Antonella's Pizzeria Fairbanks Photos
Business Info
Antonella's Pizzeria Fairbanks Popular Dishes
ANTONELLA'S PIZZERIA FAIRBANKS ATMOSPHERE
You might also consider
More like Antonella's Pizzeria Fairbanks
Recommended Reviews - Antonella's Pizzeria Fairbanks
Start your review...
Reviews With Photos
The other day I was craving a big, meaty, cheesy, lasagna. I don't usually get Italian food to-go, but my brain was telling me that I NEEDED IT IMMEDIATELY. My boyfriend and I looked around on Yelp for a decently priced Italian option nearby that had a quick pickup option. Antonella's popped up... we have had the pizza from here before which was pretty good but never the pasta, so we went ahead and ordered online for pickup (very easy process). I arrived at the shopping plaza, quickly picked up our food, realized they forgot to include our Stromboli we ordered, went back in, retrieved the Stromboli, then drove home. It was pretty packed inside their small restaurant so it's understandable that one item was forgotten to be given to me. THIS FOOD IS SO BIG. Great deal for the price! The weight of my lasagna container surprised me which is always a good thing. Antonella's definitely hit the mark with giving me a meaty, cheesy lasagna. It was "my eyes are rolling to the back of my head" type of delicious. The tortellini that my boyfriend ordered was also FANTASTIC. It was definitely enough food for two meals. The Stromboli was also very good, but it was a tad bit doughy. I have decided that this will be my to-go pasta place from here on out. I love cheese, and they do NOT skimp on it here in their dishes.
I don't think I've been to Antonella's since pre-pandemic, and I'm happy to report that not a thing has changed! We went on a Saturday afternoon and they weren't super busy. Since it's a small mom and pop spot there isn't a lot of seating inside and not ideal for large groups. However, there were only 4 of us, and it was a beautiful day to sit out in the patio. I was bragging about the lunch specials, which are some really great deals. The sliders are my fave, so those certainly got ordered. And of course you have to get the garlic knots! Just be sure to have your breath freshener ready, because they are loaded with garlic. The 2 slice special, along with the veggiboli was ordered, and a baked ziti to go. Let's just say there wasn't one complaint at the table. I highly recommend Antonella's if you want to just grab something to go or happen to be in the area and want to grab a quick bite. The service is superb, and they are super friendly. I'll definitely have to make sure I don't let as much time pass for my next visit.
Whether you're dining inside or enjoying the outdoor seating with your dogs, Antonella's Pizzeria offers a genuinely welcoming experience. The staff are friendly and accommodating, and I was pleasantly surprised by how dog-friendly they are--even offering options so my Shibas could enjoy the outing too. As for the food, the pizza is outstanding: thin, crispy, and full of flavor. Definitely a spot worth visiting, especially if you're bringing your pups along.
I've been going to Antonella's for over a year. I noticed at one point the pizza quality just wasn't the same, so I took a break. However, now the pizza quality seems to be better then ever! They are generous with the toppings that also taste really fresh! My fave is the Grandma's pizza. The staff and owner are really nice and helpful. Plus the ambience is great. Although the place seems small, I always see an available table.
Well, I work in downtown Winter Park and really wanted a Calzone today. I already tried one from another Pizza place nearby, but it was not good. And definitely worth the price. So I gave these guys a chance. And you know what? Not bad at all! Actually, it was pretty good! Today, I tried the Antonella's Calzone and although the price might be a bit high, it is definitely worth it. The thing was massive, and I couldn't eat the entire thing. I just wish it had a bit more Italian sausage, which I will probably request as an extra add-on the next time I place an order. I love that they sell pizza by the slice. It is also a great option if you want to try different toppings, are on a budget, etc. All in all.... yes, I would recommend this place. And before I forget, the staff at the restaurant was super nice and accommodating. Next time, I will definitely dine in, so I can try their pizza fresh out of the oven. I'm pretty sure it's going to be really good. So there will definitely be updates to this post.
This is my $36, extra crispy, 16" pizza from Antonella's. This pizza has $4 worth of pepperoni (22 pieces) , $4 worth of mushrooms (several slices have none and about 20 full slices accounted for), and $4 worth of onions (I count 6 total pieces of onions). To make it worse, the first thing I had to do when I got home was turn on the toaster oven to finish cooking half of the pizza. Nobody was in line in front of me and the staff was just standing around. Now I know why. Never again.
