Carsonie's on Westerville Road is exactly the kind of place that screams authentic Italian! They even have a bocce ball court outside. One thing Carsonie's absolutely nails is the variety. They have everything an Italian restaurant should have like pizza, strombolis, calzones, flatbreads, and full entrées. They serve traditional wedding soup plus 8 different salads. It's the kind of menu range that makes you want to come back and try everything. Our server was experienced, friendly, quick and well-versed in the menu. For our visit, we ordered the original Stromboli served with marinara and a small house salad. The portions were plentiful. My only drawback: both the marinara and the house dressing were a bit too sweet for me. Not bad,, just sweet enough that I wondered if sugar was part of the recipe. Still, with a welcoming atmosphere, a bocce court, a menu full of Italian classics, and generous portions. Carsonie's is an easy place to recommend, sweetness and all. read more

See all

Bartender/server only one handling the dining room and bar She did a great job (had a large group in dining room, 3-4 tables, and 4-5 bar guests). Food didn't match the service unfortunately Just good, not great. Seemingly the trend for Italian in Columbus recently. If the marinara had some effort put into it, would have changed the meal. read more

See all

You know the several times I've come here, I've always expected something maybe a little bit more. Things are just OK/good. Not great. We had the mozzarella sticks, which are clearly not made in house, but OK. We had the buffalo cauliflower which was tasty. We had the Italian fries which are pizza dough strips for dipping. These could've been so much more! I also ordered a calzone and eggplant Parmesan. Both were OK. read more

Carsonie's - Great place for a birthday! - Pizza Near Me - Westerville, Ohio

See all

Upon arriving, we noticed the huge enclosed patio area with full bar, ample parking, family friendly atmosphere in the heart of Westerville. Service was amazing in the bathrooms were extremely clean. My Parmesan fries couldn't have been better but I think my favorite thing was the coleslaw as it tasted just like my mother's. Also, I enjoyed having a window seat where I could see all the locals shuffling in on a Friday after work. The owner even stopped by our table to say thank you for coming in. read more

See all

Had the original large Stromboli and it was on point & fantastic. Sat in the bar area with a couple of friends watching some World Cup action. Got fast & friendly service. Made us feel like regulars and we aren't. Got dumbo ears to go. Also great. Large portions. Decent draft beer selection too! Will be making a return trip to try the pizza which looked amazing. Worth the trip!!!!! read more

Carsonie's - Large Original Stromboli - Pizza Near Me - Westerville, Ohio

Best Stromboli in town hands down. My take out order is always ready on time and the customer service is second to none!!!

Soooo we order the original Stromboli and the fish platter. Stromboli made to absolute perfection. The dipping sauce very good. Tried the fish platter with fries and coleslaw. Both pretty good but not the fish. Pieces of the fish seem not chewable. Didn't like it but will definitely try something else next time. Topped off the meal with Canoli and I must say it was delicious. read more

Carsonie's - Fish Platter - Pizza Near Me - Westerville, Ohio

See all

Always the best stromboli in central Ohio . Can't go wrong with it. They say they have the best fish in Columbus and I disagree strongly. read more

Carsonie's - Pizza Near Me - Westerville, Ohio

A locally owned gem, they have the best Stromboli's in town as well as bocce league's if that's your thing....

The BEST Stromboli on the planet - hands done. Tasty drinks and great service too. Great place to meet up with friends.

Food is always delicious! The service is professional. Location is ideal. Relaxing atmosphere.

Pros: Good location and lots of parking Decent Menu with lots of options Amble seating Has a full bar Cons: Wait staff not very friendly Wait times can be long for larger groups Not much light in dining area Pro tip: Leave plenty of time if you are placing a carryout order. They can get pretty backed up. read more

See all

Poor service. rude server. no waste your time. my husband constantly had his hand up waving to this lady and she would act like she didn't see him or us. read more

Stromboli is as good as ever! We tried the meatballs too. Very tender. Good taste and texture. Service was good. We'll be back!

