As a loyal man, finding the right pizza family isn't easy. A friendly smile and a clean, well-themed restaurant are always nice, but that's not what won me over. When my pizza came out with the cheesy goodness overflowing everywhere (not complaining ), the employee walked it out to me, showed me what happened, apologized, and said: "I wouldn't be happy giving you something I'm not proud of." Those might be the most romantic words I've ever heard. He made me a brand-new pizza at no charge and even let me keep the original one for the extra five-minute wait. I almost never leave reviews, but that young man earned one today. I think I finally found my marinara family. read more

The food is good. The service is friendly and the portions are large for a decent price. The ambience is a step back into a Bronx station. So all in all, it's pretty much what they advertise. For my taste, the sauce is a little underseasoned, but it has a very nice tomato flavor. All in all not a bad place to have some pizza meatballs, and hang out for a while. They did away with the lasagna, which is a little strange not to have lasagna and an Italian place which cost them a star in my opinion. And they do offer a 10% military discount! read more

See all

Service was okay only two servers working inside and out. She was as attentive as she could have been as it got busier as we were there. Multiple people complained (including someone from our table) about the sweet tea being too strong like it was straight concentrate. They were happy to change out the drink. The pizza was okay. The Detroit style was really good hot but once it cooled it became tough to chew. Same with the bread on the sanwhiches. The chicken on both sandwhiches were amazing. But the bread made it difficult to eat it as a sanwhich. My friend and I both just ate the inside without the bread. I am unsure if I would eat here again. read more

Bronx House Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Jacksonville, Florida

See all

I dined in at Bronx House Pizza for the first time. I've had their pizza before through Uber Eats, but had never previously been to the actual location. We planned to dine in, but I assumed you would have to order and then sit. However I was pleasantly surprised to learn its full service. You can pick your seat and then someone from the wait staff will bring you menus, etc. if you are ordering to-go, you can of course. There are several booths and tables to choose from for seating. There is also outside seating. We ordered a large Big Al. On the tables, they have crushed red pepper, grated Parmesan, Italian seasoning (or maybe dried oregano) garlic salt, regular salt, and pepper in a condiment caddy. The pizza stand is on top for those who order a pie. The pizza came out pretty quickly after we ordered it and it was hot and fresh with that nice cheese stretch. It tasted so good - very clearly freshly made with quality, clean ingredients. The crust is also very much worth eating! I like the end eating my slice with the top crust if it's crispy (but not too crunchy) and theirs was perfect. Our waiter was very nice and checked in on us a few minutes after we got our pizza to ensure all was well. This is a great spot to stop in for good quality pizza if you're in the mood. read more

Bronx House Pizza - 16" Big Al - sooooo good!! - Pizza Near Me - Jacksonville, Florida

I stopped by Bronx House of Pizza for lunch recently and really enjoyed the food. It was quiet, with only two other tables occupied so our service was great. I remember many nights running to grab pizza during my time in Manhattan and this place sort of reminded me of those days. Kinda simple and industrial, no frills. With family from the Bronx, I smiled when I saw a sign with their old stomping ground on it. We chose two slices each. I got the haymaker and butcher shop. While I was a little confused about Detroit-style pizza (not Grandma's) being at the Bronx HOP, I loved the haymaker. It was thick, sweet, and satisfying. The marinara sauce and bacon jam were a great combination. This is a place I'd visit again. Having slices available in this area again is great! read more

See all

The food here was made to order so I had to be patient. It was worth it though! I had the small cheese, banana peppers, mushrooms and fresh basil pizza. It was delicious!! So much cheese!!! Ambience is family style. It's a chain but I would come back. Highly recommend. read more

See all

We had a decent experience at Bronx House Pizza! We opted to sit outside, which was lovely & perfect weather but beware of the bugs. The service was on par with what you'd expect inside, which was a nice surprise. As a group of eight, we started with the cheesy garlic bread and two orders of garlic knots, both of which were flavorful and hit the spot. The kids enjoyed a small cheese pizza, and they absolutely loved it! My mom went for the Alfredo penne pasta, and she was pleased with the large portion and delicious taste. Leftovers all around. We also tried a couple of other pizzas and a calzone, which were decent! I personally ordered the wings without sauce, paired with a side of blue cheese. They were fried perfectly and exactly what I was craving. Overall, a nice dining experience with a good variety of tasty options! Chain feeling - not NY style and surprised they suggested the deep dish like Chicago pizza vs Bronx NY Pizzq - we should've listened! No white wine! So odd read more

