I stumbled into Boardwalk Pizza completely by accident while returning something to the The UPS Store nearby--so first off, kudos on the location. From the outside and inside, it looks exactly like what you'd expect from a classic New York-style pizzeria: casual, slice-ready, dine-in or grab-and-go. Being from New York myself, I admit I'm a bit of a pizza snob. I have standards. I grabbed a simple slice just to test the waters: cheese and ricotta, no red sauce. For me, the real test is always the dough. If the dough is right, the rest usually follows. I was pleasantly surprised. The crust was super thin--true New York thin--and honestly delicious. Light, properly proofed, flavorful, and most importantly, not swampy, which is something Florida pizza unfortunately struggles with sometimes. The structure, texture, and flavor were spot-on for what I'd expect from a New York slice. The slice itself could have been a little bigger, but the price was very reasonable (under $5), so it still felt fair. Because I went with such a simple slice, I didn't really get the chance to judge their sauce or the full topping lineup. But based on the quality of the dough alone, I'm sold enough to come back and explore more of the menu. For a random stop that turned into a pleasant surprise, Boardwalk Pizza passed the New Yorker test--and that's not something I say lightly. read more

See all

Boardwalk pizza is great for a quick bite to eat for lunch or dinner. I typically visit after my nail appointment and the service is fast and efficient. The pizza and salads are typically fresh and tasty. I definitely recommend for a quick quality meal. read more

Boardwalk Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Winter Park, Florida

See all

If you're looking for a place that doesn't just serve food--but delivers an experience--look no further than Boardwalk Pizza in Winter Park. From the moment I walked in, the energy was right. Warm, welcoming, and alive in a way that most places try to fake but never quite achieve. This spot? It's the real deal. Let's talk about the food first. I ordered the Hippie Roll, and I'll be honest--I wasn't prepared for how good it was. Every bite hit like it was crafted with intention. Fresh, flavorful, perfectly balanced... the kind of dish that makes you pause mid-conversation just to appreciate what's happening. That doesn't happen often. But what truly elevated this visit from great to unforgettable was the service. Kayla. There are servers... and then there are people who redefine what hospitality is supposed to feel like. Kayla didn't just take an order--she created an experience. Attentive without hovering, friendly without feeling forced, and genuinely invested in making sure everything was perfect. You can't train that kind of energy. That's natural, and it shows. She made the entire experience seamless, effortless, and honestly? Memorable in a way that will bring me back here again. Great food will get people in the door--but people like Kayla are the reason they come back. Boardwalk Pizza didn't just meet expectations--they raised the bar. (and if I could give more, I would read more

Boardwalk Pizza - Hippie roll - Pizza Near Me - Winter Park, Florida

Stopped by with friends after a group activity in the area. My friends and I split a meats pie and it was delicious. The meat ratio was perfect and didn't weigh down the slice when picked up. The cheese ratio was perfect. Great meat flavor! We asked to spit a large Caesar, and it was brought out already split up in four bowls- great call. I don't live close, but will go again if in the area! read more

Boardwalk Pizza - The meats! So good. 6/2025 - Pizza Near Me - Winter Park, Florida

We've always loved grabbing whole pies or pizza by the slice to go from Boardwalk Pizza, but this was our first time dining in, and it won't be our last! The service was excellent from start to finish, and the atmosphere is cozy and low-key, perfect for a relaxed meal. We started with the garlic knots, which were delicious, soft, warm, and perfectly seasoned. For the pizza, we tried two slices. I didn't love the sausage topping (I'll stick to plain cheese next time), the crust and sauce were still on point as always. We also had the baked ziti and a calzone, both of which were fantastic and super satisfying. To finish off the meal, we grabbed a cannoli to go, which was the perfect sweet treat. Overall, Boardwalk Pizza never disappoints! read more

See all

Boardwalk Pizza is a great place for pizza if you're in Casselberry. I ordered the anchovies and pineapple pizza, which was AMAZING. Our server, Bri, was also nice and friendly to us, and the environment here was also really nice. I would definitely recommend this place if you're nearby. read more

