I just went to get ice cream with my daughter and the customer before me paid with cash and I paid…read morewith cash and the guy was handling the cash on both transactions and he went to grab my ice cream cones without washing his hands or putting gloves on. I had to ask him to do so. it's very unsanitary. Seven

Worst food I think I have ever had. For as close as they are to Philly, I really expected a much…read morebetter cheesesteak. It was literally one of the worst I have ever had. I threw it away after 1 bite. Then the pizza HAS to be frozen pizza that they heat up. It is SO bad! For a place called "House of Pizza"?!? I'm not a fan of such a bad review, but I literally had nothing good to say, nor did the the other 5 people I came with.

The place was MOBBED! What's going on here…read more.. Four of us has flounder franceise, eggplant rolatini, bbq chicken pizza, and a meatball sandwich (sub, in Lancaster county speak). We were all happy and cleaned our plates except for three of us who couldn't eat it all. The meatballs were just the right texture and while I'm not sure whose rolls they use, it was just slightly crisp with a nice chew, not doughy or dense. Aside from it being crowded, very noisy, and cold when someone came in, a pretty good dinner.

Another great experience! We have enjoyed the Caruso family's offerings at many of their shops…read more Dining in at Willow Street is worth the trip. I bought this garden salad with grilled chicken as take out. Lots of expertly grilled chicken, fresh veges and cheese, bonus garlic bread. Few "high end" restaurants do as well, almost none are as consistent as the Carusos. A great dinner for my wife and me - for $13!

Today was my first time to visit Sal's Pizza in Kendig Sq following a strong recommendation from my…read morebrother. Wow, UNlike the run-down shopping center, Sal's was squeaky-clean as far as the eye could see, restrooms were spotless, decor was very pleasant and staff was too... but best of all was the thin crust white pizza with basil, garlic, cheese and fresh tomatoes! Cooked to perfection! Maybe area diners should give it another try. I know I will!

Pizza was okay but the grilled caesar salad wrap was not good at all…read more Terrible dressing, hot soggy lettuce, no parmesan cheese or anything. Was supposed to be a side of caesar salad and that was equally not a caesar and not very good. Would order the other items again just not this or salad's probably.

I really liked this place. I usually order what they call the round subs which looks like a…read morehamburger roll but tastes like a sub roll. Fries and salads are good as well

Romano pizza is flavorful as well as cheesy. Served hot with a crispy crust and plenty of toppings.read more

The pizza hut is located in a strip mall with a lot of parking options and a well lighted area. I…read moreplaced an order to pick up a big pizza box. The staff is friendly and assisted in adding items to the order and getting crushed red pepper and then paper plates. The order was almost ready when I reached. The staff asked me to cross-check the order before leaving the place. The pasta and bread sticks were good. The pizza was just okay. The pizza box is a good size and sufficient for one family.

I like pizza hut!! But this pizza hut changed my mind. I now love pizza hut. This location to be…read moreexact. I have never had my pizza taste so good and fresh with soft crust and perfectly made bread sticks as I do now that most of them are gone and I have to drive 20 min to this location. This location is the best!

Great costumer service! Wonderful family friendly atmosphere. Owner and wife kept coming over to…read moreask how the meal was and how they could serve us better. Food was amazing. My husband and I had the manicotti and the chicken ziti. Portion size is larger than I thought and the prices are reasonable. Our meals also included a house salad and garlic knots. Everything was made quick, fresh ,and tasted wonderful. Overall my husband and I walked out paying $26. You really can't beat the price. Highly recommend this restaurant if you are in the area.

We just happened by here one day on a visit to Lancaster, and we really liked it. If this…read morerestaurant were anywhere near the DC area, we would be regulars. There were nice toppings to choose from, and both pizzas were very tasty.

best pizza in Lancaster! and probably outside of Philly…read moreMatt's pie stacks up with anything I had in NYC too Spumoni Gardens, NY Pizza Suprema, Joe's, etc. super crispy, sauce, cheese perfection hand tossed half & half keep it simple have some pizza and snag dessert or a beer inside the market service was excellent ambiance is great love these guys

This place has me hooked on Detroit-style pies. I got a plain pie for dinner and ended up eating it…read morefor several days. They offer a variety of tasty-looking toppings that I'll have to try next time, but even the plain pie is delicious. I just wish they sold individual slices past lunchtime. Whatever wait time they give you, it's worth it!

Pie in the Sky did the catering for my daughter's baby shower in May of 2025. From my 1st…read moretelephone call with the owner and the subsequent calls with the manager, the service was friendly, professional, and very accommodating! The food was on time, made with care, and absolutely mouth-watering delicious. As the Grandmom to be, I was thrilled that we decided to use Pie in the Sky for this event. I would highly recommend. Thanks Guys!!

Absolutely the best!!! We got a pepperoni Sicilian pizza with extra cheese. It was the best as…read morealways!!!

This is my second (updated) review for this restaurant. We are not local, and we stumbled upon it…read moreabout a year ago when we were in Lancaster. This time, while traveling, we drove out of our way just to pass through Lancaster and stay the night just so we could some genuine Brooklyn style pizza without having to go to the Big Apple. This time, like last time, it was some of the best pizzas I've had, and I'm sure it may be the best in Lancaster. It is true NY style (Brooklyn) pizza made by New Yorkers. The restaurantier is a NYC transplant, and he brought with him that NY pizza. Simply stated, it's awesome. All the staff is polite, cordial, and engaging. They don't waste any time in creating your meal and making you love every bite. They offer a rather extensive menu with good variety, but we have only tried the pizza, and we love it.

We wandered into Thoze guys pizzeria after a long exhausting day at Dutch Wonderland. Great…read moreatmosphere of a neighborhood pizza joint. Informal feeling, which was great when we were walking in with three kids. The staff was friendly and the food was amazing. Super authentic and hit the spot. The marinara sauce with the garlic knots was something I could drink out of a faucet. Also loved that they had individual slices available so we could try an assortment for the family.

Hands down the best pizza in Lancaster county! I've picked up food from here many times,…read moreconsistently great food, the bread they use for cheesesteaks is phenomenal!

This place has earned the title of New York style pizza. Out of many places out here that say NY…read morestyle. No one comes close, to touching this place. Thin, well done, crispy crust. Slightly oily, slightly salty. Could use a bit more cheese, but that's an easy fix with extra cheese order. The pie actually is the size of the box. I didn't try much other than pizza, but if you're looking for that actual NY home taste. For anyone missing a NY slice. Try this place. Get you a fresh pie. Service good. Ambiance, pizza vibes. Not displaying all the NY stuff like that trash dump a slice of Brooklyn. Let the pizza do the work. First time trying them and not the last. I'll drive the 30 minutes to get a pie when I'm in the mood. Slices are actually slices and not little Cesar slices. Forget, all others. This place hits