Capizzi Reservations
Order Capizzi Takeout or Delivery
Capizzi Photos
Business Info
CAPIZZI ATMOSPHERE
You might also consider
More like Capizzi
Recommended Reviews - Capizzi
Start your review...
Reviews With Photos
Cute little spot with great service. The pizza was really good and we loved the arugula salad with artichokes and the arancini. They even have a dessert pizza with Nutella that we enjoyed.
Very cute and cozy interior. Food quality and service was great! We particularly loved the homemade sangria. The restaurant is very small, so it's best to make a reservation.
very cute small pizza restaurant with great food, wine options, and friendly waiters. everyone was so nice and love how this place is decorated. definitely would come back and get wine with my pizza next time!
Service 10- Pizza 15!!! You come into their dining room and feel right at home. The pizza is made to order and it is absolutely delicious. Love everything about the pizza. The wine was also very good, straight from Italy.
I came here with my husband and his other friend and his friend's girlfriend. They used to come here all the time when they lived near Port Authority. My husband always wants pizza, like always, so between this place and another restaurant, we chose this one. It was Sunday afternoon so not too crowded. Server was quick. We started with the artichoke. Our friend said they used to have more artichoke on the plate but now it's only 2. This was a bit shocking for them. They also so got arancini - which they also commented that it used to come with 4 balls and now only 3. My husband got the meat lovers pizza and I got a prosciutto pie. Our friends also split a prosciutto pie. The slices are sliced into 4's, so much larger than anticipated. The pizzas are wood fired so the crust is amazing: chewy and crunchy at the same time. It's a cute little pizza spot that I definitely recommend if you're looking for some quality pizza. The menu is limited so no pasta but who doesn't love pizza? Also their bathroom is super cool; it's an old-fashioned toilet with a pull down level to flush. Unfortunately the water pressure is weak so you may have to pull a few times to flush everything but still pretty awesome.
quick story... 11 years ago I came here with my brother & cousin on a whim because I saw this place recommended on Tumblr... I've been back to NYC many times since but had never saved this spot.. and I FINALLY FOUND IT AGAIN. I've been searching as I never forgot about this pizzeria!!! I say all this to say that pizza taste just like it did then. Exceptional italiana style pizza. I had the hot honey to share with my partner (2 slices each) and we ended with an espresso. Had lunch on a Wednesday @2 and it was very lowkey, no wait, great service, and good vibe. I'll be back again!!!
Dinner in New York City... My good Yelp friends were looking out for me. They noticed that I was in New York and suggested that I get some New York pizza! I told my friend and she told her brother. They had been to Capizzi in the past and said that this place is really good because the pizzas are baked in a brick oven and the pizzas are personal sized. Okay! We walked over from the theater and entered the cozy, warm, dimly lit restaurant. Service was very welcoming and helpful! We shared the Artichoke salad with pine nuts... delicious! My friend and her brother got the Loaded pizza while I got the Prosciutto Fungi pizza. I enjoyed the texture of the mushrooms and the fragrant, fresh basil. The Prosciutto added the savory flavor to the thin, crisp crust! We finished off our feast with a large piece of Tiramisu... it was moist and not too sweet! We were so full that we took an entire pizza home - one quarter from me, one quarter from Marlina, and half of David's pizza! It made a wonderful breakfast the next morning!
When in the city, make sure to visit Capizzi! This is easily my favorite pizza spot. No wait times, quality pizza, and excellent service. Highly recommend.
Was looking for a slice, opened up Yelp, gave this spot by the Theater District a chance. Service was great, the food was solid, the ambiance on the casual side, and the restaurant definitely got quite busy. Caesar Salad -- 3 1/2 Stars. Very cheesy and coated in thick dressing, if that's your thing. Margherita Pizza - 4 1/2 stars. Tasty, light, delicious! Pepperoni Pizza - 4 stars. A solid pizza, light thin crust that I really liked.
Such a cozy pizza place! Never felt rushed. Service was amazing and we will definitely return!
We loved this place! We came after seeing a show and the pizza was delciousssss. We ordered a Marguerite pizza and then got a side of hot honey and a side of Caesar dressing to dip. Absolutely amazing. The house made sangria was fantastic. Tiramisu was good too. The restaurant is so cute and the service was amazing.
