What a nice establishment, I came for a pickup order so we did not sit. There was bar seating and table seating available. It was crowded on a week day, so that was a good sign that the place is supported. I enjoyed the live music which made me want to stay. The wings were delish. We tried their honey Sriracha, extra hot, and Cajun rub. They were all delish. read more

See all

This place hasn't changed a bit since I was a young man. Now I'm an old man and it's still a fun place to hang out. Very casual. I just want to have a beer and have a good night. This is the place. read more

Caputi's Sheridan Pub - Their sign out front - New American Near Me - Tonawanda, New York

I mean what isn't there to love about this place? The wings, pizza, sandwiches and drinks are all 10/10. The service is impeccable from all staff. If you want a great night with delicious food options and a great atmosphere then this is your spot! read more

See all

Food was good. Getting service took a while. Very loud atmosphere. Server was friendly.

Another review for Caputi's: still loving this place but thought I would update with even more information. They do .75¢ wings on Tuesdays and the flavors- to die for. Newest favorite is the monthly flavor of the month, a maple peach bbq (may be messing up the name!). It rivals the cattleman's and honey garlic parm for me. The chicken finger sub we got medium and is the perfect heat. McKenzie Cat Maddie and Brittany are some of our favorite bartenders around. Also adding to my reviews that they do a weekly dessert and this weeks tuxedo cake was off the charts. The desserts come from Kevin's catering in Kenmore. I probably stop at caputi's 3-5 times a month and will continue im sure to update and rave over their food read more

See all

This is a really cool bar. From the outside, it looks like it's going to be a run of the mill locals bar. The inside is decked out in funky neon signs, vintage posters, and just a really fun vibe. There's darts, pool, and pin ball. The building is connected to Candyman pizza, and the menu is really good. We ordered some cocktails (which were absolutely delicious), some beers (great draft list), and some snacks (which were super tasty!) I got a loganberry lemonade cocktail. The cocktail was fruity and refreshing and tasted like summer in a cup! We ordered fried Mac and cheese, pizza logs, and a pizza. The fried Mac and cheese balls were massive and covered in a tangy barbecue sauce. The pizza logs were standard. The pizza was on a thin crust with a bubbly outside. It was a super delicious artisan styler pizza. SO GOOD. Our waitress was also the bartender so we had to close out at the bar which was no problem. We had a great time playing darts. I will be back next time I'm in the neighborhood. read more

Caputi's Sheridan Pub - Fried Mac and Cheese - New American Near Me - Tonawanda, New York

Disappointing at best. Kitchen had no black olives, green peppers or mushrooms (!) for pizza toppings. Kitchen has no idea how to properly make a Caesar Salad. However, they have good cider on tap. read more

This review is for months back. We went for a fish fry and was very disappointed. The soup is no longer included in the order. We've not been back since for the fish fry. read more

Ordered chicken fingers with fries and a chicken quesadilla. Fries were in a puddle of grease and they do not serve plain blue cheese. Apparently they make their own and they add spices and garlic! This is Buffalo we eat our wings and fingers with regular blue cheese! I tasted it, and it was pretty gross, not kid friendly at all! The chicken quesadilla was decent but a little dry. Lesson learned. read more

Caputi's Sheridan Pub - New American Near Me - Tonawanda, New York

I have written many many reviews over the years and can count on one hand the number of negative reviews I left. It is not my typical way. However, Caputi's pub is a special bar/restaurant that is owed special treatment. During the insane period of time that was known as the Covid disaster, this establishment demanded (without any legal authority) to know what peoples' private medical information was. If you did not disclose your private legally-protected medical information to the person at the door during that time, thereby forfeiting your right to medical privacy and bodily autonomy then you were not permitted into their restaurant/bar. I have stayed true to my response, which was "no I will not divulge that information to you and I will never step foot in your establishment again". "all tyrannies, a tyranny sincerely exercised for the good of its victims may be the most oppressive." read more

I LOVE Caputi's! Not only is the food amazing, but the service and drinks are great too! They have really good options for beer, with really great prices. I highly recommend their wings and pizza! read more

