This was the best pizza slice we had in Times Square (we wanted to try Joe's, but the line was too long). Carnegie has terrific selection, and some interesting options like vodka sauce pizza. The basic cheese slice was terrific. It had great cheese, sauce, and dough. I would definitely come back. There is limited seating in the back. read more

My first time in NYC was this past weekend, we stayed at Margaritaville Resort @ Times Square and conveniently around the corner was the most delicious pizza spot! We are proud to say we came back again again...and again...even the staff noticed ;) We had the plain cheese (the true test), Hawaiian, spicy pep (jalapeño), sausage pep, and last but absolutely not least the mouthwatering garlic knots. SO F'N AMAZING!!! read more

Carnegie Pizza - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

NY is famous for its pizza, and Carnegie Pizza lived up to the hype. When you walk into Carnegie Pizza, you order your slice(s), pay, and they heat up your pizza in the large pizza ovens. You also get to eat standing up in the small space. They did have a few tables, but that's it. I chose to stand up and get the full experience. I got a slice of the pepperoni & mushroom. One friend got a four cheese and an upside-down, while another tried sausage & mushroom and eggplant. We all LOVED our pizzas! My thin crust was crisp and had just the right amount of sauce and melted cheese. Oh man, I should've gotten more than one slice. Thanks for the great pie, Carnegie Pizza! read more

See all

I really enjoyed my pizza! Now it wasn't the best damn pizza of my life, but it was a solid choice for 12am in NYC. I have no regrets I'd come back here for a late night pizza run, I thought it was better than Joes pizza. Service was quick and there were minimal seats inside. Super casual spot. read more

Carnegie Pizza - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

Good pizza, fast, plenty of seating and standing area. Lots of variety. Tried a buffalo slice but dang, gone are the $4-$5 slice days lol. It's expected, I guess, in today's economy, but I think they also do a cheese slice and soda combo here. Either way, easy walk and stop from port authority. read more

Carnegie Pizza - B - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

See all

The line for Joe's Pizza in Times Square was obnoxious so we gave Carnegie Pizza a try. There was hardly any line and the selection of pizza by the slice was excellent. We tried a pepperoni slice, a sausage slice, and some kind of thick, square, pepperoni slice. They were all very nice, especially the square one. We also tried some garlic knots which had a ton of garlic flavor. They were decent but not essential. There is limited seating but plenty of ledges for standing. I can't compare the pizza to Joe's but there is value in not standing in a ridiculous line. And the pizza was definitely solid. read more

Carnegie Pizza - The square pepperoni slice was the best one. - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

See all

There's no way to have guessed that the pizza place closest to our hotel would be such a hit. It's a cute spot with a few tables for dining. The service is very New York (take with that what you will). The pizza did not disappoint. I went with a traditional cheese slice (well two to be exact). They were good and filling without being greasy. At only $4 a slice, it was also reasonably priced. I recommended this place to several other friends as well. read more

See all

Delicious! Must stop in! Less tourist and more locals. Pizza was delicious, thin crust and crispy and a perfect crust. The ham and pineapple was delicious and there is not any red sauce on it. The pepperoni and mushroom was excellent but the jalapeño and pepperoni pizza took the cake! The place does have limited seating so if you see a table grab it quickly! Enjoy! read more

See all

I absolutely loved Carnegie Pizza in NYC. The menu was a full display of different pizzas, which made it fun to choose. There were four of us and we all ordered different slices every one was delicious and perfectly cooked. They also have a great selection of drinks, including sodas as well as beer and wine, which was a nice bonus. The customer service was friendly and knowledgeable, and they were happy to explain the options. The environment was clean, though small. The only downside is the seating. There are only about three tables, so it was difficult to sit down during a busy time. Thankfully, someone was kind enough to let us share their table. Overall, great pizza, great service, and solid options read more

Carnegie Pizza - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

See all

Right next to Joe's Pizza but better service and pizza. Cheaper too. No line and limited indoor seating but they had a lot of interesting flavors. The calzone was large and tasty. Our hotel staff recommended this place too so definitely check it out if you want an authentic New York pizza. read more

See all

This Pizza place was right next to the Hampton INN where we stayed near Times Square. Great Pizza, lots of varieties. Super Affordable and hit the spot. My daughter and I went here a few times at night before we turned in for the night. There are a few small tables to sit at. There is also a counter top along the wall if you want to stand or don't mind standing. The guys are super nice! Tip them well.. read more

We were in NYC, and of course we had to have some pizza. I tend to like the holes on the wall where you buy pizza by the slice. Carnegie didn't disappoint. The crust was perfect, and the toppings were on point. What else is there to say? I recommend. The only drawback is that as any small establishment, there isn't a lot of seating. The pizza is worth it though. read more

Carnegie Pizza - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

This was the first pizza stop we took in NYC and it was great. The price was not too expensive which is always a plus and the workers were great. Spanish speakers so I felt at home, the place is a little small but you are in and out quick so it's fine. Great eats. read more

See all

Staff was great... very friendly. Food was excellent, quick service, good drink selection.

