Today we had a party for my grand daughter.I can't say enough nice things about the staff from the waitresses to the kitchen staff. I wish I could remember specific names but the two waitresses we had were exceptional.I highly recommend this etablishment for anyone wanting to have a birthday party etc. Everything was great, thank you for a wonderful time. Bonnie and Maleah Nelson read more

What a cute place! The ambiance was so fun and the food was just as good! I had the spinach ricotta pizza and it was delicious!! The food came out fast and our waitress was very friendly and helpful. We left after closing time but they opened the fudge counter so we could buy some. I'd love to come back here again! read more

Not too happy with this place. This is based on take out only. We came to pick up a large pizza we ordered. It was over $32.00! That's ridiculous for a pizza! These places are getting greedy when it doesn't cost no where near that to make a pizza. Well we got one that was a suppreme We placed the order and arrived early so I paid and waited till it was done. For having everything on the pizza there was no flavor or taste at all I don't know if it's because there was no seasoning or what. Plus when we got the credit statement and they don't give a receipt when it's to go apparently. The girl added a $5.00 tip! I never authorized $5.00 for a tip when she did nothing? I Called right away and told someone that answered. She told me she'd get back to me. She did was follow through and called me back, whoever she talked to said they would give the tip back on the charge card.. Like it was no big deal. I just wonder if the one who did it still has a job! It's one of the biggest scams right now That employees are doing. It happened in NC too not to me but to someone I know. Make sure you don't get charged more wherever you go for take out Can you imagine they get almost $40 for a pizza that maybe a 16" at the most. Besides not likinf it at all. I would understand if it was just one person saying they don't like it but all 3 of us didn't like it. I'm sorry I would not recommend this place read more

Boomerang Pizza Kitchen is a great place to grab a pizza and enjoy some time with friends. The service is friendly and the ambiance is pleasant enough. I would definitely recommend here. read more

Boomerang Pizza Kitchen - Pizza Near Me - Milton, Florida

Ordered a pizza to go and Caprese salad. Both were delicious. We got meat lovers with garlic butter on crust. I added some balsamic glaze to Caprese. Friendly when we picked it up. Always clean inside. read more

See all

What a charming small town spot! The Boomerang Pizza Kitchen is part gift shop, part restaurant, and part old timey looking malt shop style place. We had a buffalo chicken calzone and a pizza with pepperoni and mushrooms. Both items were good and we really enjoyed them, for dessert one friend got a brownie with ice cream, which was thoroughly enjoyed, and I had a blueberry bread pudding that was just ok. All in all, I hope to visit again soon! read more

See all

After traveling in from Louisiana and setting up camp at the local KOA we decided to look at grabbing a pizza at a local establishment in Milton. This turned out to be a good decision - we arrived and was immediately seated and greeted by our amazing server Kaitlyn, she was very busy with other customers but took the time to welcome us and go over a few recommendations while getting our drink orders. This is a pretty cool restaurant the pizza dining area is in the back of the restaurant after you walk through what appears to be several other interesting businesses (I didn't ask so for all I know they all operate as one business). We started with an order of cheesy garlic bread with marinara sauce for dipping it was really good, then came the delicious pizza served piping hot from the oven (pepperoni, italian sausage, extra cheese cooked crispy) this was a great pizza, the crust, sauce and fresh ingredients exceeded our expectations and all came at a reasonable price. The service here is nothing less than exceptional this is a beautifully decorated restaurant that I highly recommend and would definitely return to if back in the area... read more

See all

Amazing Pizza and Calzones! I always go for my birthday and Father's Day Dinner !!!!!

If I could vote 0 stars I would absolutely terrible my pizza was burnt and cold when I first got it and the service was just rude the place is ok I would only go back for the gift shop!! read more

Perfect casual date night spot! Loved the retro feel and laid back, friendly atmosphere. Highly recommend the Thai Chicken Pizza! We will be back. read more

the pizza here is so delicious - we make this a regular dining stop & they never disappoint and we had the sweetest waitress - Brianna - make sure you ask for her read more

Today I ordered a small pizza "to go' on my way to work. I was unable to enjoy the pizza because it was not cut all the way through. I arrived at work irritated, messy, and still hungry. read more

This was my first time here and they did not disappoint. Great thin crust pizza. Loved the sauce.

