Service was excellent. Food was better. Little bar and grill in Sheridan Wyoming that ROCKS. There food is screamingly good, (new word, screamingly), because it is so good I just want to scream it out. The atmosphere is totally great. Loud and boisterous, I mean it's a bar, what do you expect? I loved my server, very nice, very attentive. If you are in Sheridan, I highly recommend this place. read more

See all

Food was pretty average, I got the fried fish and shrimp. Service was great and friendly. Vibe was pretty chill. Good place to grab drinks and hang out. read more

Pony Grill and Bar - Bars Near Me - Sheridan, Wyoming

Downtown location easy to park. Lots of tables. The menu had many options. We had a mouthwatering burger and deep friend green beens. The service was friendly and excellent. Lots of TV to be able to watch the World Series. Good Vibe, good food, and a good time! read more

Pony Grill and Bar - Mouth watering burger! - Bars Near Me - Sheridan, Wyoming

The service was AMAZING! Gabriel was jus5t one of those naturally competent, helpful servers who made your experience so much better than expected. The food was terrific thanks to Gabriel's selection choices. We would return...but ask for Gabriel if possible. read more

Pony Grill and Bar - Bars Near Me - Sheridan, Wyoming

A very Wyoming style casual, friendly, and energetic bar and grill. Just had a casual pleasant "business" lunch here. The server was happy, friendly, and fast. The $16 BBQ Beef Brisket was pretty good, the beef brisket is house made with a lovely nice smoky flavor. Wish had just a tad more meat cause it was delicious. Side salad was very fresh, green, and sizable if you're trying to watch your figure like me. Place was lively and busy on a weekday at lunch, but food still came out relatively fast. read more

We had a wonderful experience. The food was excellent. I had the steak salad-half and it was larger than I expected. My guy had the Philly with potato salad and really enjoyed it. The service was the best, we had several servers check on us during our meal. We sat on the covered patio and it was a great day. read more

See all

Can I give Sheridan some praise for having an amazing bar and grill? Why yes, yes I can and this place was thee place to stop after a LONG day of driving! Sat inside since we were a larger group (they do have outside seating so maybe next time). TV's everywhere with sports and other options. Easy going atmosphere and music playing. Waitress took our orders and food was out pretty quickly. Definitely recommend the BLT (get me that bacon LOL)! read more

See all

We were seated and given our drinks pretty quickly but then...30 minutes before we got our order taken (after I went and found someone) and now, another half hour later, still no food... stay posted... Ok, I just went and asked again and I was yelled at by the manager that we have only been waiting for 1/2 hour for our order...not taking into account the 1/2 hour we waited to have our order taken...guess at the Pony the customer IS NOT always right. Last update: Arrived: 11:30 Order taken: 12:00 Adult meals arrived: 12:36 Children meals arrived: 12:48 Food quality: fair to poor read more

We stopped here on our road trip to grab lunch, and it was a nice casual spot. Tried the Santa Fe grilled chicken sandwich w homemade chips and the queso beef burrito w chips & salsa. Both were ok, queso burrito was tasty but seemed to have just a small amount of queso in it, and they gave us fries instead of chips & salsa. We were hungry so we didn't ask to correct it. Bonus was that we were seated near a TV that was playing random "fail" clips mostly involving animals doing funny things to people, so at least we were entertained. ‍ read more

Pony Grill and Bar - Queso beef burrito w fries - Bars Near Me - Sheridan, Wyoming

See all

This is a well established place off of main st. Across from the post office, we came for dinner and a brew.. we chose to sit on the covered deck to get some fresh air.. Our server adjusted the fan to keep the ever present summer flies at bay. I ordered a burger that was supposed to be cooked medium but was more like medium well but still tasted good and wasn't dried out. The wife had fish and shrimp both of us chose the house potato chips that were crispy and seasoned well. Nice place to stop by if you're in the area and the prices aren't ridiculous like some other place on Main Street. read more

The food here is pretty good. Had a tuna melt and wife had the Buffalo chicken salad. Good selections, portions, great service. We will be back. read more

Stopped in for dinner and had the meatball sub and the reuben with soup as our sides. The tomato bisque was outstanding as well as the very lean reuben! Server, Victoria, was a joy and gave great recommendations. read more

Pony Grill and Bar - Reuben sandwich - Bars Near Me - Sheridan, Wyoming

Philly Cheese was phenomenal! The service was spot on and the place was clean and calm! We will definitely tell our friends and return every time we are in town! Y'all rock!!!! read more

This will be an uncharacteristically boring review to match my limited time in Sheridan, WY. Don't be fooled by the three stars; I actually liked it here and would return. Great, friendly service and hopping on Friday night, which is quite the contrast to everything around it, which was as quiet and barren as an abandoned ghost town in Tombstone, AZ. I ordered the homemade creamy chicken noodle soup, which was the thickest soup I've ever had in my life, but it was good on a cold and icy night. A blue cheese and bacon half-pound steak burger followed, which was dry but overall was decent, with a generous side of fries included. Simply put, this is a happening downtown bar that offers pretty standard bar food with solid service. I'm sure if I was there I to drink, I'd give it a higher review, but I was only there for a quick dinner. Yawn. Even I'M bored by my review, and I wrote it. read more

My family of 5 came on an early Wednesday evening. All of the staff members we encountered were awesome. Friendly, fast and always checking on us. Food was delicious. We would come again. Dom R. was very nice. We ate on the patio and it was beautiful. read more