I was in the area and this was on my to go spots while in LA. I had to sample a little of everything. I asked for a slice of cheese pizza, a delicious vodka sauce based slice and honey pepperoni slice and a Antonella favorite that I asked the team to surprise me with. All I can say is Wow...such taste each one carried. The line was insane but well worth the wait.
We were in the area and looking for an affordable bite to eat. My boyfriend was in the mood for pizza, and Antonella's Pizzeria came up when I searched pizza. So why not, we love trying new places, and the reviews seemed pretty good. They had good lunch specials, so we both rolled with the 2 slices & salad special. They had many other lunch special choices as well. I'm sure we will be back to try out a pasta ones most likely in the future. The salad was bigger than expected but fresh and good. I upgraded my slices for tomatoe & spinach, it was hood i just felt they overdid it on the toppings. Overall, we enjoyed the food. There were not many seating spots but we chose to sit on their patio since it was so hot inside. They stay busy tho I will say, they had a lot of pickup orders and uber eats it looked like. I say if you're in the area, give it a shot, and we will be back.
This place is small and very clean. The lunch special is amazing, my friends and I thoroughly enjoyed every bite. Their pizza crust is fantastic, pasta is tasty, sliders are delicious, and salad is fresh and yummy! Will definitely be back!
Stopped in on a Saturday afternoon for lunch! Great find! Great variety of lunch specials through 4pm. I opted for the 1/2 hero (Italian cold cut, but you can choose from several heroes) and small Caesar salad. This special is #4 on the lunch menu; it's called "Twice As Nice". The salad was a generous portion for a side salad and tasted good. The hero was HUGE! Probably an 8" sub, packed with Italian meats and cheese. I had to eat it open face, with a knife and fork as it was too big to close to bite into. The pizza looked good! I think I'll try that next time. This place is small. Only 4 tables inside, and just a couple outside. If you want to dine in, visit during off hours or he prepared yo wait for a table - Butnthe wait will be well worth it! Highly recommend!
This mom and pop restaurant is secluded in one of the many nice spots in Winter Park. Stopped in, was greeted by the waitress and looked over the menu. They have a great selection of pizza, calzones, wings and so much more. I ended up doing a create your own pizza (steak, extra cheese, sun dried tomatoes and spinach) and 10 wings extra crispy with a Snapple Apple. They don't have a liquor selection but have select wines and beers. Seating is limited. Let me just say the pizza and wings were made to perfection! I enjoyed it sooo much. Definitely reminds me of authentic Italian. This won't be my last time here.
This place may be small but they do a massive amount of business and with such friendly staff. We came in for pizza and watched the pizza pro make it from Scratch. Delicious! We had the house red wine for only $6 a glass. It was very good. We also ordered a homemade cannoli to take home. No doubt it will be perfection. Antonella is the daughter of the owner of Nonno's in Altamonte--Stefano. I Good food runs in the family. read more
5 months ago
Gotta have pizza to complete a perfect Friday night. After driving by this location many times, I ordered over the phone for a pickup order. I was given a time it would be ready, but unfortunately had to wait almost another 20 minutes than originally given. The store front looked cute and had several tables inside and outside to sit at and eat. As for the food, I ordered a large pepperoni pizza, garlic knots, and an antipasta salad. The antipasta salad was delicious. It was packed with lots of meat and I enjoyed the dressing. The garlic knots were PACKES with garlic. So much garlic that yes, it will fill your car, your fridge, and you may also smell like garlic. They were cooked great. As for the pepperoni pizza, it was just okay. It did have a good amount of pepperonis on it, but the pizza as a whole just lacked flavor. It was a bit bland. Also the bottom of the pizza needed to cook a bit more. I will come back but I think the antipasta and knots will be my go to. read more
8 months ago
I always pass by this pizza place and I finally decided to grab a late night munchie session and picked up a Greek salad and garlic knots. The staff was so friendly even though it was right before closing I stepped inside. The vibe is so like a New York pizza place and the smells are amazing! The garlic knots were literally swimming in a pool of garlic butter and were so fresh and piping hot we had to let them cool down the whole way home. The salad was delicious and full of onions. My husband loved it. The next morning my car still smelled like delicious garlic knots and I was not mad about it lol. I'll go back earlier in the day and try the grandma pizza which sounded unique. But this time I'll bring the kids read more
1 year ago
