We were driving from Maine to VT and started to get hungry for lunch. I did a quick search for something close, that had good reviews, and found Broken Hearts Burger. My husband & I LOVE burgers & fries, and the reviews were all great, so we decided we had to try it. It did not disappoint. Everything in the other reviews holds true - there is 1 server who is doing everything outside of the kitchen, and she's very good at juggling multiple customers. We each got the Heartbreaker with fries, and both joined the Clean Plate Club. SUPER messy, but SUPER delicious. The fries were super crispy (a BIT too salty for me) and flavorful. It is a bit on the pricier side - $14 each for the Heartbreakers, but we also recognize that all the ingredients come from local sources and companies. The fries are only $3 for a good-sized portion, which is nice. I wouldn't have minded some AC, as it was a pretty hot day. But that's minor. If you're in the area and like burgers, check it out!! read more

Broken Hearts Burger - Heartbreaker with fries - Burgers Near Me - Fairlee, Vermont

Tasty snap hot dog with kraut. Delicious. My husbands burger was also super yummy. Nice and crisp. I have been a few times but keep forgetting to take more pictures. It's a great seat yourself, find an open table kinda place. Great for a good quick bite without hassle. And a super kind staff. Definitely worth a stop for a bite. read more

Broken Hearts Burger - Kraut/Must Dog - Burgers Near Me - Fairlee, Vermont

This burger place is awesome. The doughnuts, the burgers, and the fries are delicious. Adorable atmosphere. Friendly staff.

The burgers and fries were delicious. I have had the veggie burger too and that was great. Service was great. The theme is a creative and cozy diner bar which works. Recommend. read more

Wonderful vibe and atmosphere. Enjoyed the food very much. I have been craving a good burger and they did not disappoint. Tried the double burger with fried onions and pickles. Left with three each of their donuts. Those were delicious as well. Even brought a few home for my travels and share with my kids to try. After more than 24 hours they were still delicious. The one and only server did an absolute fantastic job balancing everyone as they came in, cleaning up the tables, and bring out the food. As well as bar back and bartend. Definitely deserves the extra tips. Food came out hot and timely. Will definitely make a point to go back the next time I am in Vermont. read more

Broken Hearts Burger - Large dining bar, and a few booths for seating. - Burgers Near Me - Fairlee, Vermont

See all

This place is 5/5. By far the best smash burger I've ever had. Probably my favorite burger of all time. The Nashville Hot Chicken Tenders are also a must have. They've really dialed in their consistency. I keep going back and it never disappoints. Thanks BHB! read more

Broken Hearts Burger - Burgers, fries, Nashville Hot Chicken Tenders - Burgers Near Me - Fairlee, Vermont

Mandatory service charge of 17% is actual robbery. Also, we traveled 45 minutes to get there, and we're told that we couldn't do takeout. This is a while ago, so things may have changed. Management could've made an exception, especially since it was not indicated anywhere on social media or your website that you don't do take out on weekends Or whatever you're stupid policy is. Rigid and ridiculous. A 17% service charge is actual theft. Tips are a reward for good service. No exceptioms! If you want to make sure that your employees are paid adequately, be honest and transparent, and build their wages into your prices so people don't get a shock with their bill. I believe this could be grounds for a class action lawsuit. Especially if the service is lacking. Mandatory service fees that take away the customers agency and personal discretion based on their experience is called dishonesty in business practice. Can't wait to see the response from the thin-skinned owner who is incapable of absorbing criticism without firing back like a petulant adolescent. I am no Maga warrior. But I despise pondscum like yourself who cannot take any criticism, and make ad hominem attacks on anyone who finds fault with your business practices. You're a pathetic joke. And I can't wait to see you fail. read more

Having grown up just south of Fairlee my entire life, the only restaurants this tiny town ever had were the Fairlee Diner and the Wippi Dip. Places have popped up over the years and operated for a little bit before ultimately closing. While visiting in December 2023 I heard about Broken Hearts Burger and tried it out one afternoon for lunch with some friends from out of town. If you aren't paying attention you might drive right by it on Route 5. Parking is limited but there is an open lot across the street. The restaurant is small inside, with about 3-4 booths and maybe 5 counter bar stools. I ordered the Nashville hot fried chicken sandwich and I was blown away: perfectly crispy with enough spice to get your nose running. The tangy pickles mixed with the creamy and sweet coleslaw balances it out. It's a bit expensive at $13 (and that's without fries) but entirely worth it. Rarely has this ever happened for me, but I was so impressed that I took a different pair of friends there the very next day for dinner. That night I tried the Heartbreaker burger, with two double smash burgers, all the toppings, and fries. Very tasty and filling. The service was on point too, with our waitress being very attentive. Overall, Broken Hearts Burger is a fantastic new addition to the Fairlee food scene, and you can bet that I'll be stopping in whenever I am in town. read more

