It is a lovely place with homey common areas, interesting history in each room, and super-friendly…read morestaff. Our happy hour drinks at the Buffalo Bill Bar were excellent, with great conversations with locals. Kudos to Jordan for being an excellent bartender. My only regret was that there no place to enjoy a cigar, but that is my personal failing, I'm sure they're serving the majority of their guests interests with their strict nonsmoking policy.

The charm of this historic hotel is amazing. So many lovely aspects and in general, a very…read morecomfortable sleeping room. Sadly, many aspects were amiss. First, was told the week prior when I called that the bar would be open. It wasn't. Also, the breakfast was very atrocious. My frittata was burned and had a "shoe leather" look to it and the bacon included within was completely not cooked. Finally - the sleeping room had no TV. I don't think I have had a room without a TV since a small motor inn that I stayed in, in Delores, CO, in 1974. Really odd that this would never be mentioned on the room description.

The room was clean, quiet, and the bed was comfortable. The ladies at the front desk were friendly…read more The continental breakfast had a lot of options, it was clean, and the employee working it was working hard to keep it that way. The hotel is within a short walk to the Dash In (which is the favorite fast food place of the locals), the Winchester (a favorite nice steakhouse), and an Ice Cream shop/mini golf place (great for kids). Bonus: They put out warm cookies in the lobby that you can smell all the way from the top floor hallway.

This is such a welcoming spot and they are pet friendly. We were glad to have a clean and quiet…read moreplace to land on our road trip. It's a safe location and the rooms are spacious and some had balconies available. The staff is kind and care about making sure that a smooth experience is provided. They serve breakfast if you are inclined in the morning and encourage a cup of coffee to go.

If you are visiting Buffalo, Wyoming, staying at the Historic Occidental Hotel is an absolute must…read more The moment you walk through the doors, it honestly feels like stepping back into the Old West. The hotel is beautifully preserved with so much authentic character, history, and charm everywhere you look. We loved exploring the historic saloon, antique decor, creaky wooden floors, and all the incredible stories connected to the hotel. It was amazing knowing legends like Buffalo Bill Cody, Calamity Jane, Teddy Roosevelt, Butch Cassidy, and the Sundance Kid all spent time here. You can truly feel the history throughout the building. The staff was friendly, welcoming, and passionate about the hotel's history, which made the experience even better. The atmosphere was cozy, unique, and unlike any modern hotel experience. We also really enjoyed walking around downtown Buffalo since the hotel is perfectly located right in the heart of town. If you love history, road trips, Western culture, or unique travel experiences, this place is unforgettable. The Historic Occidental Hotel is more than just a hotel -- it's a true Wyoming experience and one of the coolest historic places we've ever visited. Highly recommend! Check out our video on our socials @reessroots

We sat at the bar for 18 minutes before anyone spoke to us. The couple that came in after us and…read moresat at a table was helped before us. The bartender never acknowledged us. We had to get our own menu. Three more employees came by and finally one waited on us. We ordered wings and it took forever to get them. The waitress flung them in front of us and said "here's your wings". No plates, no napkins. There were probably not even 1 pound of wings in the basket. The menu said 2 pounds. No one ever came to see how our food was or if we needed anything else, like another drink. We had to ask to get napkins and that seemed to be a chore for her. After finishing our food, the bartender walked by three times looking at the empty basket but never asking if we needed anything or taking the basket away. We finally got his attention, which wasn't easy, to get our ticket.

I am a Marriott gold member and have found some Marriott properties to be pretty indifferent to…read moreour loyalty. Well this property is not one of those. Sandra up graded us to a suite, thanked us for our loyalty, was in route to our room to drop off extra pillows when we arrived. Sandra had great restaurant recommendations and the hotel has a list in the lobby for your use in the car. Our room and the entire hotel smelled clean and with a hint of citrus. Hotel is either quite new or is getting a remodel. Either way great space and great staff.

