good food, great drinks, nice ambiance and pleasant service. the food is a bit average. but I've been twice and enjoyed my food both times. read more

See all

cute local eatery serving italian food. it was super busy and i forgot to make reservation. but they did find seating and accommodated us. food was good my mom liked her fra diavolo seafood pasta. came with lots of seafood. i got the risotto- kinda taste weird with tomato reduction. perhaps a cheese or truffle sauce would have been better. my sister had the salmon which was pretty standard. service was good waitress was busy but never failed to refill water and checked in with us regularly. read more

See all

Have to shout out to BB. Wonderful spot owned by a tremendous chef. John does it right. Food is wonderful. And now that George is the main bartender, it's like home to me. The best chicken Parmesan with eggplant on the planet. Stop by and enjoy! read more

Love the food, service and ambiance! Prices are good. Often there is music which makes the evening extra special!

I've eaten there several times with my husband. The food is delicious and the service was great. I've also had lunch with friends during Street fair time we sat outside. It was so nice and the drinks are great from the bar. I have no complaints. The soup is nice and hot. Everything was superb. read more

We had our son's graduation dinner for 9 of us and everything was perfect. Food was amazing and we didn't feel rushed. Highly recommend for a large group! read more

4 stars;small restaurant with good food at reasonable prices,and a great bartender,if you order dinner at the bar

I've been to Broadway Bistro a couple of times recently and I think the food is excellent. My wife had the pork chops and they give you two big ones and they were beautifully prepared. I had the mix seafood over black ink pasta and they give you enough scallops, shrimp, mussels, and calamari for two people. The quantity is excellent and the flavors are also excellent. A really good place, worth the money. read more

I genuinely feel my money is well spent and my business is appreciated when I dine here solo, or with friends & family. The bar is a cozy vibe, and the portions are wonderful for a shared table or have some now and save some for later. The beet salad, butternut squash ravioli(home made), pesto, wine selection, seafood & meats are fresh and hand selected by the present proprietor & chef. 5 STARS! read more

Broadway Bistro - Mussels & scallops on pesto risotto, on main menu - Italian Near Me - Nyack, New York

See all

The best thing about the Hudson Valley restaurant week is the luxury of trying different restaurants and experimenting with foods that you may not normally eat. So, this past week we wanted to find a place that seemed appropriate for date night and delivered on the food. After checking out other reviews on yelp this place seemed to hit the nail on the head. I was able to make a reservation day of, but only because someone else had canceled so they were able to squeeze us in for 8 PM. I wasn't sure if the hubs was going to take advantage of restaurant week as well but I was interested in the menu. Either way regular menu has PLENTY to offer. Super cute place from the outside... appeared very intimate and the inside lived up. Crisp white table cloths, not too crazy decor. Comfortable and appropriate dinner lighting. We scored a table for two at the front close to the bar and entrance. I was a little hesitant because it was a freezing cold night and I wasn't looking forward to the door opening and closing blowing cold air on us. Thankfully there was really no traffic in or out and when the door did open we didn't feel anything. We started with some crispy rolls while planning out our dinner. Hubby ended up doing the restaurant week and started with muscles followed by the seafood pasta and strawberries and cream for dessert. I ordered Gorgonzola and crispy pancetta ravioli followed by Bronzino and mascarpone cheesecake for dessert. We added on a fried calamari appetizer. Well let's put it this way the fried calamari appetizer was awful. Would never ever order it here again. However everything else was amazing. I wanted to drink the creamy soupy tomato veg broth from the mussels directly out of the bowl, but way too embarrassing to do in public. My three giant raviolis delicious!! The seafood pasta was nice and spicy and everything was cooked well. Not overdone seafood which can happen very easily. Bronzino with the tang of the capers, lentils folded into rice was light and deep all at the same time. I really couldn't finish any dessert after our mains so was planning on them taking home. Somehow after they arrived we managed to squeeze it all in. They were too pretty to not be eaten. I definitely would recommend the cheesecake. The strawberries and cream were a little small but still good. Our server was on top of everything and he seemed to genuinely enjoy working there. Even if he didn't, he definitely faked it but his demeanor helped add to our great evening. I will definitely come here again for a date night or even a night out with friends and explore the menu. Especially their homemade pastas. read more

