Stopped for a quick bite to eat in Bergenfield and decided to try this pizza/Italian restaurant. I ordered my staple: a chicken Caesar salad. While the chicken had the consistency of being store-bought and frozen, it was cooked very well, and the salad itself was well-made and tasty. I was particularly impressed by the menus on the wall--they were very vibrant and eye-catching, without being gaudy. The staff was friendly and seemed to have a great rapport with their regular customers. Although I didn't try the pizzas, they looked very appetizing. From what I've seen in previous reviews, it appears they used to be cash-only, but they now accept credit cards, which is a welcome change. Overall, a pleasant experience, and I would consider returning to try their pizzas. --- read more

Nick's Pizza & Pasta - Menus and a sample of their food - Italian Near Me - Bergenfield, New Jersey

Fantastic pizza and great service is what this spot is all about. The servers are always friendly and welcoming. Nice people enjoying some good food eating inside every time I come here. read more

See all

Ever since the new owners took over the pizza and food they serve has been amazing. Every slice every bite is a crunch delicious- the people are very friendly. Tables are clean radio playing very pleasant to eat in too. read more

See all

Nick's Pizza & Pasta 44 W. Main St. Bergenfield, NJ 07621 Cranberry Almond Salad Chicken Parmesan Cranberry Almond Salad: The gourmet salad is a home run! It is piled with lots of fruit on top of fresh romaine lettuce. The raspberry vinaigrette dressing is the perfect choice for this fruit salad. I've also had their slices (not pictured) and that also did not disappoint. Each slice has a great undercarriage while cheesy and crispy at the same time. Chicken Parmesan: Regrettably, I can't say I feel the same way about the main course. It looked decent on the outside, but the taste didn't match its appearance. The single cutlet wasn't breaded to its full capacity; it had a rubbery texture. The thick red sauce had tasty chunks on top, but there was a puddle of water on the bottom of the plate. Cheese didn't have much of a char. When I return, I'll definitely order other dishes, but not the CP. read more

I've only ordered takeout but the food has been good and staff is always very friendly. Great selection of both hot foods and salads!!

They now take credit cards and Apple Pay! They tack on a 3.5% fee for credit card payments, but it's very convenient that they enabled that option. Pasta is just as delicious after they re-opened! read more

My heart is happy and my tummy full! So happy to see Nick's open again. They take card, which will make things easier. Got the Sicilian slice, so crispy and cheesy. read more

Nick's Pizza & Pasta - Sicilian slice - Italian Near Me - Bergenfield, New Jersey

Best pizza in NJ Grew up in Bergenfield New Jersey my whole life moved to San Diego four years ago and every time I'm in town it's a must try and take home read more

Excellent sandwiches and pastas...pizza too! Great service - very friendly staff and big portions! Can even dine in- small set up of booths and tables and very clean! We often take out but many eat in as it's a nice clean atmosphere. read more

Best pizza and food in town. And now that they take credit cards it's even better. I recommend this place to everyone. My whole family is a big fan. We are so happy they reopened after the flood. read more

Hands down one of the top 3 best pizzerias in Bergen county, possibly my favorite. The specialty slices are UUUHMAZING! Chicken bacon ranch pizza is great. 1 slice will make you full and make the button on your pants pop. But it's just too good. My boyfriend orders the veal parm sandwich often from Nicks. We have ordered delivery + ate in several times. No complaints either way. Delivery is always fast + the pizza is always exactly the way we want it. If you eat in it's always clean and the staff is friendly. They have tons of other options other than pizza as well. Stuffed shells, lasagna, eggplant parm.. The whole 9 yards people. I've also ordered salads from here before and they are always SUPER fresh! Honestly, ya can't go wrong with anything here. 5 stars all around. read more

See all

Just moved here recently from Queens, New York. As you may know New Yorkers are critical of pizza.... so with that being said.... you will not be disappointed. This is a cash only pizzeria but don't worry, if you are like me and never have cash on you, they have an ATM on the premises. The pizza is delicious, but don't stop there. Their pasta can rival any Italian Restaurant in the area. They have a few tables, you can order and eat in or take out. They deliver as well. They have a small parking lot or you can park by Rite Aid, go check them out.... thank me later read more

This is my go to spot for pizza topped with broccoli rabe and it is so delicious. Their pizzas are the real deal. I honestly think they have the best pizzas in New Jersey and when I'm not eating pizza, I get a side dish of broccoli Rabe , which has the perfect the amount of garlic. read more