I'm just not impressed. Which is sad, because I want to be!! I follow them on all social media and their photos of their food and food specials look amazing!! I went there, already knowing what I wanted from the photos online. A wood-fire pizza & wings/grilled. Well, I had better pizza from 7/11, let me tell ya. The wings, were "alright" but tasted like Chivettas chicken (I do not like Chivettas chicken) but also, I order Cajun. Their blue cheese was also purple- riddle me that! read more

Caputi's Sheridan Pub - a basket of chicken wings - New American Near Me - Tonawanda, New York

See all

While out helping a friend with her car troubles we decided to go for lunch. Not being familiar with the area we luckily happened upon Caputi's Pub. We had my 95 yr old Grandmother with us so we were a little nervous when we pulled up and saw the outside. As the say "Never judge a book by it cover" this definitely applies here!! It looked a little more of a bar to bring Gram but turned out to be the Best kept Secret yet!!!! Upon entering it was your typical bar/restaurant, very nice, they were doing some renovations. Our server went above and beyond helping my Grandma and was such a nice woman. It was very homey and comfortable there! The food was Delicious! I had the Roast beef on Weck with gravy and 5 Italian parm wings. The Roast beef was cooked just the way I like it, a little pink and juicy, along with the gravy poured over it I needed a fork and knife to eat it! They give you plenty of meat too! The wings were crunchy and the flavor had a great taste and 5 was just enough for me! My Grandmother was Very happy with her meal as was my friend and the prices were good too. I would definitely recommend visiting Caputi's Sheridan Pub soon! read more

Caputi's Sheridan Pub - Caputis Hours - New American Near Me - Tonawanda, New York

See all

Came infor the $.75 wing special, and had 10 wings medium cooked well. The wings looked great but were terrible -there was some sort of aftertaste I only ate a couple of them and tossed the rest. I won't return to try their menu. Atmosphere itself is very bar oriented, with a pool table and video games. read more

My first time here. More of a local joint than anything... Lots of TVs for sports, great craft beer and Bourbon menu and traditional Buffalo Pub food. I went with a Caesar Salad and small order of Chicken Fingers... Nothing special on hat from but appreciate they have food late. Seeing the wings and wheck coming out- I'm sure it's great... read more

Caputi's Sheridan Pub - To Ol 45 Days Pils is from Denmark Zero Gravity Green State Pils is from VT Peerless Bourbon. Stay Thirsty My Friends! - New American Near Me - Tonawanda, New York

Love the wings and the new pizza!!! Always a good place for a bite to eat a cold beer and some darts!

Candyman Pizza at Caputi's Sheridan Pub. Best wood fired Pizza in WNY. Sooo good. Stop in for great drinks too. Deadhead approved. read more

Caputi's Sheridan Pub - Candyman Pizza at Caputis Sheridan Pub. Best woo fiired pizza in WNY. Sooo good. - New American Near Me - Tonawanda, New York

My favorite bar/restaurant in all of Buffalo, for a well-rounded night! I'm surprised it's not a common recommendation on wing lists as their wings, especially the weck wings, are 10/10. I'd recommend going Wednesday-Saturday so you can also get the Candyman pizzas (any of them, candyman style!), and sitting on the Candyman side for craft cocktails or Caputis side for a great beer menu. The section between Caputi's and Candyman has a pool table, dart boards, and a couple pinball machines so it really is the perfect spot for friends, dates, or even just to go by yourself and mingle with the staff and regulars. read more

Came here on National Chicken Wing Day because we wanted to try somewhere new for wings. This bar did not disappoint! We started with the Banana Pepper Dip and ordered a double of wings. Half were medium and the other half were cattleman bbq. The cattleman bbq is mixed with mustard and bbq sauce. The mustard is not overpowering at all, really good. Bomb wings! Will definitely come back again. read more

See all

Great atmosphere and great staff. Food was surprisingly really good. Highly recommend it.

