All I wanted for Mother's Day was pizza. Pizza will never let you down. And Buccaneer Pizza? Man, they know how to make a pizza! I ordered their cap'n atkins, or better known as "meat lovers" pizza. Their description alone stole my heart: "Meats ahoy! First tomato sauce, mozzarella, a layer of pepperoni, then a layer of ham, all sprinkled with pieces of bacon, and finally topped with Italian sausage and meatballs". YUM. They are so generous with their meat toppings! Pieces would fall off as we tore a slice, and it was glorious to stack them back on. I'm not kidding when I say this was the best meat lovers pizza I've ever tasted. The meat toppings, perfectly hand-tossed dough, and flavor on point. I swore I could eat 3, but was full after just two slices! Bucaneer Pizza, I am a fan. You have a "pizza" of my heart. Highly recommend to others, especially their cap'n atkins! read more

Buccaneer Pizza - CAP'N ATKINS - Pizza Near Me - Santa Ana, California

See all

've been a loyal customer at this pizza place for a long time, and their pizza is fantastic. Their sandwiches are even better. However, during my recent visit, I was disappointed to receive the smallest slice I've ever had from them. It felt like a rip-off at $4.10. I had called my order in for a sandwich half an hour beforehand, and when I arrived, they were barely making the sandwich. There was no one in the restaurant, and the people in line had just bought slices. I'm not sure what's going on at this location, but I hope they improve their service. It's a shame because this place used to be one of my go-to places for pizza slices. read more

Buccaneer Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Santa Ana, California

10/10 What was ordered: Caesar Salad, Fire in the Hole, Great White, Cap'n Atkins, O'Hai I'Wana, and Wild Boar.My favorite was definitely Fire in the Hole because of all the meat toppings. I could have done without the pepperoncinis though. Cost : 1/2 Pan Caesar Salad $43.99, 16' Fire in the Hole $34.49, 12' Great White $21.99, 16' Cap'n Atkins $34.49, 12' O'Hai I'Wana $25.99, and 16' Wild Boar $34.49. read more

Buccaneer Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Santa Ana, California

Never again would I or my family order Buccaneer Pizza. I gave them a chance for the Manager to reach out to me to make it right, left my name and number on both pizza buccaneer locations since they messed up my order. Not once did I get a call back and that just tells me they don't care about their customers. read more

I usually love Buccaneer Pizza. Today, was a mishap. As I bit into a slice, there was a long string which was either from hair or a hair net. *Gag* I called and the young lady said she'd give me a credit on my account. Tonight was disappointing as I had craved this pizza all day. read more

Buccaneer Pizza - String in pizza slice - Pizza Near Me - Santa Ana, California

See all

Service great ...villa park However wrong pizza ordered medium Marguerite w/pepperoni received pepperoni only no basil, fresh tomatoes or mozzarella I called and no apology at all ? They lost my number ? That is so wrong we all love Buccaneers but that can all change with a bad review and no apology or explanation JoAnn Turner Inaneichler@yahoo.com read more

Pizza Paradise- This is where it's at... if and only if you want the best pizza ever created!! Buccaneer Pizza is the blueprint for pizza!!! Ordered the large O'HAI' I WANA KIKKICHIKKI.. Try saying that ten times with a mouthful of pizza!!! This pizza is definitely spot on with seasoned chicken, tomato sauce, mozz, red onion, pineapple, and bacon. I didn't get the bacon. I also ordered three garlic knots!! Someone call 911- I am in a pizza coma- one bite isn't enough- how about three slices one after the other, and I am down for the count!! The garlic knots looked so good in the display- they are filled with mozzarella cheese, drizzled with garlic oil and served with a side of marinara sauce.. for those of us who dip once not twice the marinara sauce is perfect ---thanks DANA. STEPHANIA and SOPHIA---for your ALL STAR customer service!!!! read more