Great Food, Greatest Service! We reached out to David at Carsonie's to be our caterer for our wedding in Delaware, Ohio on May 31st. We got everything we had hoped for on our wedding day, David and his son came well prepared to serve our guests (130) with a pasta buffet and appetizers! We had absolutely no worries about timing and food prep the day of and received excellent dinner. Everybody has been asking us where the food was from to go try some more ! We are so happy we reached out to them, and thankful for the exceptional service that was provided on our special day! Thank you Carsonie's! read more

Carsonie's - Pasta Rosa , No Mushrooms - Pizza Near Me - Westerville, Ohio

We are visiting from Cincinnati area; our Cincy friends recommended going to Carsonie's - it did not disappoint!! Ordered : Italian fries for app, classic Stromboli to share and elephant ear. All were outstanding!! Service was great!! Cheryl was super friendly and great energy - she was very helpful with the menu and described how the Stromboli and sauce are homemade - explaining that's why the Stromboli takes 30 minutes - no problem - I was excited and glad to wait!!! I feel like it was quicker than that, but was happily distracted by the app. Ambiance was welcoming- like a neighborhood feel with lots of memorabilia and photos of the owners. There were also tvs inside and a bocce ball court outside. Fun place!! We can't wait to come back! read more

Stromboli was great, but the server was the most unfriendly server I have ever had! Maybe she was having a REALLY bad day!

I have been a fan of Carsonie's for so long! Their Strombolis were one of my favorite items to get. Our most recent order of Stromboli's was not so great, we couldn't figure out why at first....but it's the bread! They used to use actual good quality dough, and it was chewy and dense in the best way. The current dough just reminds me of those pillsbury dough rolls at the grocery store. Taste and texture was completely off. Not sure if the cheese changed as well or it the new dough made this Stromboli meh. I'm really hoping it was just a fluke but if this is the new recipe they're using, I'll get off my Stromboli train. The quality is just not worth it for the price. read more

Carsonie's - New and not improved dough - Pizza Near Me - Westerville, Ohio

See all

I have always heard rave reviews on Carsonies food. Since I did not have a car and did not feel cooking. Had a taste for lasagna I decided to order delivery and see what all the hype is about. I have never been so disappointed in a food order, I could have ordered from Fazoli's, received a much better lasagna with garlic bread for $10.49. I could have ordered from Angie on Karl Rd, they have a great lasagna with lots of cheese, a nice piece of garlic bread, plus a salad for less then $14.00. Carsonies lasagna, I could not find any meat or cheese other than on top of sauce. I am not sure what kind of dry bread that came with the meal, that I paid $17.00 for. I guess it is more of a bar then a real restaurant, if I was drunk the food have might have tasted great. Don't waste your time if you have a taste for pasta. read more

Carsonie's - Pizza Near Me - Westerville, Ohio

See all

Basing my review off service- So disappointed. Used to live in the area back around 2017/2018 and would dine here weekly, loved it and Frank in there sometimes the girls always working. Service, Food and beer were always spot on. We were traveling through Columbus tonight as we live out of town now. I was so excited to have a stromboli for the first time in years! We ordered ahead and planned to pick it up on our way.. Came to pick up and they literally made me feel crazy because they couldnt find my order. I go back out to my car, screaming kids now because it's been so long, and take my phone in to comfirm the number I called to place an order. Yes, all correct. Yet, the manager decided to make me feel like it was somehow my fault and continue to remind me that they do not have an order... When I had an outbound call for 3 min talking to a gentleman that confirmed, it'll be ready in 30min.. Regardless, I used to serve and manage myself back in the day and I am just astonished at the lack of hospitality from the manager on duty. No, I'm sorry, when clearly a server didnt submit our order. No, I can get one in but it'll take another 30 min (because yes they cook that long). I understand mistakes happen, what has me so upset is that as a manager you can't take ownership and help serve a customer. Very unfortunate to have this occurrence and experience ruined. read more

