Definitely one of the better pizzerias in the neighborhood of college point/whitestone. I had their slices and sicilians. Both very flavorful. It's hard to find good authentic pizza now a days. It's tasting more like cardboard. read more

Caffe Rustico - Rustico brick oven pie with sausage - Italian Near Me - Whitestone, New York

LOVE this place!!!! Pizza is amazing, pastas and salads are great too. Delivery is hot & fast. Staff is awesome read more

One of the most underrated slice joints not just in Whitestone or Queens but the city at large! Both the regular and Buffalo slices and wings are all must-tries. . Delivery is super fast and friendly. Do it! read more

Awesome pizzas, awesome spaghetti & meatballs, great chicken parm... basically anything that has their amazing sauce on it is a great meal. Their pasta fagioli soup is the best I've ever tasted anywhere. They are always very helpful and friendly. Love to eat here with my kids and there is always parking right outside. read more

In town for a business trip and Caffe was recommended to me. So glad I listened. The pizza I got delivered was hot and delicious. This will be my go to restaurant when I'm in town again. read more

Still an awesome place to eat! Fast delivery, very hot and delicious food. Better than Vincents in Carle Place. What a treat to eat here. Never disappointed! read more

Delicious pizza. Dough was crispy and not burned. Perfect amount of sauce and cheese. The ingredients compliment each other very well. Pizza delivery hot and fast. read more

I know this is a pizza place and even though the pizza is good, that is not why I gave it such a high rating. This pizza place has the best wings I have ever had in my life. Everything about the wings are perfect. They are crispy, with a sauce that doesn't just add a little bit of heat but actually tastes amazing. They also have a lot of juicy meat which is a problem I have been having with a lot of wings. They have good pies but try the wings, you will not regret it. read more

I've never been to the actual pizzeria, only delivery. We recently moved to the area and a friend who is a local told me to try them out. So happy she did! Everything we've ever ordered from CR has been outstanding. Their brick oven is crisp, light and full of flavor. Their penne ala vodka, regular pizza, ravioli, soups, all great! We recently had friends over who couldn't believe how delicious everything was. Can't wait to explore more of the menu as the weather cools down. 10 stars! read more

Love the pizza from here! My co workers and I have been ordering from here for awhile so I felt it was time for me to finally leave a review. I've had the pasta dishes, salads and all different types of pizza (the caffe rustico pizza is my favorite) and have no complaints the delivery is always super fast too! read more

I have lived in the neighborhood several years now and this is where we order from after trying countless others. We always call for the Sicilian pie with sausage. Best tasting pizza around. And they are not cheap with sauce! read more

A hidden gem in the nabe I never knew about until recently and have lived in Bayside over 40 years. My hubby had tried their pizza once and really liked it. Not a fan of Baybridge, Il Villagio, Cascarino's, etc. -- all very average. Very surprised that everything we had was so good: garlic bread, shrimp fra diavolo and eggplant parm. Tucked away all the way down 149th Street so you would never know it's there. Will order from them again. read more

We travelled all day and we're starving. The chicken wings were breaded and deep fried perfectly. The sauce was spicy enough but not overly spiced. My husband and I killed the wings fast. The kids downed the pizza and wanted more. Overall it was delicious and not just because we were hungry! We ordered and they arrived to deliver it 25 mins before the estimated delivery time and it was still extra hot. Wet good experience. read more

pizza was cooked to perfection ! salad was very good , grilled chicken was tender and the dressing was tasty. it was delivered right on time , thank you read more

The food is amazing! I had the Chicken Francese and my boyfriend had the Vitello Funghi with a side of pasta in red sauce. It was all absolutely delicious. The sauce tatse home made and the food was warm and, fresh and tasty. The delivery time was the best I've ever had since moving to queens. I ordered at 7:50pm and had my food by 8:19pm. Considering that every place I've ordered from has made me wait no less than an hour and a half, I am beyond impressed and will definitely order again! Don't let the price scare you the food is worth it. It's a very good portion as well! read more

Hands down my favorite place for Italian food. Not only the pizza but every single item on their menu is amazing. Marco is always friendly and helpful if you need a recommendation off the menu. Definitely try their pasta! read more

Caffe Rustico - Italian Near Me - Whitestone, New York

They have the best eggplant rollatini, and buffalo chicken slice. I don't even like eggplant and I will go here solely for that. But now the new vice is the Buffalo chicken. Xo read more

Best Pizza In Whitestone HANDS down....... Not oily, Cheese Sauce and Crust are Perfect.... I love the Vodka Pizza ( One of my Fav) He also makes other Good Pasta Dishes... Give it a Shot read more

Vodka pie is unbelievable!! And zucchini sticks on the side! I am drooling writing this review!

