Order Cassie's Pizzeria Takeout or Delivery
Cassie's Pizzeria Photos
CASSIE'S PIZZERIA ATMOSPHERE
What's the vibe?
You might also consider
More like Cassie's Pizzeria
Recommended Reviews - Cassie's Pizzeria
Start your review...
Reviews With Photos
Say hello to my (current) favorite pizzeria. Whenever my workplace wanted to order a pizza lunch, I noticed the same name was always bandied about - Cassie's. And even as a takeaway order, it was consistently delicious. I've since made several visits to the actual location, and it's regularly a hit. The bread that comes out at the start of a dine-in meal is such a gift. I love that it's served warm, and it's a hearty serving. It's a lucky thing that the food always comes out so quickly, or else I'd be filling up all my stomach space with it. The pizzas are fantastic. Categorically, I'd place them close to a Neapolitan, which is actually not my favorite type of pie but it's done really, really well here. I don't know if it's the fresh mozzarella or the fresh crust (in fact, this is the only place where I'd happily finish all my crust pieces, they're so good), but everything tastes like quality. I especially love how they serve up their meatball toppings, which are thick hunks of well-seasoned meat and well worth the tuppence they cost. The pizza's not the only star here. I'm not sure why, but there's something about the Caesar salad here that spanks my sweet taste buds. All of their salads come in two sizes - individual ($13) and family ($28). I find that to be pretty pricey for a salad, but when I ordered an individual salad to share with my husband during my last visit, it was a decently sized plate of salad for both of us. The dining space is huge, with both tables and booths divided between two rooms. Service is both kind and efficient; I've never had any issues and I'm regularly surprised at how quickly the food comes out.
I came here for a work lunch. The restaurant is in the heart of downtown Englewood. Street parking is tricky but there is a garage near by. I ordered the pasta and salad lunch combo and ordered a Caesar salad with vodka pasta. I forgot to take a picture of the salad but it was huge! I could barely eat my pasta, which also was delicious and creamy and had to pack it for later. We sat near the kitchen so it did get a little hot while we dined but nonetheless had a good time.
Ambiance: (5/5) Went inside to pick up the pizza and they have great seating and decorations. Price: (4/5) Prices seem average for the area. Food: (1/5) I was very disappointed. I ordered my pizza and I was there 10 mins later and the pizza was cold. It seems like it was already made and they gave me one for an hour ago. The slices were also cut in random sizes. They weren't even similar. I was really looking forward to my forward to the classic pizza because I have heard great things, but I can't say I agree.
We had a really nice time tonight celebrating a friend's birthday. The bread they served was amazing! Fresh and hot! There were 6 of us. We split 2 salads. Nice portion but we probably should have ordered 3 or made one a large. Then we split 3 pizzas. It was just enough. I wasn't stuffed but did not leave hungry either. We had the margarita pie, a white pizza, and the grilled chicken pizza. My favorite was the white. We had the tartufo for the birthday girl - it was also yummy. The waitress was very friendly. It was a very quiet atmosphere and fairly empty but it was a Tuesday evening. The service was very good and the prices were reasonable.
I've gotten takeout from Cassie's Pizzeria before and had decent experiences, so I decided to dine in with a small group before a local event. The place was very busy, so I didn't mind being patient with the staff. My group placed our drink and food orders, including a pitcher of red sangria. However, over 20 minutes later, we still didn't have the pitcher and had to flag down the server just to get water. When the sangria finally arrived, it was disappointing--completely bad, which was frustrating after such a long wait. My SO ordered wings as an appetizer, and they never came out. Three of us received our meals, but two of the cauliflower pizza crusts were cold, somehow both burnt-looking and undercooked. One group member didn't get their meal until 15 minutes later, making the whole dining experience even more disjointed. This was easily one of the worst dining experiences I've had all year. Eventually, the wings and the last meal came out together, but at that point, it didn't matter. The server did inform us that we'd receive a discount for the mistakes, which I appreciated, but overall, this visit was a disaster. I'll be avoiding Cassie's going forward.
I used to come here as a kid all the time! I haven't been back in years until the other day. The food is still as good and the service is great! It looks like they maybe have redone the interior a little and it looks a lot nicer now!
Wow! This is some really great homemade Italian food, someplace you can take your family for a nice slice or a great pasta dish! In the heart of Englewood is a hidden gem that has been there for years, I had to try some apps! I got the meatballs that came with a little side of ricotta which was perfect for dipping, they were succulent and delicious. I also got the eggplant rollintini which was coded in mozzarella cheese melted just the way I like, Yum. And then to be healthy I got a chicken Caesar salad, if you were in the North Jersey area you definitely have to stop by.
