Pizza was disappointing and service was bad. Order was supposed to be ready at 7:15pm. We arrived around 7:30 and the unfriendly, spaced-out cashier said they still needed to make the garlic bread. We waited 20+ more minutes, just before they closed. The pizza was just ok. It used to be *so delicious* and was our favorite. We only have pizza a few times a year and always looked forward to getting it from Buccaneer (previously First Class Pizza) in Villa Park. But this time was so disappointing. There was some left the next day and it just wasn't good. We ended up throwing it out, along with the garlic bread which wasn't worth waiting for. read more

Buccaneer pizza in the Ralph's plaza is very good. Excellent quality ingredients. Ham and Tad salty but overall everyone loved the product Pricing is a little steep though I must say. I don't mind paying for quality but these pies are 2-3 bucks too expensive in my opinion but I will definitely be back for more read more

Buccaneer Pizza - Excellent pizza - Pizza Near Me - Villa Park, California

Tasty quality pizza (crust, toppings) and great service from Fatima. They sell slices so a great way to try it out (like I did). Going to try their Santa Ana sit-down restaurant next time. read more

Buccaneer Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Villa Park, California

Ordered pizza and meatballs online. Was given 20 minute ETA. When I arrived to pick up my order, was told they no longer made meatballs (too labor intensive, they said). Pointed out it was still on their online menu AND menu board in the store. They said they'd let someone know. 20 minute ETA ended up being 45 minutes. Too bad -- used to love this place. Plenty of other options in the area. read more

Very good pizza with great ingredients. Love this place. This is my go to place. You can't go wrong it surly beat the local chain pizza places. read more

Buccaneer Pizza - Large Pepperoni Pizza. - Pizza Near Me - Villa Park, California

Not sure what changed but it went the wrong direction. Ordered pizza online. They simplified the app. Ordered what We wanted. Fast time for pick up. The medium pizza was burnt, dry, barely olives & mushrooms on top. My 4 yr old Grandson looked at his piece and said "old". It was beyond disappointment. This place use yo have decent pizza. Never bothering ordering from them again. I get costs need to be curbed but I'd been better buying a frozen pizza and that says a lot to me. read more

Im from NY. Pizza has to droop and you get a little oil on your hand. I find this pizza good, kind of too thick to my liking, but good. Toppings are fresh and sauce is very good. Now we ordered a meatball sandwich and a lasagne calzone. My goodness, home run with these two. Enough to share the sandwich or calzone. That calzone was amazing. No skimping on the meats or cheese. Same with the meatball sandwich. 4 stars because the pizza is too thick. But thats me. Get a sandwich. Badda bing badda boom on that sandwich..... read more

The pizza was really good--crispy crust, tasty sauce, and plenty of toppings. Would definitely come back

Expensive but great! The cheese skulls are to die for (pun intended). Fresh ingredients make a great pie.

Horrible. We were regulars for five years. As usual, we ordered a pizza with double pepperoni plus mushrooms and olives. When we opened it at home there were no mushrooms. When we called the restaurant, the server said she thought we said "light mushrooms." Idiotic - plus she charged us full price for the imaginary "light mushrooms." Double idiotic. She did not offer any accommodation. Why would anybody ever order "light mushrooms" and if so why would they still be charged full price? We have not ordered from Buccaneer since. Nor do we plan to do so. read more

Another one of these spontaneous "Hey - I still need dinner, let's try this place out and order a pizza to pick up after I finished shopping at Ralphs" moments. I had been here before but I think it was Top Class Pizza, or First Class Pizza, something Class Pizza. I just remember I wasn't impressed before. I walked over, placed my order for 1 large pizza, paid ($23.00 so it's not cheap), and told them I'd be back to pick it up after I did a bit of shopping at Ralphs. I went to move my car to be just little closer, which was probably a mistake. I should have stayed in my stop near Ralphs, but I was being lazy and didn't want to carry the pizza that far. Well, between the bakery and the Chinese restaurants, there wasn't a spot to be found and people were jockeying for people to leave so lesson learned. I picked up the pizza and first thing I noticed it is was heavy!! Now you know you're getting some serious pizza when theirs some weight to it. Getting home, I was a little disappointed that the cheese had slid to one side. It's hard to keep a pizza flat when driving, especially in a hilly area like N Tustin Ave in Orange. I also like a little brown on the top of my cheese which usually solidifies it a little better on the crust. Not always, but I think it helps. Because the cheese moved, we have to recut the pizza to pull out the slices. Otherwise, the pizza was delicious! Loved the crust and also the sauce which had just enough kick for my taste. I don't like overly spicey, but I'm not a sweet sauce person either and this was just right. read more

