The Pieman Pizza

The food is great here. It was takeout and it was still hot. Always pleasant when I call and they…read morenever make a mistake or forget anything. Plus they are fast. Highly recommend

Service was excellent and we had an outside table on a perfect summer night. We tried the OVI…read morechicken which came with fresh vegetables and choice of potato. I like that the chicken could be prepared Cajun, lemon pepper, or plain grilled. The Cajun had a nice kick of spice and was a generous portion of thin-sliced breast. We also tried the Calves liver and onions which, I'm told, were prepared well and tasted delicious. Service was very attentive and quick.

Another shot of the bar.

The big cheese: your choice of cheese

See all

Best place for a Guinness

Turiello's Pizza House & Restaurant

4.2(198 reviews)

2.1 mi

Outstanding slices, fair prices, great service. As soon as…read morewe walked in, I had a good vibe, family operated, clean, friendly, the smell was reminiscent of my grandmother's kitchen We were only there for a quick lunch and the slices looked great. This is not "craft pizza", which can get annoying when you just want a good slice. They had regular slices and a nice variety with quality toppings including stuffed. My wife and I both ordered a white slice and I also had a rice ball with meat (Arancini). The arancini was the size of a softball, great flavors and fried perfectly. The white pizza was creamy and delicious. Not greasy at all, quality cheese! So perfect, we took two slices to go. I wish I knew about this place when I lived in Rockland They have a great story too, a real organically grown American success story.

Quick stop on our way to Jersey shore. Two great slices and an eggplant sub. All were perfect ! We…read morecame off hours and had the place to ourselves.

See all

Village Pizza

4.6(33 reviews)

2.2 mi

If you don't wanna read: I ABSOLUTELY RECOMMEND!…read more I originally started looking to try a new pizza spot when I noticed our local pizzerias would reheat whole plain pies they had out all day and sell them to us. Needless to say, they tasted stale! Fast forward to finding Village Pizza. Let's talk about the customer service, just for a second. I'm telling you their customer service cannot be matched. I have not had exceptional customer service from an establishment and/or pizzeria on day one that does not wither at some point down the line. Until I started ordering from Village Pizza. Everyone, and I mean everyone I've met has been nothing short of delightful. Which is refreshing if you've tried other pizzerias. From remembering names to remembering orders. I have personally seen this treatment of every person that walks through their door. And! The time they tell you it's gonna be ready, is the actual time. Now on to the food. The garlic knots are flaky and flavorful. Pizza is delicious with or without toppings. It's a thinner crust. It's tasted fresh every time and this has become a regular spot so I can't tell you how many times I've ordered from them. Quality food every time. Quality service every time. I've said it once. I'll say it again. I'm a sucker for consistency. I recommend this place to anyone who will listen. Go pay them a visit. I promise you won't regret it.

Friday, 6/12/2026 at 12:11 PM, we ordered delivery from Village Pizza at 64 S Broadway in Nyack…read more The pizza itself was just average for us -- nothing special, and the crust was dry. Even when you're hungry, it didn't taste delicious. Later that night, we realized the order was missing the one Diet Coke can that we paid for. We were charged $1.80, even though the same soda at a grocery store might cost around 50 cents. I don't know what happened or where the mistake occurred -- whether the restaurant forgot to include the soda or the delivery person didn't bring it -- but the fact is I paid for it and didn't receive it. Today, Saturday 6/13/2026 at 12:27 PM, we called and spoke with Tattiana. She said she would talk to her boss and ask what to do. When I asked when she would call back, she said she didn't know. It shouldn't take a manager to fix a missing $1.80 soda. Any staff member should be able to resolve such a simple issue, but instead it was delayed and ignored. At 3:36 PM, I called again, and no one answered the phone. It felt like they didn't want to pick up because they were avoiding responsibility. I called twice, and I'm not going to keep chasing a can of soda. Until I posted this review, I still didn't receive any call back. This is not about the price -- it's about honesty and giving customers what they paid for. When I called, they could have simply said, "Please come pick it up." Instead, she only said, "I'm so sorry," without offering any solution. I don't like paying for something and not receiving it. As a business, they should be responsive and not ignore customers. Mistakes happen, but they should fix them. When I post this review on Google and Yelp, other customers will read it and take a lesson from this experience. Next time I order from any restaurant, I will check all items upon delivery instead of trusting the delivery person. I will not order from this place again.

