Quick to go location near Columbus circle! they also offer FREE DELIVERY! We had a white slice + chicken and it was great. We ordered there and took it to go but wish I knew about the free delivery option. They just have a little tiny inside area, it's a bit smushed to wait if you're getting to go so will be doing the delivery next time. Prices are about avg for the area, for some reason I think the delivery was actually a bit cheaper. Great for a quick pizza stop! read more

You have to really stumble into this by chance to find it. Google/Apple Maps is just smothered by so many good pizzerias in Manhattan. Pop's is also smacked right in the middle of the business district, it seems very unassuming to find just a diamond in the rough. The price of a plain slice is competitive. What you get is a crispy, thin, saucy and right amount of cheese. It's not too salty and it's not too floppy. This, right here, is a New York Slice. read more

Pop's Pizza - Slice - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

Definitely a good takeout pizza spot despite being in the thick of one the most touristy areas. Like their jalapeño pepperoni, plain margarita. Their other location down in 52nd St is way sub-par. Size is huge but ofcourse its gonna be atleast 5 bucks for a slice so don't expect 99c slices. Verdict- if in mood for quick and good slice near Columbus circle read more

While staying at the New York Athletic Club, Pop's was recommended as the place to go for a quick bite. Just a short walk from the Club, Pop's offers that classic New York slice of pizza. A small space with no seating, but counter space to enjoy a slice of heaven on thin crust. Quick service gets you saucy, cheesy, flavorful and the perfectly sized slice of pizza to eat as is or folded in half. I know there are a lot of pizza places in NYC, but there is a reason Pop's was recommended to us. It's a great representation of what everyone thinks of when they think of a New York slice! Before you try anywhere else, I dare you to try here first! read more

See all

Margarita - it freshly came out of the oven so we ordered it! However, it wasn't super hot just warm and I think if they heated it up again right before serving it would've tasted better but since it was fresh I think they didn't and assumed it would be hot since we saw them heat other pizzas lol. Nice thin breading, cheese was good but a little harder (needs heat), it had a nice garlic flavor in every bite maybe through a garlic oil? It made it a tiny bit too oily but flavor was good. Sauce was very good and on the sweeter side 3.5/5 read more

See all

Wowser pizza. Their own style but fab touch and taste. Often crowded but line goes quick. A super secret find.

3.5 stars Decent slice of pizza near central park and broadway. Grabbed the spinach mushroom and vodka (didn't really taste like vodka though). read more

Pop's Pizza was ok. It's really more of a takeout or eat on the street type of place. The staff wasn't very welcoming. No greeting, just very transactional, not really friendly. The pizza itself was fine, but nothing that would make me go back, especially with so many stronger options in NYC. read more

Pop's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

Love the idea of a fast NY style slice...but to put it frankly, other places do it better. The cheese here tastes a little too artificial and the undercarriage and crust were inconsistent from slice to slice. And it made my iron gut upset, which is no easy feat. read more

Pop's Pizza - Cheese pizza - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

This place rocks! Awesome NYC style pizza, quick service, friendly staff. If you need a quick late night stop to refuel, definitely hit up this spot. read more

Pop's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

Pop's is a proper NY slice to go. Perfect cheese to sauce ratio, and it's got the exact crust you come to NY for. Thin, crispy, and just the perfect amount of slightly sweet. read more

Excited to discover this "hole in the wall" Pop's Pizza, around the corner from Columbus Circle. The slice looked great and size for $3 bucks in this neighborhood was a good deal. My fresh basic slice came out quickly. That being said, while the crust was excellent for a classic New York slice, the rest disappointed with barely any flavor - possibly only faintly of cheese. (Perhaps just a bit more sauce or seasonings in the sauce would help!) As is, Pop's Pizza's cheese slice is world's worth the extra compared to one of those $0.99/1.50 awful options you may find close by! For me, I'm likely to opt for something elsewhere. read more

Pop's Pizza - Pop's Pizza 3 Buck Slice - Great size and crust, but otherwise little flavor - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

Close to the park and as good as it gets for a low key, sidewalk slice. We were at the playground in CP and yelped what was the best pizza around and this came up. We also noticed that several families had whole pies from this place at the park so we knew it had to be good. My son still talks about this place. He isn't a pizza aficionado but he likes what he likes and he loves this place. My wife got a slice she liked so much that she got another one read more

Pop's Pizza - Slices - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

The margarita pizza was fresh and phenomenal and a huge slice Would def get again. The Hawaiian wasn't as good. Get whatever is fresh! read more