We used to live in the area, so occasionally we stop in Caputis and The Deuce next door for a beverage or two. They redesigned a portion of their space into a wood fired pizza restaurant. It looks awesome but we haven't tried the pizza yet. Can't wait to try it! read more

Came here for a special event in the banquet room, a whiskey pairing dinner with a 4 course meal. Even though the menu items weren't part of the daily pub menu, they were made by the same kitchen staff and came out phenomenal! Even though I didn't check out the bar, they had a menu board of unique craft beers on tap, priced reasonably. Plenty of parking and friendly staff. Will come here again! read more

See all

HIGHLY recommend the cattleman BBQ wings. First time at this local bar and will definitely be back! Also suggest starting with the stuffed pepper dip. Simply delicious read more

Caputi's Sheridan Pub - a hand holding a piece of fried chicken - New American Near Me - Tonawanda, New York

Very nice selection of Scotch, Irish Whiskey and Bourbon as reasonable prices. I'm not from the area but would stop back in if I'm nearby. Bar pizza pie was delicious. I had the meatball pie. Friendly and knowledgeable staff. read more

Caputi's Sheridan Pub - New American Near Me - Tonawanda, New York

See all

First off, the food was great. But, the staffing was bizarre. The bartender was taking care of the dining room as well. Our initial waters were the sole drinks we received. We received our food and that was the only other time we saw her. We had to go to the bar just to pay our bill. Lastly, the place was ice cold. It was probably 62° in the place. Bottom line..I'd say order out..don't dine in. read more

Didn't ID me and my friend and then decided to come over later and grill us for ordering multiple drinks at once. Don't come here, they don't follow the law read more

Not bad. The Mrs. and me visited on a Friday. The bar was hopping, the restaurant part was pretty much empty. However it was still a bit early for dinner rush. My wife ordered their 1/2 Fish Fry which came with soup, salad and fries. I ordered a single order (10) wings medium. They came out good. Could of been a little more sauceier though. My wife said her fish fry was delicious. The batter was perfect in her words. We also ordered the salt n vinegar fries. They had a great taste but were soggy when you picked them up. Not worth the 4.95 price. Other then that, we were happy. read more

Caputi's Sheridan Pub - Tasty single order medium wings! - New American Near Me - Tonawanda, New York

We had wings and drinks here and it was fun. They have darts and a pool table and they've totally updated their space since if been here years ago. Much more inviting and less dive-y. Wings were good and so were the G&Ts. I'd recommend for a weeknight out to play darts and have a drink! read more

Short pours and waited forever to get a drink. Never tried any food but the pour was less than a second in a mix drink. The place is nice. They just need better trained bartenders. read more

I have been going to this business forever, but I recently went in for a quick take out order and a beer at the bar. My food was extraordinary - just a simple burger and a salad. The salad had fresh tomatoes and really crispy greens - great job . The service was also great - friendly and accommodating - you won't be disappointed with this joint! read more

Was my first time here with some friends to grab dinner and I can't wait to come back again! It's a little dark in the restaurant but it looks like a fun place to go hang with friends and grab a bite to eat and some booze to drink! I had the grilled cheese and fries and the Black Bird Hard Cider IT WAS OUT OF THIS WORLD! They have so many things to chose from for drinks and great options for food too! Everything is reasonably priced too which is another plus. Charlotte our waitress was super patient and helpful too. Thank you for a great evening! read more

Caputi's Sheridan Pub - Grilled Cheese with bacon and tomato - New American Near Me - Tonawanda, New York

Thank goodness for DJ trivia, otherwise I wouldn't have found this cool spot. A bar located on what looks like a pretty commercial highway, surprisingly opens up to a pretty large spot. Drink specials every night, rotating craft brews, retro arcade games, pinball machines, dart boards, pool tables, and some pretty solid chicken fingers await. My buddy and I came by here for DJ trivia (if you're into that sort of thing, they do it on Thursdays) and decided to make the most of our time. Our service was very prompt and was well informed about the menu. We opted for a bottle of blue lights just because it was the best deal ($15). Now don't come here for fine dining obviously, but if you want bar food, they got it. Wings, fingers, burgers, fries, tots, etc. I got the fingers with some hot sauce and they were cooked perfectly. The fries that came with it were just okay, so they have some room to grow. Overall, just a super cool bar if you're looking to hang out with friends in the suburbs. read more