In my top 3 restaurants of all time, this place is special. Their pizza is perfection: it is fresh, the sauce is just the right amount of sweet, and it is super light.. I can accidentally eat 5 slices and not even feel like I did. My favorite menu item is the Cassie's Chopped Salad which is also so fresh and it is delicious with plentiful toppings. The experience is what makes this place even better. There is never a wait and the dining room is very specious so you're never on top of other people. The food comes out so quick it's incredible and you're served endless complementary bread which is sooo delicious. Highly recommend.
Cassie's is located in Englewood and has easily become my go to spot for pizza and pasta. You can't go wrong with any of their pizzas and they can also customize it. I ordered the individual chicken parm pizza but asked for vodka sauce instead of marinara. The carbonara, penne vodka, and rigatoni alla toscana have been on rotation in my house. You can customize by adding your choice of protein. The individual portions are HUGE and could easily feed 2-4 people when coupled with an appetizer or pizza. I've only ordered take out thus far but I can say the staff has been friendly on the phone and when I go in to pick up. They're also prompt and I've never had to wait very long for my order to be ready. Definitely try Cassie's if you're in Englewood and have a craving for pizza or pasta!
This is a very delicious restaurant in downtown Englewood! We came here for dinner and had a great time. The food was flavorful and absolutely delicious. They menu has pasta, pizza, sandwiches and more! For appetizers we started off with the fried calamari and steak bits. The steak bits were so so good, I'm still thinking about that dish!! Definitely get that as an appetizer to share! For our entrees we shared the penne ala vodka pasta and margarita pizza. Both were excellent options! And lastly, for dessert we had the brownie sundae which just hit the spot. If you're in the area be sure to check them out!!
I love their coal fired pizza here the flavor is delicious. The dough has such a nice flavor. Super cheesy. I love the vodka pizza that I got. I also love their pasta. I thought they were delicious and the salad was really good. They have parking around the corner and the service is great. read more
15 days ago
People are super nice. Food comes out fast. Cute little place but the food lack a lot of flavor. The ravioli dough was so thick and barely stuffed with cheese. The chicken Marsala was not good. The mushrooms were extremely undercooked and the chicken breast didn't have any seasoning. I couldn't even see pepper. The anchovy pizza smelled fishy... which I get it is fish. But it was super stinky. Like bad fish stink. The pear salad was decent. The white pizza needed seasoning but the crust was good. The best thing hands down was the cannoli. read more
The office decided to order lunch from Cassie's and I had the White Clam Pizza - personal size. When I first opened the box I immediately wanted to eat it because it was both "pretty" presentation wise and it looked delicious as well - and the looks lived up to the taste because this was really a flavor packed yet perfectly balanced pie! I will definitely order again and more than likely try a different pizza even though this pizza was amazing. read more
Say hello to my (current) favorite pizzeria. Whenever my workplace wanted to order a pizza lunch, I noticed the same name was always bandied about - Cassie's. And even as a takeaway order, it was consistently delicious. I've since made several visits to the actual location, and it's regularly a hit. The bread that comes out at the start of a dine-in meal is such a gift. I love that it's served warm, and it's a hearty serving. It's a lucky thing that the food always comes out so quickly, or else I'd be filling up all my stomach space with it. The pizzas are fantastic. Categorically, I'd place them close to a Neapolitan, which is actually not my favorite type of pie but it's done really, really well here. I don't know if it's the fresh mozzarella or the fresh crust (in fact, this is the only place where I'd happily finish all my crust pieces, they're so good), but everything tastes like quality. I especially love how they serve up their meatball toppings, which are thick hunks of well-seasoned meat and well worth the tuppence they cost. The pizza's not the only star here. I'm not sure why, but there's something about the Caesar salad here that spanks my sweet taste buds. All of their salads come in two sizes - individual ($13) and family ($28). I find that to be pretty pricey for a salad, but when I ordered an individual salad to share with my husband during my last visit, it was a decently sized plate of salad for both of us. The dining space is huge, with both tables and booths divided between two rooms. Service is both kind and efficient; I've never had any issues and I'm regularly surprised at how quickly the food comes out. read more
1 month ago
2 months ago
2 months ago
I came here for a work lunch. The restaurant is in the heart of downtown Englewood. Street parking is tricky but there is a garage near by. I ordered the pasta and salad lunch combo and ordered a Caesar salad with vodka pasta. I forgot to take a picture of the salad but it was huge! I could barely eat my pasta, which also was delicious and creamy and had to pack it for later. We sat near the kitchen so it did get a little hot while we dined but nonetheless had a good time. read more