Passing thru on our way from Ralid City SD to Bozeman MT. Service was fabulous and friendly. The salads were very fresh and large portions. Fried shrimp was perfectly breaded and fried, they tasted delicious. Staff is so friendly, efficient and welcoming. read more

The food is to be expected; the menu is mainly fried foods which have a familiar taste. The waitresses are sweet and the food comes out fast. If you sit inside, the restaurant can get kind of noisy. But they do play sports on all tvs so you can watch any game any time. An easy dinner or lunch from a predictable spot that will be an expected meal. read more

See all

We had dinner here on a driving vacation through the upper plains states. The food was good, service was excellent. The overall ambiance is pub bistro sort of a place. If we lived in Sheridan, we'd certainly come back here often. read more

We waited for 30 minutes to get seated and then find out they're putting us in the oven of a patio with hardly any airflow. It would've been nice to have known that before we had to wait that long. We've been out in the hot sun all day and were looking forward to sitting down in an air conditioned place. Also the woman who was going to be our server was pretty rude when we asked if we could be seated inside. We ended up leaving. Super disappointing. We've never been treated like that before at this restaurant. read more

Food is always great- servers very attentive, chef very creative. Love to sit on the deck and enjoy Wyoming's fake spring.

Amazing hard working staff, with great food! Would recommend this place and would come back if I'm back in the area.

We were looking for a place to watch a Utah Jazz playoff game. Checked Yelp and Google and came up with the Pony Bar & Grill. Most of the bad reviews we saw were in relation to the service. We ordered the nachos for an appetizer. I ordered the prime rib sandwich no bun for dinner with a side of coleslaw. Prime rib was ok. Service was great and the drinks were flowing. Who doesn't love a bottomless ice tea! Would come back. Should try the burger next time! read more

Pony Grill and Bar - Prime rib sandwhich - Bars Near Me - Sheridan, Wyoming

See all

Went here for lunch today and had their Shrimp Po Boy special. They sautéed the shrimp in a sauce which had a little bit of Cajun-type kick to it. Excellent lunch. I'll have to go back and try dinner with a cold beer at some point when I'm back in Sheridan. read more

Always solidly decent. It's a small bar and grille, the food is good, the service is good.

Wonderful - got stuck in Sheridan and had great food - they even recommended a breakfast option (Silver Spur) for the next morning and it was incredible too! read more

Frisco burger and fries were excellent. Try the fried pickles and bp. Great stop after a travel day and hungry. Went great with the cold beer. read more

The fried pickles and service was good but otherwise the food was pretty bad. Chips were stale, meat was cold and most things came with a mysterious nacho cheese sauce. read more

The Buffalo Wings from the new owners are terrible. I've tried them 3 different times and they still aren't as good as the old pony wings. Please go back to Frank's Red hot. read more

Food tasted great, but the quantity wasn't great. Wings were small, order of fries was maybe a handful at most, and the beer on tap wasn't cold. read more

Great food, great service! I end up eating here every time I'm in Sheridan. I try something different every time and I have never been disappointed. read more

Food was great! Wasn't expecting it to be as good as it was being a bar & grill. The potato salad is worth getting! A great variety of food. Service was fast as well. read more

The Pony is a great place that has been a Sheridan staple forever. The steak sandwich is the best, the deck is great for summertime eating, and they're always busy. I'd recommend stopping here if you without kids and looking for a place to enjoy a little fresh air or classic traditions read more

We ordered the Rueben and the Buffalo chicken wrap. Both were good, warm, and filling. The fries were crispy which was a plus - we also got our food super quickly (10mins after we ordered). Sitting on the porch and drinking a huckleberry Moscow mule was nice. read more

Restaurant is open and busy! The food is fantastic, as is the beer. The wait staff was friendly and answered any questions we had. The Santa Fe Chicken was delicious. Two of my kids had the patty melt and ate the entire thing! Fried pickles appetizer and friend green beans appetizer were both delicious and different. The pickles were whole spears. Fries were awesome too and served with a side of ranch. Glad we stopped in our our trek back home from our road trip vacation. read more

We come to Sheridan every year for Leather Week and always hit the Pony at least once per trip. Great place!

We picked this restaurant when headed back to Texas from Montana. You never know what you'll find when trying a new place and it's not common you find place where you say, "This is where we'll come every time we come through this town." We said that about this place. My wife, four kids and I were all impressed with the atmosphere, the kind service and the wonderful classic American cuisine. read more

We went in an hour before closing but still got great service and great food. Not the full menu but bar food; I only wish they had more beef choices. The wings and quesadillas were tasty and filling. The place had a friendly vibe. I'd hang out there if passing through again. read more

First time passing through the area. Great place and glad we stopped. I had the Cowboy burger which was messy and delicious! My wife had the Sirloin salad which she thoroughly enjoyed. We ordered a side of onion rings and they were very good. The place was a bit loud which was the sign of a good crowd having a good time. Chris Le Doux poster on the wall was a nice touch to fun decor. Stop in and enjoy! read more

Service was excellent I had the steak sandwich and my wife had the fish and chips Atmosphere was relaxing Very nice place to go for an enjoyable evening Highly recommend read more

Found this gem while walking around downtown Sheridan, great choice. Six of us seated quickly, amazing choices in the menu, and all of us were pleased. Food came out quickly, and reasonable prices. Brisket, Santa Fe chicken sandwich, wings.....all great! Relaxed atmosphere, friendly wait staff, don't miss this place! read more