Buccaneer Pizza - a pizza box with a skull and knife on it - Pizza Near Me - Villa Park, California

See all

What's not to love! Best thick crust pizza in so called hands down. Great ingredients. Clean restaurant. Newly remodeled. Fair pricing. And super nice staff. Love this place. My goto pizza spot. read more

Absolutely disappointed. Ordered a pizza online and wasn't given an ETA for pick up. We called to confirm approximately 30 minutes later and was given a 30 minute ETA. Well we got there about 1HR after ordering and was told all Large pizzas were cancelled. They did not have the courtesy to say the order was cancelled nor did they offer any sort of compensation for wasting one hour of our time. I will not be supporting this spot any further and believe a place that doesn't have the courtesy to let you know your order was cancelled deservs your hard earned money. read more

Best Pizza Ever! Service and food is prompt. Recommend the chiki chiki or the BBq Chicken Hawaiian pizza. Outstanding!

Amazing food and staff!! The quartermaster is probably the best sandwich I have ever eaten. It's a craving that only that sandwich takes care of. read more

This pizza that we had tonight was the best pizza ever ever made! we had a cheese and pepperoni and mushroom pizza with a cheese blanket over the top! It was over the top delicious! Got the chicken wings, fat crunchy delicious there's nobody better to buy pizza or chicken wings . this is the only place we're ever gonna order pizza from again. read more

This place offers a great lunch deal for individual pizzas. Buy one get, one half off makes it lunch for two for under $20. The pizza itself is 7/10 when compared to dominoes 4/10 this place stands out. read more

Love this pizza and highly recommend checking it out. Their sauce is so good and they are generous on the toppings!

Honestly this place has become my favorite for ordering out pizza. The service is good, the location is easy to park and pickup the pizza. The pizza itself is so delicious! If you like a good crust , this is the place. I've never eaten inside of the restaurant so I can't say much about that but there is plenty of parking as well as outdoor seating! read more

We used to like this place, tasty pizza. Friday night we ordered our medium cheese pizza and cinnamon knots at 5:13pm, received the "out for delivery" e-mail at 6:02, called at 6:40 wondering where our pizza was and was told they only had one driver for the night and she was delivering 4 pizzas, received our pizza at 6:52. Pizza is ice cold, cheese is all hardened. Cinnamon knots are swimming in congealed butter and grease and cold. Management needs to figure out delivery. Timely pizza delivery is not a new thing, figure it out, do better. Cinnamon knots are gross, see pics. read more

Buccaneer Pizza - What the cinnamon knots came in - Pizza Near Me - Villa Park, California

See all

Best pizza in town!! I always stop in for a slice while doing deliveries. Very satisfying everytime

Great food. Pizzas are well prepared and crust is very nice. We enjoy their supreme and pepperoni with mushroom. Salads are very fresh too. We love their Caesar. read more

We have gone to this location multiple times food is hit or miss, service is the same. It's happened often that they forget to give us an item we ordered. Today was the last straw, they omitted one full item menu which meant one person in our party would not have dinner. When my husband went back to pick up the item they laughed at my husband for having to drive back! They never gave him a receipt which makes me think they are scamming customers. That actually told him to go to the back of the line to wait for the food that should have been ready 20 minutes earlier. We will not be coming back to this location ever again. Going back to Zitos. Much better service! read more

After supporting this business the past year, I will no longer be doing so. They are not honest about their delivery times and I have had several deliveries where a pizza was an hour or an hour and a half late. In addition to waiting excessive amounts of times to receive our deliveries, the last couple of pizzas were not even warm by the time they got here. I would never treat customers in this manner and certainly would never over promise and under deliver on a consistent basis. read more

great individual pizzas! awesome online ordering experience and we love the location.

Our usual from their original location in Santa Ana is the Wild Boar pizza. Which is AMAZING!! Today we were by this location and craving a meatball sandwich. From this day forward I will forever add pepperoncinis to my meatball sandwiches. It gives it a nice little kick. The one thing I wish it had more of was sauce. It was a bit dry for my liking. I prefer this particular sandwich to be more saucy. I'll be back for pizza soon!! read more

Buccaneer Pizza - Menu - Pizza Near Me - Villa Park, California

See all

Delicious pizza and great service We ordered the family sized salad and there was enough for 4 generous portions with enough for the next day. Margarita pizza and mushroom-sausage pizzas were delivered hot with a crispy crust So glad we have a great pizza restaurant so close to home with friendly service read more