See all

This has been a spot I've been wanting to try for a while! We ordered the combo pizza and some cheese skulls. Listen, I'm such a picky pizza eater and since moving away from my fave spot in Long Beach, I'm finally able to say there's a spot near me in the OC I can rely on for a great pie. Im also a fan of finding food that is still tasty the next day - and this passed the test! You better believe I took some slices to work. Tip: the cheese skulls are pretty hefty so if you're getting pizza on top of that - 3 was too much for 2 of us! Lol but they're delicious! read more

Ordered the Buccaneer pizza and Buffalo wings. They were both tasty and worth the wait. Today was a busy day; and with the rain the delivery got a bit delayed but the people at the pizza place were great and followed up with checking on our order and delivery. Will definitely order again and try some other pizzas and wings. read more

The staff here are super friendly and helpful. The restaurant has a modern feel to it. But, let's face it, you come to a place like this for the pizza and you will not be disappointed. This place has my favorite pizza on the west coast. Their pizza is delicious from the sauce to the great dough they use for the crust. I can't recommend this place enough and am glad they aren't near me because I'd go all the time and my waist is already big enough. read more

Buccaneer Pizza - Pick your own with meatballs, sausage and spinach. - Pizza Near Me - Santa Ana, California

See all

Ordered a half pepperoni jalapeño and half sausage mushroom pie, along with chicken Alfredo pasta with garlic bread. I was pleasantly surprised! Very solid pizza and pasta! Ingredients taste pretty fresh and the dough is pretty soft and has a hint of sweetness, while the tomato sauce has a little kick. Each bite felt heavy (Not a bad thing) was full of cheese, toppings, sauce, and dough. Definitely better than any other corporate pizza chain (Pizza Hut, Dominos, etc.) read more

Buccaneer Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Santa Ana, California

If you want a greasy, toppings-heavy pizza, this is the spot. The garlic cheese skulls were heavy and addicting. The pizza toppings were fresh and generous. There is a bit of a wait, especially on a weekend, but that's probably because this place seems to be popular with the locals (there was a birthday party being hosted while other patrons were watching the game). read more

Buccaneer Pizza - GARLIC CHEESE SKULLS - Pizza Near Me - Santa Ana, California

See all

Pizza is pretty good and they sell by the slice. They have lunch specials, but they aren't posted anywhere, so I can't tell you what they are. I wanted a slice, a salad, and a drink, which was an option, but they don't have blue cheese dressing (only ranch, caesar, and Italian), so I opted for 2 slices and a drink. The coke mix is so sweet that it almost tastes like straight syrup without soda mixed in. Yuck! They only had cheese and pepperoni slices to choose from at 11:30 a.m. on a Friday, so I went with pepperoni. Less than 5 minutes after I got my two slices of pepperoni, a fresh pie came out of the oven just mushrooms as an option. I barely ever see a mushroom slice available anywhere and I absolutely would have preferred that over pepperoni. It would have been nice to have simply been told that was coming out of the oven shortly. read more

Food is usually great! The low rating is for the service! It's gone down lately and idk what's going on. This is second time that they haven't had a driver for delivery and didn't contact me. When I called about my pizza an hour after ordering I was told that they tried to call me and then they proceeded to read off the wrong number by one digit, telling me that's the info in their database. I went on my profile on their website and my phone number is correct. After settling on picking up my order, I called them back and told them I wanted delivery since their driver would be there soon. She told me it would be 20 min for delivery, mind you I live a mile away. It took another 50 min for my pizza to get delivered, COLD... so disappointed... this was my favorite pizza place read more

Second time trying Buccaneer Pizza. The first time was better. We got a large cheese pizza and it was delicious. Second time we ordered a cheese pizza and it was not good. It was burnt and over cooked. There was black on the crust. And under the pizza was black. I could even eat it. The crust and dough was burnt. Disappointed. My salad was fresh. It had a lot of fresh fruit on top. But the dressing didn't really complement the salad fixings. The salad was a miss for me. Overall, seems like hit or miss. We had a really good experience the first time we ordered from here. And second time was not good. Bad experience second time around. read more

