Despite having food allergies (shellfish/pork intolerant/lactose intolerant), the restaurant was willing to make adjustments in the culinary department. I received a six-slice pizza. I have no idea what the size is categorized as or what the price was since I did not pay. This is an old review for Father's Day of 2024. For some reason, I thought this place was called Deanna or Diana Maria, so trying to figure out the correct name took some time. My family enjoys the food here and has been going here for quite some time, too. They enjoy the food here. The vegetables on the pizza and the sauce were not bad. It was just the crust that ruined the experience. Hence, the one-star deduction. The waitress was quite comedic, friendly, and still professional. The other waiter seemed more shy, friendly, and professional. It is mainly the outstanding service, yet I don't know if we received this type of service since my family knows the owner. I would hope everyone receives the same service, haha. Otherwise, the ambiance seems cozy, friendly, and family-style, although it is a bit smaller than I thought it would be. ( : read more

Dutan And Duffy Restauran - Vegetable/Vegetarian Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Valley Cottage, New York

Brian, Fabio, Heather and Bella thank you so very much for allowing me to celebrate my daughter's 6 bday there! Kiddos had a blast and I learned a thing or 2 about pizza making! read more

See all

The service and owner are wonderful! They are fast, friendly, and remember you if you go there often. Everything we have tried, we love. It's our go to pizza spot. The delivery is reliable. read more

Had the most wonderful late lunch with family. We had the best server ever and the food was very good. We love this place and everyone is friendly. read more

If you want amazing Italian food at the most fair prices visit this place. Hands down the best Mom & Pop shop in Rockland County- anyone can challenge me on that, the food cannot be beat. From starters to dessert here is what I recommend: The Fabio Salad (a salad I created) mixed greens with fresh mozzarella, roasted red peppers, cucumbers and sundried tomatoes in a homemade Balsamic Vinaigrette dressing. A dinner size portion of Chicken Marsala OR Eggplant Rollatini with a side order of Penne Vodka followed by a large Cannoli and cappuccino with a dollop of whipped cream on it. If you prefer something more casual the Margherita Pizza (square) is outstanding and so is the Vegetarian Wrap. Thanks for years of great food guys! xo read more

Such great dinner entrees and the margarita and Vodkarita pies are the best in town!!!! Great, friendly waiter staff and owners. We are regulars here and that won't be changing anytime soon! read more

Had a wonderful catered meal here! For 60 people It was hot and perfect Got chicken parm Penny vodka The most delicious salads and dressing with sides of bread And chicken fingers and fries for kids This place was absolutely delicious and tasted homemade Love this place We also took out for dinner one night and their sauce is very good Great Italian food! read more

Decent pizza. Friendly staff. Definitely a go to spot in the hood. I particularly like that they sell Salad Pizza by the slice. My daughter loves it. read more

Their margaritas pizza is the bomb. The pork chops are enormous. Everything we have ordered has been made fresh from soup to cannoli's or cheesecake they cook it all fresh. read more

I love coming to Dee Maria's be it for a quick pizza or a delicious dinner. The food is not only fresh & delicious but the portions are generous! The friendly service from William, Diana, Courtney, Heather & kind celebratory gestures from Brian or Fabio...be it with a free cheesy garlic bread, Tartufo ice cream or glass of wine, on a birthday or Anniversary or some other special milestone are a special touch that makes one feel valued & keeps us returning! The ambiance is a great family home away from home feel, whether we stop daily, weekly or straight from the airport after a getaway...Service with a smile is what we always get! They also have great catering services, wonderful for those special occasions when you just want to celebrate without the fuss of having to cook, yet compromise nothing! I'm thankful for Dee Maria's & their wonderful staff! read more

Terrible pizza, they will give you an old one! TWICE I got a pie that had obviously been sitting for a long time. TWO separate times! read more

We live nearby and Dee Maria's has been one of our go to takeout spots for years. The food is great but something typically seems to go wrong with our orders. We usually get the chicken cutlet and eggplant parmesan special. The chicken is topped with the eggplant and it's so good! It comes with a side of pasta, bread, and a salad. One special is plenty to split between two people. The only issue we had is that there was very little sauce on the pasta. Last time we ordered we also had the fried calamari appetizer. And while it's likely frozen, they do a great job seasoning it. Their sauce is also very tasty. We will definitely continue to occasionally take out from Dee Maria's. read more

Dutan And Duffy Restauran - a plate of spaghetti and meat - Pizza Near Me - Valley Cottage, New York

See all

The best Italian food I've ever had is at Dee Maria's. I have been going there since the 1990s and they have ALWAYS had the best eggplant parm ever. Its a great place for a nice family dinner. We love it so much that we use them to cater all of our family parties. You cannot beat the Chicken Parm and Eggplant Rolletini. The staff is incredibly friendly and the service is top notch. They truly care about their customers. Make sure to try the Margherita pizza, too. read more

Slices are delicious and huge! The toasted eggplant hero is one of my favorite sandwiches in the area

