If buying a new car = pain in the a$$, then CarMax = Pain-in-the-a$$ remover.
I have purchased two vehicles through CarMax, as did my girlfriend about 4 years ago. All of these experiences were extremely positive, stress-free, and friendly.
First off, the price on the car is non-negotiable (plus taxes, tags, and CarMax's $199 processing fee, which I kinda find bullsh!t, but will deal with given the relaxed nature otherwise). As such, if you say "I can only spend $15k," they don't bother trying to sell you an $18k vehicle. Plus, you don't have to haggle, which can be stressful and (more critically) fosters an immediate sense of distrust between you and the salesperson. Am i getting screwed over? I am screwing THEM over enough? AAAAARGHH!!!
Second, they are willing to hold vehicles for you for a day or two to think it over if you are a serious buyer. I recently purchased a '13 Xterra, but wanted to think about it more. The sales person (Jackie Wilson) was more than happy to hold the car for me, taking it off the web and making it unavailable to other buyers for 24 hours, no charge. That really gave me peace of mind and allowed me to make a more well-thought out decision.
Third, I know that some people have groaned about the prices for traded in vehicles, but I've had good experiences in both instances when a car was traded in. First, my girlfriend's 1999 Corolla with 142k miles was valued at $2000 (in 2010). And my 2002 VW Jetta 1.8T was given $2500, despite the sunroof no longer sliding back, as well as impending repairs on the horizon ($1600 timing belt, $1200 suspension).
Fourth: financing. Granted, I have been pretty good with financial matters, but I was given 1.95%. Bomber.
And lastly, and this is perhaps the most critical, I had a previously Jetta (not the '02 I traded in recently) that was also purchased at CarMax in Whitemarsh. While I was living in Chicago, the catalytic converter needed replacing. I called the service folks at CarMax. The man said it would be $1000-1200 and asked how many miles the car had. I replied that it was a couple hundred short of 80k. He immediately replied, "The car is under warranty still from VW. Take it to a dealership before you hit 80k and it should be free." He saved me at least $1000 when I was more than ready to pay it. And because they saved me $1000 back then, I was more than happy to throw them repeat business and referrals.
This place is great. But don't forget... it's a dealership--they are looking to sell cars. And the salespeople work on commissions. As such, you're going to get some sales pitch and up-talking on cars. But it's a 1/10th of what you'd expect at a private dealership. Oh, and they make the same amount in commission regardless of what car they sell, be it a $11k Nissan Versa or a $80k Porsche Cayenne.
I will definitely be back when I need a new vehicle... though hopefully not anytime soon. And special thanks to Jackie Wilson, the sales rep who helped me out!! read more