They took over First Class. Personally I like Buccaneeers. I used to go to their other location near Hart Park. The only thing I didn't like was the distance since First Class scratches the same "itch". All in all, this place is now the king pizza of the area. I rate this higher than Zitos. It's a good pizza. I'd go here or Zitos or Tony's in placentia for deep dish. read more

Pizza is good, toppings fresh and high quality. We ask for well done and it is perfect for the hand tossed crust. Highly recommend their quartermaster sandwich...we could eat one once a week, if our metabolism was like a teenagers! Few tables outside but really meant to be enjoyed at home. read more

Great pizza but for this it just seemed over priced. Salad was $45??? Why??? It seems like a very basic salad. Sorry but we are not ordering from them again! read more

Buccaneer Pizza - $42 salad???? What ??? - Pizza Near Me - Villa Park, California

See all

Ordered the large combo and the great white Great pizza, fresh and delicious. We highly recommend this pizza place

I used to eat here when it was First Class Pizza, which I enjoyed much more. Since it became Buccaneer Pizza, I've tried to give it a chance, but the customer service at the Villa Park location has been very hit or miss, and the quality of the pizza is inconsistent. I've looked past pizzas that randomly might have a strange aftertaste (almost like cologne--whether it's from the box or cleaning supplies, I don't know), missing toppings that I paid for, and now they can't even accommodate a simple request for extra cheese on just half the pizza. I was told this isn't something they "do" and that I'd need a "special exception" for it, which is kind of ridiculous. I'm done giving this place chances and won't be returning. read more

They said its the same "family" as first class, which was very successful in that location for decades..... must be a distant, adoptive cousin through marrige as it's not even close. Different, inferrior ingredients and horrible taste, with jacked up prices. Very bad decision from the new owner to change it up read more

First off, I loved First Class Pizza. Was really surprised and sad that this place took over but was willing to give it a try. We ordered online for delivery. I ordered a veggie pizza extra crispy thin crust. Sounded delicious. Um no. What a got was a soggy personal pizza. I'm not exaggerating. It was so soggy that was leaking through the bottom of the box. Also, the canned pineapple on top was the worst. These pizzas are not cheap. Then I remembered how I went to another location years ago and hated the pizza. This place sucks place and simple. Quality is worse than pizza hut. Just go to pasta party or blaze pizza down the street. So much better than this garbage. read more

Buccaneer Pizza - Soggy a$$ personal veggie pizza. So gross. - Pizza Near Me - Villa Park, California

New favorite pizza. A little on the pricey side, but go give it a try. We always go with 2 topping large and a medium single topping.

So happy my husband got us the hot pizza lunch special at Buccaneers ‍ Pizza! You can taste the quality of this pizza and just enjoy yourself! We couldn't stop raving about the personal pan we had. read more

Buccaneer Pizza - Thinnest pepperoni fresh thick crust and savory cheese - Pizza Near Me - Villa Park, California

These guys take orders on Doordash, then cancel and refund. It must be too hard for them to make a pizza. Why are you on doordash if you can't fulfill an order? Please save us the time. read more

Buccaneer Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Villa Park, California

If I could give ZERO stars I would. I'm from orange and always went to first class. Never realized buccaneer had a location in orange. We always go to the santa Ana location and have the best service and food. This location is terrible. My husband went in about a mo th ago and the young lady at vp location was so rude. He said he never felt so rushed or disrespected by a food server ever. We were craving buccaneer for super bowl. Since his last issue, I decided I'd call in hopes I'd reach someone different. This time I was on hold for 19 minutes. They don't even answer the phone and say thank you for calling can you please wait. They pick up phone and immediately put you on hold. Very unprofessional. I waited 19minutes and not 1 time did someone come on the line. I hung up and called the santa Ana location, which has an answering machine that says thank you for calling someone will be with you momentarily. Which is professional. After waiting less than a minute Dana answered. I told her about the situation and she said although the might be busy because of super bowl which I'm understanding to but 19 minutes calling blindly, she agreed it was no excuse. She took my order and I'll be picking up in the next 30mins. Aside from buccaneer, this is terrible service and taking over the first class location, you'd think they'd want to keep up with service, needs and great customer service skills. Do better please because if someone had a simple question but making them wait without a hello, is a way to lose business and money. I guess we will stick to santa Ana location and continue driving 15miles for great service and pizza. read more

I think they have the best Pizza in California. The store is mostly takeout seating is limited.

Always love the pizzas from here! Never had a bad experience. The all white pizza add meatballs and basil. A1 pizza!