Cool place... Good food! Great cookies!! Nice folks. Beer is cold! Nice variety of food/bev. Great service. Clean. read more

Boomerang Pizza Kitchen - Pizza Near Me - Milton, Florida

See all

We, as a family, love us some pizza but we prefer a thicker crust with extra sauce. We wanted to love it as we always try to support local, but it just wasn't for us. read more

Boomerang's is a quant little restaurant. The service is usually good. The pizza is good but nothing different from a lot of pizza restaurants. read more

Food was great staff also very good delicious food A1+ been there more than ones, love there pizza yummy

We celebrated two birthdays and an anniversary last night. There were 14 of us. The food was delicious and the service was great! We love to walk on the boardwalk after. read more

Super cute little pizza place. Always get great service. We typically go here with our family and get a large pizza to share (any of the pizza's are good) but we got the Supreme pizza and some of the buffalo garlic knots.. They have a cute little gift shop and kids play area for when you are waiting you can look around. Simple but we enjoy it. Also, at the end you can't help but to get you some of the fudge or a cookie ... just amazing ! We love Boomerang . read more

Very nice place to go and eat and relax with friends the food was very good. Very clean and the service was great

Great ambiance, excellent service. Friendly staff and pizza is great. Great flavor and excellent crust.

No online menu. I was able to find a menu from either yelp or some other app and they were outdated. I got a 16" BBQ chicken pizza and it cost me over $36. They also don't accept American Express. Pizza was good, but small and not worth the price. read more

A great local pizza joint newly remodeled it doesn't get any better than this. The food is top-notch. The service was quick prompt in the servers knew exactly when to check on you without being around too much. The vibe in the restaurant was welcoming, cozy, and almost made it feel like you didn't wanna leave. If you want a good pie, this is the place. read more

it's $5 off on Tuesday, if you order large I decided to upgrade (spend more), still Large, but added half to be Supreme. asked if I would get my $5 off, waitress said yes. then returned to tell me, no I could not!? I have emailed Deb Becker. if I get no response, and fix this with her customer, I will never eat here again! read more

Order the Thai chicken pizza on colidflour crust We've been back for it 3 times now . We first learned about it from a Thursday night market , we called to place a to go order and the girl on the take out phone highly recommended it. Really is the best thing on there menu read more

Boomerang Pizza Kitchen - Pizza Near Me - Milton, Florida

Love this place! The pizza was delicious! Had a nice Church lunch here! Evertone enjoyed theirself! Will be back again!

Great local pizza place! Buffalo knots are awesome! Love the theme and the food and service are always good. This is a great place to eat, don't listen to the overly critical people on here. Support your local restaurants. read more

Great pizza and fun atmosphere in the back room dining area. Good variety of wines and beer. Service has always been spot on.

ok , What the heck is the matter with you people? how can this place have 4 stars ?? ITS A 5 star Local Favorite. I live in Milton and My wife and I LOVE to get their pizza. Excellent. Yea Im retired Army and have eaten alot of bad food LOL, I'm also a Quarter Italian and this Place makes the Best Pizza I ever had. The crust is fantastic. Try their Mack and Cheese . It will make you cry. read more

Pizza here is always delicious, authentic New York style with plenty of toppings and fresh ingredients. Vintage diner style dining room with a bar. They also have a general store up front with all sorts of vintage toys, some kitchen items, fresh fudge (soo good!), and baked goods. The staff is friendly and our server was very attentive and thorough. Some of my favorite pizza in the area. Located in the historic district of downtown Milton. Locally owned too. read more

Boomerang Pizza Kitchen - Meat Lovers Favorite Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Milton, Florida

See all

Such a nice place. Our server Kenzie was wonderful and took great care of us. And of course the pizza are delicious. Also they have a really neat collection of fruit wines that's really unique. read more

