Order Sal’s Pizza Bar Takeout or Delivery
Sal’s Pizza Bar Photos
Business Info
SAL’S PIZZA BAR ATMOSPHERE
You might also consider
More like Sal’s Pizza Bar
Recommended Reviews - Sal’s Pizza Bar
Start your review...
Reviews With Photos
We had an 18 inch, half pepperoni / half meat lovers special pizza delivered to our resort. Being from northern New Jersey, I'm always skeptical of self-described "NY-style" pizza, but Sal's is the closest I've had to a New York slice in years. Online ordering was straightforward, and the pizza was delivered warm via Uber. Expected delivery time is continuously tracked and displayed online, which is helpful if you have to meet the delivery (e.g. in a resort lobby). Outstanding crust, sauce and toppings; highly recommended.
Best pizza I've had in Florida and generally consistent. They've got plenty of options and a style/slice for everyone's palate. The service here is pretty on point and I've never had an issue getting my order together. The ONLY thing that can be a pain point here is seating. If you happen to land on a busy day you might not get a seat at all. If you're ordering to go this isn't a problem, and there is outdoor seating as well if the weather allows for it. Either way. Closest thing to a NY slice and doesn't say "NY style" anywhere. Currently my spot for pizza.
My Favorite slices. The Rosa & ricotta spinach slice. The service is always wonderful and the ambience is always relaxing and welcoming with beautiful music playing a calm environment.
This is it the best pizza Brooklyn spot anywhere within 50 miles, I ordered the standard review combo which would be a cheese slice a pepperoni slice and a margarita slice and they executed perfectly on all levels, service was great the Asian girl cook was nice and delivered accurately even though I hadn't said a thing. The undercarriage is beautiful too the sauce is a little sweet just like a nyc slice, they serve beer too which makes the pizza taste even better, it's a bit pricy about 5$ a slice but It's worth it 100%.
Just walking in it smells amazing. The pictures I posted is what it looks like. You feel welcomed right away. Food was delicious we got 3 slices one bacon and ranch, vodka and burrata,cheese slice and 6 garlic knots it was amazing from start to finish
Was recommended this place by multiple friends and as my husband is a big pizza lover, we decided to check it out. Location is good, easy to access from I-4. Very small interior so we decided to take our order to go. Probably took about 15-20 minutes to get our pizza and garlic knots. Got the Sweet Thai Chili pizza as we are lovers of this flavor and it was so fun & different. Lots of chicken and tons of sauce. Tbh I think I'd prefer the sauce as the base and could ditch the marinara completely since it doesn't add anything. But's a great pizza! The garlic knots were nothing to write home about. Very standard garlic knots and marinara. Pretty pricy for a full pizza, though the slices are large. Overall we would stop here again but I wouldn't say I'd rave about it.
There's always talk about WHERE IN FLORIDA can you find actual NEW YORK style PIZZA! And let me just say Sal's pizza is 10/10 Everything looked so good I ordered the Vodka pizza which is literally my fav. It was EVERYTHING, fresh, hot, cheesepull , saucey, crisp bottom & crust. 100000% just SOOOO good! I will definitely return !!!!
Stopped in for dinner after visiting Walt Disney World. Ordered the 6 garlic knots to start since they said it would be about 30 minutes for the pizza. The knots had plenty of garlic, but could have been warmer. Ordered the meat lovers pizza, which is a medium. The pizza has bacon, pepperoni and sausage slices (lengthwise). The flavor was good and the pepperoni has some spice. I would have liked it cooked a little longer. But, since it was my first time dining, did not know to ask. The dining area was packed. They have one long table and a few other smaller ones. If you sit at the long table, you will be dining with others. There is a tv in the bar area.
Probably the best pizza I've had! PERIOD!!! The folks at the restaurant are amazing. Very friendly and so humble. Sal is actually working be hind the former and we spoke for a minute. The food is so good. If you are in the area, YOU HAVE TO STOP BY AND EAT!!!!