Pop's Pizza - Margherita and Hawaiian Pie - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

Really good pizza spot that was near where I was staying. Highlight for me was the cheese slice as it was delicious despite its simplicity. Great chew on the crust as well. I also got the buffalo chicken which was also pretty good if you're into that type of slice. Finally I also ordered the pepperoni square slice which was okay. While the crust was good, I felt the dough to sauce/cheese ratio was a bit too much on the dough side. For me I'd stick to the slices. Definitely will be back next time I'm in the area! read more

See all

I was visiting a friend up near the park and I was hungry and wanted to grab some pizza. He had recommended this place because he said it was fast and I've never heard of it. It's a very small spot with a walk up counter. There was a little bit of aligned and really, no space in the place. The workers are super fast and they are pumping out a lot of pizza in here. They did have a lot of different varieties, but I just went with the pepperoni and the cheese slices. The cheese slice was three dollars, which is not terrible for New York City at all. I was pleasantly surprised by how good it was. Definitely a hidden gem that I would try again. read more

Pop's Pizza - Pepperoni and cheese slo e - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

[Food] - Vodka Sauce ($6.95): Yum! Crust was thin and crispy. Sauce was perfectly sweet and savory! [Service] - Friendly & helpful [Ambiance] - A small little shop where you order inside, pay, then pick up at the other window under a small canopy [Overall] - Would come back again to try their other slices! read more

Pop's Pizza - Vodka Sauce ($6.95) - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

Solid pizza place and one of the most affordable bites in an otherwise pricey neighborhood. The vodka slice I ordered was $6.50 after tax, a great deal considering it spared me from a bout of hanger. There are a few standing tables on the sidewalk outside but no seating. Pizza was a little oily for my liking but tasty. read more

Pop's Pizza - Vodka - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

First time trying this tonight & wow it deserves its flowers. I'm from NY and a lot of the popular places are flooded with lines or just fell off. I saw the pics & reviews from yelp and thought no way. I use to live on the ave & decided to support them. Each slice I got...APPROVED. The pics I have arent that great so apologies on that. Once it got delivered the mushroom slice with carmalized onion & argula smell was soo good. I do wish there were a few more pieces of mushrooms on my mushroom slice though. Will be ordering again & again no doubt. I even texted some friends and told them about Pop's before I even finished eating. read more

See all

was near columbus circle and craving a new york slice. walked here and inhaled my new york slice. lots of variety for ready to go slices and cute counters to eat standing before you continue on your merry way. servers are really kind. cards accepted for $5 min purchases and their fancy big slices are $5 so easy enough. enjoyed my white sauce. read more

See all

Vodka pizza very flavorful, fresh, and thin crust. No line, easy to order, and delicious!! There's small tables you can stand and eat your pizza with some cheese, pepper, etc outside. Probably one of my favorite pizza places so far read more

Pop's Pizza - Vodka slice - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

Solid place for an NYC pizza slice, easy, quick, hot, and fast. We were able to grab some slices and garlic knots on our way back from a show. Service was friendly, the space is small, just big enough to step inside and order your pizza and pay at the register, grab some drinks, and go. There's a small counter at the window in case you need to pick up your order or want to eat and that's about it. read more

Pop's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

See all

This pizza shop located near the central mall and park. Very Good pizzas ! Must try! read more

Pop's Pizza - Pizza - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

Wanted some quick slices of pizza & made a stop here. I chose cheese, meat lover, and bbq chicken for slices and garlic knots. The inside is small- there's slough space to look at the pizzas and order at the counter. If you want to eat they have a standing table outside or take it to go. They popped the slices and garlic knots in the oven so they were hot. The garlic knots are on the bigger size. My favorite slice was the meat lover because of all the flavor with each bite. read more

See all

Love this spot. I come here every time I'm in NY. The pizza is delicious and I love the variety they have. It is so well made and like $4-5/slice but worth it. They have a stand up outdoor counter you can eat at or take it to go. read more

Pop's Pizza - Mushroom spinach. Margherita. - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

See all

We went here on a whim for a quick bite. Pepperoni, meat lovers and their crust were SO good! Great price and friendly service too. read more

Pop's Pizza - Pepperoni slice - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

Stopped here for a slice after walking around Central Park and I really enjoyed their pizza! We ordered the jalapeño pepperoni and the meat lovers. The jalapeños they had were actually kind of sweet to me rather than spicy, but I still liked it! Their crust is perfectly thin and crispy and I love all the toppings they put! Service is quick, they reheat all your slices for you. They have a little stand outside for people to stand and eat outside of their shop. read more

Pop's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

Pop's Pizza gave us a large order of great, high quality pizza for a terrific price..