I didn't get a chance to eat as many slices as I'd hoped on my trip to New York, but Carnegie was the final slice and the best I tasted. You know the drill - order your slice and they'll chuck it in the oven. When it comes out, it will melt the roof of your mouth with the molten cheese, but you won't care because it's New York and it's a great slice and you're about to see something weird go down in Times Square. Make this a stop whenever you're in the area. read more

See all

Ehh... no. The slice I.grabbed from here had the most flavorless sauce and a mediocre-tasting crust. The only promising thing was the amount of cheese. I would like to think that I simply had an off experience based on some of the reviews... but surely the sauce doesn't change? It tasted like bland tomato paste with zero flavor. The under part of the pizza was a little soggier than I'd prefer. This was not a good slice for me. Yelpers led me right with all of my other NY pizza, but sadly this was a letdown. 2025: 58/100 read more

As an out of towner, I definitely wanted to make sure I had some New York pizza. Went to two places and I definitely preferred this over the other. I had the pepperoni mushroom. I liked the crust - thin and not too crispy. A little greasy to be expected. The garlic knots had good flavor. Staff was nice. Overall good experience. read more

Carnegie Pizza - Inside - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

See all

This definitely didn't taste as good as it looked. I had the Square Sicilian pepperoni slice. Looked great. But it was so salty I could hardly finish it. In fast if it didn't have salt there would be no flavour. On top of that it was greasy. I would for sure skip this place. read more

Carnegie Pizza - Greasy, salty and not flavourful. - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

While in New York, I had to grab a slice of pizza, and this spot in Manhattan did not disappoint! As you can see from the photos, they offer a variety of options, including deep-dish and New York-style pizza, as well as calzones and garlic bread. Everything is heated up in the oven when you order, ensuring it's fresh and hot. There was nothing particularly special about the place, but the pizza tasted amazing--definitely a must-try when in New York! I had the pepperoni and mushroom slice, and I had no complaints. The slice cost about $5, which is pretty standard. The space was small and crowded, typical for New York, but I was impressed by how clean it was, especially given how busy it gets. You can choose to dine in or take out. I'll definitely be back! read more

Carnegie Pizza - Interior - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

This is one of my favorite places to grab a slice of Pizza in NYC. It's efficient, tasty, and never disappoints. read more

Carnegie Pizza - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

Really good pizza at a very fair price, especially for Times Square! Carnegie Pizza feels like classic New York. The slices were hot, crisp, and cheesy with that perfect foldable crust. The sauce was flavorful, fresh, slightly tangy, and not too heavy, and the cheese was melted just right. Service is quick, friendly, and consistent every time. We went twice in one weekend! :) Whether you're grabbing a slice on the go or sitting down for a quick bite, this is the perfect pizza spot. read more

Joe's pizza wait was way too long even at 12am. Hubby did not want to wait so we went to try this place. Crust was thin good texture and tomato sauce flavor was good. But mushroom slice was a lil too wet. read more

Carnegie Pizza - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

See all

Any time I'm visiting New York City, you can bet I'm going to want some pizza. I have my go to spots, but this time I deviated, deciding to try out Carnegie Pizza instead. I went with the square pepperoni slice and it hit the spot! However, it was pretty greasy. Not much to note in terms of service or ambiance. This is really your typical pizza spot. Bring your appetite and grab a slice (or two)! read more

See all

There's just something at NY pizza. The crisp dough. The size. The quick, ready to go pizza. Only downfall...so much grease. Yet so delicious. One slice, will do you good. read more

Carnegie Pizza - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

See all

Between this place or Joe's... go with Carnegie! Both a short walk from Times Square. Me and my boyfriend walked passed this place multiple times before we finally decided to try it... especially after the shameful experience at Joe's, why not right? They weren't as busy as Joe's. That's a plus for us (no line), not so much for them. They should be busier! Once we walked in we were greeted with smiles and got our order taken right away. When we got our pizza slices, they were nice and hot! Just how it should be! It's a small little pizza parlor, limited seating, clean. Only reason I'm not giving 5 stars is simply because they aren't the best I've ever had but they definitely deserve to be acknowledged a lot more than Joe's. Keep it up! read more

See all

We ate here twice and loved it! We tried another pizza place and it was near as good. Well priced and great pizza! read more

