Lunchtime is busy here, but as you stand on a pretty long line you realize it's going quickly because they are doing a great job. They had about 5-6 choices of soup. My friend had the NE Clam Chowder, and she said it was very good. Our sandwiches had a good amount of meat and the bread was very fresh. I had Bazooka Pete....Corned beef, Pastrami and Turkey with lettuce, tomato, onion and Swiss. It was a real nice mix. The employees were very friendly and the dining room was very clean. read more

Brooklyn Pickle - Sandwiches Near Me - Liverpool, New York

See all

Anyone who loves a good deli sandwich and lives in the Syracuse area knows the Brooklyn Pickle. They have to best sandwich in town! My wife and I split one I could never eat a whole one by myself they are huge and delicious. Just had to say a few words about my favorite spot. read more

Brooklyn Pickle - Sandwiches Near Me - Liverpool, New York

See all

Was really easy to place an order online and go over to pick it up. Everything was ready and exactly as ordered. The food was good no complaints on that. Decent sized portions and pricing. read more

See all

Amazing sandwiches to be had here. Everything is made to order and the line moves very efficiently. The sandwiches are big so I recommend getting a half sandwich if you're not a big eater. I love how all the meat is fresh cut and you can really taste the quality. I went with my go-to roast beef with tomato, mayo and lettuce. It was great and I'll be back! read more

Another great Yelp find. I was in the area, searched for sandwiches, and this was the closest place. And let me tell you...what a find. Fresh, huge, delicious sandwiches. They have sweets, pasta, and salads too. The bread was soft. But above all...bring an appetite as the sandwiches are loaded and big; about the size of two sandwiches. I can say this place probably gets busy in the spring/summer during lunchtime, but they seem to have a good system to move it along. Bottom line: if you are hungry and want a sandwich or sub...this is the place!!!! read more

See all

Good sandwiches! Great service! Everything was clean and looking good. Good energy with the staff. Thank you! read more

Brooklyn Pickle - Logo - Sandwiches Near Me - Liverpool, New York

I hope someone from customer service reads this review. Yelpers if you don't read any other reviews read this one. First time here and a big disappointment. Where do I begin? Placed an order a veggie sub sandwich. I wanted it on a sub roll. They don't bake their bread fresh, yes it's frozen and the bread hasn't defrosted as of 11:30 am. Next the veggie sandwich is to have zucchini and they are out. Out of zucchini as a main element of the vegetable sandwich? How does that happen? So I asked the question to the guy ringing up the orders. His reply: their fresh produce arrives Monday and when they run out they are out for the week. I repeated back to him what he said and he said yes that's how it works. So if you come in on Saturday and they are out of items to make the sandwiches then they are out. Just horrid. My first and last trip to this deli. I can't recommend it to anyone. It's really sad because based upon the reviews I was excited And went out of my way to get subs from them. read more

Brooklyn Pickle - Outside of building - Sandwiches Near Me - Liverpool, New York

Visiting a couple of old friends up here in Syracuse, they offered we get lunch at this local favorite. We did take out and when we arrived, the parking lot was jam packed. That's always a good sign. i had corned beef on rye and my friends had turkey on light rye. I grew up on local (NYC) Jewish delis so my corned beef was too thinly sliced - I like thick slabs. The bread wasn't rye... It really seemed line whole wheat. Maybe that's a local thing because the locals had "light rye" for their turkey and it looked like the rye bread I know. Anyway. The bread was fresh. The Corned Beef was OK. My friends loved their sandwich ... Me, not so much. Recommend ... get the light rye and skip their take on corned beef. Go for regular roast beef. I saw a roast beef sandwich being made and it lookd great. They have real Cream soda so it really wasn't to disappointing... read more

Brooklyn Pickle is my go to for amazing sandwiches and their Chicken Riggies (currently Thursday's special). You go to the front counter to place, pay and obtain your order and then you can choose your seating choice (inside or outside) or take your order to go. Their half sandwich is the size of a normal sandwich and a hole can easily be shared. read more

Fast service with a super attitude. Great service makes a great lunchtime experience.

