Great chicken parm. tonight, they forgot my side Caesar though. I gave five stars on my first review.

Being Italian and from NYC, I was skeptical about this place, but the pizza reminded me of home. I also ordered an eggplant stromboli and an order of lasagna, both were extremely good. I am so glad someone told me about this place, I look forward to trying more menu items my next visit. I met the owner, Vito, who was extremely personable as well as his staff. read more

Went to pick up two large cheese pizzas. When I got there they said it had another 4 min. No problem, I paid and waited. While I was waiting I saw another customer go up to the register saying she was still waiting on her order that was supposed to be done 30 minutes ago. Well 30 minutes went by for me as well. I went to the counter and asked how much longer, I was quoted 4 minutes and 30 minutes has gone by. The young man started looking around like he didn't remember who I was or what I ordered. I did see two pizzas sitting on the oven in boxes. He finally checked them, and they were mine. When I got them home they had cooled down so much that the cheese wasn't hot or melted anymore, it ripped apart. One of the pizzas, half of-the bottom was burnt so we couldn't eat it. The other pizza tasted great, but it looked like it was cut by a 3 year old. It had 7 slices? Don't know how they did that, but it wasn't even cut in half. More like three quarters, one side being 3 giant slices and the other side being 4 tiny skinny slices. One of the tiny slices obviously came apart from the pizza somehow, like it fell off while boxing it up or something and they tried to put it back in place but it wasn't attached to the rest of the pizza. So disappointing. It's the little things guys... read more

I discovered Brooklyn V's about a month ago and now eat there at least once per week. The pizza is fantastic! Being from Boston, it was an absolute blessing to discover pizza in Gilbert that actually tastes like the pizza back home (yes, Boston and NY pizza are very similar). The only other place I've found in AZ like this is Vincent's Pizza in Ahwatukee. Now I would like to address Andy L's comments since my guess is that he had an ulterior motive for writing his review. So, let me address his comments directly: "I was not told a price on the phone, I figured it would be in the 10 dollar range. Lesson learned, never assume anything! When i got there, I paid over 15$, which, I'm sorry is EXCESSIVE! They need to sprinkle gold or something on there to make it worth the money at that price." I suppose Andy may have just had a phone number and not a menu but why would he not ask for a price when ordering food? More importantly, what decade did he write this review in? $10 for a pizza? Andy, please let me know where I can get a good pizza for $10. I'd love to try it. He states that "over 15$...is EXCESSIVE". Well, a couple of red flags here: No literate American that I know of writes '15$' instead of '$15'. This is a foreign way of denoting money and leads me to believe he is not even American. Does that matter? Well, it does if he's basing his statements on prices of the pizza where he is from. Maybe he pays $5 for pizza in his homeland and, thus, $15 seems "EXCESSIVE". "I don't have extremely high standards when it comes to pizza-I love dominos, pizza hut, you name it-but the sauce was bland and had no taste to it. I lived in Boston for many years and have visited NYC many times; believe me when I tell you, this place has nothing, and I mean NOTHING in common with NY pizza." So, Andy admits to having low standards in pizza, yet claims that Brooklyn V's sauce is bland? Please forgive me while I pause to laugh. I guess if you love Dominos and Pizza Hut, it makes sense that you might not like Brooklyn V's. Perhaps those two places are what Andy thinks NY or Boston pizza should taste like. I can assure you that you won't come across many Bostonians or NYers pizza that will claim to love either Dominos or Pizza Hut. BTW, I'd also like for Andy to show me what pizza he ordered at Dominos for under $15. If he doesn't think Brooklyn V's pizza tastes like Boston and NY pizza, then I challenge his claim to have lived in Boston for many years and having visited NY many times. Well, maybe he did both of those things but forgot to actually try the pizza. I'd be curious to know some pizza places in Boston and NY that he considers good pizza. Because, quite simply, this *is* NY (or Boston) pizza. Perhaps he considers Brooklyn V's pizza bland - that's a subjective matter - but that would mean he considers typical NY and Boston pizza bland as well. I am extremely picky about pizza and do not find anything bland about this pizza. The sauce is delicious and the pizza has just the right amount of cheese for me (not too much, not too little). To claim the pizza has "NOTHING in common with NY pizza" is simply laughable. This is not a subjective matter. He may not like Brooklyn V's pizza but making a claim that has nothing in common with NY crosses the boundary from objectivity into outright falsehood. I am personally looking forward to bringing visiting friends and family to Brooklyn V's to get their opinions. Thanks for bringing great pizza to Gilbert, Brooklyn V's! read more

