Brooklyn Pickle

The sandwiches are so full of flavor and well stacked. The bread is light and the Italian peppers…read moreare top notch. Definitely worth a return visit.

Unassuming location, but the capacity quickly became overwhelmed at lunch, because clearly many…read morefolks know how good these sandwiches are. Yes, the bread is quite peculiar but it's delicious, and the stuff between the "slices" is equally good as well as plentiful. I went with the Real Italian and found it full of flavor. Now I'll need to make a few return trips and try some of the other selections.

Willy

See all

The Honey Baked Ham Company

5.0(9 reviews)

1.2 mi

Delicious chicken salad sandwich! The lunch combos are great and the prices are reasonableread more

Wife just now discovering Honey Baked Ham. Was blown away by everything. According to her this is…read morethe best turkey she's ever had. She was upset that I've allowed her to drive by all these years and never told her. Soft bun. Delicious honey mustard that really ties everything together. Potato salad made with fresh herbs. When I was younger Grandma would order us a ham for the holidays. Fond memories of eating ham for a week straight. So tasty it never got old.

See all

Chicken Salad Chick

4.5(4 reviews)

0.5 mi

The food is fresh always. I enjoy the chicken salad and fruit bowls. The drinks are average.read more

Great choices Excellent service…read more All the salads are very good. The spicy salads could use just a bit more heat but for a person with just a notch more heat they are perfect. Very good place to get everyday chicken salad

See all

Roast

4.6(81 reviews)

3.7 mi

Amazing food and service!! Loved the unique menu. Will definitely be back the next time we are in…read moretown.

RUDE! Don't waste…read moreyour money on mediocre food. Quality is inconsistent but the rude customer service is consistent!

Inside

Fusion Mexican Ramen Bowl!! (Seasonal Special 9/11/2024)

See all

Fries are better than tots to me.

The Workshop Tavern

4.7(94 reviews)

3.0 mi

Workshop Tavern has quickly become one of those places I can't stop recommending. It's rare to find…read morea spot where the food, service, and atmosphere all hit the mark every single time, but they've managed to pull it off. The dishes are packed with flavor, clearly made with quality local ingredients, and the prices are surprisingly reasonable for the level of creativity coming out of the kitchen. The staff is consistently warm and attentive, making you feel like you've been coming there for years. They do take reservations, which is great for bigger groups (anything over six), and even when there's a wait, it moves fast. Never long enough to be a hassle. One of the things I love most is their daily special. The rotating menu keeps things interesting, and you can tell the chefs put real thought into crafting something unique each day! If you're searching for a place that blends comfort with standout, big‑city flavors and quality food, Workshop Tavern is the spot! Truly the best restaurant in the area!

We are so glad we found this restaurant as we were looking for a late dinner and their kitchen is…read moreopen until 9 PM Thursday evening. Staff greeted us right away and was very attentive and friendly. I ordered the chicken salad pita and had to take most of it home as it was very filling and full of flavor. It had a creamy texture and the chicken was tender. The raspberry ginger lime mocktail was packed with flavor. they offer a large variety of beer, wine, and liquor. Very clean restaurant.

Italian sandwich

See all

Best Espresso Martini in Moore County!

Jersey Mike's Subs

3.5(25 reviews)

1.4 mi

Jersey Mikes has always been good. You know exactly what you're going to get every time. I really…read morelike their sandwiches.

The staff is super friendly and helpful, the service is quick, and the food is high quality! I…read morenormally don't like dealing with the staff because they tend to be rude or unpleasant, but I was surprised by their cheerful and conversational attitude. I also really like the Pepsi products lol

See all

Rudino's Pizza & Grinders

3.7(99 reviews)

1.1 mi

Food was great. We had a burger and the Sicilian grinder ( half size) and a Mexican Mule. The only…read morething I would change would be instead of a bag of chips I would like homemade chips. My husband did get the upgraded side with the fries The server was very attentive. It did seem to take a little while for the food to come out but it wasn't bad and it seemed like food came out for multiple tables at the same time. I will definitely go back I want to try the pizza next time

Still the worst place to eat pizza in Southern Pines and surrounding areas. Don't waste your time…read more Manager and owner refuses to call me back to discuss service.