This is the pizza place for our house. We dont even say 'do want so and so' or whatever. Dee Maria pizza is the best pizza in the area. Its thin crust with just the right amount of ratio of cheese/sauce/crust. Cheese is my favorite and I am just happy with this simple, delectable treat. My kids love their cannolis too! read more

STILL has to be the best pizza in Rockland County. We always order to take out. That way it's hot and ready to eat. Brian is now the owner and he must have the title of "MASTER PIZZA MAKER". He and his staff consistently exceed expectations. Cheese, chicken cutlets, margarita pie, garlic knots, all tied together with the best marinara sauce there is. Order in for take out, order for deliver, or eat in. The place is a treat. read more

So I get it you're the only show in town... But come on. Having grown up in VC yet being fortunate to live a great number if other places, all I can say is epic fail. The orders are always wrong and there is no care taken in the food. Other than a random good slice of pizza the rest of the food is sub par and over priced. I will never go back, I do not care if I have to drive thirty minutes I'll go elsewhere. It is sad that a food establishment thinks you can just serve up garbage. Tonight's order was messed up twice, drive back to correct the first mistake to find upon return there was another error. My first grilled chicken Caesar salad was inedible it was DRENCHED in dressing. The second one came with hot chicken cutlet on top rather than grilled chicken. So either way I end up with soggy ten dollar salad. Fail fail fail. Never again. read more

Dutan And Duffy Restauran - Nasty brown lettuce with a bottle of dressing. Want some...ewwww - Pizza Near Me - Valley Cottage, New York

I have been ordering pizza from Dee Maria's since the onset of the pandemic. The staff is wonderful as well as competent. The pizza is fresh as well as delicious! read more

Dee Maria's Is my # 1 pizza place to go to here in Rockland county! The selection of specialty slices is amazing Whole Wheat Margarita slice-Crispy and delish San Marzano Slice- TO DIE FOR!!! A MUST GET!! Salad Slice- LIKE NO OTHER topped with spinach & tomato Standard Slice- Perfect balance of crispy crust to cheese & sauce ratio Many more, Just to many to name! Specialty Rolls all A+++ Chicken Marsala Chicken Parmesan Eggplant Parmesan Or anything you request to be made in roll form Entrees are a home run as well, all the pasta dishes are fresh and come out piping hot! Such a variety. If you are in Rockland or just visiting it is worth the trip to Valley Cottage to give them a try! read more

Dutan And Duffy Restauran - SALAD SLICE! - Pizza Near Me - Valley Cottage, New York

See all

I've been going to this pizzeria for years now and can confidently say that they're my go to spot for anything and all things pizza in Rockland. It's a family owned business and they make sure the service is no less than stellar. The atmosphere is very cozy and makes you feel right at home. They can definitely seat larger parties with the additional space in the back of the restaurant. Their full pies are a little on the pricey side but they're definitely worth it. I've ordered from other places in the area but nothing beats the taste of Deemaria's. They give you huge quality slices. I look forward to grabbing a slice every time I come home from school. It's a good place to catch up with your friends or even have a casual pizza date. read more

Dutan And Duffy Restauran - Very large regular slices! - Pizza Near Me - Valley Cottage, New York

I strenuously recommend the whole wheat crusted roasted veggie pie. Nothing short of amazing. A very friendly atmosphere with great people. Everything here is very good. While I feel their garlic knots ate unremarkable, they are still good, and affordable, and come with a side of sauce. Don't forget dessert -- while they don't make it all themselves, the Napoleon's are a sin to miss, and their ices come from Arturo's of Arthur Ave. read more

See all

I've been going to Dee Maria's for years and it has good pizza, especially if you're planning something. I must say the employees take their time with the food and it tastes delightful. read more

My husband and I threw a housewarming party in our new home and we both agreed our favorite food growing up was from DeeMaria's so we decided to have them cater our party. When i tell you the food was amazing i mean every single guest could not stop talking about the food. It was just so good. I honestly had 6 guests take food home! they all wanted a plate with some of everything. Its the amazing flavors and details that sets them apart from the rest. The chicken cutlet and the eggplant are made super thin its like butter! The flavors in their gravy aka sauce - just phenomenal! Cant wait for my next party to order from them again. As always thank you to Patsy and the crew at DeeMaria's. read more

I have been going to this resturant for a long time . their chicken parm the best. I had issue one time and Brian the owner was so accommodating and replaced the food for us . I recommend this restaurant and you'll satisfy with any meal you get on dine in. read more

Best Italian restaurant in Rockland. Been eating here and using catering since 1981!!!!

I am so disappointed:( I ordered two margarita pies Well done for pick up around 5 . I got there and waited til almost 6 to get home and pizza was doughy and undercooked :(( I loved there pizza and have been going there for 20+years . I don't think I will return read more

See all

Food was good but only one waitress for a Friday night and non attentive. Not sure about return.