The garlic knots are to die for and the eggplant pizza is freaking amazing. The owners Bob and Vito go out of their way to make you feel welcome and these guys do a ton of fundraisers to give back to their local community. read more

The first time we went to the restaurant many months ago, we sat at the bar that overlooks the kitchen. The service was great and we were made to feel very welcome. We unfortunately watched an order for take out fall on the floor. Imagine how mortified I was when they packed it up and gave it to the customer who did not see what happened. We made sure that didn't happen to our order. We decided to try them again over the weekend. We walked in and there were 3 tables occupied. We were not treated with kindness. The waiter came over got our drink order and asked if we wanted a appetizer. We ordered some Zuchini sticks which came in a timely manner. The waiter never came back to take our order. After waiting for 40 minutes, he finally showed up. We expressed our unhappiness with the delay and were told that he was tied up with online orders and had to deal with a mix up in the kitchen. We decided to leave since we obvisiously we were not a priority. The table next to us had their own waitress for 6 people. Maybe because the kids had Brooklyn V t-shirts on. The waiter never got a manager. He showed no emotion how about how we were treated. He offered to comp our bill which we refused and paid it. I guess if you order online or are regulars/family you will get some service but beware that your order online may have hit the floor or worse prior to you picking it up. read more

Best pizza I've had in a long time. We had the margarita and meat lovers. Both were great. We'll be back!!!!

Omg, just ate at Brooklyn v's, very friendly, fast service. Had chicken rollatini, absolutely delicious. So good I took one home. Tried a slice of pizza, so glad I did, wonderful. The crust was perfect, sauce was great. I know we will be driving back tomorrow to try more from menu. And try the cheesecake, it's to die for. read more

Exceptional pizza- I especially enjoyed the margherita pizza. I added garlic to it, which ended up being a good choice. The garlic knots are great, and the desserts are homemade and really, really good. Had the cannoli and the tiramisu. Also, incredibly good, friendly service. :-) read more

I've eaten their food three times. Two times I've eaten there and once had a pizza delivered. What was funny is the guy taking my pizza order told me the price and stopped talking. I was waiting for him to ask me my cc info. I think he thought I was balking at the price because he told me, "You realize our pizzas are not the $5 kind?" I laughed and said I don't eat $5 pizzas! He got a kick out of that and the pie was delivered warm and tasty! I was a bachelor that weekend and the large lasted me both Saturday and Sunday. Nothing like pizza for breakfast baby! Both times I visited there the food was really good. The first time I had the chicken Marsala and loved it. The second time I had the lasagne with meat sauce and my wife had the chicken cacciatore. She ate everything on her plate and loved it. I got full on half of the lasagne and had the other half for lunch the next day. Both times the lasagne was delicious. We live close by so we'll be going back again for sure. My wife and I aren't really into hearing cover music when we eat, we like to talk. The only thing I haven't appreciated about the place was the Elvis impersonator singing when we went on a Saturday night. Good singer but everything he sang was in the Elvis style...George Straight in an Elvis style...not for me thank you. Of course I did tip the gentleman because he has talent. We are looking forward to the weather cooling so we can sit either inside or out, where ever the singer is not. read more

My wife and I have been here several times. We've not tried anything but the pizza yet, so that is what this review covers. We get an 18 inch , which is huge, and we have it the next day too! We love getting a 'half and half' pizza , with half being the pesto chicken , and the other being Vito's three meat pizza (or something like that). Pretty different tastes, but we like to have the variety. We've had consistently good quality, both in the food and service. One time, we ordered homemade cheesecake... so good! They say that they made it fresh there (by Vito himself). Definitely worth the try. It has typically been busy (a good sign), although we've always been able to get a table. Glad we found this place - it's a great place to have in your restaurant 'rotation'. read more

This was our first visit to BVP and unfortunately I have to say it was probably the worst meal my wife and I have ever had. I've heard the pizza is pretty good but wanted spaghetti and meatballs and my wife wanted penne with chicken and pesto. The spaghetti sauce was really sweet and it was so loaded with garlic my mouth burned. The meatballs were mushy and almost tasteless. I ate about half of it and just could not finish it. The salad was old lettuce with a few cherry tomatoes and sliced olives. It was edible but I would not call it good. My wife's dinner was also pretty tasteless and you could hardly tell there was any pesto in it at all. On top of horrible food, they were short three staff and a person quit and walked out right in front of us. I felt sorry for the poor waitresses. I tipped her well for her efforts. They were doing their best but so short staffed, it was nearly impossible to provide any sort of service. It was too bad this was our first time as you know what they say about first impressions. I'll never go back. read more

