A very middle of the road pizza place with a big bar, lots of seating, and the best broccoli rabe this side of the Mississippi- everything else so far is decent to sub-par at best. Doesn't know how to make Sorrentino but has good Greek salad... read more

See all

Carlo's is so much more than just a pizzeria, their food is not to be missed. They have an extensive menu but our favorite go-to item is the cold seafood salad. It's clean, light, and full of fresh seafood that is seasoned and dressed to perfection every single time. They have quite the group of regulars that lets you know they're doing something right, and their staff is always so friendly. We especially love visiting when Linda & Cheryl are working on Thursdays! Ask Linda for one of her specialty martinis if you see her! read more

Carlo's Pizza Oven - Cold Seafood Salad - Pizza Near Me - Holbrook, New York

Delish pizza, I loved that it was seasoned. It wasn't your typical Long Island style brick oven pizza- you have to to ask and order it that way "Carlos style". Didn't know that till after I ordered so make sure you get that hack if that's what you're looking for! read more

Carlo's Pizza Oven - Pizza Near Me - Holbrook, New York

Carlos has some menu items from the old Aegean restaurant in the Sunvet mall. They make the pizza and have the salad dressing for the Greek salad. Some of the employees also have moved over here. It is nice to see some familiar faces. It's nothing fancy, but has traditional pizza place seating as well as a restaurant side with a bar. It is a great place to try some of your old favorites or to go when your schedule is busy and you want some "real food" to eat quick. They have a parking lot which is usually easy to find parking unless the dance studio in the building has classes. read more

See all

2 slices of Regular and a small drink. 12.45 ! A thin oily limp crust. Soggy. I saw the Agean sign and figured. Should be good. Nope. Hugely disappointed. read more

In a recent visit with several friends we sat at a booth in the bar area. The food is decent, service fine. They have several TVs in the bar area. I go there about twice monthly with a friend or alone since it's close to home. I have never been there when Fox news is not on one of the TVs. I understand or so it seems the clientele are majority conservative which is fine. But they do get people who are either Democrats or apolitical. This is a public restaurant and if the owner(s) are big conservatives fine. But keep it out of your business. I know they have lost patronage for exactly that reason. read more

This pizza here is great! If you're interested in seeing a live video review, consider clicking here: https://www.tiktok.com/t/ZThHd7L2e/

Ordered large pie (table service)...price of pizza ridiculously high...won't be going back...pizza did not merit anywhere near tbe price we paid.. read more

Not even deserving of one star. Horrific customer service, mediocre food at best and over priced. One time I walked in to order a couple of slices right at 9 pm. Lights were on, door was open pizza was on counter. Upon ordering the slices one gentleman threw them in the oven while the other told me no they are closing. I said I'll take to go and he then said he already shut credit card machine down and I offered cash and he became highly agitated. I asked why he was so angry about me ordering and paying for 2 slices and he told me to get the f*ck out and even raised a fist. Never have gone back and never will and tell all my friends and family not to either. Shameful and unfortunate to treat customers like this. And we all live in Holbrook. read more

Delicious food. Super friendly staff. Came well recommended and rightfully so. Go there soon! read more

Awesome establishment, very nice atmosphere! I came here because my friend had a coupon for one free pie, so that's something to take into consideration. The workers were nice as well. read more

This place has been getting expensive over the last couple of years, but tonight was ridiculous. We've had a couple of not so great experiences recently, but because of being a single parent with 3 kids in sports, Carlos of Holbrook won the dinner nod tonight. I paid $54 for a meatball pie and 1, yes 1, chicken parm hero. What are they charging? $35 for a pie and $20 for a hero. Absurd. I wouldn't have even wrote this review if the food was good. It was quite the opposite. The meatballs on the pizza were reminiscent of the brown balled up meatball you would get from a generic frozen pizza down any grocery store frozen aisle. The chicken in the $25 hero was so chewy that I had to throw it out after only a couple of bites. The sauce tasted like it was out of a jar. I don't know if they changed owners or not, but in a town loaded with pizzerias, this place has gone way down hill. Very disappointing. read more