See all

We went during their 10th anniversary celebration! The special menu was great with a very nice price! The choices were terrific! They had a rib steak my husband had that was done very well. We also had the sausage/ broccoli rabe pasta dish that was very tasty! The gift bag with biscotti & chocolate was especially a nice touch! Will definitely go back again! read more

My wife has a gluten and dairy allergy, this place is awesome! They are very knowledgeable about allergies and caring for their patrons. Kenny at the bar makes our date nights very special and we so very much enjoy coming to Broadway Bistro. We always make reservations to sit at the bar for this reason. I recommend this restaurant to anyone in Nyack area looking for a special gem. read more

I picked Broadway Bistro, never having been there, because it was equidistant for us and close friends from Greenwich we hadn't seen in a while. We were warmly greeted upon entering and that warmth continued through our 2+ hours there. Our server appeared promptly to announce specials and take drink orders. It was difficult to decide which of the enticing entrees to choose. My wife's snapper and my halibut were 2 of the best tasting and prepared fish dishes we have had. The Koshare was new to us and a outstanding accompaniment to the fish. We will definitely return. More than worth the 33 minute drive. read more

Decent enough food and ambience. Service is good. Typical diner food .. nothing exceptional but good value for money. Will visit again. read more

It was delicious and the price for the quality of food is pretty good. Lots of locals like coming here so you know it's decent and not overpriced. Bring cash! read more

The food was very good, but I suggest if you order some thing that comes with mashed potatoes you ask for the regular mashed potatoes. Some of us at the table got regular and some of us had greenish gray ones which turned out to be olives mashed in them. Definitely did not like the taste. It is a very small place, but very quaint! read more

Broadway Bistro - Inside - Italian Near Me - Nyack, New York

See all

Amazing restaurant with n Nyack. We were very impressed with how many of the pastas were made in house. The butternut squash ravioli and bistro salad were wonderful starters. Everyone in my party enjoyed their entrees from the branzino, lemon chicken, halibut, cavatelli. The desserts are also made in house. It's the fall now and I had a delicious pumpkin pie. My party also enjoyed the crème brûlée, cheesecake, rice pudding, and ice cream. The service was great and the chef even checked on us Highly recommend read more

It's a place I would go to once a week. Great selection of dishes, alcohol. The best service around. Just a place to enjoy a great meal and relax. read more

This is my husband in mind's favored place. It's like a little hideaway right in the middle of town in Nyack. We can walk there and when you finish you can walk around and the food is always good. read more

Smells like a gas station restroom with a lot of artificial smells. Music was very loud ( Andrea Bocelli) Food was mediocre, a lot of pepper on everything and service was poor. Busser kept refilling water glasses that were already filled to the brim but didn't remove dirty plates. We waited 30 minutes for appetizers. Steak was dry, mussels small and weird. Nothing stands out here. Close this place and start over. Cannot recommend. read more

Great food, service and selection Will go again for lunch or brunch Italian dishes with a little spin in them read more

Great food! Excellent service! Lovely ambiance! Highly recommended, great spot for couples. read more

The food at this restaurant last night was really delicious, but the woman singing was SOOO loud that it ruined my evening. I asked twice for the volume to be turned down. It was still too loud! I could hardly hear our friends across the table. it should have been background music, we weren't going to a concert to listen to her! Also, the service was ok except we had to remind our waitress a few times to get our drinks from the bar. read more

Just ate here- pleasantly pleased with the menu and the prices. Ordered the mussels- yum. My daughter loved her pasta and I had the risotto with shrimp for my entree. The risotto was way to lemony. The waitress never asked how we liked our meal and we received more sincere service from the runners. But that's ok, no NBD. The chef came to our table after our meal which was cool and made the quick decision to go here more intimate. We are traveling for a sporting event so finding this little gem in the tiny village at Nayack was a treat. read more

