Wow, one star is reserved for blatant mismanagement. If your employees screw up then management…read moremakes it right, correct? Not here. They were training on a Friday night (really??). Finger steaks served instead of chicken strips ordered. Shift manager refused to take it back or comp it. Charged again, still no chicken strips. Called and talked to a manager later in the week and received excuses, lies, and still no offer to make it right. Customer blamed. I think the owners may have become complacent here, success can do that. The hamburgers are great but the management oversight seems to be gone now. Sad.

The burger and fries were fine, nothing special, but the 5 stars is for the milkshake! Truly the…read morebest milkshake I've ever had

First time I have been there. Person making the food on the grill was great and the cashier was…read morevery friendly and helped us in a timely manner!

Nasty raw cheese burgers me and my boyfriend ordered from here 9/12/26 at 740 pm all four…read morecheeseburgers and then another lady ordered from here and hers were the same really disappointed and sick they said it did look raw to them

Super great burgers with great sauce. Everything is wonderful. Friendly staff. Inside seating is…read morecozy and food is delivered to you. I go here frequently.

We tried Gem In & Out a couple of days ago I first thought…read moreit was drive through only happy to find more seating options than I expected. I must say the service and wonderful people were very welcoming! My wife told her it's our first visit and she gave us a coupon for $10.00 off our meal! Hamburgers were simple but delicious! Had fun reading all the signage on the walls. To top it off went back to window and ordered a cone from another worker and she gave me a discount also! I'll be back!

Phenomenal service, delicious food, resonably priced. Start to finish a very good experience.read more

Seriously the best hamburger I've ever had. That's no exaggeration. My husband and I split a…read moreClassic burger. The burger was cooked perfectly and the presentation was beautiful. The service was excellent and the price was fair. the next time I'm in Caldwell, I'll definitely be back.

I ate here over the weekend and it was honestly one of the best burgers I've ever had!!! I ordered…read morethe Forager (bacon and blue cheese) and it was so flavorful! My mother in law got the Left Coast and that was also great ! The avocado on it was so fresh! The server was attentive and friendly and food came out quick! Restaurant was clean and welcoming! I would highly recommend!!

Nampa, Idaho September 2026…read more HOLy COW! What a great restaurant. This brick lined restaurant sits on the corner in downtown Nampa. The menu is mostly sandwiches with a few appetizers and salads. Booths line the restaurant, with tables and metal chairs in the center. Restaurant is extremely clean. All the tables have a mason jar of fresh flowers. They have paper napkins with real cutlery. There is a large room adjacent to the restaurant that they are converting to a bar. Specific for those 21 and over. As of the end of September, it is not completed . Our waitress is Morgan. She also is the manager of the restaurant for the evening. What a delightful, outgoing, personable girl. So glad we had the opportunity of having her serve us this evening. I ordered the Yardbird minus the bacon. It comes on a ciabatta roll with cheese, lettuce, tomato, and red onion. The roll was slightly toasted. The chicken is accompanied with a pesto sauce which I put on the side. I think the chicken is marinated. It had a delicious flavor and very moist. I accompanied it with the french fries. They are beer battered and I asked for extra crispy. Ask for the fry sauce. It is a ketchup, mayonnaise, horseradish mixed with spices. Absolutely delicious. My suggestion for the sandwich would be to melt the cheese. Mine came out, not melted just sitting on top of my chicken sandwich. My husband ordered a cheeseburger with the extra crispy fries. He said the roll was buttered and it made the entire meal. This is a little extra that a restaurant can do to elevate their hamburger. Score!! The music is too loud for the restaurant. It was difficult to have conversation. I would get the following scores: Food - 5 Ambience-4.5 (took off metal chairs and loud music) Service- 5 (Morgan was phenomenal) Overall rating 4.8

This place is our go to spot in downtown Caldwell. The piggy sandwich with brisket instead of…read morepulled pork is fantastic! Great beer selection too! They offer gluten free bread and the back patio is a nice change during nice weather days. Friendly staff too!

Me and my wife went here for dinner today, we had a bad experience the first time we went here (bad…read moreservice, food was ok at best). We wanted to give it another try because we had a bad experience the first time but the drinks were good. Stay away from the food. My wife ordered the pulled pork sandwich, bread was soggy upon it being dropped off at the table making it inedible, I ordered the French dip Philly style, the meat tasted freezer burned and it was also inedible. The server took both plates back to the kitchen (full of food because we couldn't eat it) and we still had to pay full price. Stay away

Fast and friendly service. great breakfast and lunch menu. Biscuits and gravy are the best in town.read more

Came here with my son after church on Sunday and honestly we can't say enough good things about it…read more The place itself is cute, not super big, but old school diner vibes, and it even has a counter you can sit at. The service was amazing from the time we walked in the door- we were seated right away, our server was so sweet and attentive. She made great recommendations since it was our first time in, and made sure that we enjoyed everything. The food came out quickly and was fresh, hot and everything tasted great. Honestly though, the pancakes are a must if you go. Hands down some of the best pancakes we have ever had. We tried the cinnamon roll, which was okay, but not near as good as the pancakes- my son got the country fried steak, which had a generous portion and he really enjoyed it, and I got the breakfast burrito, which was delicious and big (I took half home). If you are nearby, definitely check them out. They have a big menu. Including lunch, and the price point is amazing. Overall we were super happy with everything and know we will be going back.

the food was absolutely incredible hands down some of the best american around. everything tasted…read morefresh and flavorful, like they actually care about what's going into your plate i got the taco salad and the shell was perfectly fluffy on the inside and crispy on the outside, total win. they really stuff the dishes to the brim, so you definitely feel like you're getting your money's worth

I wanted to like the place. Server was super nice but food service was super slow. Wife had the…read morefish and chips, it burnt and seemed like it was cooked in old oil and over breaded. I didn't want to try it. Kids enjoyed the milk shakes. My burger was okay, had the nitrous burger. Glad it didn't get the hot sauce on it. Shoe string fries were okay. The garage vibe was okay but a bit dark and grungy.

Very cute spot I have drove past many times and didn't even think twice about. So glad I finally…read morestopped to check it out. Service was fast, waitresses were polite and the food was delicious. The outside is a cute little orchard. Perfect spot to have a meal with a friend or solo like me. Got the mushroom spinach scramble I think it's called with crispy potatoes and sourdough toast. Cup of hot coffee. And the most delicious piece of strawberry rhubarb pie.

My favorite is the Orchard House Fish and Chips!! So delicious!! ...and their Key Lime Pie is to…read moredie for!! Thank you for excellent food and service every time!! Terri Warren

My friend and I went to Stewarts for dinner. My friend was surprised they had fresh haddock so he…read moreordered it. We'll let me say he loved the haddock and was so happy with his dinner. I have never seen him this happy about a meal and he said it was perfect.

Only getting 2 stars because our waiter Jimmy was AMAZING. But the manager, I think, stopped at the…read moredoor to tell us my husbands service dog is only welcome if he is a true service dog, I told him what the service dogs duties were and then he proceeded to tell us over and over that he must be a service dog not a comfort animal even though his vest clearly states he is a service dog. He then proceeded to tell us he must not disturb others and has to stay on the floor, REALLY??? Then my salad had raw chicken. But our server was absolutely amazing, we were here from out of town visiting our kids and grandkids and he took great care of us! Thank you Jimmy, your manager could use some tips from you on how to treat people!