Cancel

Open app

Search

Caryville Inn

3.6 (9 reviews)
ModerateHotels

Services - Caryville Inn

Hotels

Caryville Inn Photos

You might also consider

Recommended Reviews - Caryville Inn

Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
Yelp app icon
Browse more easily on the app
Review Feed Illustration

Reviews With Photos

Gingerbread man
Sara P.

I have visited a couple of time, and find this a consistently solid spot. The aesthetics are a big plus. Whether you visit in the summer and enjoy their beautiful patio, or sit inside and enjoy the rustic farm decor, or come during the holidays when the decorations are top notch, the presentation of their facilities is very good. On our most recent trip, we came to enjoy $0.25 wing Wednesdays! We ordered 30 wings including bbq, medium and a cajun rub. All ere good, not the hugest wings, but good, especially for 25 cents. The bbq were nice and saucy, and the cajun dry rub had a good kick, but the medium could have used more sauce, they had a unique medium flavor, but they were a little too dry for my taste. We also ordered the pull apart pizza bread which was a special for the week. It was OK, nothing too special but fine. My husband also enjoyed one of the specialty coctails. The service is generally fine. It is not a large place, but was especially packed as one might imagine on wing night. We did make a reservation, and waited a little, but were seated within 5 to 10 minutes of our scheduled time. I did appreciate the waitress bringing a carafe of water when she realized she wasn't coming to our table very often. Overall the food is good and I would recommend this spot. We will be back!

chicken wings
Jeech N.

We heard this place was a dive similar to billygoats or the old sunny's and the apple maps said it was latin american cuisine. It was none of those things. The restaurant was full so we sat on the patio. It was okay but the chairs were kind of strewn about. We heard the chicken wings were 50 cents each on Wednesdays so we ordered some along with a beef on weck. The food took over an hour to come out and I was starting to get impatient. Anyway, when it arrived it was good western new york fare and worth the price. Beef on weck had a flag in it which is a classic move. There should always be flags in sandwiches. There was also a guy who kept looking out the upstairs window onto the patio. Maybe a ghost. Hard to say but he was in flannel. Beers were four bucks and I liked that. Also, large connect four if you feel like gaming.

Cool aesthetic

See all

5 days ago

It is so awesome and so are the owners!!! They are so kind and stop in every once in a while

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

8 months ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 1
Love this 0
Oh no 1

2 months ago

Best spot around, fast and authentic service. I come around this area a few times a year and this is my must stop spot!!

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

2 years ago

Helpful 3
Thanks 1
Love this 1
Oh no 0

8 months ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

4 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0
Photo of KL G.
34
34
22

4 years ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

7 years ago

Helpful 2
Thanks 0
Love this 2
Oh no 0

10 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

Ask the Community - Caryville Inn

You might also consider

Verify this business for free

People searched for Hotels 343 times last month within 15 miles of this business.

Verify this business

La Quinta by Wyndham Batavia - Breakfast Area

La Quinta by Wyndham Batavia

(37 reviews)

$$

I'm giving 4 stars instead of 2 or 3 because I imagine the parking lot side of the hotel is great…read more But in my 3 times here traveling for work, I've never experienced that - including this last time when I asked for a quiet room because I had a big day the next day. Big rigs fly by on the road just outside all day and night - often engine breaking to add to the noise. I was in a corner 3rd floor room this last time, and despite white noise at full volume on one phone and earbuds in with soft music coming from the other, it was still loud to the point I called the front desk about 1: 00 asking for another room - but none were available. I'm not a light sleeper and colleagues have also said they slept poorly. Otherwise, the hotel is clean and comfortable - 5 stars. The breakfast is good (with higher protein options) and the location is convenient as well - easy to get in and out of. Can't decide if I'll go back. Perhaps I'll call first to see if I can be guaranteed an even-numbered room...

The Scarlet Vetter says....we were closed out of the Batavia Downs Hotel so we looked for an…read morealternate nearby. This was very close and had four stars and the reviews were good. The good stuff: the parking lot was spacious, they offer a free breakfast and wifi and they have a decent gym and pool for those looking for those amenities. Now for the issues. The Elevator was out of order. The gentleman in line ahead of us asked about the location of the gym. He then was asked if he wanted a first floor room due to the inoperable elevator and he said yes. Hmmm. Then when my husband and I (in our 60s and me with an injured right knee) were being checked in, she told us we were on the 3rd floor and that she hoped we did not have alot of luggage. Not good. We inquired about the availability of a first floor room and were told that they were sold out. Serious demerit for giving the first floor room to the workout oriented buck ahead of us in line. The hotel is well appointed and the room was seemingly clean but smelled like cigarette smoke. The temperature was difficult to control. My oura ring said my overnight body temp was +.08 which is very unusual for me. The bed was hard. It was quiet overnight and that was a plus. The bathroom was clean and well stocked with lots of towels. However when the fan was turned on in the bathroom, it sounded like a jet engine was in there with you. A helpful feature for them is a text in the morning asking what your intended check out time was so they could plan. That is efficient. The lobby was spacious with late night snack and food offerings with a microwave available. In short, I would likely only come here again failing other known quantities in overnight accommodations in Batavia.