Would definitely stay here again - hotel is definitely older but everything looked super clean…read more The highlight of the trip was the young front desk, lady when I checked in yesterday around 3 PM. She had so much energy and immediately jumped up to help. And made a point to greet every single person that walked by. I wish I would have gotten her name to properly give her her credit, but she had a shorter brownIsh hair.

We love visiting the quaint city of Story every July and Story Pines Inn is our first stop! We…read moreenjoy chatting with Paula and hearing about the current wildlife around Story! Cleanest, most accommodating place we've ever stayed in!! A true 5 Star rating at best!!!!

Everything was clean, parking was very easy, and the room was very comfortable. There was a nice…read moreoutdoor sitting area and the motel is in a good location.

Looking at the pictures, not all rooms are the same. We happened to get a room that was 2 "single"…read morerooms merged into one. That means, 2 TV's, 2 bathrooms and a lot of space.

We stayed in a condo 12/23-12/26 2024. it was very clean,…read morecomfortable and awesome!! highly recommend this Inn. Very friendly and accommodating staff. Very reasonably priced.

Pleasantly surprised with the food. The sirloin was…read more"excellent." The Brisket was so good it didn't need bread or bbq sauce. The vegetables seemed fresh and tasted great as well. We will DEFINITELY be back!! The atmosphere was great, friendly staff and great cabin decor. HIGHLY RECOMMEND

Newly opened, I went with my Mother in Law who was pleased to see this local lodge back opened…read more Our party was 3 adults and 2 children for an afternoon lunch. Service was excellent. Decor is lodge style with heavy furniture. My wife had the steak sandwich with Chimi churri sauce. Served on a soft roll with fries. The meat was a bit tough and had not been seasoned well. Pretty heavy on the grease, and light on the Chimi churri. I had the Dearhaven Burger, which was thick, and well flavored. A dijon.mayo sauce was good and not overpowering. Swiss cheese, mushrooms and onions. Very light on the mushrooms as I couldn't find them until I pulled back the cheese a bit. Kids burgers were big and good. Probably could have shared one kids burger between my 4 and 6 year old. The fries were EXCELLENT. Looks as though they are using the Chimi Churri on the fries...it worked well. Don't let the 3 stars make you discount the place. I will be back as I like local joints and the food was good for the area. Being from the SF Bay Area we get spoiled with our dining options.

Great Rustic Lodge experience!! Everyone was so friendly! The meals were hearty and good. The…read moreBighorn Burger & French Dip are worthy.

Man bun bartender is either too cool for school or just rude. Either way, I felt like we were…read morebothering him by sitting at the bar he was tending. Asked if WiFi was public and he mumbled something and gave me a piece of paper with the password, writing was illegible and I couldn't connect. I needed to get in touch with my elderly parents. He did not care. We quickly left (as to not be a bother anymore) and went 3 miles up the road to Bear Lodge where we had a great time with friendly bartenders that didn't make us feel unwelcome; and I was able to connect with my folks.

Kenny and Christa are the lovely owners of this establishment, and they are true delight! Very…read moreclean rooms, very comfortable and homey atmosphere. Beautiful sitting area outside in the trees with a gazebo, tables and chairs. Breakfast is at a large table for all guests to sit down and meet/visit with over the most AMAZING home cooked farm-to-table food! They even sat down with us and we had a great conversation before we left on the last leg of our long motorcycle trip. We will most definitely be back to support this down to earth and hard working couple. Highly Recommend!!!

Great breakfast, super clean, and the new owners are amazing!!!! Fun town to spend the night inread more

Hotel was exceptionally clean. Bed is very comfortable. Water pressure for shower was good. Slept…read morebetter there than I do at home. Very quiet, no doors slamming when guests come and go. The front desk ladies Tracy and Nicole were so hospitable and informative. Breakfast was good and they provide free cookies and ice cream. Highly recommend this hotel.

Nicki (not sure of spelling) was amazing, helpful, pleasant and went out of her way to make sure…read moreyou were happy! Rooms were clean and was a great nights sleep after a loooong drive ! Nice and quiet! Will definitely return when in WY!