Oh, Borealis.
I really, really, really wanted to love this place. They're committed to providing a local and sustainable dining experience to their customers, which is something I definitely respect. It has great decor and killer branding. The menu always looks amazing, and judging by the full patio in the summer months -- it's a popular spot to sit and sip some white wine with 20-30 of your closest girlfriends.
We live nearby, so we end up passing it 3-4 times a day. After much waiting, I was so excited to try Borealis that we ended up going for an anniversary. It fell on a Wednesday, which seemed pretty fantastic because they have "Wednesday Date Night" offers with a shared appetizer, choice of two mains, and a choice of two desserts for $49.
In retrospect, I'm not sure that it was a great idea to go on a Wednesday after all -- and I'm kind of hoping that our experience had more to do with it being busy or the chefs "mailing it in" because the menu was a date-night special.
We had bruschetta as an appetizer, and something just tasted... off. We're both usually big fans, but neither of us could eat more than half a slice. For dinner, our mains were decent, but not great. I know that's not an excellent description, but I think we were both expecting something with more of a taste to it. Instead, everything was kind of dry and disappointing. All in all, our experience was kind of "meh." We were both thinking that we could have made the same dinner at home, which is a nice nod to simple cooking styles, I guess -- but also not how you want to feel on date night. We were hoping the date night menu would give us a good idea of the kind of menu, ambiance, and experience we could expect from Borealis in the future, but instead we walked away talking about how glad we were we hadn't paid full price for our dinner. We could have had like... 12 sad frozen pizzas for that $49. Or like, 4 decent pizzas from market fresh.
With that said, the wine list and dessert was pretty good. We had a bottle of Merlot and ended up ordering extra dessert (little jars of different seasonal cakes and a cobbler), so absolutely no complaints there.
I actually feel really guilty about not loving this place, but it just seems like it could do so much better. If we end up trying again I'll come back and update this review, but it doesn't seem likely. Sorry this review is kind of a downer! I know a lot of people do like it here, but maybe check out a night that isn't Wednesday if you're going to try Borealis for the first time. read more