See all

Soggy messy pizza, dont go here. Go to the villa park location and it's 10 times better

Food was fresh and delicious. First time here. It's a drive from home but definitely worth coming back! Staff was friendly and helpful. Many tv's to watch your sports! read more

See all

This was my first time going here and I loved it! We ordered our pizza to-go and ordering online was super simple and easy! I had been craving a pizza from my childhood and this was perfect to settle that craving. This is also the go to place if you want somewhere that won't be stingy with the toppings. Just the regular amount of cheese was like extra cheese from your average place, same with the size of the pizza!!! I will definitely be ordering from here again!! read more

I had a great experience at Buccaneer Pizza! Greg was amazing--he took the time to explain the menu and was so patient, making me feel comfortable without rushing me. I ordered one skull at first then came back for 3, they were that good! The pizza was absolutely delicious, some of the best I've had. However, the other employee wasn't as friendly. She seemed bothered while taking my friends' order and was rude for no reason. I believe her name was Steph (can't remember) I understand people have bad days but I don't understand why you are taking it out on a first time customer??? Despite that, Greg's excellent service made up for it. I'll definitely be back for the great food! read more

Buccaneer Pizza - yum yum yummmm - Pizza Near Me - Santa Ana, California

Very kid-friendly as our son loved all the skeleton pirates! There were probably 15 skeletons. Pizza was great. Caesar salad was really good. And prices were very reasonable read more

Buccaneer Pizza - Cheese pizza. Caesar salad - Pizza Near Me - Santa Ana, California

See all

Good food hot food with great service brought it to me on time no problems will be coming back again multiple times

Very disappointed with the 3 chicken pesto sandwiches purchased. There were 4.5 pieces of chicken on each half and very little pesto sauce. Each sandwich was about $15 with tax. I will think twice before returning and ordering this sandwich in the future. read more

Buccaneer Pizza - Pesto chicken sandwich. - Pizza Near Me - Santa Ana, California

Great tasting pizza. Never had a bad, under or over cook pizza. I have order pepperoni, Hawaiian, BBQ all those pies taste delicious, fresh ingredients. I have recommended to all my friends and family also great tap beer. read more

A literal 10/10 to the sauce actually tasting like tomatoes and the crust being so soft !! It was actual pizza! read more

Buccaneer Pizza - Literally THE BEST pizza, you can taste the tomatoes in the sauce and the crust PERFECTION literal 10/10. - Pizza Near Me - Santa Ana, California

Cheese blanket!!! If you love cheese this is the place for you. Their specialize in thicker crust pizzas but you can request a thinner crust pizza. I like them both. It's not a thin crust like a cracker just thinner than the thick crust they will make. Just depends on my mood really. When you eat the pizza fresh it's literally like something you see from TNMT or any other cartoon pizza. Gooey at the top but the toppings manage to stay on if you're fast enough to catch it. I didn't know about the cheese blanket until later but you can add it to your pizza for an additional cost and it will be covered in an additional layer of cheese, an actual blanket of cheese. read more

Buccaneer Pizza - Cheesy goodness - Pizza Near Me - Santa Ana, California

Every Saturday, my wife and I have "bad movie night". The usual meal is pizza and salad. Dominoes just does not cut it. Buccaneer Pizza is only a few minutes away. Here's some pros and cons: Pros: They make very good pizza. They don't skip in the ingredients. The crust is good. They have a wide variety of toppings. They have my favorite combo garlic and basil. If my car smells like garlic the next morning they did it right. My order is hot when I arrive and it has never been late. Cons: Okay, Villa Park is pretty upscale so I don't expect things to be as cheap as Orange. However, a personal salad, and a medium pizza with custom toppings, pickup ,for $40 (with tip) is hard to swallow. There was a pizza place on Chapman called Magic Mikes with similar pricing. They went out of business. They have a pretty limited selection of pasta dishes. Sometimes it would be nice to have cheese ravioli. No such luck At the time I pick up the pizza, parking is iffy. That's not their fault, obviously, but it something customers have to deal with. Will I continue to get my takeout pizza there? Sure. Will I continue to grouse about the price? You bet. Come on guys, for $40 you can throw in some garlic bread. read more

Pizza by the slice fresh out the oven. Few different slices to choose from. Will definitely be back to order a whole pizza.