The other day I was craving a big, meaty, cheesy, lasagna. I don't usually get Italian food to-go, but my brain was telling me that I NEEDED IT IMMEDIATELY. My boyfriend and I looked around on Yelp for a decently priced Italian option nearby that had a quick pickup option. Antonella's popped up... we have had the pizza from here before which was pretty good but never the pasta, so we went ahead and ordered online for pickup (very easy process). I arrived at the shopping plaza, quickly picked up our food, realized they forgot to include our Stromboli we ordered, went back in, retrieved the Stromboli, then drove home. It was pretty packed inside their small restaurant so it's understandable that one item was forgotten to be given to me. THIS FOOD IS SO BIG. Great deal for the price! The weight of my lasagna container surprised me which is always a good thing. Antonella's definitely hit the mark with giving me a meaty, cheesy lasagna. It was "my eyes are rolling to the back of my head" type of delicious. The tortellini that my boyfriend ordered was also FANTASTIC. It was definitely enough food for two meals. The Stromboli was also very good, but it was a tad bit doughy. I have decided that this will be my to-go pasta place from here on out. I love cheese, and they do NOT skimp on it here in their dishes. read more
2 months ago
2 years ago
I don't think I've been to Antonella's since pre-pandemic, and I'm happy to report that not a thing has changed! We went on a Saturday afternoon and they weren't super busy. Since it's a small mom and pop spot there isn't a lot of seating inside and not ideal for large groups. However, there were only 4 of us, and it was a beautiful day to sit out in the patio. I was bragging about the lunch specials, which are some really great deals. The sliders are my fave, so those certainly got ordered. And of course you have to get the garlic knots! Just be sure to have your breath freshener ready, because they are loaded with garlic. The 2 slice special, along with the veggiboli was ordered, and a baked ziti to go. Let's just say there wasn't one complaint at the table. I highly recommend Antonella's if you want to just grab something to go or happen to be in the area and want to grab a quick bite. The service is superb, and they are super friendly. I'll definitely have to make sure I don't let as much time pass for my next visit. read more
6 months ago
Whether you're dining inside or enjoying the outdoor seating with your dogs, Antonella's Pizzeria offers a genuinely welcoming experience. The staff are friendly and accommodating, and I was pleasantly surprised by how dog-friendly they are--even offering options so my Shibas could enjoy the outing too. As for the food, the pizza is outstanding: thin, crispy, and full of flavor. Definitely a spot worth visiting, especially if you're bringing your pups along. read more
I've been going to Antonella's for over a year. I noticed at one point the pizza quality just wasn't the same, so I took a break. However, now the pizza quality seems to be better then ever! They are generous with the toppings that also taste really fresh! My fave is the Grandma's pizza. The staff and owner are really nice and helpful. Plus the ambience is great. Although the place seems small, I always see an available table. read more
8 months ago
Well, I work in downtown Winter Park and really wanted a Calzone today. I already tried one from another Pizza place nearby, but it was not good. And definitely worth the price. So I gave these guys a chance. And you know what? Not bad at all! Actually, it was pretty good! Today, I tried the Antonella's Calzone and although the price might be a bit high, it is definitely worth it. The thing was massive, and I couldn't eat the entire thing. I just wish it had a bit more Italian sausage, which I will probably request as an extra add-on the next time I place an order. I love that they sell pizza by the slice. It is also a great option if you want to try different toppings, are on a budget, etc. All in all.... yes, I would recommend this place. And before I forget, the staff at the restaurant was super nice and accommodating. Next time, I will definitely dine in, so I can try their pizza fresh out of the oven. I'm pretty sure it's going to be really good. So there will definitely be updates to this post. read more
1 year ago
This is my $36, extra crispy, 16" pizza from Antonella's. This pizza has $4 worth of pepperoni (22 pieces) , $4 worth of mushrooms (several slices have none and about 20 full slices accounted for), and $4 worth of onions (I count 6 total pieces of onions). To make it worse, the first thing I had to do when I got home was turn on the toaster oven to finish cooking half of the pizza. Nobody was in line in front of me and the staff was just standing around. Now I know why. Never again. read more
1 year ago
I was in the area and this was on my to go spots while in LA. I had to sample a little of everything. I asked for a slice of cheese pizza, a delicious vodka sauce based slice and honey pepperoni slice and a Antonella favorite that I asked the team to surprise me with. All I can say is Wow...such taste each one carried. The line was insane but well worth the wait. read more
9 months ago
10 months ago
9 months ago
11 months ago
We were in the area and looking for an affordable bite to eat. My boyfriend was in the mood for pizza, and Antonella's Pizzeria came up when I searched pizza. So why not, we love trying new places, and the reviews seemed pretty good. They had good lunch specials, so we both rolled with the 2 slices & salad special. They had many other lunch special choices as well. I'm sure we will be back to try out a pasta ones most likely in the future. The salad was bigger than expected but fresh and good. I upgraded my slices for tomatoe & spinach, it was hood i just felt they overdid it on the toppings. Overall, we enjoyed the food. There were not many seating spots but we chose to sit on their patio since it was so hot inside. They stay busy tho I will say, they had a lot of pickup orders and uber eats it looked like. I say if you're in the area, give it a shot, and we will be back. read more
Business owner information
Sid S.