Another great visit to boardwalk pizza. Every time I come here I am blown away by how awesome this place is, the severice was really good and the pizza was great. I started my meal with there garlic knots as an appetizer. They come with this red sauce which tastes delicious this was almost enough to make a whole meal. Lol but I came here for the pizza. This time I went with the deep pepperoni and mushroom and like I the menu said it's worth the wait Lolita was pretty big too i ate pizza for like two days lol all in all I had a great visit and will be back. read more

See all

Quick, tasty, and good service! Love this little local pizza joint here in Winter Park. I suggest getting the Alfredo with the Garlic Knots and a class pizza pie! Their wings are pretty good as well. Be sure to check their daily specials as well! read more

See all

Great pizza, salads and subs...been around forever and always good. Nice homey atmosphere and near Maitland, Winter Park, Casselberry..consistently good food with friendly service for years read more

I visit this location a couple of times a month. The pizza, pasta, salads, Stromboli, wings..... all of it has been consistently good. They have indoor and outdoor seating and the staff is always amazing. If you are looking to order to go on a weekend, I would definitely call your order in because the line gets hectic. Even with this, the seating time is never long. if you're looking for a good pizza spot that is economical and will satisfy your craving look no further. Plenty of parking as well. read more

Boardwalk Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Winter Park, Florida

See all

We have been customers since '05. Boardwalk has always been our favorite since we came from upstate New York, as did the owner. Last night's order to go was a large Stromboli and large meat and mushroom ,pizza. Sitting down to eat with our company last night, we realized something was definitely wrong. The crust was thin and dry, with very little cheese and sparse mushrooms. ( Yes, My husband picked it up on time) The Deluxe Stromboli was lackluster and not as full of meats as usual. I hope this was a 'one off' rather than , I fear, a new owner. The lady who answered the phone today when I called to ask what happened , said, they were training someone new. I would be greatly surprised if it was a new trainee without proper supervision! This will not work if it is the new normal for Boardwalk. I surely hope not! read more

My favorite pizza place for when we want to have pizza. Great salads too. The Stromboli is to die for!! read more

Love this New York style pizza! The slices pass the flop test - you hold it and it stays straight instead of flopping down. The quality of the dough, cheese, and toppings are clear signs of the freshness. The white pizza is my favorite - so garlicky and cheesy! The pies are a bit pricey but totally worth it for the quality that you won't find at any chain. read more

Boardwalk Pizza - Half pepperoni, onion, and pineapple (yes it belongs on pizza) and half great white - Pizza Near Me - Winter Park, Florida

I've tried many of the area pizzarias near Winter Park and Boardwalk consistently beats them all. The sauce is perfect - not overly acidic but not too sweet. The crust is perfect - not too salty, with great flavor and outstanding crunch. The calzones and baked ziti are excellent - they put fresh herbs in the ricotta, which nobody else does, but everybody should! They also make great chicken Parm and eggplant parm, and their tuna hero is simple yet really addictive. Heartily recommend if you're looking for a great pizzaria in the area read more

Nice it's a little more than a pizza parlor. Great food great service I will definitely be going there again.

I still like this place and our (spinach/mushroom) pizza this afternoon was delicious, but I just gotta say $27 for a 15 x 16 (this is large?) pizza? It's too much. Have to find an affordable place. read more

This is a great place for a quick or leisurely bite to eat and everything we've ever ordered is delicious (salads, sausage sandwich, pizza, etc). We try to go every time we're in town! read more

awful food and employees the manager has a problem if you have an issue that you want to discuss with him his response is shit happen. he's not fit to run an establishment and the employees are rude. the manager has a problem dealing with people. I'd stay away from this awful run pizza place. read more

I ordered a large Greek dinner salad with 4 knots to go. I was charged $20??? I was surprised at the cost, but I figured that this must be some big salad perhaps. I opened the bag at home and saw a tiny little basic salad that should cost around $4.99, with no meat, a little feta and 4 hard stale knots. It was mostly lettuce. I wouldn't have minded paying $7.99 total for this, but $20!!! I felt ripped off. I won't be back. read more

Been coming here for 33 years and love this place! Food and service is very consistent read more