Ambiance: (5/5) Went inside to pick up the pizza and they have great seating and decorations. Price: (4/5) Prices seem average for the area. Food: (1/5) I was very disappointed. I ordered my pizza and I was there 10 mins later and the pizza was cold. It seems like it was already made and they gave me one for an hour ago. The slices were also cut in random sizes. They weren't even similar. I was really looking forward to my forward to the classic pizza because I have heard great things, but I can't say I agree. read more
We had a really nice time tonight celebrating a friend's birthday. The bread they served was amazing! Fresh and hot! There were 6 of us. We split 2 salads. Nice portion but we probably should have ordered 3 or made one a large. Then we split 3 pizzas. It was just enough. I wasn't stuffed but did not leave hungry either. We had the margarita pie, a white pizza, and the grilled chicken pizza. My favorite was the white. We had the tartufo for the birthday girl - it was also yummy. The waitress was very friendly. It was a very quiet atmosphere and fairly empty but it was a Tuesday evening. The service was very good and the prices were reasonable. read more
I've gotten takeout from Cassie's Pizzeria before and had decent experiences, so I decided to dine in with a small group before a local event. The place was very busy, so I didn't mind being patient with the staff. My group placed our drink and food orders, including a pitcher of red sangria. However, over 20 minutes later, we still didn't have the pitcher and had to flag down the server just to get water. When the sangria finally arrived, it was disappointing--completely bad, which was frustrating after such a long wait. My SO ordered wings as an appetizer, and they never came out. Three of us received our meals, but two of the cauliflower pizza crusts were cold, somehow both burnt-looking and undercooked. One group member didn't get their meal until 15 minutes later, making the whole dining experience even more disjointed. This was easily one of the worst dining experiences I've had all year. Eventually, the wings and the last meal came out together, but at that point, it didn't matter. The server did inform us that we'd receive a discount for the mistakes, which I appreciated, but overall, this visit was a disaster. I'll be avoiding Cassie's going forward. read more
3 years ago
I used to come here as a kid all the time! I haven't been back in years until the other day. The food is still as good and the service is great! It looks like they maybe have redone the interior a little and it looks a lot nicer now! read more
Wow! This is some really great homemade Italian food, someplace you can take your family for a nice slice or a great pasta dish! In the heart of Englewood is a hidden gem that has been there for years, I had to try some apps! I got the meatballs that came with a little side of ricotta which was perfect for dipping, they were succulent and delicious. I also got the eggplant rollintini which was coded in mozzarella cheese melted just the way I like, Yum. And then to be healthy I got a chicken Caesar salad, if you were in the North Jersey area you definitely have to stop by. read more
2 years ago
In my top 3 restaurants of all time, this place is special. Their pizza is perfection: it is fresh, the sauce is just the right amount of sweet, and it is super light.. I can accidentally eat 5 slices and not even feel like I did. My favorite menu item is the Cassie's Chopped Salad which is also so fresh and it is delicious with plentiful toppings. The experience is what makes this place even better. There is never a wait and the dining room is very specious so you're never on top of other people. The food comes out so quick it's incredible and you're served endless complementary bread which is sooo delicious. Highly recommend. read more
9 months ago
Cassie's is located in Englewood and has easily become my go to spot for pizza and pasta. You can't go wrong with any of their pizzas and they can also customize it. I ordered the individual chicken parm pizza but asked for vodka sauce instead of marinara. The carbonara, penne vodka, and rigatoni alla toscana have been on rotation in my house. You can customize by adding your choice of protein. The individual portions are HUGE and could easily feed 2-4 people when coupled with an appetizer or pizza. I've only ordered take out thus far but I can say the staff has been friendly on the phone and when I go in to pick up. They're also prompt and I've never had to wait very long for my order to be ready. Definitely try Cassie's if you're in Englewood and have a craving for pizza or pasta! read more
This is a very delicious restaurant in downtown Englewood! We came here for dinner and had a great time. The food was flavorful and absolutely delicious. They menu has pasta, pizza, sandwiches and more! For appetizers we started off with the fried calamari and steak bits. The steak bits were so so good, I'm still thinking about that dish!! Definitely get that as an appetizer to share! For our entrees we shared the penne ala vodka pasta and margarita pizza. Both were excellent options! And lastly, for dessert we had the brownie sundae which just hit the spot. If you're in the area be sure to check them out!! read more
1 year ago
Was in the Englewood area and was in the mood for pizza for dinner. Yelped led me to this spot and after checking the reviews and pics, decided to give it a go. There was a parking area next to the restaurant which we did not need to pay for (not sure if it was just that night). Once we entered we were greeted by a waiter and sat us down to our table. It wasn't crowded although there was another dining area in the back. We ended up ordering a large pie with Half Grilled Chicken and other half BBQ Chicken. The bbq chicken does not come with tomato sauce so that was the reason we got half grilled chicken which came with the sauce. The pizza was solid. Seemed to be all fresh ingredients. The service was great as well. If I was in the area, I would go there again but I would not travel out of my way here. Overall def solid pizza place. read more