It's been a while since we visited Nick's Pizza in Bergenfield, NJ. We were near and decide to stop by the other day; after getting out the car to turn back around made me realize why did not visit that often: -1* Management/Clerk - they are not nice and unprofessional. -1* Restaurant - is small, damp and not really clean. -1* Payment - options are very very limited to JUST cash; during this pandemic one thing we learned is to updated your technology to make more MONEY & be more customer SOUND & friendly. +1* Food - I heard the pizza was okay but near got the chance to taste it. -1* - parking is limited, no curbside service, no mask, no nothing. I guess we may not get a chance to taste their brick oven food as they are not following any CDC guidelines. read more

Every thing I've ordered was delicious specially their meatball parmigiana sandwich which is undoubtedly the best I've ever tried at a pizza shop read more

The place is solid. We had two slices and a chicken parm hero. Slices were nice and thin, minimal sauce and well done. I prefer full cutlets in my chicken sandwich rather than the chicken being cut up in strips. It fills the sandwich up while using less chicken. It's not the end of the world but it $10 for a sandwich you should some nice large chicken cutlets not a chopped up mess of chicken cubes smothered in processed mozzarella cheese read more

Worst service ever. I order 2 slices. And they don't take cash granted they had signs up. But some people just walk straight in so am not gonna nick pick that. The guy puts both slices wrapped in foil and in a bag. I don't realize it after I pay. I look inside not even a paper plate under. Nothing. I ask the old lady at the register if it's possible if I can get a small box so I can eat in my car. You know what she had the audacity to say. " am not doing doing! For 2 slices! No way." I was shocked. Let it go. I go in the car and sure enough the whole paper bag is filled with grease. Get on my arm rest. I go back inside and have a nice old chat with that rude lady. I show her the bag and the grease and tell her that's why other places put paper plates or even in a small box you don't talk to customers that way. And oh yeah guess what I check the reviews it's all about this rude old lady. She should not work there. Don't buy from there. And good luck if u run into her. read more

Nick's Pizza & Pasta - the front of the restaurant - Italian Near Me - Bergenfield, New Jersey

I wanted to get a couple pizzas for a bunch of folks. Somebody recommended Nick's. The service was good. Cash only. The pizzas were delicious, made to perfection the way we all wanted. A good find! Check out the menu - they have FAR more than just pizza and Italian food! I'm sure it's ALL good. read more

I've been a bergenfield resident for almost 2 years. I think this is the best pizza in town so far. I've tried a lot of their different slices as they always have a variety of different slices in the counter. This place is cash only which I don't like, its 2016 come on. I've ordered full meals a few times always excellent. this place doesn't fail check it out. read more

Nick's Pizza & Pasta - Fresh mozzarella slice. 3.50$ - Italian Near Me - Bergenfield, New Jersey

Was so happy when Nicks opened back up. The new owners kept the food and pizza the same. When they closed after the flood we tried so many pizza places for good pizza and none were as good as nicks. We eat pizza from here at least twice a week. The subs and salads are so good too. And the staff is so friendly. read more

Nicks seriously does the best Italian sandwich in the area. The meat and cheese used is of the highest quality one can expect. The portions are also very very generous for the price. A large sandwich can easily feed two people or one very hungry individual. The pizza is also very good, I love to order they're 5 cheese pizza. They are very generous with the fresh mozzarella compared to other pizza joints. read more

Nick's Pizza & Pasta - The perfect italian sub every time - Italian Near Me - Bergenfield, New Jersey

See all

Pizza is always good. Many different specialty pies. Great salads as well. Dinners are good and there's a nice variety. They use fresh ingredients and a lot of homemade dishes. read more

One of the best pizzerias not just in Bergenfield, but in all of Bergen County. I ordered a couple of pies for pickup, and it was a very easy process. The pizzas were so delicious due to the tasty crust overlapped by the flavorful cheese and tomato sauce. The employees were very friendly when I picked up my order and the service was smooth and simple. Overall, it was a wonderful experience filled with mouthwatering pizza. A great choice if you are in the area! read more

Ordered for the first time tonight. Got the Fresh Mozzarella pie, Chicken Parm, Apple Walnut Salad and the Caesar Salad. Ordering was easy and pleasant, food came quickly, driver was great but the food was all delicious. Highly Recommend! read more

Finally !!!! So happy for Nick's pizza to be reopen !!! Hands down the best pizza and chicken wings I have ever had. Now taking credit cards !!! Yay read more

Couldn't wait for Nick's to reopen, and it was well worth the wait. They never disappoint!