Broken Hearts Burger - Nashville hot fried chicken sandwich - Burgers Near Me - Fairlee, Vermont

See all

Hands-down, this place has the best burgers in the entire state of Vermont. I have been traveling around the state in a quest to find the best burgers. Looking for my burger list Google search burgers of Vermont or check out my YouTube channel review time with Tim. read more

See all

Great beer list, great burgers, great fries. The double 'heartbreak' burger was well cooked with lacy smashed edges and a juicy center. The pickles and sauce were a good contrast and the potato bun was soft and fresh. A nice small shred of iceberg lettuce gave just the right bit of crunch. The donuts looked great but that will have to wait until next time. Maybe not the most healthy choice but who cares. The food was fantastic. We sat at the counter and the server did a great job handling a late lunch rush on a soggy day. On a nicer day we'd have sat in one of the nice shady tables out front. I bookmarked this place and will definitely stop in anytime I'm in the area. read more

God bless this establishment! This is... dare I say... better than Worthy Burger?! Broken Hearts may have a simple menu, but what it does, it does well. The patties are thin, and the fries are McDonald's shoestring style, so you don't walk out feeling like you ate a tub of lard (like you would at Worthy Burger, since their fries are literally fried in lard). Heartbreaker was fantastic. Soft bun, crispy edges on the patties, crunchy pickles, and a delicious sauce make for the perfect textural experience. You don't need to put in a lot of work to eat this burger; it just melts in your mouth. SO, so, classic. Would definitely recommend checking out this spot, which has taken the cake, in my opinion, for best burger in VT. Only thing I'll say is that I'd love for the wonderful people that dreamed this place up to add some sort of milkshake to the menu. Other than that, this place is burger perfection! Fairlee's such a lovely little town, so points for atmosphere too! read more

A nice, retro-themed local burger place in the area. There's both indoor and outdoor seating, though outdoor seating gets filled pretty quickly around dinner time. The menu is pretty minimal and contains three main categories: burgers, fried chicken, and hot dogs. I've been here twice, and it's been a bit inconsistent. I ordered the same food both times--a single with fries. Burger patty is more of a "smashburger" type of patty, so it's pretty thin and crispy. Pickles tasted different than the usual ones in other places (in a good way). The first time was great and I would give a 5/5; however, the second time I was here was more of a 3/5. The patty was a bit too crumbly and the buns weren't toasted enough, so it was kind of floppy. Fries were overdone and too salty for me, though they were much better the first time. All in all, I'd have to come back here to give a more concrete opinion verdict, but from my two experiences, it's a 3.5/5. I would still recommend people to come try it out, even if it's not consistent all the time. read more

Broken Hearts Burger - Single with cheddar and a side of fries - Burgers Near Me - Fairlee, Vermont

We were so disappointed! We brought out-of-town visitors because we'd had such a good previous experience. Burgers were slathered in so much mayo, that the buns became mushy and were falling apart. The previously delicious fries were now almost inedible. They seemed as though they'd been sitting in the fryer too long, and were soaked through with grease. None of us could eat more than a few. And, curiously, they're still serving their wonderful Mexican cokes without ice. You broke our hearts! read more

Cute burger and fried chicken place next door to samurai soul food. In my opinion their burger is better than five guys but may not be as good as shake shack. Soft serve ice cream is good. read more

Broken Hearts Burger - Ube ice cream - Burgers Near Me - Fairlee, Vermont

See all

Service was friendly but slow (it was not busy). The hot dog was good. Fries were as crispy as burnt toast. The hamburger, I can't even describe it. It looked like someone took all the pieces of burgers that were cooked on the grill, took a little bit of ground meat and formed it into a patty, read more

We traveled 50 minutes to check this place out and it did not disappoint. The food was delicious!

Took us a while to finally head over to Fairlee and try this amazing establishment. We decided to sit in a nice comfy booth inside but there is also outdoor dining. Went for the signature heartbreaker burger with American cheese. The crunchy meat from the smash burger to the creamy melted cheese and tang from the jumpback sauce wanted me to just inhale this tasty burger. I controlled myself to a point to savor it. I also got the Nashville fries which had just enough kick to them. Can't wait to go back to try a special or their chicken sandwich. read more

Broken Hearts Burger - Heartbreaker burger and Nashville Fries - Burgers Near Me - Fairlee, Vermont

See all

Awesome burgers,nice staff. We had to wait forever to get them. Outside seating a must in the summer.