Broadway Bistro - Shrimp and lemony risotto, I thought it would be more of a mushroom base but it was strictly lemon. - Italian Near Me - Nyack, New York

See all

It literally warms my heart to think of how nice kind understanding and helpful the staff here was last night. Last night for my birthday, in a rain storm, during COVID my family and I came here to have a last attempt at a bday dinner as most other places are closed. To our surprise we were seated right away and catered to from there on. The food!!!! Omg from the appetizers to dessert they did not disappoint! We had calamari, fresh mozzarella, poach pear salad, pork chops, coconut crusted halibut, Salmon and a wonderful piece of heaven(raspberry cheesecake) and on top of all of the they sang happy birthday to me at the request of my boyfriend of course but with a great big smile on their faces. All of t s while still taking the necessary COVID-19 precautions. Thank you Broadway Bistro! read more

Broadway Bistro - Italian Near Me - Nyack, New York

See all

We recently dined at the Broadway Bistro, ( a group of six) and the food was delicious from appetizers to dessert. Our server was very attentive and efficient, and made sure we were able to leave in time to attend a play at Elmwood. We will definitely be back! read more

Absolutely delicious food, very professional service and a nice ambiance. We did the prix fixe and everything was great, but I think my scallops and shrimp pasta dish was the star of the show. Excited to come back and try other menu items read more

One of the best Italian meals we've had in the states! What an incredible unexpected find here in the quaint town of Nyack. We headed in on a holiday weekend expecting to wait for a table...didn't happen. We were seated immediately outside on a lovely night, and greeted promptly by our kind waitress and efficient bus boy, who both remained reliable and super sweet our entire meal. It's a very welcoming cozy place. We started with the crispy angel hair spaghetti pancake with rosemary-grilled shrimp smothered with balsamic coconut emulsion, which for me, stole the show. What a unique dish! Crispy fried spaghetti with balsamic and topped with shrimp? Way cool. Even if you personally don't eat the shrimp, the pasta texture with the balsamic is worth ordering alone! A must try, because really, where else would you see this? -Caeser salad -Forest mushroom soup -House-Made Lobster and Fennel Ravioli Crispy pancetta, toasted almonds, Parmesan and touch of cream. -House-Made Potato Gnocchi with Sweet Italian sausage on the side, oven roasted tomato and light pesto cream ....everyone was blown away by everything! The pasta, which is made fresh to order (so bring patience) is incredible. The sauces were all so flavorful and different. (They were so accommodating to our pain in the a** dietary restrictions also!) I recently sent my mom a s cousin here, and they too loved their meal and commented on how great and warm the service was. I feel super confident in sending everyone here for a fantastic filling meal, and great time. This place is definitely worth checking out while in town! Yum!!! read more

Okay, we were coming to Nyack for a wedding. It was our first time. We came here based on the yelp reviews and it did not disappoint. We ordered items off the menu and chef John was more than willing to accommodate us. The items on the menu are also delicious! I ordered Alfredo with penne and chicken francaise. My husband Ordered the Caesar salad. Others at our table ordered chicken parmesan, sautéed shrimp and scallops, and the flat iron steak. We all were so amazed how delicious and homemade everything was. They make everything from scratch. The waitress was very sweet and so was the hostess. We did not have a reservation but we came around 5:30. If you are coming after 7, you'll need a reservation. I live very far away but would go on a plane and return to Nyack JUST FOR THIS FOOD! Also, order the desserts, they are all gourmet! Here's the cheesecake and the ice cream! read more

Broadway Bistro - Dessert - Italian Near Me - Nyack, New York

Everything about this place is great. The service was outstanding, but the food was even better. Would recommend to anyone.