We have used there takeout several times. Food always comes quick. The sauce they use for there pizza and hero's is great. Good bread on the heroes also. We will comeback next trip for more good pizza..... read more

This place is awesome. Great service and great food every time! We especially love the Caesar salad and chicken parm. Also, they were great during coronavirus. And Bea is the BEST. read more

I went to Nicks one afternoon and ask the guy if I can have 2 slices he said sure. He pulled out 2 dry looking slices and put them in oven. At the same time he pulled out a fresh pie. I asked him if I can have my slices from the fresh pie and he said "no , once I sell these then I sell those" I was like really? I can't have fresh slices instead of these slices that look like they're from this morning? The guy was like "that's rite if you don't like it get the hell out of here" and this was in front of other customers I was mortified. SO I NEVER WENT BACK THERE AGAIN. Where I eat now, they gladly give you your choice of pizza and never try to sell me old pizza first. It took months of me seeing this place to become a customer, and 1 minute to lose me as a customer. read more

Came in and asked for grilled chicken with vodka sauce on a roll and they wouldn't make it. He said that vodka sauce was only made for a dinner plate? Not sure how that makes sense. Not coming back. read more

Food was good and its very customer friendly... They accept cash only... read more

5 stars for their plain pie. It's everything you want from a cheese slice. Crust is good, sauce tastes great and the sauce to cheese ratio is also perfect. I've had toppings before, but unless I'm in a mood, I usually stick the plain when I'm here because I won't ever complain about it. Small spot by railroad tracks so I wouldn't dine in, but it can be done if you don't mind the noise of the train. There's usually these two old grandpas sitting together by the window having dinner and they don't seem to mind it. Besides the noise pollution from the train, only downside is that it's cash only. read more

I've been here twice and it's not even in my area. Really polite staff and the pizza is just delicious! I just had their rice balls and they are just amazing. Overall just a nice cozy place with great pizza and other foods and even more polite staff!!! Will be back!! read more

For those who enjoy having their food cooked, or being served by non mask wearing individuals during this horrible covid-19 situation, being yelled at by owners, or the refusal of refunds by owners due to unsafe practices this is the place. The guy is a clown and deserves his restaurant closed due to not following orders. This is going on in the front of the house can you imagine the back. I was forced to call 911 and now will be following with the health department. The arrogance of the man is wild but potentially putting my health in danger is unacceptable. read more

The owner has a serious anger problem. I ordered two slices. I sat down, received a phone call and had to leave in a hurry. I took my plate.to the counter an d asked for.a paper bag. I wanted to bag it my self and leave. After i asked for a bag he started ranting and raving. He has no human kindness skills, nor customer service skills. He is the wrong business. I am not going ever back. read more

Soggy philly cheese steak, fell apart before I could even take a bite . Couldn't even finish the rest before having to immediately running to the best room! Never again! read more

Nick's Pizza & Pasta - Philly cheese steak - Italian Near Me - Bergenfield, New Jersey

I love the specialty slices. Eggplant or spinach and mushroom or white or chicken parm - no matter what you go with you will be more than satisfied. I also like their salads (along with a slice of course.) there have been issues with the customer service, but the quality of food trumps the attitude of those serving it! read more

If you live anywhere near or around the area that Nick's pizza is in, WHY WOULD YOU GO ANYWHERE ELSE? Literally one of the best pizzas I have ever had! Everything from the Calzones to the Rice balls are to die for! Like pizza?! DEFINITELY COME HERE!! read more

Great family pizza restaurant for over 35 years. Grew up eating Nick's pizza and still visit once in a while. Great fresh pizza, and outstanding fresh roasted turkey and roast beef sandwiches. Good stuff. Check it out. read more

I want to give this place 5 stars just for the food alone, but because they don't accept cards and seating is kind of cramped, I can only bring myself to rate it a 4. Pizzawise, they have a great Sicilian. Slices are crisp on the bottom with gooey cheese (not too greasy) on top. Not too expensive, either. Good selection of soups, salads and sandwiches for whatever you may be in the mood for. read more