New York has so many great Italian options, so I was very excited to try this restaurant. Upon entering the establishment, I was very pleased with the ambience of the restaurant, which was decorated in a very charming, quaint style that reminded me of Italy. There were vines hanging on the ceiling and lots of vintage memorabilia on the walls which were a fun conversation starter at our table. The restaurant is very small inside. We ordered several pizzas, though I mainly had the eggplant one. It was ok, and the crust was beautifully cooked and charred. However, I'm rating Capizzi 3 stars because my friend ordered a gluten-free pizza because she is legitimately gluten-free. The waitress assured us that this was an option provided at this restaurant. When the pizza came out, my friend was pleasantly surprised because the crust looked too good to be gluten-free. And she almost ate it, but her skepticism made us double-check with the staff again. And unfortunately, the crust was not gluten-free. There was a mixup, which they promptly fixed. I appreciate how the issue was handled, it's just that this could've been a compromising situation for my friend. Overall, the food was okay, though the vibes were very fun. I don't know if I'd go out of my way to revisit this place, but it's a solid choice if you're in the area.
1 month ago
Amazing. Made a reservation about eight days ago, for after our river cruise. Such a cool little spot. Ambience is quiet, chic and cozy. We ordered the hot honey pepperoni pizza. Incredible! The prosciutto and arugula was also great. The dough is perfect. Firm, yet soft, yet not soggy or chewy. Don't forget to start with the Caprese salad. Wine list is great. We had a bottle of Montepulciano. Massimo is an incredible server! Not sure there are many humans like him. Connected perfectly with us. So friendly. And we could tell he loved his job. Gonsalvo was also great! A wonderful team. Definitely would return if/when we visit NYC again. read more
5 months ago
I loved my meal here with my partner! We started with the Burrata which came with prosciutto, roasted peppers, artichoke hearts and cherry tomatoes. The olive oil and salt and pepper paired perfectly with everything and was rich but not overwhelming. We also shared Pane & Olio which was a yummy, well seasoned flatbread. We both shared a Bianca pizza which was so good. All our food was served quickly and our server was kind. We thought overall the restaurant has a cute, intimate Italian vibe. Perfect for a romantic date night that doesn't have to break the bank. read more
Came here for a pre show dinner. Very pleasantly surprised. Rustic vibe and super cozy. We started with sangria which was yummy and the Caesar salad which I loved. Got a margarita pizza and added a chicken cutlet to it. Honestly probably one of the best I've had. We really enjoyed it here. Service was good.Would definitely come back again. read more
1 month ago
Cute little spot with great service. The pizza was really good and we loved the arugula salad with artichokes and the arancini. They even have a dessert pizza with Nutella that we enjoyed. read more
2 days ago
2 months ago
Service 10- Pizza 15!!! You come into their dining room and feel right at home. The pizza is made to order and it is absolutely delicious. Love everything about the pizza. The wine was also very good, straight from Italy. read more
1 month ago
I came here with my husband and his other friend and his friend's girlfriend. They used to come here all the time when they lived near Port Authority. My husband always wants pizza, like always, so between this place and another restaurant, we chose this one. It was Sunday afternoon so not too crowded. Server was quick. We started with the artichoke. Our friend said they used to have more artichoke on the plate but now it's only 2. This was a bit shocking for them. They also so got arancini - which they also commented that it used to come with 4 balls and now only 3. My husband got the meat lovers pizza and I got a prosciutto pie. Our friends also split a prosciutto pie. The slices are sliced into 4's, so much larger than anticipated. The pizzas are wood fired so the crust is amazing: chewy and crunchy at the same time. It's a cute little pizza spot that I definitely recommend if you're looking for some quality pizza. The menu is limited so no pasta but who doesn't love pizza? Also their bathroom is super cool; it's an old-fashioned toilet with a pull down level to flush. Unfortunately the water pressure is weak so you may have to pull a few times to flush everything but still pretty awesome. read more
2 years ago