See all

A solid NY pizza. It is what you expect to eat here, and it was not a terrible price. Came back here twice during our trip. Staff was delightful. Not a long line. Only - was that there's not much space to sit and eat your pizza. However that's the beauty of a pizza slice. Take it and eat on the go! read more

Carnegie Pizza - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

See all

We wandered in to this place due to the close location to our hotel and not wanting to walk a lot during the heat wave. The spicy pepperoni and grandma slices were the best. The barbecue chicken and margherita were gross. read more

Carnegie Pizza - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

I've been to many New York pizza joints and I have to say, this one is my favorite so far! The restaurant itself is simple, and was crowded! We were still able to snag a spot at a counter to eat. It's got the typical NYC vibe. Busy, quick, and filled with pizza. We ate at the one in Times Square. Get yourself some pizza! read more

Carnegie Pizza - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

See all

Grabbed a slice of the spinach mushroom pizza, it was pretty decent, though definitely on the pricier side for what it is. The place stays open late, which is a plus, and it wasn't too busy when I went. Just keep in mind there's limited seating, so it's more of a quick stop than a sit down spot. read more

Carnegie Pizza - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

Was going to another pizza place and after seeing the LINE... We ended up here and boy were we satisfied! Im so glad we ended up at this little pizza place. Theres barely any seating inside but... its new york what are we expecting? The service is fast and efficient, the food is delicious, the ambiance is good vibes! The choices of pizza are endless and the garlic buns are delish! I definitely recommend stopping by here for a little lunch vibe during your stroll in NYC. read more

Carnegie Pizza - Spicy Pepperoni Pizza Pie - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

See all

Enjoyed another delicious lunch at Carnegie Pizza. I really enjoy the cleanliness of this pizzeria, the brightness of the lighting, and the many options of slices. Today's selections were onion/pepper/mushroom and Grandma slices. Both were crispy, fresh, at the perfect temperature, and VERY GOOD. Carnegie Pizza will be my top 3 lunch options and I hope you make time to enjoy their menu. TIP: If you pay cash, you'll save on the 3.5% credit card usage charge. read more

See all

Wanted to get a nice slice of New York pizza so I went to the highest rated place near hotel. Of course there was a line of kids staring at the board wondering what to order so I caught a guys eye and pointed to the pizza that I wanted. He grabbed it in put it in the oven minutes , in about five minutes it was ready Ambience of this place is just what you'd expect and the service is pretty good but I was disappointed in the pizza - just average and I have had better in Greenville and Miami read more

Carnegie Pizza - Veggie Sicilian Pizza Slice - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

A couple banging, albeit expensive Sicilian slices. Friendly people, limited seating. Good for a quick slice in your NY travels. read more

See all

Bland tasting pizza, crust not thin enough nor crunchy enough, sauce not enough flavor, it can also use a tiny bit more salt.

This place was not as crowded as the other pizza places in time square. Nobody is serving you, you have to order and wait for it. Luckily we were able to get some seats. Prices are affordable by the slice. I was expecting Italians making this pizza since I am at an Italian Pizzaria! Workers were blasting Mexican music in the back. Lol Overall I recommend. Can't give it 5 stars since they reheated my pizza with small portable oven. Was not fresh but still tasty. read more

Carnegie Pizza - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

See all

My family and I are on vacation and wanted to try NY pizza. We wanted to go to Joe's pizza at first, but the line was way too long so Carneggie pizza was our second choice. I'm so glad we ended up here. The ambiance was small, but it wasn't bad and we were lucky to grab a table for 4. On to the pizzas. It was so delicious we had to get seconds. I highly recommend coming here if you are in the mood for pizza. read more

See all

This is a great pizza spot if you are looking for a quick bite in Times Square! There are plenty of options to choose from, and we ordered the pepperoni pizza pie, a slice of Margherita pizza, and garlic knots served with marinara sauce. Each item was very filling for 2 people, and the servers/cashier behind the glass were efficient with our order. My favorites were the garlic knots and the Margherita slice, each were soft and flavorful upon being warmed. The pepperoni pizza pie was good, but could get a bit messy with the big bites you'd have to take and is on the chewier side. There is limited seating and there doesn't seem to be any restrooms if you intend to wash your hands after. However, most people tend to stop by to buy to-go, so you are likely to have seating if you plan to dine-in. read more

Carnegie Pizza - Pepperoni Pizza Pie - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

See all

Came twice in 3 days, mid day and midnight; good both times. Ask for it extra crispy. Quick service . Chill atmosphere. read more

Carnegie Pizza - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

Visiting NYC (not our first rodeo), and stopped at Carnegie for a few slices. It was EXACTLY what we needed. Service was quick and despite the small seating area we were able to squeeze in! The pizza tasted great- thin crust, just the right amount of sauce and lots of cheese. I will definitely return! read more