If you like sandwiches this place is for you. My favorite is the Brooklyn Pickle on dark rye. Pastrami, corned beef, sauerkraut, Swiss cheese, and Russian dressing. Plenty of options for everyone. Got it to go for work and all were perfect. My favorite location is on West Genesee St. This one is new to North Syracuse and still impressed me. Enjoy. read more

Brooklyn Pickle - Yeah baby!! Classic Reuben. - Sandwiches Near Me - Liverpool, New York

See all

I love this place. I used to stop in here once a week when I worked two miles down the street. They have an awesome selection of sandwiches to choose from. I picked up a Ruben for my wife and ran it over to her for lunch. Not much more to say, I enjoyed a Turkey sandwich and a Coke, then back to work. read more

Best sub I've ever had. Also got a tub of fresh pickles they excellent too. Their new Liverpool location is beautiful big , clean and efficient. read more

Love this place! Always consistent and pleasant staff. Kind of overpriced though! That's why they're getting 3 stars instead of 5

I used to always look forward to having Brooklyn pickle growing up at the East Syracuse location, but now that it's in Liverpool, I've tried it a few times but it lacks flavor. It is not that great for the price they charge. read more

I visited the Buckley Road location recently and was turned off by a tall black female sandwich maker wiping her runny nose on her sleeve. Gross! I waited for a different sandwich maker. I got a whole corned beef on dark rye with lettuce, tomato and provolone cheese. I was getting it to go so requested Russian dressing on the side. Not too complicated! When I got home, no dressing and no pickles! Very disappointed! They need to pay attention to details instead of yapping amongst themselves!! For the price I paid, it sucked! read more

Sandwiches and soups were great. Don't be afraid of a long line it moves very fast. Great service. Next time I going for a Reuben.

Hands down the best sandwiches in the Liverpool, North Syracuse, Cicero area. Let's start with the bread. It is so soft and melts in your mouth like cotton candy. No matter if its white or dark rye it's all soft. Now for the meats yeah you've heard arby's say "they have the meats" but Brooklyn Pickle has the meats and they've done it right. Meats are tender and seasoned so well you'd think you just cut it yourself. I ordered 3 sandwiches while I was here. A turkey, corned beef, and a Pastrami all to share. I wish I could tell you what one was the best but, it's to close to call. All three were spectacular. All piled high with meat and vegetables. These are some sandwich artists they have here. What they do is art, I get so much on my bread I'm not sure how they can cut it. They do this without making a sloppy sandwich. So well put together it's not even messy when I eat it. The employee's are all friendly and happy to serve. They are great and will answer any questions for you guys that have never visited before. I'm so glad they finally opened one up by me. read more

Brooklyn Pickle - customers at the check - in counter - Sandwiches Near Me - Liverpool, New York

The woman who served us today was so rude. We ordered around 12:30 pm. They don't wear name tags, but she was wearing a necklace with an image of a person, and she had a bun. It was our first time here and I came with my individuals who I have to look after. They have to pay separately as per the homes rules, and they have to stay with me. When we ordered the first sandwich and she asked if we were paying together, we told her separate. She snapped at my individual saying "next time just say seperate!". First of all, I work as a food server as well and its not hard to talk to people with basic respect. Second, she acted like anything we ordered was an annoyance, so I wound up not ordering half of what we were going to get. Third, we gave this place a chance, this first time will be our last time here. And last, we ate in the resteraunt and she only gave us one tray to eat all of our food on, that was messy between 3 people. Will never return. read more

Disappointing. You make a special stop to get a sandwich at a place that makes nothing but, you expect a good sandwich. It was a Saturday and there is a sign on the door saying they are closing at 3:00. We figure no problem as it was 2:35 and we're getting food to go. The wife ordered a sub. They are out of plain sub rolls except their "everything" sub roll. She opts for a sandwich on white. I'm thinking a roast beef on an everything roll sounds good. I wish this roll was day old. It was more like week old. Too hard on the ends to attempt to eat. Seems like they stock up at the beginning of the week and when they are out, they're out. Since I would only go on a Saturday, probably won't be back. read more