I have been to Cassie's since my high school years. They always provide amazing food and I always have a go-to order of their margarita pizza and pear salad. A few days ago, I ordered the chicken parm lunch special with the side of tomato pasta. I was extremely satisfied with the portion size and the overall experience at Cassie's (like usual)! read more
1 year ago
4 years ago
I have been to this place a few times and this is my first review. I called in my order for myself and others. For myself I ordered the tuna sandwich. When I arrived I parked nearby. I walked in and was greeted. The nice young man gathered my food and I paid and left. When I dug in I noticed the tuna had no mayo on it. In fact it was very dry so I had to add my own mayo. Once I added that and the oil and vinegar it wasn't bad. All in all I had a decent experience. read more
1 year ago
One of our bosses treated us to lunch and she really likes the Pear Salad so I accessed their menu through Yelp and called to order. First I want to point out that the menu states that the wraps come with fries BUT I was told fries were extra...ok 86 the fries! My coworker and I wanted the grilled chicken, mozzarella & roasted pepper wrap instead we got chicken cutlet which was dry & greasy. The other 3 meals ordered were Pear Salad, Veggie & Mozzarella wrap...fries extra...& Chicken Parm Hero. Each person said it was good and they were satisfied. REVISIT/REORDER: unlikely read more
We ordered take out from here on a Friday night. Penne vodka - this was everyones favorite of the dishes; good sauce- not too heavy or light. Chicken parm with linguine - tender chicken and nice think red sauce with linguine Garlic bread w cheese - this was a bit on the dry side Plain bread sticks - tasted like pizza crust - good but nothing special Chicken francese - this was ok - chicken was tender and was served on linguine with a mild sauce Pizza- it was gourmet style from their coal fired brick oven. If you like this style pizza it wasn't bad. Could have been done a bit less since some parts of the crust were charred and could have used a bit more sauce/cheese. It was not too memorable overall. Fries - didn't try these but they were not a big hit with the group. Cassies has standard Italian restaurant food that will satisfy if you are in the area but I wouldn't go out of the way to eat here. read more
Owner Andy is super personable and the server Marianna really puts all her best in taking care of you. Which says a lot, it's a big place for one girl to be running the floor, so props to her! With that said, I did have to wave around for service several times. Given she's the only woman on the task to bus the food and serve customers, I can oversee it. The food itself is tasty. The salad was crisp and the portobello tasted fresh. As for the egg parm? Depending on how hungry you are, this is standard American Italian fare. I'll come here when I want a no frills easy weekday dinner, but by no means this is a place for super special occasions. read more
2 years ago
6 years ago
I ordered takeout from Cassie's and was very impressed with the food. I got a Rigatoni Bolognese, Chicken Milanese, Chicken Marsala, Spaghetti and Meatballs. My favorites were definitely the Rigatoni and Chicken Milanese. All the dishes tasted fresh and portion sizes were huge. Everything was well packed and delivered on time. Their menu is quite large and I'm looking forward to trying out their other items next time. read more
I've been to Cassie's throughout the years, but honestly haven't been there for a few years. Not really sure why I stopped going... however with the Covid-19 pandemic, and dining more locally, I'm not really sure why I stopped! I needed several pies of pizza for an event (ordered 12 total) and they were ready for pick up at the specified time, still warm and fresh, and stayed delicious throughout the car ride back and by the time it was served. We even had a couple slices left over, and they reheated perfectly the next day. Come to think about it, I've never had anything that wasn't delicious from Cassies. Their wings are good (even during Superbowl season, they are prompt and delicious), their salads are good, even their pastas are good! And, in my opinion, the cherry on top to Cassie's pizza pies is that they use fresh mozzarella instead of the pre-shredded stuff that some other places use. I think I've found my local favorite pizza shop again. read more
Thank you to Louis and Dominique and our amazing wait staff! I picked this restaurant on the basis of Yelp reviews and a few phone conversations with the staff. We were a group of 18 coming for lunch on Sat after my mom's Memorial gathering. They were able to seat us all inside at a giant table because Covid restrictions had lifted a bit in mid-May. I made all the reservation details from down in FL. I grew up in NJ but hadn't been back in 40+ years. We started with family size apps of calamari, wings, garlic shrimp, and cheese sticks. Then we ordered several pizzas and a few ordered their own entrees. EVERYTHING was delicious!! Thank you Cassie's! read more
3 years ago
2 years ago
4 years ago
3 years ago
Page 1 of 7
More info about Cassie's Pizzeria
Ask the Community - Cassie's Pizzeria
You might also consider
Why does Yelp recommend reviews?
16 reviews that are not currently recommended
The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.
11 years ago
16 years ago
17 years ago
16 years ago
13 years ago
11 years ago
16 years ago
8 years ago
11 years ago
7 years ago
6 years ago
10 years ago
9 years ago
13 years ago
12 years ago
15 years ago
