Kathy (and her husband Gary) were nothing short of extraordinary, going above and beyond for our…read morewedding cake. The cake was probably the only thing my wife and I were really picky about for our special day. We wanted unique flavors, a light buttercream frosting that would not be too heavy since we also served ice cream and an elegant design; all in a reasonable budget. Kathy delivered on all fronts with a beautiful four tier cake in two flavors. We chose a white cake with strawberry balsamic buttercream filling and lemon curd filling, it was delicious, moist, sweet and tart. Our other flavor was a take on Buckeye flavor: chocolate cake with ganache filling along a with peanut butter-buttercream filling, decadent and a real hit here in Ohio. Kathy made the whole cake experience unforgettable with a tasting right at her dining room table and a handmade sketch of our cake to go along with our design decisions. It was delivered on time to our venue and finishing decorations were placed on site. It was gorgeous. And all this for less than $4 a serving + a $35 delivery charge. Kathy is amazing and we can't thank her enough.

Food and service was awesome. Went there for a wedding cake tasting. Angela was very nice and…read moreattentive to us. Dessert was really good as well, had a lot of flavors we could try. We tried chocolate, red velvet, and vanilla cake. With Oreo butter cream, cream cheese frosting, chocolate mousse, and chocolate butter cream. The frostings were light and creamy. The cake had a small issue that they fixed right away when we discussed it. They take all feedback to help make the experience better. We even tried their tiramisu, which was excellent as well. All in all I'd recommend them as a bakery and as a wedding dessert place. Angela brought great experience with weddings and helped us get enough cakes without going overboard or breaking our budget.

I am very disappointed in the sheet cake I recently bought for my daughter's birthday. The extra…read morecharge of artwork for a basic volleyball that looks like my 11 year old drew is unacceptable. The cake looks very basic for the price I paid. I could have went to Giant Eagle for the same cake for a cheaper price and most likely a better appearance. Whoever designed this should be ashamed of themselves for the price I was charged. When I brought this to the young man's attention prior to checking out, he didn't seem to care one bit. Definitely won't be coming back! Which is a shame because this is where I always bought my girls cakes.

I'm so sad to see so many people had such a disappointing experience at Cakes by Nadine! I knew as…read moresoon as I tasted one of her cakes at my cousins birthday party that Nadine would absolutely need to make my future wedding cake!! Fast forward a few years and sure enough, Nadine constructed the most beautiful and mouth watering cake for my wedding! I scheduled to meet with Nadine one Saturday (she gives free samples on Saturdays!) without the slightest idea what I wanted my wedding cake to look like. She was so patient with me and she worked through it, really paying attention to every word I said and got so creative. She drew up a sketch of what she gathered that I wanted. When I saw my cake on our wedding day I was speechless. It was more beautiful and perfect than I could have EVER imagined!!! Nadine is extremely talented, and it's very obvious she loves what she does. She is expensive, yes, but she only makes a few wedding cakes every weekend so they are high quality. I couldn't imagine having a better experience or having a more beautiful wedding cake. Thank you, Nadine!!!

We ordered our wedding cake for our wedding May 20 of this year. Our bottom layer was pretty good…read moreobviously ate it at the wedding and enjoyed it other than the cake being a little dry. We went to go eat our top layer last week because we are moving and could not keep it frozen any longer. When we went to eat the cake we realized the filling was not what we asked for. Scraped it off the cake to confirm and taste it by itself. I called and told them about the issue today and told them how highly disappointed we were. They told us that In their records we received the correct filling but there is absolutely no flavor to it once so ever and they didn't offer any kind of small refund or to make us some kind of small replacement or anything didnt seen to even care that I was clearly upset over the matter. Extremely sad we won't get to enjoy our top layer of our cake because it is extremely plain.. but glad I didn't wait a year to find this out on our special 1 year wedding anniversary or I would have been about 1000 times more upset... I got this cake because my mom had her wedding cake from here and I loved it so I am sad to say the quality has significantly decreased in the last couple years..

I happened to have stumbled upon WFCS online and what a pleasant surprise. They have the most…read moreBEAUTIFULLY designed cakes and cupcakes! It's really worth whatever you buy.