Holiday Inn Express & Suites Batavia - Darien Lake - Ants on ottoman

Holiday Inn Express & Suites Batavia - Darien Lake

(28 reviews)

$$

Stayed here with my son on our way to Cooperstown. On par with most Holiday Inn's we've stayed at…read more The rooms were clean and they had a nice indoor pool and exercise room. The morning breakfast was standard for this chain, but evidently their convection oven was broken (that is what the lady working the breakfast area said) and they were having to cook everything by hand, so at times food took a bit to get out. I did have to call for towels since there was none in our room upon arrival. The hostess said they were swamped trying to get all the rooms ready because there was a big concert the day before and the hotel sold out. I wanted to do laundry (since we're half way through our 8 day trip), but I noticed the laundry room was out of order. I asked a lady from room service if there was another self laundry room on a different floor and she said, "No, but give me your laundry and I'll do it for you in our big laundry room." I thought that was extremely nice of her and sure enough it was done later that night when we returned from a ball game. High marks for them for taking care of that for us. Hostesses were nice and despite some issues, this was a good stay for us on our way to Cooperstown.

Walked in at last minute (11 pm) for a hotel room. They had three rooms left because the pga tour…read morewas in Rochester. The desk clerk told me it would be $299. I was pretty shocked at the price but the clerk said she heard other hotels were charging $1000/ night. I really needed a room so I took it. King suite. One washcloth (there were two of us)!!NO trash can. No Kleenex in the Kleenex box. I don't believe the sheets were clean- found a hair when pulled back. Soap dispenser in shower was not affixed to wall- Just sitting in tub side. Heater made ticking sounds (similar to when you are waiting for a flame to light on a gas stove) every five minutes or so... lasting about a minute. The clerk had told us they had recent renovations. We noticed lots of paint spots all over the bathroom floor. Pool closed due to maintenance. At breakfast- two sets of tongs broke apart when we tried to use them. They only had 5" plates to eat on (kitchen monitor told us "that's all they gave me"). When I used the pancake machine she came out of kitchen and said "oh, is that working?" I said yes. Unfortunately I said it too soon. It spit out one pancake and then stopped working (it was supposed to give two). She was buzzing around and said she needed to clean it up because "corporate is coming today." I'm not one to bitch and get a discount. We were just amused by all of it. For $300 we expected better, but it is what it is. The desk clerk was very nice. We just told her about the room and said they may wish to address those items before someone else comes in. We did notice that she did not apologize or seem surprised by our less than perfect stay. There are many hotels around there. I am an IHG rewards remember so I try to find Holliday inns for my stays. Rewards member or not, I would not stay here again. I would choose one of the others in this location. They share a parking lot with a Hampton inn. Next time, we will try there.

Hampton Inn Geneseo - Guest room

Hampton Inn Geneseo

(20 reviews)

$$

"Jenny, Jenny, Jenny Won't you come along with me…read moreYou know that I love you We could live so happily" (Little Richard) Great location just minutes from Geneseo's Main Street restaurants and the State University campus. Our room had a nice TV and workstation, the bed was comfy, the HVAC and Wi-Fi worked well, and the bath and shower were fine. Included breakfast included scrambled eggs, sausage patties, home fries, a waffle machine, cereal, yogurt, hard boiled eggs, bananas and apples, oatmeal, breads, and pastries. The only odd thing about our stay was the check-in process. The attendant wasn't very friendly and was so slow and silent while working on her computer, we feared that our reservation had vaporized and drifted away into cyberspace somewhere.

Stayed here for a very uncomfortable few hours on my way to Georgia on the 9th of July…read more After trying to sleep for a few hours, I realized the AC was broken. By now it was 12:30 am. I thought "If I'm packing my shit up, I'm only doing it once." I packed and ran into the night manager on the way out. I told him his ac was broken. He said " It'll freeze up if you crank it all the way down!" I replied "Is 69 degrees cranking it all the way down?!" He told me I could change rooms. I told him thought "If I'm packing my shit up, I'm only doing it once." I'm leaving. He told me he could refund $50. I started laughing and said "that's ridiculous, it's not even 1 am. You should give me a full refund". And I left. I drove right by my next Hampton Inn reservation in Ohio 8 hours later. And drove straight home. The Hampton Inn in Geneseo to speak to "Stephanie" today inquiring about where my refund was. She asked what happened and I explained. She said " someone should have offered you another room ". I replied "If I'm packing my shit up, I'm only doing it once." She said, " Well I was going to give you a $50 refund but I'm not, because you're cussing at me!" I said " I sure hope you're recording this call, because I haven't cussed " at you" once! She said, " You said "If I'm packing my shit up, I'm only doing it once." I said" That is not cussing at you, I'm talking about packing my shit up!" She hung up on me. I'm done with Hampton Inn completely. They clearly can't make a repeat guest comfortable and I drive for a living. I'll be staying elsewhere.

Caryville Inn - hotels - Updated May 2026

Loading...
Loading...
Loading...