Service always great! Food is tasty and I love their sauce. Lots of choices. Entrees are huge

Food is good. Which is important yes but at the end of the day why go to somewhere good when you can go to somewhere great and not be disrespected. The staff here has some nice kind young ladies but the older lady who was there when i dined with my family. Was rude and told me to " take it away" like i worked for her when i was checking to see if my family ordered a salad. After waiting 20 minutes after my order was "completed" on the app her company works with. There was so many people waiting and she was questioning what everyone ordered. She was clearly the reason this restaurant has people's family's waiting to eat and is the co owner i think. I dont remember her name. Dont have your family wait on this rude woman like me and the other last night. And disrespected because ur checking if r fam got a salad when you said yes unsure and checked for a second time i was the person i said i was. Ambience was nice! Not a bad wait with some instagram reels, thankfully these young ladies are calming people down with their kind assistance in running this restaurant. read more

Had a very unpleasant experience with one of the owners who wouldn't give his name. I called up to question the 65 dollar charge for 2 plain cheese pies. There was a credit card fee which two other local pizzeria don't charge. It was never disclosed to me when I ordered over the phone for delivery. Owner was arrogant complaining about rising costs and that he's still the best deal around. I called around and his pies are 6-7 dollars more each.He had the audacity to say why should I absorb the credit card charge when you're using it for your convenience. When you order over the phone, what other choice is there? Come to find out that it's illegal to charge the fee without informing the caller, and it's illegal to charge a fee when it's a debit card, which is what I used. They have lost my business. Their pizza is just ok, they happen to be a convenient option. Will never go there or order from them again! Total ripoff! One of the local places I called afterwards to compare was 15 dollars l3ss for the 2 pies with tax and delivery. read more

Chicken Parm on the old roll isn't worth the calories. Had the baked clams which came with 6 and were chopped and very good. $7 wines for happy hour everyday! Chicken Parm on the old roll isn't worth the calories. Had the baked clams which came with 6 and were chopped and very good. $7 wines for happy hour everyday! read more

Carlo's Pizza Oven - Chicken Parm slider... comes with two, but the bread is definitely a few days old. It's $9.50 .. - Pizza Near Me - Holbrook, New York

Yeah. No. Never. Again. This was the first time we went to this place and the welcome... was not welcoming to say the least. The young lady at the register did not look pleased to assist us at all. We placed our order with her anyway and she gave us a ridiculous total for a cheese pie and some garlic knots. When I questioned her about it, it went downhill from there. Instead of telling us what she did wrong, she called someone else over - who seemed to be the owner or manager not sure - and the experience got worse from there. They were unorganized as he had other receipts in his hand, then proceeded to charge us for what we actually ordered without issuing a refund for the first order. The young lady proceeded to say that we will see the refund "later on or tomorrow" without giving a receipt as proof of refund. I asked for the refund to be completed now, and to provide us with a receipt as proof that it was completed. The gentleman who was assisting her became more irritated, showing that he was not pleased with us demanding the proof of refund. There was also a gentleman picking up a DoorDash that he ordered and he was waiting just as long as us. One of the other employees was kind in her apologies to him for the wait, but the minute he left - she sarcastically yelled out "Happy Easter" and "why would he order through door dash?" Then proceeded to mimic his "just cancel it" comment because he was upset it took 30 minutes for them to tell him they never received his order. As military veterans who were referred to the establishment by fellow vets, we will never go back. We saw who were treated with happy greetings and well... no one else was treated any less besides us. God bless my husband because he still left them a tip. This place is a complete disappointment. 0 stars if I could. read more

Horrible. Undercooked, super thick , OVERLY cheesy with NO sauce . What a waste. We threw this out after a few bites of one slice . Large reg Pizza half meatball read more

Carlo's Pizza Oven - Horrible. Undercooked, super thick , overly cheesy with hardly any sauce . What a waste. $34 for Large Pizza half meatball!! - Pizza Near Me - Holbrook, New York