quick story... 11 years ago I came here with my brother & cousin on a whim because I saw this place recommended on Tumblr... I've been back to NYC many times since but had never saved this spot.. and I FINALLY FOUND IT AGAIN. I've been searching as I never forgot about this pizzeria!!! I say all this to say that pizza taste just like it did then. Exceptional italiana style pizza. I had the hot honey to share with my partner (2 slices each) and we ended with an espresso. Had lunch on a Wednesday @2 and it was very lowkey, no wait, great service, and good vibe. I'll be back again!!! read more
Dinner in New York City... My good Yelp friends were looking out for me. They noticed that I was in New York and suggested that I get some New York pizza! I told my friend and she told her brother. They had been to Capizzi in the past and said that this place is really good because the pizzas are baked in a brick oven and the pizzas are personal sized. Okay! We walked over from the theater and entered the cozy, warm, dimly lit restaurant. Service was very welcoming and helpful! We shared the Artichoke salad with pine nuts... delicious! My friend and her brother got the Loaded pizza while I got the Prosciutto Fungi pizza. I enjoyed the texture of the mushrooms and the fragrant, fresh basil. The Prosciutto added the savory flavor to the thin, crisp crust! We finished off our feast with a large piece of Tiramisu... it was moist and not too sweet! We were so full that we took an entire pizza home - one quarter from me, one quarter from Marlina, and half of David's pizza! It made a wonderful breakfast the next morning! read more
5 months ago
When in the city, make sure to visit Capizzi! This is easily my favorite pizza spot. No wait times, quality pizza, and excellent service. Highly recommend. read more
Was looking for a slice, opened up Yelp, gave this spot by the Theater District a chance. Service was great, the food was solid, the ambiance on the casual side, and the restaurant definitely got quite busy. Caesar Salad -- 3 1/2 Stars. Very cheesy and coated in thick dressing, if that's your thing. Margherita Pizza - 4 1/2 stars. Tasty, light, delicious! Pepperoni Pizza - 4 stars. A solid pizza, light thin crust that I really liked. read more
6 months ago
Such a cozy pizza place! Never felt rushed. Service was amazing and we will definitely return! read more
We loved this place! We came after seeing a show and the pizza was delciousssss. We ordered a Marguerite pizza and then got a side of hot honey and a side of Caesar dressing to dip. Absolutely amazing. The house made sangria was fantastic. Tiramisu was good too. The restaurant is so cute and the service was amazing. read more
New York has so many great Italian options, so I was very excited to try this restaurant. Upon entering the establishment, I was very pleased with the ambience of the restaurant, which was decorated in a very charming, quaint style that reminded me of Italy. There were vines hanging on the ceiling and lots of vintage memorabilia on the walls which were a fun conversation starter at our table. The restaurant is very small inside. We ordered several pizzas, though I mainly had the eggplant one. It was ok, and the crust was beautifully cooked and charred. However, I'm rating Capizzi 3 stars because my friend ordered a gluten-free pizza because she is legitimately gluten-free. The waitress assured us that this was an option provided at this restaurant. When the pizza came out, my friend was pleasantly surprised because the crust looked too good to be gluten-free. And she almost ate it, but her skepticism made us double-check with the staff again. And unfortunately, the crust was not gluten-free. There was a mixup, which they promptly fixed. I appreciate how the issue was handled, it's just that this could've been a compromising situation for my friend. Overall, the food was okay, though the vibes were very fun. I don't know if I'd go out of my way to revisit this place, but it's a solid choice if you're in the area. read more
I've walked past this spot so many times on my way to work and just noticed it for the first time tonight. We showed up right around 5:15, and we were surprised to see the place was already packed, but we were able to get a spot after a 20 minute wait. The pizza is pretty solid and they have a great salad selection. I also appreciated their very generous wine pours. But the best part about the place is the atmosphere and decor on the inside. I'd hang out here all day with some friends and a bottle of wine if they'd let me! read more
3 months ago
3 months ago
Stopped in for dinner before a show and would definitely come back. Really cozy decor inside, and my one caution would be that it was VERY hot inside on this winter evening. We started with the pane and olio, which was good but not worth the $10, so I'd recommend avoiding that. We split margherita and eggplant parm pizzas and really enjoyed those. The Margherita was a little undercooked and the dough was very chewy, but the crisp on the eggplant parm pizza was perfect and absolutely delicious! For dessert, we split the Oreo truffle cannoli which was great. I'll give benefit of the doubt that the pizza is more often cooked like the eggplant parm and not the chewy margherita and rate 5 stars since that is definitely the potential of this place! read more