Pizza was tasty the scull garlic bread was delicious. A bit pricey but worth it for the size of the pizza and the quality staff was nice and pleasant. read more

Pretty decent pizza! I was a little disappointed in their bbq chicken pizza but their pepperoni was really good! Staff was nice. Cool place!

Love the sauce. Awesome thick crust pizza. The chopped salad is a terrific way to get in veggies and it is customizable.

Buccaneer is a bit on the pricey side for pizza but you are paying up for good quality (and quantity of) ingredients and a consistently delicious pizza. Recently (April 2024) ordered a medium Hawaiian pizza (pineapple and Canadian bacon; $24) and I can't lie, every bite was good including the crust. Perfectly chewy bread that wasn't too doughy, nice layer of sauce that wasn't too sweet, healthy layer of cheese, with enough ham and pineapple to fully cover the entire pie - no skimping on toppings here (you get what you pay for!). A medium is 8 slices and great for 1 person to have leftovers, or split between two people with there are other snacks around and no leftovers. Buccaneer might be too expensive to order 5 pizzas to feed a group, but for an individual "splurge" pie or two, I think it's worth it. read more

Buccaneer Pizza - Medium Hawaiian pizza, $24 (april 2024). Pricey but quality and quantity (of toppings) was totally worth it - Pizza Near Me - Santa Ana, California

Great food! The only issue is that I came across as done-in was: 1. No ice 2. Paper plates were so thin Besides that I think I'll just order for delivery next time. read more

See all

Been here many time. Probably some of the best pizza around. Service was good and pizza came out pretty fast. It looks like the restaurant has been remodeled and has new tables, chairs, and several large tv's. read more

Just the best pizza in OC that you can find! Always delicious and made as requested. The staff is amazing and always friendly!

loved this place until my delivery order last week was not handled with care. contacted business via email with photos included and received zero response! read more

Amazing pizza and friendly service always, always a treat when I bring Buccaneer pizza to a party and everyone loves it. I love coming here for a slice of pizza and cold beer, however recently went through a prison themed gut job renovation so every time I ate pizza here it feels like I just did time. What's UP with that?? read more

Buccaneer Pizza - Cute pizza vibe gone, replaced with prison themed dining area - Pizza Near Me - Santa Ana, California

This pizza is definitely delicious. Coming from Marina to Anaheim is a mission but this pizza you can't get any kind anywhere else. Highly recommended hand on 10/10 read more

Online ordering is terrible! You get a confirmation email but no indication when the order will be ready for pick-up.......Hmmmmm, they must lose a lot of revenue because of this? Probably the employee benefit program! read more

Buccaneer Pizza is probably one of the best quality pizza shops in the area. I'm a big believer in "you get what you pay for"! You're gonna pay more for this pizza versus the 'buy one, get one free shops' but you're gonna get a great pizza with lots of quality toppings - and they are very generous with their toppings. It's totally worth the pice!! And there's just no comparison! We usually call-in our order then pick it up rather than having it delivered. You definitely get your pizza a lot quicker! And occasionally we'll order one of their salads to go along with our pizza. Their salads are great too! Our three main 'go-to' pizzas are the Italian Galleon, Cap'n Atkins, which is their meat lovers pizza, and the Buccaneer combo. You can't go wrong with any of these! Once you have this pizza, it'll be tough going back to the BOGO pizza! read more

Very good Super fresh super fast super freshhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhh read more