I ordered the parpadellel in meat ragu. It was hands-down the most delectable pasta dish I have had in all of Rockland County! The pasta was super fresh and cooked to perfection. The sauce was flavorful, fresh , and high-quality. They served warm crusty bread at the beginning with a pesto dip, was pretty good too. read more

Broadway Bistro - Parpadelle in meat ragu. Perfection. - Italian Near Me - Nyack, New York

Convenience, excellence, a bit of a limited menu, but what they do, they do well. Love the hand made pasta and the always fresh seafood! Also the duck! read more

Wow, what a fabulous discovery. The food was amazing and our waitresses were so genuinely helpful, responsive And hospitable. Their recommendations were spot on!!!! Thank you from two happy sisters!!!! read more

Loved ! Dined last night for the First time ! Our visit was superb! Dinner was delicious from appetizer to dessert! I had the shrimp and scallop entree! What an amazing dish! The mix of flavors was so delightful! My poached pear salad was delicious aEven my Banana Foster was terrific! Our guest equally enjoyed their meals ! Hats off to the chef! An additional surprise was a brilliantly talented singer. Her voice was added delight to our evening out!!! read more

Four of us had an excellent lunch - the Winter Special Lunch is an exceptional value. Range of choices, quality and quantity all exceeded expectations . The mushroom soup was possibly the best ever: believe every review that's posted about it! Nice setting, friendly service; the waiters listened and accommodated requests. We'll be back! read more

Been here twice recently. Had fish both times. Halibut and red snapper. My friends had grouper and shrimp risotto. The fish is really excellent. Large and thick pieces of fish, and expertly cooked. Could do with a little more imagination on the accompanyments - most just come with rice and steamed veg. Overall I'd recommend this place - hard to find fish this good outside NYC. Couple of grumbles (which is why I gave 4* and not 5*) 1. At peak hours drinks take ages to come out - on an early Saturday evening we were waiting 20 mins at least! 2. We were a table for 4. Even though there is plenty of room around the tables, the waiters bring the food to one end of the table and reach right across the table to serve the plates to the guests at the far end of the table - or expect the guests to hand the plates down the tablle themselves. Similarly when clearing the plates, the waiters reach right across the table, or expect the guests to pass the dirty plates down the table. The waiters should be trained to serve and clear the plates from behind each guest individually. Also they need to remember who ordered what. I don't mind badly trained waiters in a diner, but it's a shame when it happens in a good restaurant - and so easy to fix! read more

The food is unbelievably good. Everything is homemade including the ice cream. The service is wonderful.

This was probably the best meal I have had in a long time. The food was excellent and better than that, John the owner was so attentive to us. He came over spoke to us a number of times, to make sure the food was our liking. I would highly recommend the Broadway Bistro My friend Richard and I will surely be back, and very soon. Even met friends there, who had same opinion. Hi 5's to John and Broadway Bistro . read more

Broadway Bistro - Italian Near Me - Nyack, New York

Restaurant week comes twice in Rockland county; November and March. So be on the look out for flyers. Wanting to try a new restaurant on a quiet school night we ended up here. Three course meal for $36 can't be beat. Especially in a restaurant that usually serves $20- 50 plates. First course: I had the mussels in white wine sauce. Heavenly! Mussels just melted in your mouth and great broth to dip your bread. My foodie companion had the ravioli which was also great; filling was not over powering just delicant. Second course: I have never had black squid ink pasta so this was my opportunity to. I had the black squid ink fettuccini with seafood melody in a tomato based sauce. Clams, mussels, shrimp, squid, scallops; you name it it was in there. My partner had the half duck with mashed sweet potatoes and vegetables. Crispy on the outside, moist in the inside for the duck. Third course: I must admit I only had a third of my entree because I was saving room for dessert. Now let me tell you about the Lady purse dessert. BEST I HAVE EVER HAD!!!! Picture this truffle chocolate wrapped in a flaky dough and deep fried on a bed of white chocolate and raspberry sauce with a scoop of raspberry sorbert. Warm chocolate oozing out onto the cold white chocolate. Simply devine I wanted seconds but alas no room in the belly. My partner had the cheesecake which was light and fluffy. Great atmosphere! read more

See all

We love this place! The food is yummy and the service is top notch! They have a great menu with lots of tasty dishes. My favorite is the seared scallops over polenta appetizer!!! If you go, you must try it!! They have great wine offerings and great desserts as well. read more

See all