3 years ago
Cool, old school coal fired pizza joint. The menu is small, but still covers a lot of options - salad, pizza, wine, etc... The place is small so be prepared to wait a bit. We waited about 20 minutes. They updated us several times on how long the wait would be. Once seated we opted for an artichoke salad, a sausage and onion pizza plus a spinach special pizza. Everything was delicious and the service was great as well. read more
5 months ago
Capizzi does have some solid pizza but honestly I feel like they've gone down in quality since the last time I've gone years ago. My family and I ordered the hot honey chicken, margherita, spinach white, and eggplant pies. Nothing was necessarily bad, but nothing stood out either. The hot honey chicken pizza I've had at other places and really enjoyed it but it completely fell flat at Capizzi- I firmly believe this pie needs it's red sauce. The eggplant pie was quite watery. The margherita and spinach pies were good but again, nothing to write home about. I will not be returning unless I'm in this area as there is no dearth of great pizzerias in NYC. read more
1 year ago
4 months ago
Fast friendly service, excellent pizza. Traditional wood fired pizza. Ordered the Neapolitan Classic #1 with pepperoni, mushrooms and onions. Not sure what varietal of shrooms those were, but they were very good! read more
5 months ago
10 months ago
5 months ago
My sister and I stopped in at Capizzi for lunch while we were in New York. We each ordered our own wood fired pizza. I got the number 1 with peppers instead of mushrooms and it was phenomenal. The crust did get a little soggy (maybe from too many toppings) but I happily ate the entire thing. Service was quick and the interior was adorable. read more
There are some Italian restaurants that just give you a very warm and homey vibe, and @capizzinyc is one of them! Their food are straightforward and with a homemade warmth to them. Service was great too! The pizza was nice but the eggs did make the dough soggy. Caesar salad was not overloaded with dressing but with a good amount of fresh cheese. Very refreshing! read more
The service is terrific and the restaurant is a throwback to 1960. Unfortunately the pizza is just ok. Not a spot I would be going out of the way for. The owner says that he wants his food to be just like his Nonna's. My only conclusion is his Nonna wasn't a terrific cook or she would be disappointed with the food at Capizzi. read more
Hands down, this is the best pizzeria in Manhattan! We are lucky to live nearby, where this is now our go-to weekday spot (I have seen long lines on the weekends). The personal-size pizza is honestly big enough to be shared by two. You can always add a salad or an appetizer to make it a complete meal. Every pizza is delicious here, but our favorites are the loaded pizza, prosciutto funghi, and hot Italian sausage/caramelized fennel. The restaurant is charming, with a wood-fired oven in the background making those delicious pizzas. The place retained this old farmhouse charm that you feel like you are in your grandma's kitchen. The sangria is also delicious here!! I wish they'd come in a carafe. read more
The ambiance and service is a true 10/10! I loved how cozy this restaurant was because of its size, lighting, and decorations. It's a great place for a small group or even a date! Both of the pizzas honey chicken and proscuitto&arugular were delicious. I loved the bread and the crust. The honey chicken was a little underwhelming, it didn't have the hot honey kick that I wanted. The prosciutto was also a little dry and more difficult to eat but the flavoring was nice. I would go back again to try some of the other items! read more
Page 1 of 26
More info about Capizzi
547 9th Ave
New York, NY 10018
Midtown West, Hell's Kitchen, Theater District
Directions
(518) 619-5524
Call Now
Visit Website
https://capizzinyc.com
Full menu
Hours
Payment methods
Food & Alcohol
Indoor Amenities
Outdoor Amenities
Other Amenities
From the Business
More Info
Health Score
Capizzi Reviews in Other Languages
Ask the Community - Capizzi
Are they back in business? Can't reach anyone by phone or social media.
Do they take cards or is it cash only?
I paid for dinner with credit/debit - no issue.
You might also consider
Why does Yelp recommend reviews?
56 reviews that are not currently recommended
The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.
10 years ago
11 years ago
3 years ago
16 years ago
16 years ago
11 years ago
10 years ago
14 years ago
12 years ago
10 years ago
8 years ago
3 years ago
12 years ago
8 years ago
8 years ago
7 years ago
11 years ago
11 years ago
14 years ago
4 years ago