A literal hole in the wall place near Carnegie Hall, but the slices are correct. Large, great sauce and a good crunch to the thin crust. You have two dining options, eat at a tiny standing table or while you walk. Either is just fine when you want a solid NYC slice. read more

Really decent pizza near Central Park. Love the meat lovers and the Pepperoni Jalapeno. It's small and there's no seating, but there's lots of places nearby to eat, or you can stand at the counters. I do wish it was open later as the 10pm close time makes it hard for those of us who want a late night pizza. The business is certainly there, but not for me to decide. read more

Goals are to do a pizza trip of New York. Let's compare all the pizza windows and figure out which one is best. This could take a while. Now keep in a mind there are a lot of posers out there in pizza window world. Hot take but If they have to advertise their pizza deal (2 slices + soda = $6), they are probably not the best pizza in New York. Our first find on the first day was Pops Pizza. It's off 7th/57th street next to a dry cleaner. There is construction going on at the moment but don't let that deter you. Pops takes cash or card. They have a variety of pizza options. We got the jalapeño & pepperoni along with the margherita pizza. They warm it up and put in a box for us. Seasonings are all outside with garlic, crushed red pepper and Parmesan. You can easily walk to Central Park from here and enjoy your slice. Walking to Central Park gave us the perfect amount of time to let the pizza cool off a bit. We found q seat in the lawn and had our slices. It had a floppier crust, but the sauce and the toppings were well worth it. Even the crust was great to finish. Does this taste better in Central Park? probably. Does this pizza rank as one of the best, in my opinion yes. The variety, ability to take credit cards and proximity to Central Park let it take the cake. read more

Pop's Pizza - Pizza window - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

See all

Omg this is the greatest pizza in NY!!!! Truly!!! Super thin crust, plentiful ingredients, kind service! It was light enough that it didn't spike blood sugar and entirely delicious! read more

Pop's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

See all

Great slice place near Carnegie hall. Slices were crispy and well balanced. One was plenty!

The perfect slice on the go! After a long walk through Central Park, we popped in here for a bite. There's a stand outside if you want to stand and eat with friends on the street. This spot delivered everything you want in a NY slice, minus the long lines at the tourist traps. We tried the garlic white and pepperoni with jalapeño--both were delicious. I'm already craving my next slice. read more

See all

Amazing pizza to pick up and eat in Central Park! I thought their vodka slice was really good with big pieces of mozzarella. The pepperoni slices were yummy too and very huge. read more

Pop's Pizza - Pepperoni and vodka slices - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

So good! Really authentic loved it & the sauce was amazing! Loved the cheese pizza & the crust was delicious and fluffy

Is this place new? Has it changed recently? How have I never heard of this? No seriously, this may be the best pizza in the Columbus circle area. You may not see something uniquely exceptional about them at first glance, but their fundamentals are as solid as anywhere and once you actually go you'll appreciate how delicious it is. Their crust has a perfect tender yet structured texture. Their toppings are familiar yet paired intelligently with some combinations I don't often see elsewhere (peperoni-jalapeño and mushroom-spinach are two favorites). Their sauce is good (and crucially not too sweet), and the service is quick, easy, and pleasant. If you're looking for lunch or dinner on the go anywhere in the upper 50s on the west side give pop's a try, you won't be disappointed. Note, no seating, it's grab and go (or eat at their outdoor counter). read more

Pop's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

Had Pop's Pizza at a Sobriety Society event, and it was delicious! I'll definitely check out the shop next time I'm in the area.

I felt so bad when I called to see if they sold by the slice. I tried to find info on it on Yelp but struggled seeing any new information about it. So alas, I went there for science and to try this place out. Walking distance from our hotel, it took just a few minutes to get there. They had so many options for by the slice and settled on 4 different ones. Honestly, enjoyed every single slice with the spinach one coming in as our favorites. They now have two locations so if you decide to order online, make sure you go to the right one. Come give some love to this place and get some great New York style pizza. read more

Pop's Pizza - Huge by the slice menu, every one was great. - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

See all

This is a very classic NYC grab and go, stand by the ledge while you eat a massive pizza spot! We got 2 pizzas and they were both very different. The vodka pizza is thicker and crunchier while the pepperoni was thinner with the flavor growing in each bite. Each slice was about $6 (not sure what pizza economics are) but the portions for each slice were massive! read more

Pop's Pizza - Pop's Spicy Jalapeo Pepperoni & Vodka - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York