I think we found one of our new pizza spots in Orlando! Sal's is in a new-feeling plaza, a smaller building but still a good amount of seating, both indoor and outdoor. We wanted to try a few things, so we started with the garlic knots and a slice of vodka pizza! The garlic knots had a lot of garlic on them (the best way to be) and were cute and small! The vodka slice was a big hit - I'm not normally a huge vodka slice gal, but it was really great! The cheese was so fresh and the crust was a perfect texture. The 2 full size pizzas we got were great as well; the pepperoni and hot honey was classic and the prosciutto and arugula pizza had a good mix of ingredients without being all arugula. Again, the crust and cheese are standouts here! The slices are thin without being too floppy. Service was prompt and polite, and I can't wait to come back!
So I stroll into Sal's Pizza Bar in Orlando because apparently every local within a 10-mile radius has decided it is their personal mission to tell me, "YOU HAVE TO TRY THE UPSIDE-DOWN SICILIAN." When strangers start giving you pizza instructions with the intensity of a flight attendant during turbulence, you go. Right away, the staff is super friendly--like, "if you need anything, even emotional support, we got you" friendly. The menu is enormous. I'm convinced Sal printed it on a scroll somewhere in the back and they just keep adding items like it's a medieval prophecy. The atmosphere screams Brooklyn comes to Orlando in a pizza place. Nice. The food: First up: the classic cheese slice. Thin crust, nice flop, enough oil sliding down my arm to moisturize me for the next three days. This is the kind of slice where you instinctively fold it even if you're not from New York. The only issue? It wasn't hot. It was the temperature of pizza that's been sitting in a conversation too long. Tasty--but it had "warming tray trust issues." Then the upside-down Sicilian arrives. Cheese on the bottom, sauce on top. Basically a Sicilian slice that wanted to cosplay as Chicago deep dish but didn't want to fully commit. Thick, bready, saucy, the kind of slice that could double as a self-defense weapon if needed. Flavor? Really good. Hotness level? Eh... more "warm hug" than "fresh out of the oven." Overall, Sal's is a cool spot. Tons of options, great people, solid pizza. But the hype had me expecting a spiritual awakening. I was ready for a slice to float down from the ceiling while an Italian grandmother whispered blessings in the background. Instead, I got "very good, slightly lukewarm pizza," which drops my rating from a celestial five to a practical four. Still worth checking out--just ask them to serve it hot enough that you briefly question whether touching it was a mistake.
The food was great! The penne sauce was flavorful, the chicken was cooked well, and the fried burrata was so good-- perfect balance of balsamic. The food came out in around 10 ish minutes, hot. The service was good, the server answered all of our questions, and was kind. The area and tables were clean as well. The place is a little small for bigger families, but if you come at a good time, the vibe is right. Would definitely come back again, nothing critical to add.
I've heard too many good things about this place that I had to make the 45 minute drive to check it out for myself. We walk in and the place is poppin', the case is filled with deliciousness and I felt like a kid in a candy shop... but even better, a pizza shop! I wished they would've had labels for each of their pizzas but the person helping us was kind enough to quickly go through everything with us. You can also order pastas, whole pizzas, etc. We decided to grab a few slices, garlic knots, a spinach pin wheel and everything was so so good! Honestly you can't go wrong with anything, I would literally try a new pizza every time I came because I love that they offer unique slices.