Service is great! We walked in got seated right away and ordered drinks. Very personal pizza hall. Pizza is delish..they have kick ass crust and I believe a homemade sausage that was mild and tastes yummy. Usually never order sausage and we've had it 3 times. Service was great, checked on us, filled drinks promply. Very enjoyable dinner on a tired Friday night.Ty read more

You know, I like their food, but they always get our order wrong. It's been SEVERAL times. No apologies when you call and tell them. With all the new business in Gilbert we tried to give them another chance, but perhaps Pomo and Oregano's will be our go-to places. read more

May give it another shot for lunch, but will not be getting delivery again. Ordered through Grubhub, and it took almost 2 hours to arrive. Pizza was cold and tasted like Grocery store pizza. Meatballs were good. Wings were meh. read more

Wanted to try a new place for lunch and found a gem. Not only did I have a great experience, but the food was amazing too. Bob and Desiree are the sweetest people and helped me custom my lunch order. A very pleasant and clean environment. I'll definitely be coming back. read more

I was at the place from day one. Excellent service, great Chicken Marsala. Vito and family have arrived! Love the new closed in room, the old patio. GO Vito go! read more

I'm so glad we found you! This is the best pizza we've had since arriving in az around a year ago. The crust is second to none, everything about this pizza is wonderful. I wish there was a smaller size, because I like a margherita pizza and my husband prefers pepperoni and will die of a tantrum if a vegetable is touching his pizza. It's a little pricey, but the product is so great I couldn't deduct a star for the downfalls. I hope you guys start doing more specials, keep up the great work. read more

Pizza not the same quality as before! We found Brooklyn V 's about 3 years ago and the pizza was delicious, (Warner/Lindsay) location, so we have only bought their pizza and recommended to our friends. About 2 months ago our Pizza was very dry, had little sauce and lacked flavour. We always had delicious pizza in past so thought it was a one time issue. But, today we ordered our usual half and half, 3 V 's meat and Bianco. So disappointed!! the pizza is so dry, crust burnt which made even drier, very little sauce again and lack of flavour. I made a call to them just now, 4:45pm, to inform them of our dissatisfaction and disappointment and asked if they changed the recipe or have a new cook. The person I spoke with said "no we haven't changed it and I'm sorry you didn't like the pizza". Didn't ask my name, in fact I told her (in case she cared). Sad to say goodbye Brooklyn V 's. Nancy L, pick up name was Rick. read more

Very, very good! Great surprise find! Loved the food and don't forget the cheesecake it was yum!!

Went for the first time about three weeks ago, ate inside. Service was good even though it was busy, and the pizza was amazing. The crust is delicious, cooked well but not burned( I hate burned crust). Went back and go take out last night, and it was as good as I remembered. This may be my new go to got pizza!!! read more

Ate at Brooklyn Vs last night. We were a group of about 25 people. No fuss, no hassle. Anna and the crew got us all setup with a private room and helped us with selections from their catering menu. The food was great. We did about 6 pizzas, a half tray of meatballs and three half tray pastas and two half tray salads. Everything was excellent and the meatballs in particular were a standout with our group. Was just the right amount of food and what we had leftover, they generously packaged for us to take back to our hotel. We could've maybe done one less pasta, but everyone enjoyed the added variety as did I. And while everything we had was delicious, it was the service that really stood out. Anna personally took care of our group with some help from a few of the other girls on the wait staff and they did a fantastic job keeping the drinks, beer and wine flowing. Everyone in my group was complementary of the service. A lot of places make large group arrangements a hassle. Not here. It was painless start to finish and culminated in a great evening for our large family gathering. Would recommend to anyone looking for a simple, yet satisfying solution for a large group gathering that can fit any budget. read more

Great little place. Went to see a friend perform live music there, and they accommodated all of us - three adults and three babies. I had the sausage and onion Stromboli, and hubby and his mom got the margherita pizza. My Stromboli was enormous, easily two meals-worth, and delicious! Hubby and MIL really enjoyed their pizza as well. We'll definitely be back! read more

We love Brooklyn V's and are so happy they opened a Queen Creek location! They have the best pizza and service!

