from New York I had one of the best experiences I've ever had for a pizza joint in Florida State. I don't know what kind of water they using but they are doing something right. The crust is mouth-watering and the pizza literally taste like it does in New York state the oil no matter what it is they are doing it right. I give this restaurant 10 out of five stars. Enjoy your pizza because I do read more

This is for the service, cleanliness, and class of staff. We unfortunately experienced a bad incident. As my 2 young kids (3 and 8) were sitting waiting for their food. My son turns to me uncomfortably and asks Mommy what are they doing. I look up in shock to see Pornography playing on the flat screen TVs above the counter. I immediately turn his head and yell for the less then stellar lady behind the counter to alert her of the problem. She looks and giggles and laughs off and tells everyone in the back. They switch the channel then back again it still is on. A gentleman had to completely disconnect the TV and he says I don't know how that happened must've been hacked. Took no responsibility or recourse to remedy for the mishap at all. It was quite a shock to my kids and I, Which ended in us walking out. The food is decent but not that good for such crappy service. I'd rather support another standup business owner. read more

Food is overpriced for the quality they offer. Not worth spending money here. Last call means order by 9pm when they close at 10pm. Menu is too pricy for what you get. read more

This was my first time enjoying Stromboli's. We were celebrating a co-workers retirement and her choice was pizza from here. Since we needed a rather large order and when we were given the pickup time for 11:30am and they were hot and ready at that exact time. We had cheese, sausage, pepperoni and an Aloha. My favorite by far was the Aloha with ham and pineapple, so yummy . Great New York style pizzas, huge slices that are totally foldable! I look forward to returning and trying some of their other menu items. Happy dining! read more

See all

I asked the guys at work where I could find "NY Pizza" and everyone said Stromboli's! Best pizza in the area in my opinion.

If I could give a 0/5 stars I would. The only reason they got one is because you had to. Not only was I hung up on twice, the guy was super rude and inconsiderate. Our food was delivered wrong, missing 2 items. One of which was for someone with a food allergy that couldn't eat anything else delivered. The guy on the phone was not accommodating and wanted us to reorder the food because he couldn't just sent a replacement. When he asked if we wanted a refund he prompted to hang up on us. I am highly disappointed and will never be getting food from here again. read more

I live near Stromboli's and it was quickly become my replacement for any chain pizza. I love their pizza viagra, their fried mushrooms, their fried Mozzerella, and their garlic bread. Their food is always fresh and made with care. read more

I love pizza so that's what we ordered for a weekday lunch. It was NY style and very tasty. The place was comfy, with a TV and a few tables. The service was good and they didn't mind my special requests for my toddler ( cut a slice into bite/size pieces). They even had cartoons on the TV, which was appreciated by the little one. The location was convenient with easy parking. I will return! read more

Visiting some family that just moved into the area from out by the airport and I know my Bro likes the real NY style pizza like we had over there so I figured I'd give it a shot. I got one slice $2.25 add Italian Sausage $.55 It's alright. Not great. I didn't see the 2-slice with one topping each lunch special for $4.50 and she didn't offer it. I really didn't want to eat two anyway. They make their dough fresh and it reminds me of my corner joint in Freeport, NY. I caught a glimpse of a calzone coming out of the oven that looked right. I'd come back. read more

Stromboli's NY Pizzeria - Slices are crispy and fold like it supposed to. - Pizza Near Me - Windermere, Florida

See all

The pizza is good but the service is horrible. If they make a mistake, they will do little or most likely nothing to fix it.