See all

As a New Yorker of course I had to check this place out! I absolutely love all the Bronx memorabilia and themed decor through the building. I was very intrigued by the menu. I had to take a moment to absorb all the offerings, the young lady who was helping me was very nice and patient. I finally decided I wanted a couple of slices. Rule of thumb, I always get a slice of cheese. They had no cheese slices. And had no idea when more cheese was coming out?! Red flag!! Anyway, I ended up ordering two slices - the SPOP - sausage, pepperoni, onions, peppers; and the margherita. The SPOP was very tasty. Nice variety, good flavor. The Margherita was hard and chewy; seems like it was in the over too long. I ordered a Yuengling with my meal and it was ice cold. Very nice touch. All in all, I would probably say 3.5 stars for the overcooked margherita and no cheese slices, but I'll round up to 4 for the rest of the experience. I'm willing to come back and try other menu items. read more

Bronx House Pizza - Margherita slice, SPOP slice - Pizza Near Me - Jacksonville, Florida

I stopped by Bronx House Pizza for the first time today after church for lunch. They didn't open until 12:00 PM so I sat in my car and waited about 20 minutes. After reading several reviews I knew it would be worth the wait! They serve appetizers including bruschetta and Nonna's (grandma) meatballs, salads including Greek and grilled chicken Caesar, New York style and Detroit deep dish pizza, pasta, heroes, calzones, pizza rolls and stromboli just to name a few items lol! Plus if you have a sweet tooth they offer mini and regular size cannoli as well as cheesecake. Today I was here to try the New York style pizza. I ordered two slices. One slice of Beast of Burden with pepperoni, meatballs, ricotta (imported from Italy) mozzarella as well as one slice of cheese. The Beast of Burden was bursting with flavors and the ricotta was smooth and creamy. But I also enjoyed the cheese slice as well. The cheese had a very nice flavor and was not overly salty like other places I've tried. I loved the thin yet crispy but not overcooked crust. And the New York style pizza sauce was a hit. And I appreciated that the pizza was not overly greasy. I met the owner who was very sweet. He told me about the rotating oven which was handmade and imported from Canada. He can fit roughly 40 pies in this oven at one time....woe! Don't forget to sign up for the rewards program so you can get all the points. I'm so happy this new pizza joint opened near my house. And I love that they sell several options by the slice so I don't have to commit to a whole pie! read more

See all

Bronx House Pizza opened a new location at Beach & Hodges, so I was excited to check it out. I've had their pizza delivered while hanging in Nocatee, but this was my first in-person visit to one of their locations. I tried to order directly at the register & learned that dine-in is a full service experience. I was waited on by Claire who was incredibly sweet & friendly. She told me she typically works at the Nocatee location & they don't offer pizza slices there like at this new location. Bonus points for the Beach/Hodges location! I decided on a slice of the Buffalo Chicken pizza from the pies available for slices. It was delicious! I liked everything about it - the crust, the sauce, & the toppings. Loved the amount of cheese on it and the flavor of the chicken was great. In addition to pizza, Bronx House serves a variety of classic Italian appetizers, entrees, hero sandwiches, desserts, and salads. There are plenty of options to choose from! read more

Bronx House Pizza - Buffalo Chicken pizza slice - Pizza Near Me - Jacksonville, Florida

Decided to try them since we always pass it by. Glad we did!!! 10/10 experience! Everything was delicious. We've never had a New York pizza but this is one of the BEST pizzas we had ever had! The pizza had the perfect crisp without being burnt, and the garlic knots were so good. My son absolutely loved his kids butter pasta, they even added Alfredo sauce & cheese for him. The guy who served us was super nice and welcoming. Definitely will be coming back to try out the rest of the menu. read more

See all

When I tell you that was the BEST pizza in Jacksonville; I mean it!! I have done my research and there is one other pizza place that comes close but we're here to talk about the BEST!! moving to Jacksonville from Long Island I have been longing and looking for pizza; bagels; hero's and bodegas. Welp I just found it! That was my first time ordering from here, at first I saw the name and was clowning it saying they not from the Bronx lol. Well I don't care where they are from the pizza was epic! First off they sell slices I had a chicken parm slice and my partner had a butcher shop. The toppings were awesome but the way the slice was cooked showed they know what they are doing in there! The whole place was nice; love that outdoor sitting and the authentic pizza shakers on each table was a nice touch. Definitely coming back; and trying everything on their menu! read more