Went for wood fired pizza it wasn't available in this dingy dive bar. Ordered salt and vinegar fries the fries had wayyy to much salt they weren't edible the fries were hand cut fresh too which is the sad part that I couldn't eat any of it due to the over obnoxious amount of salt. The beer was cold the ambience was dark and dreary black ceilings and dark woods. I will definitely not be back to this place The bartender asked me if the food was good and I told her that it was not good at all and had only ate 4 fries and that was it, she never asked why the food was not good and didn't even remove it from my ticket so I paid for bad food and lack of customer service she was to busy talking to her regulars instead of giving customers that are having issues with their food resolution. And I still tipped her even though I had to pay full price for food that it would never get eaten. This place is not recommended by me at all. I give this place an F. read more

While contemplating how many stars to give the new Candyman Pizza (inside Caputi's), we thought "what's better?" This is bomb pizza, awesome atmosphere, and great wine, whiskey, and beer offerings to quench your thirst. We'll be back and now the secret's out! read more

My wife and I stopped in to try Candyman pizza for the first time. We shared 2 pizzas, the Quattro Formaggi, and the Margherita. Both were amazing, even the crust! Paired with a hazy IPA, a great experience was had. Really enjoyed the music as well. We'll be back! read more

Thank Goodness Caputi's Pub is still going strong and staying open late. It was 8:00 pm and I had driven and called around tons of places between Niagara Falls and Buffalo looking for an open kitchen and found Caputi's was still open til 4:00am! Vrroooooommm!! We pull up and get greeted by a nice guy telling us to go right in and a server will be right with us. And she was, allowing us to sit where we felt most comfortable so we chose to sit outside. The service was great and we never once felt like we were forgotten about sitting outside. We both ordered the Combo ($14.99) which came with Beef on Weck and 5 chicken wings with the sauce of our choosing so we went whimpy and asked for medium. It was late and I wasn't in a "Fire-in-the-hole" kinda mood plus we had a drive back to Niagara Falls after we finished, . Anyways, the Beef on Weck was absolutely delicious. It was piled high, served with horseradish and omg it was so juicy and flavorful! Like so many foods served in Buffalo, I had to explain the slurp-bite* to my girlfriend in order to save her shirt from getting juice all over it! The chicken wings were cooked perfectly. Crispy, hot, just the right amount of sauce so they didn't get all soggy and juicy in every bite. I washed down my meal with a Sloops Juicy IPA and being a pub they have many options to chose from. Give all the restrictions and new rules that restaurants have to play by, I was wildly impressed with how great Caputi's took care of us and our meal. If you're in Buffalo, come here and enjoy a great meal, a cold drink and some friendly staff. You won't be disappointed! read more

Caputi's Sheridan Pub - The original signage still hanging outside! - New American Near Me - Tonawanda, New York

See all

OK this place is a must for Friday fish fry. The food was so good I forgot to take a picture. I got the broiled Cajun fish - it was awesome the sides were homemade it came with soup too. The wings are also amazing - food management may have changed because the food out of the kitchen is with waiting for!! Super great! read more

This is for sure a little Tonawanda hidden gem. There is nothing fancy about this place but it's a good little hang out spot. Drinks are wings are surprisingly good. I tried the Italian wings, it's very different but I would get it again! If you are looking for a quick place for a beer or some wings, come here! read more

Caputi's Sheridan Pub - Italian wings at midnight. Yum :) - New American Near Me - Tonawanda, New York

Caputis is definitely not my choice for a night out, but I've been dragged here more than a couple of times. Luckily they usually have decent drink specials and more than a couple pool tables and dart boards to keep you busy. For some reason (which I don't understand) this place is always packed. It's difficult to get a drink here when it is and ways feels like it's understaffed. The bathrooms are tiny, tiny, tiny, and usually very dirty. I guess if you're looking to have a couple bud lights and throw a few darts it's an OK spot, but anything more than that and I'd probably recommend you keep driving. read more

Ordered a fish fry to go and I received 11 french fries. They were cold and under cooked. My slaw and potato salad were two fork fulls, plus it was a mess and mixed together. There was no salt and pepper or ketchup. Pretty poor for take-out. read more

Caputi's Sheridan Pub - New American Near Me - Tonawanda, New York