A fantastic smash burger. I'm surprised this place hasn't been featured on a food travel show, it's got lots of scrappy character. Their spinach and cheese-based veggie burger is also great, as are the donuts, fries, and everything else. read more

After eating only the chicken sandwich since they opened (because it was so good, I couldn't imagine going there and not having it...) - I finally decided to listen to my family and friends and have the burger. Well... I must say they were right! The burger was VERY tasty - bun is toasted and perfect and the homemade pickles are the bomb! The French fries are probably the best I have ever had - really! They must bake them first then fry them or something because they are small and crispy and delicious. Really - you won't be disappointed. read more

Broken Hearts Burger - The single burger, with cheddar, jump back sauce and homemade pickles. - Burgers Near Me - Fairlee, Vermont

This was one of the best burgers I've had anywhere. Classic smash burger. The patties are perfectly crispy on the edges. Well seasoned. Great crunch from thick pickle slices. So good, I finished mine and ate another 1/2 of it. The fries were crispy and delicious. The Nashville chicken sandwich was equally amazing. They even serve Mexican coke! I'd come here more often if I lived closer. I would not only recommend this place, but I look forward to coming back! read more

See all

Everything on the menu is perfect! We had a fried chicken sandwich, a burger (smash burger style), a hot dog, fries (perfectly crispy and skinny), and followed by the most perfect summer treat: a twist soft serve cone. This small but perfect menu has exactly what you need. I look forward to seeing what this establishment does in the future, I know we can count on them for the best. Also was so pleased to find a nice outdoor dining option. The grassy courtyard was a perfect backdrop for a summer dinner. read more

the worst place I have ever been. if you want to have an overpriced meal and rude staff and owner by all means go there. I am a local and will never go back. no burger and fries is worth $25 . I waited over an hour for my burger to arrive. the owners feel that their burgers are with it. they are not. would never ever recommend this place. read more

I would call this place a hole in the wall gem. Very limited menu. Great smash burgers. Excellent fries. It has a few booths but mostly it's outdoor seating. Nice beer list. Service was friendly. It was a bit hard to locate because they don't have a sign saying "Broken Hearts Burger," just a small image of a heart broken in two. Restaurant is behind a fence. Parking in front and on the street. Very local. This was my first visit, but I'll b back to try their chicken. read more

Broken Hearts Burger - Look for this sign out front. - Burgers Near Me - Fairlee, Vermont

See all

I'll start by saying my favorite burgers are at Shake Shack. this was ... not good. The burger was was too overcooked for me and the nashville HOT was...sweet? also, the fries are super crispy and overcooked. I am also baffled that this burger place does not serve milkshakes? but why? kind of pricey, and certainly not for me! read more

What is not to love? Fries that are dusted with magic, burgers that are amazing, fried chicken that will make you cry and donuts to die for. They also have an awesome beer and wine list. Not a lot of options on the menu, but that isn't needed when everything is so good. read more

Ridiculously delicious. Juicy, sloppy, quality perfection. And there's a free pinball machine and juke box. We got there 2 minutes before closing and they didn't turn us away. read more

This is our 'regular spot'. My partner and I are here at least every other week, if not every week for the past 6 or 7 months. We love it. We often have Cheyenne, as our server. She is amazing. There's an ever-changing great beer selection, which we have fun working our way through, and very interesting/exciting wine list. As for the burgers, I dream about them. This is where I came for my birthday dinner and will for probably every one after. Don't even get me started about their fries. Good God, there isn't many things on this earth I love more than potatoes and these folks treat them right. The fried chicken isn't to be ignored either, whether it's the tenders, drums, or sandwich, we've had them all and they're great. As for the donuts, do not order them. Save them for us, please :). read more

Heavenly. The heartbreaker burger was just the most perfect combination of melty and crispy; a perfect American smash burger with fresh pickles and excellent sauce. The lemon-frosted yeast donut was divine. Great ambience, excellent service. The music is so good. Highly, highly recommend. read more

Had a burger w fries and a coke. And a spicy drumstick. The place is small and cool as fuck, hoping to get back again to try a donut and grab a beer. read more

Great place, fresh and fabulous food. Very simple menu, but well done. Great place for kids. Soft serve ice cream is among the best, and the donuts are to die for! read more

My god this place is exactly what we need. Fun classic food made with care and good ingredients. It also has a very fun vibe and great staff. First visit I had the Heartbreak burger and it was the best burger I've ever had. The next time I tried their cheesesteak special and it was better than the supposedly best ones in Philly! I know that's sacrilege to say but it is what it is! read more