Probably the greatest.pizza in the Northeastern section of Queens. Nice, friendly establishment. The brick-oven pies are extraordinary but the regular pies are awesome as well. The Penne alla Vodka and Margarita brick-oven pies are absolutely delicious. You know if a pizza place is good based on how good their plain slices are and Caffe Rustico has the best slice around! read more

This review is a long time coming.......This is a good ole family run spot, we used to live around the corner and would order from them 2-3 times a week when we worked late. The staff is always friendly and they take special requests (dressing on the side or extra lemon). You gotta check out their chicken franchise they make it fresh for every order. Their grilled chicken Cesar is also on point!! We currently live near bell but still order from cafe Rustico! read more

Love this place. Service is always excellent. Food is always fresh. I must say the chicken alla rustico is my favorite, but all the dishes are really good. This restaurant is a hidden gem in Whitestone. read more

The Vodka brick oven pizza is SOO good!

Pizza is very good, but the real gem here are the dinners. Pasta and chicken dinners are fabulous. Excellent salads. Much more than you would expect! read more

One of my favorite spots in all of queens. Classic Italian dishes with excellent Pizza, not to mention untouchably delicious brick oven pizzas, which are a personal favorite of mine. Their prices are very fair, and their menu is so expansive, I've never left there wanting. If you call yourself a brick oven connoisseur, you cant miss Caffe Rustico. My father is a regular here, and every single time I've been in town to visit, I make sure to stop by. Great food, great owners and friendly and attentive staff, you simply cant beat it! read more

We have yet to find a great pizzeria in Whitestone. Before you order from Caffe Rustico, please be sure to confirm what their menu definition is of a "grandma" pie. It seems that they do not know what "fresh" homemade mozzarella is. Their grandma pie is nothing more than a sicilian square pie with sauce on top. This was nothing different than a regular round pie. We were very disappointed to say the least. Will not be ordering from them again. To be honest, the cheese tasted old and processed. read more

Best wings ever! My boyfriend works in Queens, we live in Staten Italy, and this place is better than 90% of the places here on SI. Love the meatball parm, the mozzarella sticks, penne vodka, but the BEST are the wings. You will not be disappointed! I'm Italian born in Brooklyn, stereotypical guiodette- lol but honestly it makes me love Whitestone even more. Obviously by the time my better half arrives back to SI in 2 hours of traffic we have to reheat the food- but even as left overs, it's still delish! read more

I order in from them at least 2x a week. Best brick oven mini pizza's. Try the traditional margharita, the eggplant or the white. Excellent chicken francese and amazing penne vodka. Baked ziti with meat sauce is very yummy too. Try the spinach ravioli in the pink sauce ; you will not be disappointed. Garlic knots are just right, not too greasy. They are very friendly, prices are great & delivery guys are very pleasant. read more

Stopped here on the way to JFK last night. It was delicious. We started by sharing a mixed salad, which was plenty big to share. The salad was fresh and the balsamic dressing was delicious. (The only thing I didn't like we're the tomatoes. They were cut in thin slices and then quartered. Would be much better in wedges or thicker so that they hold up better.) Soaked up the remnants of the dressing with their deliciously crusty bread. We then shared a rustico supreme pizza. The crust was perfectly thin and crispy. The pizza was huge so we had them wrap two of the slices in foil for him to take on his flight with him to eat during his long layer and I took the test back home with me. We will make a habit of stopping here on the way to JFK from now on. read more

I love, love, love the grandma pizza from Caffe Rustico. Always order grandma slices along with their regular pizza for take out. This pizza also freezes well if there are any slices left. Found this pizzeria about a year ago and wouldn't order from any other place. I even catered eggplant parm, chicken parm and penne alla vodka a few times when we were having company and everyone raved about the food. A must try for the pizza fanatics. read more

saw on yelp the review of caffe rustico and they were right!! The sicilian and regular pizza was delicious!! We also had a chicken roll and that was delicious!! Not a lot of dough and crisp! This will be my only Pizza Place.! read more

Decided to try because of the review that read 'best wings ever'. Pretty bad. Soggy, small, and tasted like nothing but pepper. The plain pizza was overcooked. Won't order again. read more

Excellent service and food. We stopped there on the way to upstate NY and really enjoyed the Italian!!! We had pizza and pasta.