My experience at Carsonie's was okay, which is why I'll give it a 3/5 stars. I wouldn't recommend nor not recommend coming here, it was simply average. They are known for their Stromboli's which is why I decided to try this place. Mine came out between cold and lukewarm even though the restaurant was empty so I don't know how that happens unless that's just how they come out of the oven. The Stromboli itself wasn't anything to write home about, would rate it a 6.1/10 because it had a nice crispness to it. Tasted closely like any other Stromboli I've had before. They are on the expensive side, $14 for a small and $24 for a large. I completely ate my small Stromboli and could easy still go eat another meal so I don't know if it's completely worth the price. Overall, my experience was just average and would probably go somewhere else in central Columbus that is cheaper and better. read more

Carsonie's - Pizza Near Me - Westerville, Ohio

Great Stromboli! They have the best Stromboli crust around. This was a good rainy day lunch treat. They were very busy for lunch and the service was still excellent. Very authentic atmosphere here. read more

Carsonie's - Small original Stromboli - Pizza Near Me - Westerville, Ohio

See all

Great food, great service. If you are looking for quality Italian, this is the place!

Energy was definitely off. I sat at the bar. Bartender got me a drink (mediocre martini...but whatever.) She was hustling- I'll give her that. But she had plenty of time to ensure other patrons had what they needed. Walked past me multiple times while waiting on others. I finally had to ask the manager for a menu. Whatever. Even after seeing me with a menu, the manager took my order. Literally the only interaction I had with her was when she took my drink order/ brought my drink and when I had to flag her down for my check. YET she had plenty of time to ask other patrons if everything was okay and if they needed anything else. Location has a touch tunes machine. I noticed any time "urban" music played, somebody promptly overrode it and played another song. Also noticed several patrons that would have rather stood at the other end of the bar than sit at the bar next to me. Make of it as you want...I won't be back. It wasn't openly racist but I definitely did NOT feel welcome there..... read more

took 45 minutes of waiting for a to go order ..... they quoted me 20. be accurate and stop wasting peoples time . also the bartender was annoying, not addressing the mis match on the quote time and referred to me and my (very obviously nonbinary boyfriend) as "ladies". literally will not come back here because it was so unpleasant. there was a nice waitress who offered me a menu to fan myself (it was ungodly hot in there) so shout out to her but wow this establishment is not it read more

My husband and I live close by and stopped here for lunch recently and were really pleased with the food here. This is a casual hometown Italian restaurant with super savory and flavorful food. The wait was a little long to dine in, but worth it. Casual atmosphere with good service. I will probably be ordering the Stromboli again soon for carry out... yum! read more

See all

1st time trying food here. Pros: Portion size is great Cons: Chicken was burnt Food had no seasoning (I had to add SPG) Not enough sauce Overpriced I'm glad I had the foresight to order extra Alfredo sauce as it was definitely needed. Visually, everything looked great. Disappointing that there was no flavor. Well I guess I can't say "no" flavor if I acknowledge the burnt flavor from the chicken. I had to scrape off the breading. I don't foresee myself ordering from here again. read more

See all

I've been to Carsonie's a couple times over the years and have always found it to be just alright. We were literally the only table in the place today and had sub-par service. We shared several dishes - the Italian fries, ultimate loaded fries and pepperoni pizza. The Italian fries really reminded me of funnel cakes - just a *little* less sweet. Probably not worth the calories, in my opinion. The ultimate Loaded fries were pretty good - crisp, hot, and loaded (as the name would imply) with a good amount of pepperoni, bacon and cheese. The pizza was very meh. Maybe stop by if you're in the area, but I wouldn't say it's worth a special trip. read more

See all

Had me wait 20 minutes for my pizza while they made my other food, making my pizza cold. My gf made a joke about how the pizza that's been sitting out for 20 minutes was gonna be mine and I said no way ( I've worked at roosters, they wouldn't have served that crap). No cooperation was going on either our meal was 20 mins late. Will be trying the other carsonies and you should too! At least with pick up read more