Village Pizza of Nyack Menu...

See all

Village Pizza of Nyack Menu...

Tarantella's Pizzaria & Italian Restaurant

3.2(152 reviews)

2.0 mi

impeccable -- exactly what you want from a NY pizza shop. authentic flavors, incredibly cheese to…read moresauce ratio, light yet crispy crust (that's not overcooked) with just a hint of brick over flavor on the undercarriage. super friendly staff, i could have yapped in there all day! check out their outdoor seating and lil pizza window now that spring is here :)

I order a chicken piccota pasta. And got shrimp piccota when i called back to ask them exchange it…read morethey said it was my fault but meanwhile they charged me for a chicken. Very bad service how the Person spoke to me on the phone trying to blame me and complaining meanwhile he read my order back to me as chicken.

Plain slice

Buffalo Chicken Parmigiana Sub

See all

Chicken Parm vodka sandwich

Dutan And Duffy Restauran

4.2(102 reviews)

0.5 mi

Despite having food allergies (shellfish/pork intolerant/lactose intolerant), the restaurant was…read morewilling to make adjustments in the culinary department. I received a six-slice pizza. I have no idea what the size is categorized as or what the price was since I did not pay. This is an old review for Father's Day of 2024. For some reason, I thought this place was called Deanna or Diana Maria, so trying to figure out the correct name took some time. My family enjoys the food here and has been going here for quite some time, too. They enjoy the food here. The vegetables on the pizza and the sauce were not bad. It was just the crust that ruined the experience. Hence, the one-star deduction. The waitress was quite comedic, friendly, and still professional. The other waiter seemed more shy, friendly, and professional. It is mainly the outstanding service, yet I don't know if we received this type of service since my family knows the owner. I would hope everyone receives the same service, haha. Otherwise, the ambiance seems cozy, friendly, and family-style, although it is a bit smaller than I thought it would be. ( :

Brian, Fabio, Heather and Bella thank you so very much for allowing me to celebrate my daughter's 6…read morebday there! Kiddos had a blast and I learned a thing or 2 about pizza making!

Vegetable/Vegetarian Pizza

See all

SALAD SLICE!

Amici Italian Restaurant & Pizzeria

4.0(113 reviews)

1.5 mi

It's always a delicious treat to eat in the lovely restaurant with tablecloths on the tables or…read moretake out a meal. Never disappoints!

First time stopping here and I love it! The people working were so sweet and accommodating. I…read moreordered dinner to go and it was amazing. Everything tasted fresh and I was happy with my whole experience!! Highly recommend

Very nice salad. easily split.

See all

Wall art

Valley Pizza

4.1(37 reviews)

0.4 mi

I normally order the sausage and peppers slice. I usually order whatever pizza is available. I…read morethink the reviewer who said the onions and peppers were raw was because he ordered a regular slice and had them add it. Happened one time to me when they did not have any sausage and peppers available. I also get the pasta fagiola soup. Best pizza especially when u have them heat it up in oven. No flop.

My family and I have been regular patrons of Valley Pizza for over 10 years. Staff are always…read morefriendly and the food is always on point. Today I ordered 2 slices to go on my way home from work. The young man working as the cashier/counter person greeted me as I walked in. He took my order and was attentive, polite and courteous throughout our entire interaction. I was pleasantly surprised, as it has become more and more common when I patronize various shops and stores, that I have been treated as though they are doing me a favor for ringing up and bagging my items. Just wanted to let Valley Pizza know you guys are doing great. Keep it up!

Pizza with onions and peppers

Sliders - skippable

See all

Pizzarena

3.9(73 reviews)

2.0 mi

I am sure most order the pizza and stick with that. I thought the pastas were good and I would…read moreorder again. The gnocchi is underrated. The penne vodka with sausage and mushrooms was delicious. The pizza I thougt was ok. Had the square and it didn't do it for me. Not dying to come back but if I did I wouldn't be upset.

A friend and I stopped for lunch today. We were totally blown away about how phenomenal the food…read morewas. The fried calamari was the best either of us have ever had. The salad was fresh with a variety of veggies. The main dishes were beyond generous and extremely flavorful. The staff checked on us frequently to ensure we had what we needed to enjoy our meals. Will DEFINITELY be going back again. I suggest young and see for yourself. You will not be disappointed.

The new dining room is beautiful and so spacious! Congrats pizzarena on the renovation!