Bronx House Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Jacksonville, Florida

The crust is amazing. Like, amazing. The pizza had flavor with oregano, red peppers and Parmesan cheese added to it. Toppings were fresh, but not as much as I was hoping. Wyatt our server was awesome. The place is cute and quiet. The menu has lots of good options and the music was awesome. Next time we come we'll try the meat only pizza. The NY crust was awesome and awesome saw the Detroit crust and it looked phenomenal. Overall we'll be back. read more

See all

Decent pizza place off Hodges. Flavors were great. Wish the pizza was a bit crispier and the sauce for the penne dish less acidic. It is a pretty harsh marinara sauce. Cute interior. The best things were the nugget ice, the customer service, the garlic knots & the Popeyes pizza. read more

See all

I have to admit, when I saw a new pizza place was coming to Beach/Hodges, I worried that they might suffer the same fate as the other two restaurants that occupied this spot previously. After stopping by for dinner during their grand opening tonight, I'm not worried. Everything we tried was amazing. At the suggestion of the server, we tried the meatball sliders. My advice to all: just order them. Now. We also ordered "build your own" small pizzas and they did not disappoint. This will definitely be our new neighborhood pizza spot. I can't wait to try some of their signature pizzas and pastas. The service was friendly, the vibe is NYC- inspired casual/fun, and we love that there's a small patio for outdoor dining. We will be frequent diners, for sure. read more

See all

Excellent food and service. Came at a shift change and both servers were amazing. I was surprised it was basically a pizza joint but the food and service made up for it. read more

The pizza here is very good, and I'm so glad they finally came to Jacksonville! The owner is always incredibly polite, and the entire staff provides fast, excellent service every single time. My only slight wish is that the prices were a little lower, but the high quality of the food and the top-notch hospitality make it well worth it. It's a fantastic addition to the local food scene, and I'll definitely be back! read more

I am from NY and this us the closest yet It has a nice ny feel. Pizza takes a bit too long though read more

We loved it! Pizza at its best / (Detroit style)and great service which is what's it's all about !!! Awesome Detroit style and sides. Try it!!! Clean and friendly! Mngr owner great service!!! Waiter Wyatt super nice read more

Bronx House Pizza - Yummy white pizza - Pizza Near Me - Jacksonville, Florida

See all

We always get the Butcher Shop pizza which is very good. We don't like the meatballs so we usually ask for mushrooms instead of the meatballs. I don't understand why but they don't take any money off for the meatballs but they charge extra for the mushrooms. And the young lady who took the order was very blunt when she stated that policy. Not sure that their customer service is what you'd expect but I guess that's New York for you. We always order ours to go so we can pick it up and eat in front of the TV for college football games. read more

Food is amazing, it really is. There's one huge problem here.. the management and employees were obviously putting on a show for the opening. Now the masks are off and WOW RUDE servers, horrific customer service on the phone.. & what's with the elusive table that is excluded from patrons in the restaurant? We were forced to move after we STARTED our meal because it's 'where HE works' ... never again. read more

Food was great. Great NY recipe and plenty to eat. Service was quick. Food was hot and fresh. Only drawback was not a lot of seating and some of the benches were set too close to the tables to sit at. read more

Bronx House Pizza - Eggplant parmigiana sub - Pizza Near Me - Jacksonville, Florida

This place nails it. Crispy bottom, bread cooked all the way through, and just the right amount of cheese -- not excessive, not skimpy. Classic New York style done right. Hard to find a pizza this well executed. I'll definitely be back. read more

Did a pickup order Got a pizza- pizza was great Mozz sticks were just okay, nothing to write home about Garlic knots good Now this is the reason for the 3 stars. Ordered 2 sides of ranch- don't know about anyone else but I look forward to dipping my pizza and mozz in ranch. Especially if it's homemade ranch. Paid for the two sides of ranch and we got home, you guessed it no ranch. Kinda ruins the whole meal. Was the pizza still awesome, yeah but am I mad that people don't know how to do their jobs? Yeah. Do I want a refund for the ranch? No, it won't fix my experience. If I did order again, I'll definitely be checking my order. read more

Bronx House Pizza - Proof of ranch purchase - Pizza Near Me - Jacksonville, Florida

I saw there was a new pizza restaurant at Beach And Hodges and it appeared. They've been open for a few months. I pulled up and at 6 o'clock in the evening they're closed. I'm not sure why we've tried the Bronx house Pizza in Saint Augustine and really wanted to try it here I don't know why they're closed, but it was very disappointing. read more