Decided to try the famous Aegean pie. Under cooked, thick dough, floppy, and way too much cheese. I almost choked on the amount of cheese. I Honestly have gotten better pies at Costco. We tried to reheat it to cook it and make it crispy, it didn't work. We wound up throwing it out. Almost $30 for a pie, save your money go somewhere else. Worse pizza I have ever eaten! It doesn't even deserve the one star. read more

Omg !!! Talk about the tastiest pizza ! We got the regular pie and the flavors swirling around my mouth were so delicious. I can't believe I never went and had an Aegeans pie.I didn't even need any other spices like salt or pepper because whoever made this pie was a scientific genius with their recipe. I'll be back read more

Carlo's is a great spot for pizza and more!! Customer for over 30 yrs and pizza is always consistently good! Love the pasta primavera dish .. hearty portions! read more

The food was beyond delicious. Our server, Gary, was fantastic. He was very attentive to us.

Wonderful food, service and atmosphere. Truly a neighborhood gem, great extensive Italian food menu! Dishes like grandma made :)

Good food, but way over priced Good food, but way over priced Right now their price for an 8 slice cheese pizza is $24. The food is pretty good but pasta dishes are also in the high $20s. There are better places around then to be ripped off by a neighbood pizza type place restaurant. read more

Chicken parm slice, white slice and garlic knots all . Loved it all!! People at the counter were super helpful and very nice. Will be back!

I walked in wanting just one slice of pepperoni pizza, but fell in love with food, quality and customer service within a short amount of time. Can't wait to go back and eat five slices of pepperoni pizza. read more

This is a nice small restaurant in a busy strip mall, the food is very good, take out also. Sometimes the parking can be hard as this strip mall mall is busy. read more

WOW!! My husband and I just moved to the neighborhood and received a coupon for a large pie. From now on we will be ordering pizza from here. Great pizza, great breadsticks, great zeppoles, and gelato is 10/10. Would definitely recommend. Also staff at counter that helped us gave us free gelato to try and was very nice and professional. Great place read more

Carlo's Pizza Oven - Large Plain Cheese Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Holbrook, New York

See all

My family, my friends and I have been coming to Carlo's for years. Everything on the menu is fantastic, although I admit I stick with my favorites. The food is flavorful and satisfying! Staff is welcoming and attentive. Definitely our 'go to' gathering place! read more

First time at Carlo's today. Gary, our sever was friendly, efficient and made a great impression on us. He was one of the best waiters we've ever encountered! Food was delicious , huge portions ! We'd gladly recommend this place to our friends and family. read more

Expensive. .La Margarita in Bellport is $4.00 cheaper and so much better!

Tucked away off Patchogue Holbrook Road, in your typical Long Island strip mall you'll find Carlos Pizza Oven. However don't let the name fool you as it's not just a pizza joint, nor is it owned or managed by a guy named Carlos. It has a full service bar/restaurant and while the menu is a bit overwhelming, the food is consistently good considering all they offer. The pizza itself isn't bad but it's not the best I've ever had. The selling point by far is the bar experience. It's kept extremely neat and well managed. With a decent variety of beer on tap and more liquors than I've ever seen for a bar this size. The overly confident and extremely sarcastic bartender Gary is always on top of his game with his attention to detail and service. read more

Carlo's Pizza Oven - Jameson - Pizza Near Me - Holbrook, New York

Amazing place with great food and people. Love the bar experience. The size of the portions is something you don't get now due to everyone being cheap!! This place will feed 2or3 with their portions. Give it a try. You won't be disappointed!! read more

Carlo's Pizza Oven - Stuffed Chicken breast. Wow - Pizza Near Me - Holbrook, New York

Spent Saturday night with a group of friends at Carlo's pizza oven. Felt like you were in a neighborhood place where The food was great and our waiter was so personable. It felt like home. Made for a real fun night out. Added bonus the Portions were huge so there was lunch the next day. read more

I attended a private party, Carlo's catered the food. Everyone enjoyed it. I will be a returning customer. Thank You.