Margarita pizza is life

See all

They really did a beautiful job rebuilding

Bigg Belly

3.9(37 reviews)

0.3 mi

This place is an absolute gem of a spot. There are so many items on the menu that you literarily…read moredont know what to order, but everytime the food hits no matter what you get. I got the Salmon avocado plate. Food was super delicious would give it a 8.5/10. This came with some tomatoes onion, black beans, avocado as well and was a great touch. The salmon was crispy and they had a sweet sauce that they gave that made everything taste even better. The Mac and cheese bites was also super good 8/10 and the curly fries was 9/10 so good and tasty. I also got a tracksuit cake and was 9.5/10 some of the best i ever got. Def chek it out

Came here thinking this place was a breakfast spot, why advertise it if you don't serve it? I ended…read moreup ordering the chicken salad sandwich with fries , for 17 bucks definitely not worth it. The front desk person was nice but more focused on her phone. I would ask her why do you guys have a sign saying serving breakfast? She said we never served breakfast. Anytime I asked her what do you think about this or that, she would say I don't know I only eat the bowls. Why do you work here? I definitely will not be back here, one and done I'm out of here. Please spend your money somewhere else.

Mac and cheese bites. 8/10

See all

Menu

Giovanni's Pizza Restaurant

4.0(52 reviews)

4.0 mi

Food is fresh and delicious. Dave, Serge and Sara go above…read moreand beyond. Always have best service, with smiles . New tables and benches make it like "home" Nothing fancy , just the way I prefer. Come as you are and enjoy a good meal with friends

This is our small little towns favorite spot... of course pizza is great but so many other things…read moreare good , fresh salads and meatball and pasta and I love the eggplant flatbread sandwich so good!!!! The owner and staff are family owned and so nice ....Blauvelt would not be the same with out them

Things to do in Valley Cottage

BEST PIZZA EVER! **Chicken bacon ranch

See all

Buffalo & BBQ Chicken mmmmmmmmmmmmmm!!!!

Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

Hundreds of millions of reviews are posted on Yelp, and our automated recommendation software works in the background to showcase the reviews that it …

7 reviews that are not currently recommended

The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.

William K.

0

1

0

4 years ago

I did not like the pieman. When I sat down with my friends we all asked for Shirley temples they said that they were out. Then we asked for lemonades and I asked for a Caesar salad. I never got the salad. When the waitress came with a pitcher of lemonade, She poured lemonade to everyone except me including the person that never asked for lemonade! Then they came out with the pizza, (it was nothing special) it tasted like every other pizza. The plates they gave us were still wet and had cheese on them, from the people that used them before. Ten minutes later my mom went up to the waiter to ask for to Caesar salads for me and my friend. They put it on the table and we tried it, like everything at the pieman it isn't that good (it tasted weird). This is hard to describe but I will try, inside the dressing it felt like it had a bunch of salt which left a weird feeling in my mouth. This is why I will never go back to the pieman read more

Travis K.

0

6

4

3 years ago

Great service. Great ambiance! Great craft beer selection! Amazing thin crust pizza! Definitely recommend!

Ashley M.

143

16

4

4 years ago

Great pizza! Awesome service! Great atmosphere! Great prices! Great for easy family night dinner.

Max N.

283

3

0

4 years ago

The best of the best. I'll be back forever and ever. Order the wings and a cold one. Enjoy!

Steve B.

Elite 26

81

364

314

4 years ago

After thinking and seeing how much my grandkids liked this place I change my mind to a 4.

Betsy B.

0

7

2

3 years ago

I thought it made a comeback of how it used to be, unfortunately not. Nice staff though

Anthony I.

0

5

1

3 years ago

my favorite place love it great food service and family friendly

The Pieman Pizza - pizza - Updated October 2026

Best of Valley Cottage

People found The Pieman Pizza by searching for…

People who viewed The Pieman Pizza also viewed

Posa Posa

3.6

(253 reviews)

A family favorite when we're all together. They have a great back room to let us all sit together…read moreand not disturb the rest of the restaurant. Pizza is delicious, the stuffed Sicilian is a favorite of mine that I have not seen elsewhere.

I was shopping in the area and starving so decided to come here for a quick bit. I was surprised by…read morehow busy and big the place was. They were so nice in there. They heated up our pizza and brought it to us. Large booths that were spacious. Pizza was unique I loved the stuffed ones. We'll be back!