Everybody's really nice, has a really great feel with good music. The balsamic dressing for the house salad is really awesome and the pizza is excellent as expected. read more

Bronx House Pizza - Classic Bronx Pizza with black olives and spinach - Pizza Near Me - Jacksonville, Florida

Ok so pizza is good decent compared to other places Al's , Tony ds etc however one thing I disagree and really don't understand is why do you ask me for a tip when I have to come pickup my own pizza because you don't deliver and your third party delivery people charge almost 38 dollars for the fee . So now I have to come and pick up my own pizza but yet you want me to leave a tip ? I know tips are optional by the customer but what I'm saying is you really don't need to ask for anything more then a form of payment period take that stupid tip option of . Last what reason do you expect a tip for ? You cooked the pizza I picked up the pizza I drove there I took time to do what you don't offer to do and you ask for a tip ? Crazy crazy crazy . read more

Amazing garlic knots and I am obsessed with their meat lovers pizza. Servers were very kind and will definitely be back!

I made a special order for my pizza and they declined. Went all the way to the top and their response is we will not do that. I will never go back. Customer always comes first. Screw them! read more

From the moment we walked in we felt very welcomed. The service we got from Wyatt was fanominal. The Pizza was just like you get in New York. If you have not tried this Pizza place I strongly recommend you do. You will not regret it. The inside is very clean and not loud. They also have an outside seating area. read more

Awesome food and service!. Definitely in love with the meatball sliders! Service was great as well! We sat outside and enjoyed a great meal with the family. read more

Bronx House Pizza - Meatballs sliders - Pizza Near Me - Jacksonville, Florida

See all

This is good pizza. Different from Rennas but I'd say it matches for quality - a little crispier crust. My family will definitely be back. read more

We had an online order for pizza to go and got a 20% off that online order. It's our families favorite pizza. Always hot, delish and great service. Thank you for great pizza near my neighborhood. read more

Food was ok, waiter made us feel invisible as he seemed to constantly be looking for something else. Other server seemed annoyed, especially when we asked her to ask our server for a check. I could see was over talking with the cooks and eating something. My biggest issue was that they although they are ADA compliant, they certainly did not come across as ADA friendly. Too much to go into here. But the thought of calling the ADA office for the COJ certainly did cross my mind. What makes them a maybe, is the food we had was pretty good. We each had a small pizza and both were good. So our plan is to go back again shortly and see if the service side has improved. read more

Pizza is good but their rewards program just plain sucks. Food is pricey but good, takes awhile to earn points at large cost and then you have limited time to use your expensive earned reward. Coupons are kind of cheap to for cost of food. Love the place but the rewards and coupons are a slap in the face read more

Nice location, good set up but the booths are really small and the chairs for the tables are not comfortable at all. The restaurant was full when we went and there was only one server. She did her best but the customer experience was poor. We shared a calzone and a slice. The marinara was good, the Alfredo not so much. Calzone was generous with cheese but not nearly as much with the meat (we got the meat lovers). Pizza was "okay" but for someone born in the Bronx, it didn't make me think of home. read more

I came in to pick up pizza and the lady on the phone was super helpful, recommended the Popeye pizza and was super explanatory about what my wife could eat with celiac. We're from New York and this pizza is the closest in the area we have found to true Ny style pizza. Definitely would be back to dine in. read more

I feel like I'm back in NYC when I come to Bronx house. The pizza is perfect New York style and the service is quick and amazing. Even when they are super busy the servers are very accommodating and accessible. Definitely try the Department of Sanitation if you like a supreme pie and the garlic knots. read more

My best friend and I get there pizza all the time. The chicken bacon ranch pizza is so good and the garlic knots are absolutely to die for the service is always impeccable and everybody in there is so kind all the time and helpfu read more

Ordered two pizzas and salad before the Jags game on Sunday. Got a text that they were ready as I arrived. When I went to the counter, the cashier said he had just given them away by mistake. So, they had to make new ones, which took about 30 mins. Which was during the first half. He said he was sorry, never asked if I wanted something to drink, or any reduction in price of what I ordered. I sent an email to amos@bronxhousepizza.com and he responded in less than 1 hour. He apologized for the way I was treated. He also offered me a credit for the dinner. I understand how mistakes happen; it is how the customer is treated when that happens. read more