Meat Lovers Pizza Neat pizza place, food was good, crust was better than average. Meat pizza has some grease but that is to be expected. If you get an chance in Milton Florida check it out. read more

Boomerang Pizza Kitchen - Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Milton, Florida

I loved it here! The ambiance was really cool with a 50s vibe decor theme, the pizza was good with a thin crust and garlic butter on it, and the service was attentive and friendly. I would definitely come back. read more

See all

Been reluctant to go here because the price was high. Never will I come back. Paid almost $35 for this and a salad that was not even that big. Going to Socios from now on and if I want a Margarita pizza definitely going to Graffiti Pizza down town. Don't waste your money read more

Boomerang Pizza Kitchen - Margherita Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Milton, Florida

We had been wanting to try Boomerang Pizza for awhile and finally got the chance to! We placed a pick up order- 45 mins wait. We ordered the pepperoni pizza with fresh mozzarella added and butter garlic crust. We also ordered the garlic knots. When we arrived we were instantly acknowledged by 2 separate people. While we waited we took a look around and it's super cute inside with desserts ( fudge and cookies) and a little shopping area. The back was much bigger than I expected and looked nice. While waiting we bought some peanut butter fudge and the raspberry truffle fudge both were good. Our pizza and knots were great. The crust was delicious as were the sauce and cheese and large pepperonis. The garlic knots were perfectly crisp on the outside and soft on the inside. After you shake up the garlic butter it great on the pizza and the knots. We plan to done in next time. read more

See all

The pizza here is fabulous!!! It was my first time here and will be coming back. We started with the cheese bread for appetizer then ordered a large pepperoni pizza. The service was A+. Mason was our server and he was superb. The ambiance was great and I have to recommend the wine flight. You get to choose four wines. I recommend the raspberry wine. It was a big burst of flavor in my mouth. Next time I'll get a bottle. Take care and help support this family owned business. read more

Boomerang Pizza Kitchen - This is our fantastic server Mason .Go see him, he will take care of all your wants and needs. - Pizza Near Me - Milton, Florida

I just celebrated my birthday at Boomerang's yesterday August 2,2025. We had 14 adults and 4 toddlers in our party. We had such a great time and the food was delicious. The staff was so accommodating. They played special 50's/60's music for me while we were there. Our server made sure we were happy as we waited for our food. Our server was Beth and she was so friendly and kind. She made my 75th birthday party memorable in a great way! Kudos to you, Beth!! read more

Place is really nostalgic, seated in a reasonable amount of time, and they were pretty busy. Ordered 3 meatballs, garlic dough knots and small mushroom pizza. Wait time was reasonable, but the garlic knots were under cooked a little and super bland. The mushroom pizza was pretty good, and the meatballs were bland and cold. Hopefully it's better on the next visit. read more

Boomerang Pizza Kitchen - Pizza Near Me - Milton, Florida

See all

We stopped for lunch on our way home from Holland Farms. This place was so cute, and the pizza was tasty. The staff was super friendly. Great place to go with kids! read more

See all

we were pleasantly surprised by this place on a quaint street in Milton. The first thing you notice walking in the door is the aroma, "pizza is gonna be good here" I thought. The second thing you notice is the fudge and dessert on display, I don't know how I passed that up. There's plenty of seating in the back. I had a 7" Margherita, I didn't want anything getting in the way of tasting the dough, sauce and cheese. I didn't ask but I wouldn't be surprised if the mozzarella was made fresh on site. We also had the Mac n Cheese (wife really liked it) and our guests had a couple of calzones. Everything was cooked perfectly, tasted fresh and was served very friendly and professionally by Brittney. A "must try" if you're in the Milton area. Updated edit: stopped in again two weeks later and tried the Meatball calzone. It's the perfect size with two large delicious meatballs inside. There's a sprinkling of parmesan, garlic and herbs on top that complete the presentation. They supply a small but plentiful dish of marinara sauce on the side is perfectly textured and is also delicious. This time we ordered the cinnamon apple bread pudding ala mode and it was O-M-G so good. Mason was our server and also very professional and friendly. read more