Everything we've had has been amazing. Moist cake, rich but not cloying icing. It's our official go…read moreto for all birthday cakes from here on out. The cupcakes are spectacular & are my favorite! Great customers service! Recommend!

Jamie is amazing! I recently hired her to make cake pops for my wedding reception and she really…read morewent above and beyond. Jamie offers flavors and ideas that I have yet to see from other similar services. She not only really listened to what my husband & I wanted but was open to any suggestions as well. Since one of my wedding colors was apple green & it was held this Oct, she developed a marvelous apple spice cake pop. My husband later suggested a green tea pop since I'm obsessed with the flavor & Jamie was more than willing to accommodate that request as well. And talk about paying attention to details, my overall theme was eco friendly, so Jamie chose actual cinnamon sticks for the apple spice pops & used hemp twine when she wrapped them for us. And of course, all of the cake pops were beautifully decorated! Her maple bacon cake pop was the favorite amongst my guest. I would gladly recommend Jamie's services to anyone who wanted a more personal touch at reasonable prices :)

Pies, pies, pies except for the occasional brownie that's all they sell. But they sell out quick,…read morebest to call ahead and pay online. The two girls that work there can be busy when a bus load comes in. They probably make a hundred different pies, but only make five or ten different a day. But if they are making 1,000 apple pies don't expect them to make one peach for you. The Ambiance, well they sell pies, other than being clean, what do you expect.

Gardner pies are delicious and there are so many great flavors. We got there around 2 pm and they…read morehad already sold out of a lot of their fresh pies. They had a lot of frozen options, but we decided to go with what they had left - cinnamon pumpkin, pineapple, and one peach crumb. They were all good, especially the cinnamon pumpkin which had the best flavor and perfect creamy texture. The outlet prices are great - treat yourself!

Beyond expectation. This is one of those special graces that you feel like only you know about…read more In 2021, Veronica and I started planning our May 2022 wedding. When it came time to try the cakes, we selected around 5 top rated cake places to try in the area. Frosted Cake Art was one of them. Mind you, before I review the cakes, know that Seema (Frosted Cake Art) is a home based business going up against long standing bakers, and the wedding venue itself which has over a dozen fine dining restaurants. We cannot complain about the other venues we sampled, however Seema's cakes were an obvious cut above the rest. "The Cake Tasting" itself was a beautiful experience, trying several frostings, cake types, and many fillings. Elegant and organized "The cakes" are consistently moist while still keeping their interior structure. We like to headline that point. Rare "The frostings" are ALL good. no alkaline taste, no granules, no empty taste, not hard like cold butter, nor are they too light and whippy. Smoothest texture you have ever experienced. Rare "The fillings" are exceptional. We wanted to use everyone of them. Even the more dramatic flavors we considered, although we didn't come in to the tasting thinking we would. All-in-all, for a small 75 person wedding, we decided to go with a multi flavored, 5 layer behemoth of a cake because we just wanted everyone to experience greatness. Greatness, folks Seema is a true professional. Seamless Seema. Aside from being a good baker, she has an excellent format of execution that sees the job through from beginning to end. She is patient and literally listens and applies all the details. She uses digital and actual templates throughout the process, willing to change and offer advice. Some fancy decorations we used....One was a "floating" top layer, giving a great effect. Another was a false cake layer where there was a statue of the bride and groom in a tunnel. She molded the bride and groom to spec. Seema used a picture of us both, plus a picture of the wedding dress. It was spot on and we plan on preserving this for life. God bless you, Seema. Thank you for an unforgettable experience Rick and Veronica Married May 28, 2022

On 12/9/2023 we had our wedding reception and Seema did everything perfectly from the time we…read morestarted to the time it was finished everyone loved the flavors and the details on the cake it was amazing

Kim made my son's college graduation cake and it turned out better than anything I could have hoped…read morefor! I sent her some "visions" my son wanted and she went over the top with them! The cake was delicious and everything on it was edible, even the diploma. It was so beautiful that I felt bad cutting in to it when the time came! Kim was in constant communication about the cake and pick up time, she was flexible and always honest about things. I will definitely be getting more cakes from Kim in the future and have been recommending her to everyone!