To be honest. Not as good as it used to be. The pickles out in the open and without a lid on it. Everything just thrown together and you can just taste the low quality in the sandwich. Mac & cheese just off and not tasty at all. Maybe it's this location. Disappointed every time now! read more

It's set up like a subway restaurant, but with sandwiches too, and more choices. The sandwiches are huge, maybe 4 by 7? Service was fast, there are plenty of tables in and outdoors, and if you want pickles, there's a cute pocket for them when they wrap your sandwich. Great place to meet up with someone. read more

opuit Always had great and accurate orders from here. Last 2 visits not so much. one my wife ordered an antipasto salad and it was a plain salad. Had nothing on it. The second time I ordered a corned beef sandwich and when I opened it at home it was ham. The staff needs to be more careful! read more

If you never had deli from Brooklyn you may like this spot. If you have wait until you go again

Disclosure: First timer therefore my expecations were fair. I didn't see a Reuben on the menu board but it appeared they had what it took to make one. Indeed they do make this popular sandwich and apparently it's a go to for a lot of their customers. I questioned that it was made like all other Reubens, but unfortuantely it is not. The meat is warmed however the bread is not toasted. I was there and craving it so I gave it a go. It may not seem like a huge deal but since this was take-out I had my concerns that it would be soggy from the sauerkraut. Well my intuitions were correct; I had to place it in the toaster over at work in an attempt to firm the bread back up. I give the portion size a 5/5, the price at a 4/5, but the lack of toaster/pininni maker is a deal breaker for me. It's a shame since they 50 bucks on Amazon and it would have been a near perfect sandwich. read more

Unsure as to what is going on with this business but my sandwich looks nothing like the quality a Brooklyn pickle used to have. Not worth 3 bucks let alone 9 bucks for a crappy sandwich. read more

Brooklyn Pickle - Little bit o ham and not much else. Even stingy on the onions. - Sandwiches Near Me - Liverpool, New York

Always the best!!! My faves are corned beef on dark rye and seafood salad sub. One quick suggestion? Regional sandwich special day, like Muffuletta or Philly Cheese Steak. I would come running for either! read more

Best sub you can get anywhere in the Syracuse n.y. area. A lot of times you have enough for to meals. The meat is very high on us sub hard get us mouth on it read more

Horrible! Went to the Buckley road location. Preordered 2 rubens. What I got were corned beef sandwiches. When I brought it to the managers attention she said it didn't have sauerkraut? I said no it had lettuce no cheese and it wasn't warm. It's a corned beef sandwich. Also the ladies room paper towel dispenser wasn't working and again brought it to the attention to management was met with ok. Terrible! read more

Have been a Brooklyn Pickle fan and customer for 20+ years. Work near the W.Genny St location and have been there often, was excited to see one coming to the north suburbs. Stopped this past Thursday 600pm-ish. Layout of restaurant was little odd. Especially if you're at sandwich station near coolers. Extremely tight fit there. Ordered the Brooklyn Pickle on a sub roll to go. Woman behind counter had trouble finding the whole sub rolls. (Which was no biggee, I wasn't in a hurry) After walking around for a bit, she found them and came back and said "the Brooklyn Pickle? Right?" To which I replied "Yes, Thank You". What I got when I got home was a Roast Beef sub with very little lettuce, 2 tomato slices, mayo and swiss. Not only was it not what I ordered, it was not the normal portions I had grown accustomed to from previous BP visits at other locations. It was a tiny sub on a big roll. As I sat in disappointment that I got the wrong sub I was thinking "where's the meat?". I ate it anyways, I wasn't going to drive back after getting home already. It was as tasty as any BP sub I've had in the past. The service itself was great. Friendly staff as used to at BP. No waiting when I arrived, I was able to walk direct to the counter. Yes, the layout in there is odd, but it is a huge room. Getting in and out of the parking lot is tricky. It's one of the busiest roads in the area. Turning left is a chore, and a challenge. Hopefully something will change in the future. As far as the sub. Yes its BP, but apparently all new staff. Seems a learn as you go situation. No biggee, I'll go back again, and again, its Brooklyn Pickle for crying out loud. Hopefully this location will get up to par with the others soon. Happy to have it in the neighborhood. read more