Nonna Rosa Pizza

4.2

(55 reviews)

Pie was delicious and reasonably priced, friendly folks, great service, and relatively quiet. Love…read morelittle local spots like this!

Popped in here on a whim. It seems so unassuming, sort of off to the side in a parking lot area…read morewith nothing else going on. It was a Thursday evening around 6:30 and we walked in and ordered a cheese pizza to go. It took only about 10 min. BUT had to we come in 5 min later there would have been a wait. Suddenly groups streamed in and I overheard them ordering everything from sandwiches to pasta and different types of non-pizza items. Seeing this in a pizza shop always is a good sign. There is ample seating and everything looked clean. There is a bathroom on site as well. We were starving so ate the pizza on the car ride home and although it was super warm, it was delicious and flavorful. The sauce was a little sweet for my liking but still very good. I would definitely return if in the area.

Turiello's Pizza House & Restaurant

4.2

(198 reviews)

Outstanding slices, fair prices, great service. As soon as…read morewe walked in, I had a good vibe, family operated, clean, friendly, the smell was reminiscent of my grandmother's kitchen We were only there for a quick lunch and the slices looked great. This is not "craft pizza", which can get annoying when you just want a good slice. They had regular slices and a nice variety with quality toppings including stuffed. My wife and I both ordered a white slice and I also had a rice ball with meat (Arancini). The arancini was the size of a softball, great flavors and fried perfectly. The white pizza was creamy and delicious. Not greasy at all, quality cheese! So perfect, we took two slices to go. I wish I knew about this place when I lived in Rockland They have a great story too, a real organically grown American success story.

Quick stop on our way to Jersey shore. Two great slices and an eggplant sub. All were perfect ! We…read morecame off hours and had the place to ourselves.

Stella Luna

4.0

(34 reviews)

Great Pizza. My husband loves their Gluten Free Pizza…read more Reminds me of our Pizza place in the Bronx. Comfortable and friendly.

Best pizza around! I moved to NJ from Mount Vernon, NY 4 years ago. Shall I say we are all Pizza…read moreand Bagel snobs. Still haven't found a bagel place that fits the bill but Stella Luna is the closet slice I can find to authentic slice that I grew up with. I grab a slice on my way home all the time. Every slice is delicious, just depends on my mood. I only write reviews if something is superb in my opinion and it is.

Sorrentos Pizza & Restaurant

3.7

(83 reviews)

Best pizza in Rockland for sure, probably even better than the city. I ask for the crust extra…read morecrispy and they get it right every time. Been coming here my entire life and couldn't recommend it more.

Pizza is some of the best I have had in the area. I no longer live in Rockland but when I come back…read morefrom time to time I make sure to grab a slice!

Bob's Thin Crust Pizza

4.7

(122 reviews)

Tastes even better than it looks! And the sauce, oh the sauce! It's Devine.Best pizza Northvale of…read moreManhattan!!!!

Ordered Pizza here after driving by 100s of times. I'm a sucker for a good thin crust pizza so I…read moreneeded to try Bob's out! Ordered the large Thin crust Margherita pie and it totaled almost $30. I picked the pie up at the restaurant which was simply a kitchen and a pick up counter. The owners were very friendly and thanked me for my business. Once home we tried the pie. The pizza was delicious and you could tell the invite diners were fresh,however not much for for the price. Overall 4 stars for a good experience and food but slightly pricey pie!

Valley Pizza

4.1

(37 reviews)

I normally order the sausage and peppers slice. I usually order whatever pizza is available. I…read morethink the reviewer who said the onions and peppers were raw was because he ordered a regular slice and had them add it. Happened one time to me when they did not have any sausage and peppers available. I also get the pasta fagiola soup. Best pizza especially when u have them heat it up in oven. No flop.

My family and I have been regular patrons of Valley Pizza for over 10 years. Staff are always…read morefriendly and the food is always on point. Today I ordered 2 slices to go on my way home from work. The young man working as the cashier/counter person greeted me as I walked in. He took my order and was attentive, polite and courteous throughout our entire interaction. I was pleasantly surprised, as it has become more and more common when I patronize various shops and stores, that I have been treated as though they are doing me a favor for ringing up and bagging my items. Just wanted to let Valley Pizza know you guys are doing great. Keep it up!

Three Boys From Italy

4.2

(35 reviews)