They were a 5 star place until they started to expand. The quality control at the Werner - Lindsay location has gone downhill. Rapid expansion + not enough good personnel to support it and lack of management attention = disaster! read more

First time ordering. We had a pizza (half V's 3 meat/half bianco) wings and garlic knots and everything was really good. We will order again for sure! read more

This is a local mom & pop that you could easily mistake for a chain restaurant once you go inside. For now, its the one and only.:) It strikes an expertly crafted balance between the look of a fine dining establishment and a lounge, all while providing the comfort and ease of a fast casual restaurant. There are nice marble counters at the bar, where you can relax and order a beer or a glass of wine, and an outdoor patio with comfortable seating you could easily spend hours in. What's more, is that there is often live music on Saturdays, which is another plus, and their events makes it a great place for families, couples, and friends hanging out. In my opinion, you get more than what you pay for. They use authentic Sicilian recipes and make a mind blowing Antipasto salad. This is because of how particular they are here about the quality of their ingredients. Everyone that I have taken here has really enjoyed their food. I'm pretty sure you will too. read more

See all

We just tried their sausage, meatball and pepperoni Stromboli and it is by far our new favorite!!! It's a must try :) We also got an order of canolis, not a fan - we ended up throwing away. read more

Awesome little place. Awesome pizza and wings. Service was great. We'll be back often.

Well we are back. Had their special 18" pizza and 12 wings for $19.99 and they made a mistake on our order since we wanted 1/2 cheese and 1/2 sausage and mushrooms and it was all sausage and mushrooms. So the waitress said they are making another 14" cheese for free and she brought another 18"!!!! For free! Ay ay ay!!! I also had a free dessert for my birthday and asked if I could use it now or next time. She said of course now! They didn't have their Oreo cookie cheesecake so I ordered the cannoli. So super nice and great tasting food. Will have to try their pasta dishes soon! read more

Great food, staff and atmosphere! We had our local lunch club here and it was great! I would recommend everyone to try the ziti as well as the pizza! read more

This place is delicious! My favs are the pepperoni pizza, garlic knots and spaghetti with meat sauce! If You haven't tried Brooklyn V's, you're missing out! read more

You search for a real New York pizza, especially if you come from Brooklyn. This place comes thisclose. Vito has the "touch". The pizza is delicious. Their marinara is wonderful and the garlic knots are like Brooklyn's best. It was also amazing that there were a lot of N.Y. ex-pats the evening we were there. read more

Ordered an eggplant parm hero and side order of meatballs. Both were solid. Meatballs could have been a bit bigger but other then that they were tasty. Being it was my first visit there and I wanted to add on a slice to my order ,Desireé set me up with a free slice of pizza while I waited for my take out order. I can say it definitely holds up to Long Island pizza. I will be back for sure. read more

This place is AMAZING!! I'm a total snob when it comes to Italian food as my family is from Sicily. Ivan already tell I'm going to become a regular at this place. We had the garlic knots, stuffed shells, and Calzone with sausage and pepperoni...everything was amazing!!! To top it off the owners brought us out some Cannoli's for dessert which were so good! Can't wait to come back and try the eggplant roltinni :) read more

Went for dinner on a Saturday with my husband and son. We had the garlic knots and a special appetizer, baked caprese salad. The baked caprese salad was incredible! The balsamic vinegar was delicious, the mozzarella was chewy and the bread was crispy. Perfect combination. I had the penne pasta with chicken, broccoli, black olives, garlic and olive oil. Hubby had spaghetti and meatballs with a side of sausage. Son had V's Three Meat pizza. Everything was outstanding and we had enough leftovers for us all to eat twice more. :) We even got to enjoy live music while having dinner. We'll definitely be back again! Just remember, the rest of Gilbert loves this place, too, so it can get pretty busy. read more

I love everything about this place and am almost here everyday. I recommend everyone to come blow your tastebuds away.

I was craving spaghetti with meat sauce and just so happened to be at the intersection near this place. I usually prefer specialty Italian dishes but I ordered what I was craving and oh my gosh!!!!! I know spaghetti with meat sauce isn't a difficult dish but it was probably the best I've ever had! I have been around some really great Italian food and this place really impressed me. So glad that I found them and they aren't far from me!! read more

Cute little restaurant tucked away, I had no idea it even existed until I read reviews on tripadvisor. It is a nice lil corner restaurant with indirect lighting and tv's turned to the sports section. We had the bruschetta as an appetizer, it was tasty, a lil different since it had chopped onions on it but it sure was messy. The balsamic got on my shirt and I put the extra seasoned tomatoes in with my pasta. Seems like a nice place for many different customers to enjoy. I think they could use more walking room since the traffic patterns make you feel cramped. The food was delicious and the waiter was friendly, she did take a lil while to refill our drinks but for the most part a good experience. read more

Just moved in the area and this is top of our pizza list. Amazing pizza, the (I assume) owner, walked around greeting everyone. Nice wait staff, fast service, good prices and really good food. I got pizza and wings and they were both amazing. Perfect New York style pizza. read more