2 months ago
Oh gimme all the pizza please ! Located in Pointe Orlando directly across from PBR cowboy and next to Still lounge, this is a perfect late night spot to grab food. It was so good we came back twice in 2 days after dancing the night away. The first visit , me and my friends split a large pizza for $20 and grabbed soft drinks , all under $30! The pizza was so good we were all like , yea this beats any place we've been too outside of so do square and that's a good tie for first place. The following night , I came back after a date to grab a slice to go and it was so good , we ordered a pie to go ! Service was quick and I loved that the pizza was made fresh. I'd definitely come back just to grab a pizza and chill. read more
1 month ago
I'll take my pizza with an attitude on top thank you? So right from the start walking up to the counter we were greeted by a girl who just seemed blatantly entitled from the start as we ordered a very simple two pizzas to go one pepperoni and onion and one vodka sauce it was then that the girl who hadn't said more than two words to me says is that all and I said yes but thankfully I noticed on the screen she gave me one with hot honey on it and was charging me for it I told her I didn't want that and she said well you told me you wanted hot honey it was then the other person with me said that I never said that and the girl caught even more of an attitude knowing someone else knew she was in the wrong like I'm not sure what her problem was but learn how to be nice to someone who's actually being nice to you and that's coming from someone who's worked in the retail and hospitality sector for a very long time as I could have been rude back but that solves nothing! After dealing with her we waited for our pizza and after it was done we went to get it and then upon opening it we discovered that they must be on a onion budget because there was a few pieces of it on our pie with more than half of it lacking one of the toppings we had paid an extra few dollars for not wanting to deal with her attitude again we just ate it. Of the two pizzas the vodka sauce one was the better of the two but the pizza itself felt like it lacked a good amount of vodka sauce leaving one to eat just what it had on top of it, with the pepperoni one being about the same but with the missing onions. Either way I feel as if our whole group just felt as if we weren't wanted here as our pizzas were lacking what they were supposed to have and the encounter left us feeling like this was done intentionally to us for correcting one entitled cashier who likes to argue, needless to say I wouldn't come back here again. read more
3 days ago
We had an 18 inch, half pepperoni / half meat lovers special pizza delivered to our resort. Being from northern New Jersey, I'm always skeptical of self-described "NY-style" pizza, but Sal's is the closest I've had to a New York slice in years. Online ordering was straightforward, and the pizza was delivered warm via Uber. Expected delivery time is continuously tracked and displayed online, which is helpful if you have to meet the delivery (e.g. in a resort lobby). Outstanding crust, sauce and toppings; highly recommended. read more
Best pizza I've had in Florida and generally consistent. They've got plenty of options and a style/slice for everyone's palate. The service here is pretty on point and I've never had an issue getting my order together. The ONLY thing that can be a pain point here is seating. If you happen to land on a busy day you might not get a seat at all. If you're ordering to go this isn't a problem, and there is outdoor seating as well if the weather allows for it. Either way. Closest thing to a NY slice and doesn't say "NY style" anywhere. Currently my spot for pizza. read more
This is it the best pizza Brooklyn spot anywhere within 50 miles, I ordered the standard review combo which would be a cheese slice a pepperoni slice and a margarita slice and they executed perfectly on all levels, service was great the Asian girl cook was nice and delivered accurately even though I hadn't said a thing. The undercarriage is beautiful too the sauce is a little sweet just like a nyc slice, they serve beer too which makes the pizza taste even better, it's a bit pricy about 5$ a slice but It's worth it 100%. read more
19 days ago
Just walking in it smells amazing. The pictures I posted is what it looks like. You feel welcomed right away. Food was delicious we got 3 slices one bacon and ranch, vodka and burrata,cheese slice and 6 garlic knots it was amazing from start to finish read more
5 days ago
Was recommended this place by multiple friends and as my husband is a big pizza lover, we decided to check it out. Location is good, easy to access from I-4. Very small interior so we decided to take our order to go. Probably took about 15-20 minutes to get our pizza and garlic knots. Got the Sweet Thai Chili pizza as we are lovers of this flavor and it was so fun & different. Lots of chicken and tons of sauce. Tbh I think I'd prefer the sauce as the base and could ditch the marinara completely since it doesn't add anything. But's a great pizza! The garlic knots were nothing to write home about. Very standard garlic knots and marinara. Pretty pricy for a full pizza, though the slices are large. Overall we would stop here again but I wouldn't say I'd rave about it. read more