Great atmosphere and about to try this food

Manager and owners refuse to return my phone calls and end emails

See all

Outside restaurant

The Villager Deli

3.7(79 reviews)

3.1 mi

We stopped by for Sunday brunch and appreciated the ample seating and relaxed atmosphere. While the…read morebrunch menu was limited, there were still plenty of solid options. We tried the French toast and the eggs plate -- both dishes were fresh and thoughtfully prepared, reminiscent of classic diner fare with a touch more care. The main drawback is the pricing. You'll pay Pinehurst-level prices for what is essentially elevated diner food. A half-glass mimosa runs $9.50 (albeit with quality champagne), and two scrambled eggs with toast and potatoes is $14. The food is good, but be prepared to pay a premium for the experience

Outstanding food and oh so fun professionals (Alisha was fantastic). On a cold, sleeting day, The…read moreVillager gave us a warm welcome and filled our bellies with tasty food. Each time we're in Pinehurst, we eat at least one meal at The villager and we are always happy.

The Villager Deli - French Dip sandwich. I upgraded to fries instead of potato chips. Au jus dip is in the small white cup at lower right corner of photo. Yum!

French Dip sandwich. I upgraded to fries instead of potato chips. Au jus dip is in the small white cup at lower right corner of photo. Yum!

See all

Quiche of the day- Bacon cheddar tomato and side salad with bleu cheese and balsamic

Firehouse Subs

1.8(21 reviews)

1.4 mi

Lady here is super rude , food is expired everywhere bread hard I will never visit here againread more

At our recent visit to the Firehouse Sub restaurant in Aberdeen, NC, the manager worked on a…read morenon-functioning drink machine, wearing her food service gloves, then returned to the food line to make our sandwich without changing the dirty gloves. The brisket sandwich we received was mostly grissle and fat, so we asked if we could have a different sandwich and they refused to make another sandwich or refund our money. They just lost our business. The restaurant was not very clean, just a negative experience all round. Too bad.

See all

Pine Scone Cafe - Southern Pines

4.5(58 reviews)

0.2 mi

This place has the best vibe. Who doesn't like a good scone?? We're traveling in the area and…read moreneeded a little something. The staff here is amazing. The scone selection is great. So many drink, syrup and "sconewich" options. Be sure to check it out. I had the hot chocolate and a green goblin scone.

Today was my first time coming to the Pine Scone Cafe. Café was clean. Staff was friendly and…read moreaccommodating. Staff was knowledgeable about the menu, and very patient because I know we took longer than we should have to make decisions. Restaurant offers what appeared to be scone dough for purchase, as well as other numerous items, such as local honey, and some apparel. I got the rise and pine, a traditional scone with jam and butter, and a vanilla latte. I asked about the jams they offered. Unfortunately, the one I ordered was not available so I got strawberry jam. I gotta say I was a little bit letdown because I assumed this was freshly made jam and not prepackaged store-bought. Either way it tasted fine. The downside to cold store-bought jam is it was impossible to spread on the scone. The scone was so brital that it literally fell apart in my hand. It almost had the consistency of a day old homemade biscuit. There was no salvaging this scone to eat properly I had to eat it in pieces. That aside it did have good flavor. I wonder what would it have tasted like if I could've actually put the jam and butter on it. Latte was good as well as the rise and pine breakfast scone. Seating was a bit different. Meaning that you felt like you were right on top of one another. Not very roomie. The most comfortable seat I must say is the one near the restroom which is a leather loveseat and a chair. I paid $23.73, which included a tip. In my opinion for what I got, this was too much, especially since the scone fell apart in my hand.