NY pizza snob here. Dee Marias is the best around. This is not a close call. I'm generally the plain-slice type, but DM's margherita pie puts all others to shame if you want thin. And the Brooklyn slice is sublime for a thick crust. read more

I have to express how happy I am with all of the staff and the delicious meals that I have ordered and then delivered to my mom over the last 3 weeks. She has been locked into the house with minimal contact and I'm in Florida I wanted to do something for her to make her smile and I ordered the chicken francese one week and the following week I ordered the chicken marsala both were according to her better than going out to a restaurant. Thank you so very much for being there and being available and providing the quality foods such quality service and making her so happy. I can't wait to come up this summer walk in the door shake your hands and thank you in person you guys truly are the best and if I can't be up there for her to make it I'm really glad that you were able to do it for me bless your heart please stay safe read more

Tried a couple of their speciality pizzas as well as the plain, plain was surprisingly my favorite. I am a huge pizza snob and I could taste that they used good quality ingredients on their pizza. The dough was chewy and fresh and the place is always packed during the evening. I find it weird that they close on Monday's though! read more

This pizza blows my balls off every single time. And the guy who runs the joint has a pair a legs on him that you have to see to believe. If you like great pizza and a set of legs that belong on a thoroughbred race horse, Dee Maria's is the place to go. A+ every time read more

This place doesn't even deserve a star! Gross. Nasty. They try to pass anything off for food. read more

Dutan And Duffy Restauran - Mm delicious? I think NOT! Can I get some lettuce with that dressing? Disgusting. - Pizza Near Me - Valley Cottage, New York

See all

We have been going here since moving in to the area 8 years ago. The service and food has gone downhill and taken Dee Maria's off our list of Pizza places. The last 4-5 experiences have been terrible. Each time we have ordered delivery, the wait time was too long and the pizza has come to us cold, even to the point we had to microwave it before eating. This last time we tried pick-up, hoping it would be better, but it was not. The pizza has changed and tastes very "bready" and the calamari we had was like rubber. We kept going back hoping that it was just an off night but have now given up. We are truly sorry as this was always our "go-to" place for good pizza, but has recently lost it's touch. read more

Who would imagine that the best pizza and pasta joint in the area will be in Valley Cottage? All pastas I ate here so far were excellent and they really know how to make a perfect Margherita Pizza. I thought giving them a 4 star because of the service but the food is so good so I just decided to suck it up. Keep in mind that if you order in, the delivery may take some time. You may not be able to get through to them and they confuse orders sometimes otherwise just enjoy your food! read more

I just moved into the area and my boyfriend and I decided to check this place out. We called up to order and when my boyfriend was giving his credit card information the guy on the phone kept pushing for him to put the tip on the card ahead of time. My boyfriend kept telling him he would do it when the pizza arrived (he likes to check to make sure everything is there, and how we ordered it, since sometimes the driver mis-handles things. But especially depending on time!). But the person on the phone kept PUSHING to tip now, instead of later. My boyfriend is a patient guy but this really upset him. At least 2 minutes was wasted on this guy trying to get him to tip now. I'm not sure if they've had a problem with it before or what, but not a good way to try to get us to come back. It looks like a lot of people order online which might be a better option. Coming from living in New Jersey the pizza was delicious, re-heated well the next day too. My boyfriend is REALLY picky with pizza and enjoyed it. The garlic bread was delicious and fries were to die for. Their BBQ and honey mustard was good too. I feel like chicken sandwhich was a little 'tough' but was okay. Honestly, if the person on the phone hadn't of pushed us so much this would have been a minimum 4-star review. I own a small business myself, and most of my income from it is tip so I completely understand the phone person, who hell- may have been the driver himself wanting a good or garenteed tip, but one of the biggest rules of customer service is you don't push it. Big fail on their part. We'll maybe try one more time, online. But callers beware. read more

I wish there was a way to give no stars. Officially done with DeeMarias. The girl at the counter has such a bad attitude n is so rude all the time n over the phone she sounds like she just couldn't care and writes the orders wrong ever time we order we have to call them to fix it! Tonight I at there we ordered two strumbolies n 3 slices of pizza. After sitting for almost 30 min the Stromboli finally came out and it took another 10 minuets for the Pizza to come out. 40 min for 3 slices!! placed an order to go n get home n the pizza is burnt on the bottom the service is horrible n I'm over it. read more

Best margarita pizza ever!! Definitely best in rockland! They make it in whole wheat also! Friendly and welcoming staff who are always happy to see you! read more

Showed up late on a Saturday night for pizza and the restaurant still had some customers in the dining rooms. We ordered two regular slices and they were great: enormous and crispy. We also ordered a small salad pizza. It was a thin crust layered with spinach, Parmesan cheese, onions, plum tomatoes, minced garlic and oil. It was sooo tasty and light. I had to bring the leftover home and my fridge smells like fresh bruschetta now! I will definitely go back. read more

Dutan And Duffy Restauran - Small Salad Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Valley Cottage, New York

The eggplant with gorgonzola is wonderful . It does not have a name so you have to order it by it's menu number, #1 hero

They catered my son's birthday party for us and did a fantastic job. The food was delicious, ready on time and the portion sizes were huge. Would definitely recommend! read more