There's always talk about WHERE IN FLORIDA can you find actual NEW YORK style PIZZA! And let me just say Sal's pizza is 10/10 Everything looked so good I ordered the Vodka pizza which is literally my fav. It was EVERYTHING, fresh, hot, cheesepull , saucey, crisp bottom & crust. 100000% just SOOOO good! I will definitely return !!!! read more
Stopped in for dinner after visiting Walt Disney World. Ordered the 6 garlic knots to start since they said it would be about 30 minutes for the pizza. The knots had plenty of garlic, but could have been warmer. Ordered the meat lovers pizza, which is a medium. The pizza has bacon, pepperoni and sausage slices (lengthwise). The flavor was good and the pepperoni has some spice. I would have liked it cooked a little longer. But, since it was my first time dining, did not know to ask. The dining area was packed. They have one long table and a few other smaller ones. If you sit at the long table, you will be dining with others. There is a tv in the bar area. read more
Probably the best pizza I've had! PERIOD!!! The folks at the restaurant are amazing. Very friendly and so humble. Sal is actually working be hind the former and we spoke for a minute. The food is so good. If you are in the area, YOU HAVE TO STOP BY AND EAT!!!! read more
I think we found one of our new pizza spots in Orlando! Sal's is in a new-feeling plaza, a smaller building but still a good amount of seating, both indoor and outdoor. We wanted to try a few things, so we started with the garlic knots and a slice of vodka pizza! The garlic knots had a lot of garlic on them (the best way to be) and were cute and small! The vodka slice was a big hit - I'm not normally a huge vodka slice gal, but it was really great! The cheese was so fresh and the crust was a perfect texture. The 2 full size pizzas we got were great as well; the pepperoni and hot honey was classic and the prosciutto and arugula pizza had a good mix of ingredients without being all arugula. Again, the crust and cheese are standouts here! The slices are thin without being too floppy. Service was prompt and polite, and I can't wait to come back! read more
So I stroll into Sal's Pizza Bar in Orlando because apparently every local within a 10-mile radius has decided it is their personal mission to tell me, "YOU HAVE TO TRY THE UPSIDE-DOWN SICILIAN." When strangers start giving you pizza instructions with the intensity of a flight attendant during turbulence, you go. Right away, the staff is super friendly--like, "if you need anything, even emotional support, we got you" friendly. The menu is enormous. I'm convinced Sal printed it on a scroll somewhere in the back and they just keep adding items like it's a medieval prophecy. The atmosphere screams Brooklyn comes to Orlando in a pizza place. Nice. The food: First up: the classic cheese slice. Thin crust, nice flop, enough oil sliding down my arm to moisturize me for the next three days. This is the kind of slice where you instinctively fold it even if you're not from New York. The only issue? It wasn't hot. It was the temperature of pizza that's been sitting in a conversation too long. Tasty--but it had "warming tray trust issues." Then the upside-down Sicilian arrives. Cheese on the bottom, sauce on top. Basically a Sicilian slice that wanted to cosplay as Chicago deep dish but didn't want to fully commit. Thick, bready, saucy, the kind of slice that could double as a self-defense weapon if needed. Flavor? Really good. Hotness level? Eh... more "warm hug" than "fresh out of the oven." Overall, Sal's is a cool spot. Tons of options, great people, solid pizza. But the hype had me expecting a spiritual awakening. I was ready for a slice to float down from the ceiling while an Italian grandmother whispered blessings in the background. Instead, I got "very good, slightly lukewarm pizza," which drops my rating from a celestial five to a practical four. Still worth checking out--just ask them to serve it hot enough that you briefly question whether touching it was a mistake. read more
2 months ago
The food was great! The penne sauce was flavorful, the chicken was cooked well, and the fried burrata was so good-- perfect balance of balsamic. The food came out in around 10 ish minutes, hot. The service was good, the server answered all of our questions, and was kind. The area and tables were clean as well. The place is a little small for bigger families, but if you come at a good time, the vibe is right. Would definitely come back again, nothing critical to add. read more
1 year ago
I've heard too many good things about this place that I had to make the 45 minute drive to check it out for myself. We walk in and the place is poppin', the case is filled with deliciousness and I felt like a kid in a candy shop... but even better, a pizza shop! I wished they would've had labels for each of their pizzas but the person helping us was kind enough to quickly go through everything with us. You can also order pastas, whole pizzas, etc. We decided to grab a few slices, garlic knots, a spinach pin wheel and everything was so so good! Honestly you can't go wrong with anything, I would literally try a new pizza every time I came because I love that they offer unique slices. read more
2 months ago
Being from the New England area I am always looking for that New York brick oven pizza and Sals got it! A must try when in the Orlando area. Place has friendly staff and a great layout with a lot of food to try. read more