Hi Dava! Thanks for giving our shop a stop! We hope to see you soon.
2 years ago
This place is small and very clean. The lunch special is amazing, my friends and I thoroughly enjoyed every bite. Their pizza crust is fantastic, pasta is tasty, sliders are delicious, and salad is fresh and yummy! Will definitely be back! read more
Stopped in on a Saturday afternoon for lunch! Great find! Great variety of lunch specials through 4pm. I opted for the 1/2 hero (Italian cold cut, but you can choose from several heroes) and small Caesar salad. This special is #4 on the lunch menu; it's called "Twice As Nice". The salad was a generous portion for a side salad and tasted good. The hero was HUGE! Probably an 8" sub, packed with Italian meats and cheese. I had to eat it open face, with a knife and fork as it was too big to close to bite into. The pizza looked good! I think I'll try that next time. This place is small. Only 4 tables inside, and just a couple outside. If you want to dine in, visit during off hours or he prepared yo wait for a table - Butnthe wait will be well worth it! Highly recommend! read more
This mom and pop restaurant is secluded in one of the many nice spots in Winter Park. Stopped in, was greeted by the waitress and looked over the menu. They have a great selection of pizza, calzones, wings and so much more. I ended up doing a create your own pizza (steak, extra cheese, sun dried tomatoes and spinach) and 10 wings extra crispy with a Snapple Apple. They don't have a liquor selection but have select wines and beers. Seating is limited. Let me just say the pizza and wings were made to perfection! I enjoyed it sooo much. Definitely reminds me of authentic Italian. This won't be my last time here. read more
1 year ago
Where do I start? What happened to this place?! Used to be great. It's like children are in the kitchen. My Italian sub was a thick slice of what looked like ham loaf- no salami, cheese,or any other meats and was cold and I toasted- the opposite of what I ordered. My pizza slice had the wrong toppings and looked like someone took a cheese slice and tossed pepperoni on top before it went out the door. The slice of cheesecake was actually hard and looked 6 months old! Needless to say, it went right in the trash. I will NEVER order from that place again. Such a shame. Must be new owners who have no business being in that business! Would give zero stars but you have to click at least one on this app. read more
7 months ago
1 year ago
1 year ago
10 months ago
I'm from NYC and my review may be a bit bias. I was disappointed to see their Margherita pizza look like a regular pizza with tomatoes on it (see my picture below). There was no basil, nor garlic, nor were there any mozz balls. Taste wise...when I bit into the tomato, it felt like I was literally biting into a tomato instead of the sauce or cheese taking over. Their crust is decent so no complaints there. The wings are fried then tossed in sauce. I prefer baked wings and less sauce but overall decent meat. read more
9 months ago
Dropped in on a Friday night. Sat comfortably outside. Nice glass of chianti while waiting for soup and my chicken parmesan entree. Both were delicious. They were super busy with takeout orders that night. Those people did a great job from where I was sitting. Speaking of great job so was our server. Very pleasant. read more
Business owner information
Sid S.
Hey there Larry S! We're glad your meal was delicious! We hope we'll…
1 year ago
2 years ago
I ordered in on this rainy Friday night and my craving for NY Style Pizza and salad was fulfilled ! The crust was thin and crispy and the cheese and toppings were fresh and yummy. I ordered the 10 inch Specialty and a small Greek salad with creamy Italian dressing. I also ordered a lemonade. I'd like to visit in person next time. *I would've liked the pepperoni to be crispy but the pizza still tasted great! read more
Business owner information
Sid S.