Saturday 9/2020 ordered a julienne salad. Gal takes it out of a cooler and adds meat and cheese. This salad had to have been in that cooler many days. The cucumbers were so degraded that they were absolutely slim. Some of the greens were slimy and most lettuce was brown. I can tolerate a bit of rust on lettuce but this was beyond that! Have always enjoys their subs/sandwiches but stay away from the salads. I've had better at McDonald's. read more

Brooklyn Pickle - Suppose to cucumbers! Disgusting! - Sandwiches Near Me - Liverpool, New York

Out of towner, in town for work, and the locals recommended for lunch. This place did not disappoint at all, a bit confusing as they have huge counter space and at least to me no identifiable place to order. Just workers at the counter greeting you with a smile and making you order right then and there in front of you. This place reminds me of a Deli where I grew up with their regular sliced bread sandwiches and no hoagie rolls. Would highly recommend this place, and next time I am in town this is a must stop place. Thank you! read more

Love the sandwiches here. Can't go wrong with the Italian !! We love that they put one so close to us in liverpool.

First of all, the employees here are some of the most friendliest, efficient, and well trained staff you will meet. I walked in right before lunch, ordered 8 large subs, and they knocked them out like champs. It was so good I went back for dinner subs for the evening team. Go, you will not be disappointed. read more

Poor service, staff were extremely rude. Was treated like I was an idiot for not knowing where to order. Treated like an idiot when asking what breads they have. Treated like a bigger idiot for thinking my tuna sandwich could be toasted and be a tuna melt in a sandwich shop. The food was ok so I gave a star for that. Terrible experience with staff so I won't ever go back read more

We LOVE Brooklyn pickle. We typically eat at the one off Buckley Rd. The staff is extremely friendly, the food is delicious. We've tried the Italian sandwich, the Roast pork sandwich and a few others. A half size sandwich is enough to fill me up, and I'm usually a big eater. They are stacked with meats, cheese and toppings. Definitely a place we will continue to frequent. read more

Used delivery for my brother's 71st birthday during COVID-19 because we usually get together, in-person, to have a birthday dinner together! This year, I was able to order from the Capital Region with the local Brooklyn Pickle in Liverpool to deliver to their door. And during the Order there was a "problem"! Both Brooklyn Pickle locations ran out of ham and 2 of the items were ham! But have no fear, Susan called me (remember I'm out in the Capital Region) and I asked if she could call the number I put in the "special notes" area because I was making this order from Albany for my brother's 71st birthday and the food is for them. Not only did she call them and they got to tell them what to get in exchange but she also caught my mistake in the area code while on the phone with me AND when she called the house, got the changes and said "Happy Birthday to whomever's birthday it is" and provided chocolate chip cookies for everyone! I loved Brooklyn Pickle and order or eat in every time we are in town. But now, I love them even more because they not only provided great food but delivered it and provided a service that made everyone smile! I'd give you 5M starts if possible. Thank you for everything and I'm very happy the second location is doing well as the Original location is thriving! Kudos to you all! read more

First time visiting the Liverpool location. Just like the old one on Burnett Ave. couldn't have been more pleased

Just had this and I should of gone to 5Guys. There was nothing Brooklyn about this place. The bread should be toasted for one thing no one likes soggy bread from the 8 table spoons of Mayo. Cut the portion down a bit. The chili was less than desirable. Step up your whole game and I'm sorry for being real. read more

This new location is awful. They constantly get orders wrong and definitely don't make the sandwiches as big as the other two Brooklyn Pickles. I've been to this location 5 or so times now and 3 of those times they have screwed up my order, all 5 times they have given me a small sandwich (compared to the other two restaurants). Stick to the old Brooklyn Pickles, this one is terrible. Never going back. read more