Boardwalk Pizza - Italian hoagie - Pizza Near Me - Winter Park, Florida

I've ordered from them before and the food has always been average at best. When we've done takeout it's only been for convenience. Got a pizza tonight and it looked AWFUL! The crust was extra thick and bubbly with little cheese. I called, they were rude and said "so what, there's nothing we can do". No offer for a refund. Brought it back and the manager was obnoxious. We'll never be back. read more

The best and most consistently delicious food in Winter Park. I've been eating here for over 30 years, and I've never been disappointed--only more impressed. read more

The Boardwalk is good, but not great. We showed up a little over an hour before closing and were the only ones dining in. The garlic knots that came with our meal were old. They were cold, tasteless and hard. It wasn't as if we arrived right before they closed, so fresh knots would've been appreciated. We came here specifically for chicken parmesan, which we were told they were out of upon ordering. We ended up getting chicken alfredo and baked ziti with added sausage for an up charge. Our salads came out first and both were pretty good. Our two pasta entrees were good as well, but not something I'd come here specifically for. Our friends got a pepperoni pizza, which I didn't try but looked good. With all the other Italian options in the area, will I be back, probably not. read more

See all

Fresh and delicious food. I love the Greek salad, pizza and grilled chicken. The people who work there are amazing! Love Kayla, Lauren and Nigel! Always open! Great food. Great for kids!! I would give it 12 stars if I could. read more

Boardwalk Pizza - Server in restaurant - Pizza Near Me - Winter Park, Florida

See all

Boardwalk Pizza's extensive menu offers a delicious array of Italian and American dishes. Each one that I have had the pleasure in trying has tasted flavorful and authentic. You can expect great food that is made from fresh, high-quality ingredients. Their pizza is conveniently available by the slice. For just a couple bucks, these giant slices are made-to-order with your favorite toppings, making it a great option for a quick and delicious lunch break treat. Of course, I recommend the whole pie, and I think you will be glad if you do. Broadway offers several unique signature pizzas, such as the "Great White": A heavenly blend of garlic, mozzarella, provolone, and ricotta. The classic pizzas are equally as satisfying with their perfectly baked crust. But Boardwalk Pizza has so much more than just pizza! Their Specialties menu features mouthwatering Calzones, Stromboli, Veggie Rolls, and Hippie Rolls (sausage, green peppers, onions, mozzarella, and provolone,). My personal favorite is the Garlic Knots appetizer, the biggest and most delicious knots on the planet. You can't fully experience Boardwalk Pizza without allowing yourself to give in to temptation: Dessert is calling! The Cannoli and Chocolate Mousse Cake are the 'cherry on top' of an excellent meal. The restaurant is family-friendly with a kids menu and tables inside to dine in. You can also order delivery or takeout by calling or ordering on the web. The only thing I would change would be their limited hours. Staying open later, especially on weekends, would definitely be a nice bonus, not to mention open up endless opportunities to broaden their market and reach more customers. Broadway Pizza in Winter Park is a must-try for authentic, fresh, and flavorful food. read more

I went to this location and it did not disappoint. My husband and I absolutely loved the meatballs here. The service was swift. The ambiance was good. There were people in and out picking up orders as well as others sitting down. We stumbled upon this place as we were at Monkey Joes just a short walk away. read more

Been ordering stromboli for years from this place. Great service... But quality on the food has dropped substantially. Last stromboli ordered had just cheese and barely any meat. Zero pepperoni and zero sausage. Won't be coming back. Obviously quality control is an issue or the ownership changed. 27 bucks for a block of cheese..is theft! read more

Hygiene and Cleanliness Issues! * Server was friendly and pleasant but definitely needs some training in the hygiene/cleanliness department. * Food was hot and tasted good as usual, but the cleanliness issues we witnessed has made us decide not to come back. * Server grabbed our cups (with our straws) and took them away to refill them, without asking first. Let me at least remove the straw for safe keeping. * Server overfilled my glass and brought it back to the table with the liquid spilling all over and onto the table. Server said nothing, didn't seem to care, server clearly saw it spilling over at the table. I had to ask for paper napkins to clean up the mess they made. * Server touched my wife's straw when filling her beverage. Again, server didn't seem to notice or care. My wife used a new straw after that. * Server proceeded to use the dirty broom handle and dust pan, then touched plates and cups without washing their hands. * Server brought out "clean" plates that were greasy and clearly not cleaned properly. Had to ask for new plates. Dishes not being cleaned properly, this speaks volumes to me. * Server took our pizza away to put it into a box. A nice gesture, but I'd like to do that myself to ensure hygienic practices. Reference the next two points below. * Server put wax paper x 2 into our to-go box with their bare hands... again, server didn't wash their hands. * Server just dumped our pizza on top of each other. Meat pizza on top of veggie pizza. Shaking my head. See attached photo of what we found after walking out to the car (before we drove anywhere). * We used to love this place, but sadly due to the above, we won't be back. read more

