The baked goods from Caramici's is first class. The cakes, cookies and cannoli are absolutely delicious. I've enjoyed them all!

Coworker brought in some treats from them. Was not a fan of the cannoli. Tasted bland.

Oh doggy, The pies and cakes here are to die for. We stumbled across Caramici's Bakery on our trip. I love the Cassata Cake, which was recommended and delicious. I had never had such good cake in my life until now. Pies are good, and many different flavors. Employees are friendly here. I had the pleasure of a good experience on the best pastries. We wii be back on our next trip. read more

This place was a genuis find for my search for Italian bakeries. If I wouldn't have looked on YELP, would have never known about this bakery. The location isn't where you would think to find a bakery. Located in a former elementary or middle school is where you'll find it. Cute set up, my boyfriend was thrilled that the bakery made cuccidati, lemon cookies and we both loved the orange pecan biscotti, there flavorful, and great for dipping in coffee. Defintly check it out if your in search of authentic Italian cookies, and cascata cakes. read more

See all

Five stars is not enough for caramici's! The owner is so kind and accommodating. She did my cake and dessert table items for my wedding. Every single thing was phenomenal and the guests raved about everything they had. We were so pleased she took our favorite dessert and made such a stunning cake with it. Thank you for making our wedding so special!!! read more

Caramici's Bakery - Wedding tiramisu cake - Bakeries Near Me - Buffalo, New York

See all

EXCELLENT cassata cake! Followed the yelp reviews for the best cassata cakes near me and was not disappointed. Custom order, soooo fresh, highly recommend. read more

I ordered a Cassata Cake for Easter last year. This year was homemade pies. What a bakery Reasonable prices very tasting Ricotta cream filling. Also very moist cakes! read more

I just had the very best eclair of my life from here! It was served at Remington's for dessert. The waiter mentioned how good it was so me and another friend shared one. It was so big and filled with cream- we could not finish! The experience for me was like going back to childhood and reminding me why I always thought eclairs were my favorite pastry. Best ever!!! read more

Didn't realize that they were here until I went to vote. I remember how good everything was prepared and tasted. I am glad I happened to have found it again. I bought about a dozen different cookies and pastries. They were as good as they always were. I will definitely return to purchase these well made treats. read more

I ordered my son's first birthday cake and varieties of cupcakes. Not only the look was great, but the flavors and the taste was spot on! Specifically, the pistachio filling on the almond cake and spumoni cupcake was delicious! Highly recommended. read more

Caramici's Bakery - a variety of cupcakes - Bakeries Near Me - Buffalo, New York

See all

Diane is a very talented Baker and a sweet lady. Her cookies are so delicious. Her bake shop is in the back of a Church but its worth stopping in. You can always order just about anything fresh. I recommend her highly. read more

When I say I love this place, I LOVE it. Anything you get from Caramici's will be amazing! I would give them 1000 stars if I could. The pies are to die for. I had an apple, pumpkin, and coconut cream for Thanksgiving this year and I couldn't get enough! I usually hate pie crust because of how dry and bland they are , but they were all flaky and tasteful! The homemade nutmeg whipped cream on the pumpkin made it to die for! It balanced the rich pumpkin very well. My favorite was the coconut cream, though I'm a suck for anything coconut. Not only are the pies good, but every dessert made here especially the cannoli's or a cassata cake! I've been getting Caramici's for years and the quality has NEVER changed. If anything, it keeps getting better. I highly recommend ordering here whether it's for a holiday, birthday, wedding or something to treat yourself. read more

What a cute little place to stop in for dessert! It's small and has three tables for seating. There are also two display cases when you walk in. There's a limited selection of cookies, cupcakes, and cakes, but I did also stop in an hour before they closed. I had the cassata cake (which was delicious) and a bite of the carrot cake (which was good but loaded with frosting). It seemed to be a little pricier and I didn't see prices posted either. The person who worked there paid attention to detail and decorated our plates before serving it to us. Mine had a gorgeous chocolate drizzle surrounding my cake. It's worth stopping when while walking and shopping along Hertel! read more

Caramici's Bakery - Bakeries Near Me - Buffalo, New York

See all

The cassata cake is the best ever. Not too sweet and just light as air. Our new bakery. Owner was sweet and kind! Love!