1 month ago
In town for a quick get away and decided it's pizza night for the big UM v/s Notre Dame 2025 College Season (go CANES!!!). We ordered a 18" meat lovers pizza, 12 garlic rolls and mozzarella sticks. The food was fresh, tasted great and was ready on time. The restaurant was packed and the foods was being cranked out. Nice place to eat and do a take out orders. The prices were fair and worth it. read more
My old favorite New York style pizza restaurant from the time I was a kid--Pisa Pizza--recently closed, and my family was devastated. Coming "back home" to visit my family this month, I searched for the best NY pizza in Orlando and up came Sal's Pizza Bar. We decided to stop in yesterday for lunch, and opened the doors to a casual, comfortable ambiance. We approached the counter where we were met by a sweet staff member and ordered a few things to share. We got a house salad with Italian dressing, a penne alla vodka pasta, and a NY cheese pizza (18" round). The salad was crisp and refreshing, perfect for a warm summer late afternoon. The pasta was creamy and tasty, and was super saucy which I love. The main attraction, our classic pizza, affectionately known in NY as an "orange slice" was absolutely perfect. The crust held up so nicely and didn't flop... the cheese was salty and delicious... the sauce was light and savory... and the oil dripping off made it feel that much more authentic. We loved everything, and felt our already high expectations were somehow exceeded. We will definitely be back to try more! read more
1 month ago
4 months ago
Food was just amazing. Service was that of a diner and very upbeat. Ambience made me feel like i was back up north, lol but in a good way. read more
This place is amazing! I tries two different pizzas: the pepperoni and the upside down scilian, which were both were equally as good. The pepperoni has a thin but crisp crust with a good amount of cheese and toppings on it! The crust is delightful. The upside down scilian is a must try! Think focaccia bread but in pizza form. Very light and tasty. All ingredients were fresh and tastes even better the next day! read more
I've been back a few times and service has improved greatly. Never have a complaint about the pizza. Recently stopped in for a vodka and marg slice, and they were great. They did have live music that day, but in my opinion, the space is too small for this so we opted to sit outside. read more
1 month ago
I was driving around starving and in the mood for something cheesy. We came across Sal's Pizza bar as one of the restaurants with best yelp reviews in the area. We decided to stop by for a quick bite & refreshing drink while spending a fun day of shopping. We got our order started with a nice cold San Pellegrino sparkling water & a nice cold draft Peroni. We ordered a slice of cheese pizza and another dish, which I'm not sure of the name, but it kind of looked like a croissant stuffed with cheese and Parmesan chicken. The chicken dish was the best one. It came with a side sauce of marinara which we were told was made in house daily. There are some nice looking boxes with assortment of cookies you can purchase to go! Plenty of indoor space, and a nice sunny/shadded outdoor seating area. Sal himself was at the pizza place wishing all patrons happy holidays and checking to make sure that everybody's order was satisfactory if in the area we would definitely stop by again. read more
Came here after it was recommended and while visiting over Thanksgiving. They sell whole pies or by the slice and have an expansive menu. We got the garlic knots which were good. My spouse got the cheese slice with added sausage. It was crispy and had the no dip tip. The pizza had good flavor and all staff were super nice. They also have beer on tap and a selection of wine. read more
This places does pizza so well! I love the atmosphere and the customer service but this time around I am giving them a 3 star. I went to try their entrees. I had the chicken parm and the sauce, this hurts me to say, was watery. The sauce didn't even stick to the pasta. The sauce didn't have much flavor. The portion was big and I will say the chicken was crusted well and had great taste. My husband got the chicken parm hero he also mentioned the sauce was watery and didn't have any flavor. I will stick to the pizza from now on. read more
11 months ago
Loved the pizza here the first time we tried it and came back for more. Staff is always friendly. It's a small space and always busy but staff always keeps a smile on. This time just went for one slice and the garlic knots which were both delicious! read more
1 year ago
My absolute favorite Pizzeria in Central Florida. When I go to Sal's, I feel back in NY, the service is super friendly and you can feel that from the moment you walk in. The vibes are always great here. Definitely love the pepperoni pinwheels and grandma slices. read more
20 days ago
2 months ago
4 months ago
Came here for the first time last week, got the cheese pizza, and it was a good New York style pie. Pizza was thin, large slices, and tasted pretty close to New York pizza. The inside of the place was really cool. They had a brick oven that you can see how they make the pizza. Staff was nice, but the weight was pretty long. read more
Page 1 of 7