Boardwalk Pizza - Pizza dumped into box... shake my head. - Pizza Near Me - Winter Park, Florida

Excellent service, great fresh food. The atmosphere is pleasant. Your food comes at a reasonable time. This now new pizza headquarters is close to home. read more

Boardwalk Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Winter Park, Florida

We always get great food and great service!!!!! And those pizza slices are huge! My favorite is the eggplant Parmesan. read more

Boardwalk has been a staple in the community for decades. The proprietor, Matt DeMike is an exceptional operator. They use the best ingredients which results in the best examples of the dishes offered. My most recent visit was to obtain several pizzas for a dinner party. All guests were very happy with the pizza and the garlic knots we also ordered. I will continue to return for their delicious food. read more

The salad are really good here and the service is very nice with a bright smile. They have outdoor seating and they have a doggie bowl for your animal after the work out next door read more

I'm from New Jersey... Aka "Cheesesteak mecca". I have NOT found a great cheesesteak sandwich, until I came HERE for lunch last week!!!! Holy feckarolli !!! This place makes the BEST cheesesteak sandwich I have ever tasted anywhere in Florida!!!!! read more

I have been coming here for ages. Always an awesome time here. Service has been extremely good and the food has been nothing but spectacular. This location has been here for about 30 years. A local favorite. The food is simply great and the service is always fast and prompt. Parking is plentiful. Friday and Saturday nights are the more busier nights. You might wait for a few minutes but the wait staff usually will turn over tables quick and efficient. My go to items are your standard pepperoni and cheese pizza, mozzarella sticks, tuna or Greek salad, chicken or eggplant parmesan, calazones or lasagna. There are plenty of items to choose from. A small beer and wine selection with a 4 item dessert menu rounds off the list of items to choose from. This is your casual pizza place that will make your stomach full and the desire to come back again. You won't be disappointed. read more

See all

Best Philly cheesesteak! I have never been to Philadelphia but this sandwich has moist ribeye with white American cheese throughout but not gooped in a sauce. I recommend the White bread over whole wheat. What is not to love? read more

This place was pretty good. Staff was friendly and welcoming. They have a reasonable lunch combo - a slice, a salad and a drink is $7.99. I just ordered a slice of pepperoni pizza. The pizza is NY style, and it was tasty. They can be pricey since every additional will cost you. They also have gluten and lactose free options. 4 stars. Just a great little neighborhood pizza shop. read more

See all

Delicious pizza and great service. The wait staff is so personable you'll want to come back just for them. But it's the best place in Maitland to grab a slice and a beer! read more

Outstanding AMAZING FOOD! Fast and friendly service. It was my first time here with my family and our dine in experience exceeded all of my expectations. Food was extremely fresh, from the house Italian salad to the extra large pepperoni pizza and wings. This place is definitely our new pizza place!!! Loved it! read more

Boardwalk Pizza - Pizza, wings and salad. 5 stars!!!! Outstanding fast and friendly service. Super super fresh food. Couldn't ask for more. Loved it. - Pizza Near Me - Winter Park, Florida

Had to stop for a quick lunch while visiting the area and was in the mood for pizza. Being from NY, I know a good pizza. The dough was good but they are nothing like NY style. Very small for the price. 4 small slices and small fountain $20. Sorry, you 3 stars because the dough was good. read more

Garlic Knots-5* Pizza 4.2* Chicken Parmigiana- 4.0* Michelob Ultra - 5* Service was great and food was hot and fresh I was so hungry I forgot to take a pic. read more