Store on swing

See all

Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

Hundreds of millions of reviews are posted on Yelp, and our automated recommendation software works in the background to showcase the reviews that it …

3 reviews that are not currently recommended

The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.

Patricia K.

2 years ago

A young man named Aidan was so helpful and had such a pleasant personality. I decided on the Reuben and it brought back memories of growing up in NYC. Highly recommend! read more

Michelle B.

1 year ago

I am originally from the Syracuse, NY area. I was thrilled to hear they were coming to Southern Pines! The sandwiches are amazing!

Richard S.

2 years ago

Just as good as home back in Syracuse New York good to have something in North Carolina wish they had one closer like Greensboro.

Brooklyn Pickle - sandwiches - Updated October 2026

People who viewed Brooklyn Pickle also viewed

Wedgies

4.6

(121 reviews)

The sandwiches are so full of flavor and well stacked. The bread is light and the Italian peppers…read moreare top notch. Definitely worth a return visit.

Baldinos Giant Jersey Subs

3.6

(32 reviews)

Sandwiches were fresh and delicious! Such a great spot! We ordered a veggie/cheese sandwich and…read morenumber 9. I don't even like sandwiches but my husband was craving one and what an unexpected delight! We will be back again! Definitely recommend.

Being from NJ, the land where we take subs (or hoagies, depending on who you ask) very seriously, I…read morehad to see if this spot could really hang in the cheesesteak department. So I went straight for The Cheesesteak Baldino's way, which basically means "load it up with everything": mushrooms, onions, peppers, cheese, oil, vinegar, lettuce, tomatoes. I customized mine with mayo and ketchup, and held the oil, vinegar, lettuce, and tomatoes because... boundaries. The roll? Softer than what I'm used to back home, but surprisingly solid. It held the entire situation together without splitting at the seam (impressive considering it was stuffed). But the real star: the meat. TOP. NOTCH. Sirloin. Tender, flavorful, and honestly better quality than a lot of places that swear they're the real deal. Online ordering at their website was a breeze. Plenty of customization options and smooth site to store experience. I'm quite pleased with my order and would happily swing back to try a few more menu options. Jersey girl approved!

Quick Bites

4.4

(67 reviews)

Stopped here while in the area as I wanted some soup. I was hoping for homemade but the soup fell…read moreshort. It was too close to canned soup for me. I ate it because I was hungry but wasn't satisfied. This was my second trip here and the sandwich I ordered last time was good. Also, I don't care to eat soup with a plastic spoon out of the semi-plastic bowl. I like a real utensil.

Quick Bites is a great sandwich shop. The menu here offers a variety of options including…read moresandwiches, soups, and salads. I ordered the Buffalo chicken wrap during my first visit to Quick Bites. The wrap came with house chips, a pickle and ranch dressing. Everything was tasty + the customer service was great.

Pete's Family Restaurant

3.9

(67 reviews)

I was traveling through the area and wanted some soul food and found Pete's and old fashion diner…read morewhere they know every one by name. Well that's the good part of this review. I ordered chicken livers with grilled onions and gravy and I got raw onions thrown on as an after thought. They did offer to remake them but I had already been waiting a while so I asked for gravy on the side which had onions it...go figure. Well they didn't have much flavor and neither did the cabbage. The fried green beans were just ok as well. I like the hush puppies and the cake the most. My meal was $20 and I tossed all but the cake and hush puppies.

This place is really good! Southern cooking at its finest! And is super clean. I got the rib…read morespecial which was so tender it falls off the bone! The only thing I didn't really like was the mac and cheese.

Bob Pizza & Grill

3.0

(13 reviews)

I've heard there's new management or owners - all I know is today's pizza was absolutely delicious!…read more The dough was delicious, the sauce is delicious, the toppings were delicious. They now deliver up to 7 miles away - score!!!!