Well what can I say? I used to LOVE Stromboli's!!! The pizza was good (lunch special is a great price), zucchini fries are awesome with a bit of ranch... but hands down my favorite thing was the veal! It was always so tender and freshly hand-cut. Well- things have changed. I ordered a veal Parmesan hero tonight (first time in over a year) and it was ghastly. It was so tough and dry, like it had been frozen or was old. It was practically inedible. It is possible it was just fried way too long- but whatever happened, it wasn't worth the $20 to have this with fries and a drink. It is also surprise that there isn't an option to add fries or something to the hero... where you pay a smaller fee for a smaller portion. I had to pay so much so they could give me a pound of soggy fries (half went into the trash because it's clearly meant to be for the whole group- if you have one). It was just a sad experience. Don't know if the pizza is still good, but I don't think I'm willing to go back to see. :( read more

We ordered from here through DoorDash. They missed part our order and after calling the restaurant, the lady I spoke with took to liberty that this was not their problem to address or even help with. Also attached is a picture of the salad I threw away thanks to the quality of the lettuce. Terrible customer service. Will never order from there again nor will recommend anyone to order from there. Lost a customer. read more

Stromboli's NY Pizzeria - Part of our salad - Pizza Near Me - Windermere, Florida

If I could give 0 stars I would, yesterday I came here 20 minutes before closing and they won't let me order because they were "closing". If you are closing earlier, make sure you change our business hours. read more

This is a frequent pizza place for coworkers and I, it's always quick and delicious. The portions and pizzas are large so you'll normally always have leftovers. Maddie and Lexi are always so helpful and friendly just the service alone makes you wanna keep coming back!! read more

Stromboli's NY Pizzeria - Pepperoni Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Windermere, Florida

See all

Pizza was good. Chicken parm hero was so bad we threw it out after trying it. The chicken tasted like it was freezer burnt.

When I first moved to the area 12 years ago, Stromboli's was one of the only restaurants in town. It's definitely not fine dining, but it's always been a solid option for mom and pop style Italian. Whether dining in or taking out, the service is always friendly and the food is consistent. The spinach roll is probably my favorite, but the baked ziti is a close second. Prices are a smidge high for a neighborhood pizza place, but they do offer a Disney Cast Member discount. read more

Stromboli's NY Pizzeria - Baked Ziti - Pizza Near Me - Windermere, Florida

We've ordered pizza from here a few times since it's right down the road from our house. The pizza is good. We always just get a plain cheese pizza because we're boring. The garlic rolls are great! We tried the garlic puffies once and we didn't like them at all. Stick with the rolls. My favorite thing from the menu has to be the meatballs. I'm pretty picky when it comes to meatballs and these ones are amazing. They're big and come with a side of garlic rolls I think the prices are fair. I've spent about the same at any pizza place getting the same amount of stuff. This place just had a broader selection of food. I would much rather support these local guys than go to dominos with less of a variety of food. read more

Stromboli's NY Pizzeria - Garlic Rolls - Pizza Near Me - Windermere, Florida

See all

Great pizza. We always get an extra large primavera. They have veggie toppings that are very fresh! We have also had their Stromboli which are delicious. Love their veal Parmesan, meatball, and eggplant Parmesan heros too! I've never had a delivery but we pick up and take it home. It's a good location, especially coming home from Disney, we order when we leave Disney and it's already when we arrive to pick it up. read more

Very good NYC Pizza.- the best in West Orlando Ziti and garlic knots - we order whenever guests are in town and it's a big hit!! read more

I will never go back here again we ordered a pizza a few weeks ago end it was delivered with a long hair in it no one in my family has blonde hair. so we called the pizzeria and they told us there was nothing they could do. What type of restaurant does not even own up to the fact that they delivered you a pizza with hair in it, absolutely disgraceful. I guess they claim it's New York style pizza because it's made with very little care or sanitation in mind just like in NY not because it taste anything like a New York slice of pizza!!! read more

Walked in and was pretty shocked. Nobody wearing masks or gloves, floor was filthy, employees wearing dirty clothing with sweat stains. The place was dark and smelled BAD. Walked up to the counter was rudely told "You gonna order something or what". Quickly walked out. Will never return. Save yourself the trouble, this place is filthy, with rude workers who don't wear masks and haven't cleaned the place in years. read more

We've been ordering from here at least once a quarter for the last 3 years, more frequently due to COVID-19 and all of our orders have been spot on! If it helps, my wife normally gets the lasagna dinner and I the traditional stromboli. read more