Always a delightful time at Carsonie's and the food is delicious! I had the Mediterranean Pasta with shrimp and my friend had an Italian sub, both were amazing! Reasonable pricing, lots of choices, friendly staff and always a military discount, what more can you ask? read more

Ordered 3 pizzas and a salad for carryout. All 3 pizzas were cold, greasy and pretty disgusting. All 3, except for a few pieces, were thrown straight in the trash. Not sure who's cooking or managing, but the food quality has gone downhill for me over the last few years. After 30 some years of going there, I'm done. There are too many good pizza places way better for the money. read more

Wife wanted a Stromboli from Carsonie's today. She loves the Stromboli. We decided to have it delivered - never had an issue with that before. Today, however, the food was burnt and dried out. We ordered a small sausage Stromboli with onions, green peppers, and extra cheese. Never have I seen a Stromboli from Carsonie's look like this this. Extremely disappointed!!! read more

Carsonie's - Sausage Stromboli - Pizza Near Me - Westerville, Ohio

Very cool old style restaurant. For Italian food, it was very bland. Nothing stood out as being great, or even good. For the quality and flavor, it was over priced. The house signature dish was not good. The bar might be cool to drink at. It's kind of like a dive bar atmosphere. read more

It's been at least 20 years since I've had Carsonie's Stromboli. Holy moly it's still DIVINE!! DEEEEEEVINE!!!! We ordered online for a certain time to pickup and not only was it ready but steaming hot!! Regular Stromboli, sweet heat boneless wings, and bbq wings. That will definitely be on repeat! read more

See all

Delicious food at a reasonable price. Wonderful children's menu and also a sumptuous dessert selection. Great selection of beverages. read more

Carsonie's - Yummy Root-beer - Pizza Near Me - Westerville, Ohio

Stromboli is outstanding, my family and I get it every year for Super Bowl parties. Guess are always amazed at it.

My girl and I came here for the first time to try it out. Service was very slow. When they finally took our order, she let us know that pizza or Stromboli would take up to 45 mins (also posted in the restaurant as well as the menu) We thought that was ok and placed our order, put in a couple drinks and some salads to tie us over til the Stromboli was done. When I got my salad, I noticed a strange looking "stem", I assumed. When I touched it, it felt cold and very hard. I pulled it out and it was a nail. A literal nail you could hammer into a wall. I notified the server and she took it back and brought me a new one she insisted she watched the guy in back make. By that point we decided to cancel our orders, pay for our drinks and leave. Not a great experience for a first time and I will not be back. Bummer, too.. I was looking forward to my Stromboli. :( read more

I love coming here. Always have great service and when we get food it's always great. Sure from time to time something might get messed up, but they are awesome and fix it! What kills me is reading reviews of this place and I see people complaining about food yet their plate is completely clear or they make comments of how something should be made, yet they don't read the menu. read more

Stopped by for lunch today. Ordered the 8" pepperoni pizza and garlic cheese bread with marina. Service is was slow with just one waitress taking care of the whole restaurant and bar initially. The sooner you get that the better. The garlic cheese bread came out first. It is a good crusty bread with olive oil, garlic and mozzarella cheese on it. Baked just enough to melt the cheese. It was sprinkled with herbs. The pizza had a great, lightly, golden brown crust. Plenty of mozzarella cheese, with a nicely spiced tomato sauce. You get close to 3 huge pepperoni's on each slice. Drinks were filled in a timely manner. Brittany did a great job keeping up with customers orders. read more

Carsonie's - 8" pepperoni pizza - Pizza Near Me - Westerville, Ohio

See all

Sadly, the food has always been good but, for the love of God, don't order for pickup or delivery. They will f*@! it up EVERY time. I'm still waiting on an order I placed through doordash and the restaurant sent the wrong food. Called my dasher, he picked it up but lo and behold, my food is still at the restaurant and I have to call them. I'm assured another dasher is coming and, after asking, that my food will be hot. Not fresh, just got. Underwhelming to say the least. Thanks for your best effort, carsonies. ​​​​ read more