I ordered a cheesesteak and cheese fries and it was the worst cheesesteak & cheese fries I ever ate…read morein my life! I asked for American cheese & provolone cheese on my cheesesteak and was told they don't have American cheese in their restaurant. I was in shock because, aren't we in America?! Not only do they make pizza but they make sandwiches. They told me that all they have in their shop is mozzarella & provolone, I was appalled! The cheesesteak was very oily and had no flavor (what so ever!) the fries were dry a hardly had any cheese on them. I could see if they were busy but I was the only one in the place (now I know why!) The food here is horrible and I will never order from here again. They were nice but UGH! The food is terrible!

Firehouse Subs

3.6

(27 reviews)

Firehouse Subs is one of my favorite sandwich chains, but as much as I love their sandwiches, I'd…read morerather take the time to talk about an employee at the Sanford location. Her name is Allison and she's awesome. The hubs and I frequent this location approximately once a month. The past couple of times we've been in, Allison has been behind the counter. She's a diligent worker with an amazing personality. I've never seen Allison without a smile on her face. She's always kind and her attitude is always positive. As the hubs and I ate lunch there yesterday, I noted how she treated everyone with respect. She knows her usuals by names, but it doesn't matter if she knows you or not, she treats you like a friend. In this day and age, excellent customer service is becoming a rare commodity, but not with Allison. She is an amazing example of what quality customer service looks like, and I am grateful. She's an asset to your business, and one that will keep us coming back.

My most recent visit to Firehouse was extremely disappointing. Usually, it's great and a go-to…read morechoice for me and my family. This time, my Turkey Bacon Ranch ™ sub came with two long purple dyed strands of hair. I reached out via their website to report the issue and instead of an apology or compensation, I got a coupon for a drink. The staff REALLY should be wearing hair nets when preparing food.

Mac's Breakfast Anytime

3.9

(115 reviews)

Absolutely phenomenal small-town diner. Highly recommend. Service is great, and they do all the…read moreclassic breakfasts really well. Greasy spoon at its best.

Old style breakfast place for sure. Plenty of free parking. Attentive staff…read more Omelette was very good, surprisingly so.

Valenti's Italian Restaurant Vass

3.8

(134 reviews)

We really enjoy this restaurant. Staff is very good, and food is best in the area. Plenty of…read moreparking. We often phone in our order and it's always ready on time. You must try the tiramisu. We enjoy the vegetable pizza. Thin crust and crunchy.

I don't know what happened. This is so unusual for this restaurant. I normally love getting the…read moreJumbo shrimp rustics penne. Did you fire the Chef? The whole meal was extremely dry. The garlic bread seem old and the shrimp were little mini that were overcooked and dry. were the cost of the meal I feel like I was ripped off. I hope this was an unusual circumstance and not the new norm.

Jersey Mike's Subs

3.3

(29 reviews)

This was my first time ordering food from here. When I received the subs one cold and the other…read morehot, I was excited! The Big Kahuna cheese steak was so good that I wanted another order, the steak was tender and seasoned to perfection, all of the condiments were fresh, the bread was soft and not mushy, this was a 6 inch, the other, the other the Original Italian, was just as tasty, not choosing one over the other! The meats were fresh as well as the condiments, the vinegar and oil was the finishing touch. I am not usually satisfied overall, this time I have enjoyed it all!

Ordered online.... Only received half of our order in the bag and was told to "have a good day!"…read more Found out after we got home that we were missing a whole sandwich. We then decided to go back to the store, where the employees rudely welcomed us back and finally decided to make the "missing" sandwich after making us wait another 10-15 minutes. Now my drink was warm and my #26 sandwich was getting cold. Had to warm up my food when we got back home for the 2nd time and the chips were stale!! NOT GOING BACK TO THE BOONE TRAIL JERSEY MIKES

Brixx Wood Fired Pizza + Craft Bar

3.4

(147 reviews)