After visiting a few bakeries and being unable to find one that would bake and slice several pies for a reception I was organizing, I found Caramici's bakery online. Not only did Caramici's agree to slice the pies, Sam the baker agreed to open the bakery on Sunday (when the shop is normally closed) to slice the pies so that I could pick them up for my Sunday afternoon reception. You couldn't ask for better service, and the pies were delicious! Thank you - I will recommend you to all my friends! I also sampled the cupcakes - yum! read more

Amazing!! I called from TN on a Tuesday asking for a Cannoli cake for Friday. They were so friendly and got the job done. The cake was incredible!! read more

Found this place on Hertel, next to Lloyds. Wow, choices after choices, everything looks great. Only got cupcakes this time. Got home and had trouble only having 1 cupcake, so very good. So very very good. read more

See all

I ordered a cake for baby shower from Caramici's Bakery a few weeks ago and was exceptionally happy with Diane's creation. The cake was beautifully decorated and very tasty. Everyone at the party was delighted. I will be returning customer. Highly recommend. read more

My daughter, a student at University at Buffalo, had the most amazing birthday cake delivered to her door! It was not only decorated with care and attention to detail, it had an element of fun ( cookies! ) that had my daughter and her suite mates laughing and happy to take it out of the box. They also said it was delicious! It was the next best thing to being with my "grown up" daughter, just to hear her as excited as a kid as she talked about her birthday cake. Many thanks to the bakery for taking care of my girl! read more

Custom cakes, Italian cookies like grandma used to make and killer creative cupcakes! read more

See all

The absolute best cake I've ever had. My wife gets one every year on her birthday and this years cake was absolutely spectacular. We get the pistachio cake every year and it never disappoints. It's something I look forward to every year. read more

My daughter's Emoji Birthday cake was very cute!! It was just like I wanted it to look and it tasted amazing too! I loved how you could taste the CC's in the cake and the pudding in it. It was so moist and yummy. She loved it thank you! read more

Caramici's Bakery - Bakeries Near Me - Buffalo, New York

The appeal is very good. The cupcakes looked like they should be in a magazine! Were very tasty and had many different unique flavors

Old school Italian cookies cakes deserts. One of the best canollis. In Buffalo. Cookies are a treat. Shame on Lloyds for taking the storefront over. Two thumbs up read more

Cute little Italian bakery on Hertel. I walked in because it's right next to Lloyd's Taco Factory. I wanted dessert, but Lloyd's was too busy and I had decided to go home. My boyfriend pointed out the bakery and we went inside. It's a nice little place that made me feel like I was somewhere else. The display case had cupcakes and other Italian treats. I went for a cupcake. Salted caramel. The frosting was really good and not too sweet like others I've had. It had the perfect combination of sweet and salty and the cupcake was nice and fluffy. I would definitely go back after dinner at Lloyd's. I'm not a coffee drinker, but that is one of their main menu items. My boyfriend, who is a coffee fiend, was interested in returning to try some bakery treats and coffee. The ambience and lighting make it ideal for a sweet coffee/dessert date. read more

Best cake in the world!!! And you can buy it by the slice. The cannoli are pretty amazing too. Great dessert place.

Ordered cupcakes for a memorial day picnic and I was not disappointed. Delicious cake and the frosting was not only beautiful, it was delicious. Can't wait to order more for the next birthday party! read more

I spoke with Diane via phone and e-mail. She was very prompt and polite. I traveled from Florida for a surprise birthday weekend. I ordered her signature "cassata" cake and was beyond happy. The cake was delicious and the design was exactly like the photo I had sent her. She even came out to the bakery on Sunday (non business hours) to arrange for my pick up convenience. I could not be any happier with my selection. From The Sunshine State I say "Thanks!". read more

Came across the little place walking down Hertel and stopped in to get a couple cannolis. Delicious..will be going here again soon!

My boyfriend and I decided it was nice enough to walk to dinner tonight from my place. I am glad we did, because walking home, we passed by Caramici's and decided to stop in and check it out. It is such a cute little bakery. We decided to get a couple canolis. They were out of the big shell, so she offered us 4 small canolis for the same price, which was so nice. I especially liked that they fill the shells fresh when you order them. Having grown up in an Italian family, I am pretty picky about eating Italian food and desserts. That being said, these canolis were so delicious! They weren't too sweet and they had the perfect amount of filling and chocolate chips! We will definitely be stopping in again soon! read more

Diane made exactly what I was looking for in a specialty cake for my daughter's 5th birthday! After receiving very poor customer service from a popular Amherst bakery, I was on the hunt for a new place. I couldn't have asked for better service from her! She was so nice, and the cake was divine; everyone raved about the taste! Most definitely will be returning for future cakes and desserts, as will my family. read more

The Cassata cake is my favorite... Stopped in today after dinner & couldn't get home to eat it ! Wny friend & I just stayed on the car talking & eating it with giving each other a compliment on how delicious it was....! We could've Made a commercial about this cake read more