For better or for worse, Bloomington has a reputation for a gorgeous and rigorous university and a pleasantly funky vibe. C3 and the mixed-use development which houses it are so antithetical to what Bloomington has come to represent that perhaps it really is what residents have felt was needed for some time. But it's simultaneously so generic and so inconsistently conceived, I cannot imagine its becoming a Bloomington fixture. Perhaps I'll be proven wrong.
First, the whole Renwick place. The C3 website calls it "quaint," but it resembles a residential subdivision from Disneyworld. Nothing looks lived in, everything looks fake. It's fitting that it's located down the street from the mall and the glut of chain restaurants. C3 has a nice outdoor seating area looking over the nondesript plaza of the Renwick Village Center (the business part of the area). Yes, it's a "village," and the street is really called Piazza Drive.
The interior of C3 closely resembles a hotel bar. The one exception is a seating enclave to the left of the front door which is actually quite cozy and inviting. A few drinks on the menu show some imagination, and they're prepared decently. The name C3 comes from the bar's plot on the site plan for the development, but they've adapted it to mean "crafted cocktails and cuisine." Or something like that. They're obviously going for a sophisticated cocktail lounge with exciting drinks and complementary small plates and bar snacks.
But the small plates ain't so small, and they're much more reminiscent of the owner's other establishments in the state (Scotty's Brewhouse, Three Wise Men) than the swanky joint the place aspires to be. The heavy, heavy sweet potato skins would not be out of place at Scotty's, nor would the fillet sliders. And then -- bam! - there's mac and cheese. This is not the kind of food one imagines accompanying sleek craft cocktails. The crab and corn hush puppies were delicious, and the obligatory charcuterie plate is offered, but where is the bowl of nuts? Where are the olives, maybe some duck confit, some cheese with preserves? In their place is -- I kid you not -- grilled cheese with a bowl of tomato soup.
Perhaps I am just wishing C3 were a different kind of place, but the imitation swank surrounding it is just oppressive. On top of that, our server mentioned that he was happy the place was priced and located beyond the reach of most students, since students don't tend to tip very well. Bloomington deserves better. Maybe the place will evolve with time. read more