So disappointed in recent order from your shop. Last night ordered a plain pizza for delivery. We were charged 34.00. The pizza cheese was sliding off and the Dough was so thick we couldn't enjoy it. We also gave a $5.00 tip. We live less than 5 minutes away but didn't feel like taking out the car.. Shame on them. This will be the last time I order from them.. read more

Bring your appetite, bypass the pizza counter and go sit at a booth in the back. I can never decide what to have here: linguine with clams with broccoli rabe and garlic (the broth in the bowl is soooo freakin' good!), chicken cacciatore or fra diavolo. Order the artichoke. Get full. Leave happy. read more

Amazing food and service! Special shout out to Gary! Looking forward to many more visits!

Well, I stopped going here for years. Due to their way over priced pizza & food. Along with being rude! I'd figure I'd try it again, after finding out that they partnered up with Aegean pizza (Sun Vet Mall). Aegean pizza was amazing! I was skeptical of ordering just a "Regular Large Pie" for $24 as advertised on their website. Again, OVER PRICED. When I picked up my order, the TOTAL with tax was OVER $27! More than the $24 as advertised. The pizza was very good! I don't mind paying slightly more than other LOCAL pizza places. However, 25%++++++ more is a little ridiculous! Along with charging more than advertised. I'll wait & see how this "merger" works out before ordering again. read more

Placed an order through door dash, Carlo's confirmed/accepted the order, took the payment and stated the order was complete. When the driver when to pick the order up they were locking the doors and told him they did not have any orders. So in a nutshell they accepted the order, took payment and did not fulfill it and took 30 mins for me to get a call from the driver telling me the situation. So now there is no dinner coming and the driver who is out in the middle of this crisis is not getting paid either. Do yourself a favor and go anywhere else if you actually want to eat dinner. Carlo's is completely unreliable, unorganized, and unprofessional. Thanks for nothing but wasting my time and causing aggravation. Edit: Hi Billy! It seems Jennifer F. agrees with me, guess she had a similar experience. Lets go one by one here: - yes I ordered through a third party service which you participate and offer your business services through - I placed this order while you were still open and accepting orders as anyone who uses these services knows once you are closed you can not place an order - I paid the service I was using that you do business with who only accepts payment after the participating restaurant, you, verifies/accepts the order - The matter and time frame as to when and how you receive your payments is a business matter and really has nothing to do with anything as you agreed to those terms when you agreed to be a part of third party delivery services. - yes, the driver did in fact call you since you confirmed/accepted the order and it was 35 minutes later and he was showing up to do his job and pick up the delivery just to find the doors being locked - Billy, now you are just flat out lying. Please tell me when and how you "personally" notified me, the customer, you were closed and "sorry"? IT WAS A THIRD PARTY SERVICE YOU HAVE ZERO INFORMATION ON WHO IS PLACING AN ORDER OR ANY OF THEIR INFORMATION. You are just making yourself and your restaurant look even worse by lying to people, its sad. As far as my "petty" comments: - first off Im not lying to people like you are. Not a great business model if you ask me. You're right it does speak for itself, "50 years of business and lies" should be your new slogan - Secondly you say you and your staff are working seven days a week to service your community and people appreciate your delivery service. You obviously weren't servicing anything that night and had zero delivery service, if you did this review wouldn't exist. - as far as your phone call from some random women goes, that seems like a personal problem to me. I assure you, i have not and will not ever call you or be a women. So it seems as if I'm not the only one that shares this experience with your business. - you could be in business 100 years, bad customer service is bad customer service - once again I ordered WHILE YOU WERE ACCEPTING ORDERS AND WERE OPEN. YOU ALSO CONFIRMED/ACCEPTED THE ORDER. if you were closed why would you confirm the order?? Its not rocket science here Bill. Lastly you seem to have no regard for your customers let alone the delivery driver who was working during this difficult time trying to make money for his family just to have his time/gas wasted by showing up to pick up a confirmed order that was supposedly ready just to be told you are closed. So imagine how he must feel since, like you said, no one got paid including the delivery driver who then missed out on other deliveries from other restaurants that were actually open and had the orders ready that they confirmed. So Bill, I hope this clears things up, it sure does for me. The fact that you write a review respond with flat out lies in it is all I need to know what kind of business and person you are, unprofessional and dishonest. Its really that simple... read more