Dear Sam G! We're happy to serve you and are so glad you're here for…
5 years ago
The staff here treated us like a family. A group of 10 walked in and they immediately catered to us, moving tables around so we had a place to eat. They brought us crayons and coloring books- like real, legitimate coloring books, not a piece of paper. They were amazing!! They really take care of their customers and constantly checked to make sure that everyone was okay. I ordered the small antipasto salad which had a good amount of olive oil dressing on it. Our friends ordered the 10 inch pizza which was like a personal size. We ordered the 14 inch medium pizza that was cut into 6 slices. It was perfect to split with 2 adults. This is a family business where the owners familia came from NEW YORK, so it's real authentic pizza! read more
Business owner information
Sid S.
Hi there, Jonathan L. Thanks for visiting. We're so glad that you…
3 years ago
Yesterday I stopped by Antonella's Pizza for the first time with my friend! It was such a cute little place that had delicious food and large portions. We started off with their Pasta e Fagioli Soup! All of their soups are homemade and this was exactly what we needed on a rainy day. You HAVE to dip your garlic bread into the soup! Next we tried their Mambo Combo on their lunch menu which come with chicken parmigiana, manicotti, and meatballs. It was perfect since we wanted a taste of a bit of everything. For one of our entrees, we ordered the Penne alla Vodka, and this definitely has some spice. The flavor was amazing and I loved how the pasta was al dente. The spice builds so be prepared! I love spice, so this was perfect for me. Lastly, we had to try one of their pizzas! We got the 14" Margherita Pizza which was massive, garlicky, and cheesy. This Margherita was very different from the ones I'm used to, they put fresh tomatoes on the pie and it was great! I do wish there was a bit more sauce, but other than that, it was incredible. The crust has such an amazing texture and taste. I definitely recommend checking out this place to try some amazing pizza, pasta and other Italian dishes! I can't wait to try some more of their menu next time! It is a family owned business so the staff were so so friendly. Thank you to Emily for being so helpful and kind! - Homemade Pasta e Fagioli Soup - Garlic Bread - Mambo Combo - Penne alla Vodka - Margarita Pizza - Cannoli read more
2 years ago
2 years ago
4 years ago
I went for dinner and got a seat inside just make sure to go early to beat the dinner rush because it's a small place inside. I got greeted by my server Emily and she was nice and friendly! For appetizers got garlic knots and antipasto salad both was delicious! Entrees got the Antonella pie large pizza and beef Stromboli both was tasty! It was a lot of food so got lots of left overs and Emily was nice to box up all our food and wasn't expecting that since I'm used to doing it by myself but was very appreciated! Food and service was excellent! Definitely recommend if you are craving Italian food in the winter park area! read more
Business owner information
Sid S.
Elizabeth, thanks for visiting! We're thrilled you enjoyed your visit!
2 years ago
Went over to this Antonellas after the closer one by me closed down, safe to say ill never go back. I walked in and knew what i was g into with the dirty environment and 2 workers who looked at me like i had 10 heads when i asked if they had my order i called in for pickup. They did not of course, then proceeded to completely burn my pizza! Bottom of the pizza black, and after sitting for just 2 hours the cheese already looks bad and no good. Easily my worst pizza experience.. Even any marcos, dominos or other fake pizza is better than this! read more
Page 1 of 11
More info about Antonella's Pizzeria Fairbanks
360 W Fairbanks Ave
Winter Park, FL 32789
Directions
(407) 636-5333
Call Now
Visit Website
https://fairbanksantonellas.com
Full menu
Hours
Payment methods
Food & Alcohol
Indoor Amenities
Outdoor Amenities
Other Amenities
From the Business
More Info
Health Score
Antonella's Pizzeria Fairbanks Reviews in Other Languages
Ask the Community - Antonella's Pizzeria Fairbanks
You might also consider
Why does Yelp recommend reviews?
15 reviews that are not currently recommended
The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.
2 years ago
11 years ago
11 years ago
10 years ago
10 years ago
11 years ago
10 years ago
7 months ago
8 years ago
10 months ago
1 year ago
9 years ago
8 years ago
11 years ago
